How I handle a tenant who stops paying (Section 8 vs market)

Question

I run 236 doors in Memphis, mostly single-family Section 8. When a tenant stops paying, I do not treat every case the same.

Section 8 first. On a 3BR at $1,395 to $1,950, most of that rent is the housing authority portion, and that portion keeps coming even when the tenant portion stops. That does not mean I wait. I contact the tenant the first week, document everything, notify the caseworker, and enforce the lease on the tenant portion promptly. If the tenant portion is not cured, it is still a lease violation. The math is steadier, but letting it slide teaches the house that the tenant portion is optional. It is not.

Market tenant is different. There is no housing authority portion. When $1,400 stops, $1,400 stops. I move fast on communication day one, I listen for a real reason and a real date, and I only do a payment plan if it is credible and in writing with dates. If it is not credible, I start the possession process promptly. At 236 doors, vacancy plus nonpayment plus turnover bleeds fast. One month lost, one month vacant, plus clean and repair is thousands gone on one house.

Rule for both: be direct, be documented, do not let hope replace a timeline.

How do you handle it — do you give a payment plan a chance, or do you file right away when rent stops?

Drew Sygit · Answer

For all tenants, we auto-send 7-Day Notice of Nonpayment - no matter what.

That starts the "clock" on them and we use Polite Pressure to remind them.

We do work out Payment Plans, with specific dates & amounts, as long as they make sense and the tenant keeps communicating.

Several of our standard messages deliberately include, "please communicate otherwise YOU force us to assume the worst and proceed accordingly".

If they can't make significant progress on their past due balance, we start the process to get a court date.

• We want a judgment to keep the pressure on them!
• Many that ignored our communications, now want to negotiate a payment plan
• We've seen progress on getting judges to waive our 56 day judgment limit in exchange for court ordered payment plans.A decent percentage of tenants fail to follow the court plan, but we try to still be a bit flexible - especially during the winter when a vacancy attracts squatters the most.
• A decent percentage of tenants fail to follow the court plan, but we try to still be a bit flexible - especially during the winter when a vacancy attracts squatters the most.

We want a judgment to keep the pressure on them!

Many that ignored our communications, now want to negotiate a payment plan

We've seen progress on getting judges to waive our 56 day judgment limit in exchange for court ordered payment plans.

• A decent percentage of tenants fail to follow the court plan, but we try to still be a bit flexible - especially during the winter when a vacancy attracts squatters the most.

A decent percentage of tenants fail to follow the court plan, but we try to still be a bit flexible - especially during the winter when a vacancy attracts squatters the most.

Some tenants we have to get the Writ of Eviction to get their attention!

• Seems too many landlords are pushovers and allowed tenants to develop bad habits:(
• We'll still do a payment plan if it makes sense.

Seems too many landlords are pushovers and allowed tenants to develop bad habits:(

We'll still do a payment plan if it makes sense.

Payment Plans: we created a spreadsheet that we can enter their balance and proposed payment schedule and it tells us how long until the balance is paid off.

• Some tenants want to make ridiculously low payments that will take YEARS to pay off.

Some tenants want to make ridiculously low payments that will take YEARS to pay off.

All this applies to S8 tenants and their portion of the rent + repairs, etc..

Our biggest challenge is actually owners willing to accept the S8 portion and NOT wanting us to pursue the tenant for their portion - other than phone calls.

• Many S8 tenants are immune to threats, so goes nowhere.
• Unfortunately, most of our local housing commissions will NOT take away a voucher for violations:(We've heard it's because caseworkers don't want the hassle of having to interview new applicants and all the corresponding paperwork.
• We've heard it's because caseworkers don't want the hassle of having to interview new applicants and all the corresponding paperwork.

Many S8 tenants are immune to threats, so goes nowhere.

Unfortunately, most of our local housing commissions will NOT take away a voucher for violations:(

• We've heard it's because caseworkers don't want the hassle of having to interview new applicants and all the corresponding paperwork.

We've heard it's because caseworkers don't want the hassle of having to interview new applicants and all the corresponding paperwork.

Leo Stein · Answer

James, thanks for laying out the Section 8 vs market split so clearly. In California the calendar looks different, so operators here build the same discipline around a shorter notice window. Market nonpayment usually starts with a pay-or-quit style notice on a tight clock, then documentation of every payment attempt and communication before anything moves forward. Local just-cause and habitability rules can change the path, so the file has to be clean from day one. Not legal advice.

On voucher units the housing authority side adds another lane: confirm what portion failed, keep the HA copied on status, and do not mix “tenant portion late” with “HA portion delayed” in your own ledger. Same end goal as yours — consistent process, dated proof, and no improvising mid-month.

The owners who stay calm are the ones who decided the order of operations before anyone stopped paying. Happy to compare notes by message.

How I handle a tenant who stops paying (Section 8 vs market)

3 Replies