401k contributions or Real Estate Investing

401k contributions or Real Estate Investing

Member since 2023 · 37 posts · 32 votes

It's the end of the year and I am considering investing in a rental property as a first-time owner, who already owns a primary home. However, I am also thinking about whether I should max out my 401k like I did this year. The pros and cons of both options are driving me crazy!

4Reply
302 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Somewhere over the Rainbow · Member since 2021 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
2y

It's mind boggling to me when I come across people (mostly realtors or people heavily in the RE industry) that have zero retirement other than rent houses. I do get it's a strategy, and it may work, I just don't love it honestly

A 401k is hard to beat - I'm saving 32% right off the top (already hard to beat that return in RE), my employer is matching 5% (free money), the money that's not taxed now is now growing in my 401k. And over the long term you can expect an 8% return (I invest in fidelity's s&P 500 tracker) again a solid return over the long-term 

I personally do a Roth IRA on top of that. Tax free gains. Another thing that's hard to beat.

Then I do an HSA - again saves me 24-32% depending on the bracket at this point. Tax free growth again. Can convert 35k into a roth IRA in later years as well, if I remember right

Then I do a 529 for education. 

Then I do a regular contribution to a taxable brokerage (S&P 500 tracker) 

"Savings" stays in an HSA and I keep the minimum in my bank accounts 

I invest in RE after all this. I don't get to save on the taxes now (can't be REP due to W2 and can't deduct due to income limitations) so I have to pass the tax savings forward...until I retire essentially or make less than 150k and have passive income/gains I can deduct from. RE for me is diversification, increasing net worth through equity by buying at a discount, and a small monthly cash flow. Over the long term (think 20+ years) you'll have some equity paydown and appreciation as well. This is where RE shines, in the very long term. Retiring on LTR cashflow is, in my opinion and for my lifestyle, not realistic unless you are running a really big operation (which most mom and pops are not)

See this reply in the discussion

59 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Byron VallesPro Member
    MSFP, CFP, Financial Advisor · San Francisco Bay Area · Member since 2020 · 66 posts · 53 votes
    2y
    Quote from @David Fals:
    Quote from @Justin A.:

    It have done both types of investing over the last 15 years and this is where we're at. 

    $100k into 401k type funds that are worth about $150k now.  

    $30k down on our first house that's now a rental.  We have about $250k equity in it now (conservative estimate).  Our next house will need 20% down which will take twice as much cash but should still have a better cash on cash return than a 401k.  And that doesn't take into account the tax benefits of the rental. 

    We only contribute to the 401k up to the employer match, just to diversify.  And the rest goes toward our next down payment on a rental.

    Just my .02

    I think I have decided on my plan. I won’t be maxing out my 401K contributions this year since my employer only matches 50% up to 6%. Instead, I plan to diversify my investments. I’m aiming to save 20%, but contributing more to my 401K would stretch my finances too thin, especially considering the need to maintain my emergency fund. Just for context, I’ve been saving and investing in ETFs and Index funds for the past 5 years and am currently working on catching up with the US financial system, being an immigrant. It’s a learning journey!

     Hopefully some of the answers many generously shared here helped, David. I'd also like to say congratulations to you for taking ownership of personal finance education. As an immigrant myself I know it can be a daunting topic, but learning these things will yield great results for you. 

    best of luck!

  • John MorganPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Grand Prairie, TX · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2y

    @David Fals

    I would only put in your company match. Invest the rest in RE. That’s what I’ve been doing the last 8 years and doing much better with RE. Plus I like all the tax free passive income I get monthly vs having to wait til I’m 59 1/2 to receive any of the 401k money.

  • Member since 2024 · 6 posts · 0 votes
    2y
    Quote from @David Fals:

    It's the end of the year and I am considering investing in a rental property as a first-time owner, who already owns a primary home. However, I am also thinking about whether I should max out my 401k like I did this year. The pros and cons of both options are driving me crazy!


     MAX OUT 401K - it's a simply dumb decision to go for without thinking an iota of any real investment at this time. 

  • Member since 2022 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    2y

    You could always sell your primary home to buy a multi-family home to house hack while continuing to contribute as much as you can to your 401k. 

