Preferred Return Structure and Accounting

Preferred Return Structure and Accounting

Investor · Member since 2025 · 32 posts · 23 votes

I'm currently doing due diligence on a ground-up development project. I've previously invested as an LP in one other ground-up multifamily syndication that offered a 9% compounding preferred return. This new project I am evaluating from a different operator offers a 12% simple preferred return. Which of these (compounding or simple) is more common in the ground-up syndication space?

In particular, I like to track all of my investments (single family, syndications, etc.) once per month to evaluate performance. For ground-up syndications, this can be tricky, as a development is technically worth very little until it is completed, yet I want to amortize the expected return by accounting for preferred return (conservative assumption) and the projected IRR (idealistic assumption). Is there a standard practice for this? Do most people account for the value of their ground-up development by committed capital only, by committed capital + pref, or by committed capital + projected IRR? Or all 3?

0Reply
129 views

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    13h

    I structure my projections based on the GPs structure and how they are paying the return. If its a pref with upside i typically juts track the pref only and then may put several exit numbers to also get an IRR, but reality is the moment you hit enter on the computer your model is wrong and the deal could also go to zero. My question is what are you trying to accomplish by tracking this?

    7e investments53 Reviews
    • Investor · Member since 2025 · 32 posts · 23 votes
      12h

      Thanks Chris. The deals I have invested in/am considering involve a pref and then GP/LP split. My goals in tracking this have largely to do with smoothing out the portfolio growth and accurately representing project progress. It doesn't make a lot of sense to me to have a line item that doesn't change for 2-4 years, and then all of a sudden double. I feel like that is not reflective of what is actually happening. On the other hand, assuming the projected IRR for the growth seems overly optimistic, and likewise not representative. In both cases, the value could also go to zero, in which case even just recording committed capital would be overly rosy based on what COULD happen in the project. That's why I settled on committed capital + pref as it seemed to be the middle ground, but wanted to get feedback from others as well.

      I have clients that I serve where the value of my overall portfolio (including the ground-up development projects) lends confidence that I can generate a return for my clients. I send updates on the portfolio monthly, and so wanted to understand best practices for accounting for in-progress projects.

  • Investor · Charlotte, NC · Member since 2026 · 54 posts · 7 votes
    12h

    Really sharp break down, Victor. Feel free to send over a connect request! I have a go to lender doing flexible real estate loans if you ever want another solid option for your pipeline.

  • Stuart UdisPro Member
    Attorney · Philadelphia · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12h

    @Victor Mora Until the pref is actually paid, I’d treat it as zero for purposes of calculating your actual return. Sure, the pref accrues, and I assume the operating agreement gives it priority in the distribution waterfall. But that priority only matters if there’s cash available to distribute. You can track how much pref has accrued, but what happens if the deal flops and there’s nothing left to distribute? The pref can go entirely unpaid. Since it seems you are currently underwriting and performing diligence I would focus more attention on the real estate itself. Are all permits obtained, bank financing in place, what are the bank financing terms? Are there extension options in the event the construction is delayed? Who is guaranteeing the loan? Suitable contingent funds and Interest Reserve? Has the GP fully developed the budget? Where is your last dollar of exposure? Is your capital protected if the property sells for 90% of anticipated outsale number? 80%? 70% etc. That's where I would be focusing all my attention.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.