Maybe you bought another property. Maybe you sold one. Maybe your income changed.
But your estimated tax payment may still be based on last year’s numbers.
That can be an expensive mistake.
So I’m curious:
Do you actually recalculate your estimated taxes during the year, or just keep paying the same amount?
What’s your approach?
@William Thompson, I’ve learned not to assume last year’s estimate still makes sense once the year starts moving. If I buy or sell property, have a big change in income, or something else shifts, I’d rather check in during the year than get surprised later.
What has worked best for me is treating estimated taxes like something that needs to be reviewed when the facts change, not just something I set once and forget. I’m not trying to do the tax math myself, but I do want my CPA looking at the real picture as the year goes on.
It really depends on the client. The ones who get their return done early will usually pay safe harbor amounts for the first couple of quarters and then we circle back in the third and fourth to true things up once we can actually see how the year shaped up. For the folks who tend to run late, we carry estimates through the third quarter and square it away in the fourth. Either way, what I like to do is put two numbers in front of them, what the tax looks like exactly as things stand today, and then what it could look like if they moved on a few specific things before year end. That second number is usually the one that gets people's attention, because paying the same amount you paid last year is still a decision even when it doesn't feel like one. Where you land depends on your own facts, so it's worth walking through it with your CPA instead of letting the old number ride.
Safe harbor keeps you out of underpayment penalties. It does not mean your tax bill is right.
If you bought, sold, refinanced, or had a big income swing this year, Id re-run the estimate off current year numbers, not last years voucher amount. Quick pass I use with landlord clients:
Pull YTD P&L by property (rents, interest, repairs vs improvements).
Check W-2 withholding + any other pass-through K-1s.
Compare (a) 100% of last years tax (110% if AGI was over 150k) vs (b) 90% of this years projected tax. Pay the lower of those for penalty protection, then decide if you want to overpay toward the real bill.
September/October is the cheap time to catch it. January is when people find out the hard way.
Not advice for your specific return. Just the checklist.