  • Investor · Richmond, VA · Member since 2023 · 459 posts · 474 votes
    2y

    Calculate the actual return on investment year over year if you invest in the 401 (including employer match) and compare to RE returns.

    That employer match returns 100% on the first year, but the original return is lower year after year and drops below the actual YOY ROI of real estate pretty quickly.

    That "free money" will cost you if you compare its returns against the long term sustained returns of real estate investing in income properties.

  • Member since 2022 · 186 posts · 192 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Peter W.:
    Quote from @Basit Siddiqi:

    401K Pros
    Hands-off - good for people who can't manage their own money.
    Grows tax deferred/Free(depending on if traditional or 401K)

    Cons
    Can't tough the money until you reach retirement age with penalties if you touch the money early
    Limitations of stock options depending on broker that your employer chose.
    Stock market returns is normally less than real estate


    Also 401k/IRA protected from lawsuits and bankruptcy. But, you can never put enough in there to be truly wealthy but can prevent you from getting zeroed.

     Gotta disagree. If a person maxes out 401k/roth they can make a lot of money. We had this conversation at work today. If a person starts in thier twenties and maxes them out. They can sit on2/3 million in the future. Saving 25k a year at 8% returns adds up fast. In less than ten years you can be making 20k a year in returns. Yes waiting till 59 sucks. However some places allow you to take loans on 401k that you pay back with interest to yourself. 

  • Member since 2020 · 351 posts · 329 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Jeremiah Dunakin:
    Quote from @Peter W.:
    Quote from @Basit Siddiqi:

    401K Pros
    Hands-off - good for people who can't manage their own money.
    Grows tax deferred/Free(depending on if traditional or 401K)

    Cons
    Can't tough the money until you reach retirement age with penalties if you touch the money early
    Limitations of stock options depending on broker that your employer chose.
    Stock market returns is normally less than real estate


    Also 401k/IRA protected from lawsuits and bankruptcy. But, you can never put enough in there to be truly wealthy but can prevent you from getting zeroed.

     Gotta disagree. If a person maxes out 401k/roth they can make a lot of money. We had this conversation at work today. If a person starts in thier twenties and maxes them out. They can sit on2/3 million in the future. Saving 25k a year at 8% returns adds up fast. In less than ten years you can be making 20k a year in returns. Yes waiting till 59 sucks. However some places allow you to take loans on 401k that you pay back with interest to yourself. 


     2-3 million is definitely enough. But at 60, I wouldn’t consider it wealthy. 90th percentile is just over 3 million. A 4% draw down is 80-120k/yr which is solidly middle class. But I guess at this point we are arguing over what wealthy is.

  • Morris County, NJ · Member since 2020 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2y

    @Peter W. sure but... Just ~$100k/yr from ONE savings account... for doing what should be a minority percentage of one's paycheck.. That's pretty good when you consider if a person is doing other saving and investing.. That could be IRA's, side jobs, and whatever other investing..

  • Member since 2022 · 186 posts · 192 votes
    2y
    Quote from @David M.:

    @Peter W. sure but... Just ~$100k/yr from ONE savings account... for doing what should be a minority percentage of one's paycheck.. That's pretty good when you consider if a person is doing other saving and investing.. That could be IRA's, side jobs, and whatever other investing..

    I am in same boat. That’s the equivalent of having 10 properties cash flowing 1000 each. Except no toilets,evictions,lawsuits, drywall, hvac. A 401k is the most passive thing in the world. I check my deductions to make sure I’m on track a couple times a year and that’s it. I get a statement every quarter or so that tells how I’m doing. I literally spend max five minutes a year on it. It gives me an almost 10% every year. Where I work some of us have pensions some of us don’t. While I have one I would rather have a match on 401k like others. The 401k and Roth IRA is a huge wealth builder for the future. It’s gonna allow me to retire and not skip a beat. I have also borrowed of off mine to buy real estate. So I’m not waiting till 60 to reap its benefits.

     To each their own. I’m not a financial guru at all. I just feel like a 401k is an overlooked tool that gets discredited because it’s not sexy at the water cooler like real estate or crypto

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.