East Elmhurst, NY · Member since 2017 · 125 posts · 27 votes
Hello BP,
What are the pros and cons to owning rent stabilized apartments as an investor ? I’m looking at a property that is rent stabilized. Curious to know if it’s beneficial as an investor.
@Julio Velazquez, "So why wouldn’t an investor want such property?"
I can tell you why: because the Govt via the cities of the community/state you are in have made it clear that they have both the capacity (i.e. votes) and willingness (i.e. political ideology) to say that the free market doesn't apply and your rights and an owner will be limited in at least one major way.
Any guesses how that's going to play out down the road? Me neither. The Govt is getting broker, people are getting nuttier, and to me that suggests that some day not only will you have your rent increases CAPPED, your current rents might also get CUT. Because...you know..."fairness." Even with "rent stabilization", rents are still increasing faster than wages in these markets; ergo, the voters will eventually require their lap dogs....err, I mean representatives to pass new laws to make housing "affordable". How do you do that? Cut rents.
If you decide to invest in a market where Govt forces are already meddling with the free market substantially, be prepared to get skinned alive is all I can suggest. If it doesn't happen, hey, great! But if it does happen, then you'll have no one to blame but yourself because the signs and actions are already there. Rent control (I prefer to use accurate words vs. the make up social justice malarkey "rent stabilized") is the first step in crushing property owner rights. I could see you being required to rent to violent felons, people with multiple evictions, terrible credit, etc. That has already happened to a limited degree in some markets where you can no longer deny based on background checks or eviction records.
The ideology in these markets says that people deserve housing as a basic human right. If you deny people for any reason, you are violating their human rights. You really want to own an apartment in a place like that?
The handwriting is on the wall. Proceed with full knowledge of what you're getting into.
@Julio Velazquez a stabilized property will provide more income, cost more and be less work if the tenants were properly screened and everything is documented. Tenants are only an asset if they behave and pay rent on time.
@Julio Velazquez, "So why wouldn’t an investor want such property?"
I can tell you why: because the Govt via the cities of the community/state you are in have made it clear that they have both the capacity (i.e. votes) and willingness (i.e. political ideology) to say that the free market doesn't apply and your rights and an owner will be limited in at least one major way.
Any guesses how that's going to play out down the road? Me neither. The Govt is getting broker, people are getting nuttier, and to me that suggests that some day not only will you have your rent increases CAPPED, your current rents might also get CUT. Because...you know..."fairness." Even with "rent stabilization", rents are still increasing faster than wages in these markets; ergo, the voters will eventually require their lap dogs....err, I mean representatives to pass new laws to make housing "affordable". How do you do that? Cut rents.
If you decide to invest in a market where Govt forces are already meddling with the free market substantially, be prepared to get skinned alive is all I can suggest. If it doesn't happen, hey, great! But if it does happen, then you'll have no one to blame but yourself because the signs and actions are already there. Rent control (I prefer to use accurate words vs. the make up social justice malarkey "rent stabilized") is the first step in crushing property owner rights. I could see you being required to rent to violent felons, people with multiple evictions, terrible credit, etc. That has already happened to a limited degree in some markets where you can no longer deny based on background checks or eviction records.
The ideology in these markets says that people deserve housing as a basic human right. If you deny people for any reason, you are violating their human rights. You really want to own an apartment in a place like that?
The handwriting is on the wall. Proceed with full knowledge of what you're getting into.
@Julio Velazquez it depends on your plans for the property. Existing tenants and leases become a liability if you want to raise rents and/or remodel. Hope that helps.
@Erik W. your explanation is very good, unfortunately in Elmhurst (Queens) NY it already happened. Everything you mentioned already happened in June 2019.
@Julio Velazquez what are you looking to buy? the rent regulations in the city are making it impossible for landlords to make money, especially the smaller landlords. are you looking at a multifamily 6+ units? if so, you'll be very restricted in raising rents but taxes and other expenses will be less restricted. Which means less ablity to profit over longer period of time.
As of June 2019, there are no more pros of owning rent regulated properties in NY. Let me know if you have any specific questions, I'll try to help you out.
@Peter Nikic yes I was looking for 6+ units. I spoke to a broker and he asked if I’d be interested in looking at one just wasn’t sure of the pros and cons. I was concerned for that very reason the limitations one would have.
The advantage is that the price of a rent stabilized building is somewhere in between what it is work now and what it is worth if you can replace the existing tenants with ones that pay more.
If you are successful in doing that you can run a successful business. If you can't, then... that's the con.
@Michael Dang interesting read thank you for that, Now if I purchase a non rent controlled apartment complex one could raise the rent as the area allows correct not to what the city demands.. discrimination should be removed in all aspects of life.