New Paltz, NY · Member since 2018 · 22 posts · 10 votes
Hi everyone,
I'm wondering whether my fiancé and I should begin to pay our debt down ASAP or begin investing in RE. I know there are intelligent arguments on both sides of this issue and that it depends on the details of our situation.
So here is our situation:
We both are therapists in private practice with incomes approximately between 60 and 70k per year at this point. I am 36 she is 29.
Between us, we have 120k in student debt. She has about 80, I have about 40. Interest rates are 6.5% for her and 6.8% for me.
While we do have a wedding coming up with some more expenses on that front, if you set that aside, we have the ability together to save probably 2k total on top of minimum payments of $800 minimum payments a month on the student loans, which means we can put approx 2800 towards student loans a month.
I feel pretty sure that using an FHA loan to buy a multifamily unit (most likely a duplex given what is around us) is a smart play. We currently pay 1450 in rent with everything included. If we could live for free in the unit and have the tenant pay off the mortgage, then we could add that 1450 to our monthly savings that we could put towards the debt. For simplicity, we'll call that $4200/month. Accounting for some unexpected expenses, we could probably pay off our debt in 3 years that way. OR we could get very aggressive in real estate.
What do you all think?!
PS: I should add that we live in a smallish college town where a lot of people rent.
You are not going to like my answer. Each of you get a part time job on the side and attack that debt faster. Don't invest in IRA or 401K and attack this debt and make it gone in the next 12-15 months. Get rid of car payments and live like NO ONE now so you can live like NO ONE ELSE later. Brown bag your lunch, streamline everything. Stop going out to eat more that one or two times a week too. The most we ever made W2 earnings for my family was $80,000 before taxes.
You are both so young. Fast forward to 52 like I am now and you could have 122 front doors and $160,000 cash flow and rising every year. If a lowly paid teacher can do this, anyone can.
"If you change the way you look at things, the things you look at change right before your eyes."
I for one am never afraid of risk. However I am a smart investor that believes taking unnecessary risk is foolish.
To invest smart as a long term plan to grow you take the time starting out to remove as much unnecessary risk as possible. In planning for success in investing you do not ignore any opportunity to control risk through elimination. Ignoring bad debt with the belief that it will not interfere or have a negative impact is fool hardy when eliminating it requires little more than additional time.
Taking risks based on assumptions and preparing to deal if the risk is realised is reverse thinking. Eliminating that risk before you start is the path a wiser investor would choose to prepare to begin..
Michael Swan I applaud your responses, even though they might have been lost in the weeds. My generation, especially those of us who are professionals, compare ourselves to everyone else our age and if no one else is doing it, you shouldn’t either. So many people think “I’m (x) years old, I can’t do that. What will (abc) think?!” I say screw it. I have two side hustles (part time jobs) and even my girlfriend asks why I’m doing it, I have a good, “regular” job. I’d love to hear more about your story, sounds like you just keep on grinding, no matter what you’re facing.
I think a lot of this depends on your market. If you are in a cash flowing market then invest in Real Estate. If you are in California with little to no cash flow and are just hoping for appreciation then I would focus on the student loans.
My student loans are much higher interest rates so be happy with your less than 7% interest.
We were in the same boat. We took our savings to buy cash flowing rental properties. We use the monthly income to pay down on the loans much quicker and focus on the loans with the highest interest rate. So far, we are very happy with our decision.
After I accepted and did Podcast 238 this past summer, I offered to talk to anyone that wanted to do what I did on a combined $80,000 or less combined w2 earnings in an extremely expensive part of the United States (San Diego). I was resisting many podcasts elsewhere that was reading my posts on BP and wanted me on their podcast for a year or two prior. What I didn't want to happen was people assuming what I did was something for nothing, instantaneously gratifying, kind of a diseased mentality. People on BP, family, and friends etc... said I was crazy to buy in 2011 in San Diego. I was just trying to get cash flow with my low W2 family income and living in pricey San Diego. Then when these properties doubled, they said I was crazy to sell. All I know is that I went from $50,000 cash flow in San Diego and after 1031 exchanging and making a few mistakes along the way, now have $160,000 cash flow and rising. This cash flow is paying for my child's college at San Diego State too.
The key is you will pay for your brand new truck that you purchase or lease after you get this constant cash flow coming in every month. Also, I sold all my IRA's and refinanced my personal residence to do this. As one person said earlier, people will say it is not smart to get a new truck, before you chunk in that new truck with cash flow from your rental properties. I have pretty low W2 combined family income. So, my path may be a little different than others that have much higher W2 earned family income.
After only 7 years of investing in RE, I have found you need plenty of cash in reserves to be ready when Murphy's law raises its ugly head. It is not if, it is when. I am proud that my son is using my old clunker 2000 Chrysler Concorde and I have a Hyundai Hybrid Sonata and Honda Pilot that are both completely paid off. You know what the best kind of car is? A paid off car. That is what I have told my son since he was young.
He could never understand why people would want to get themselves into such debt when they graduate college either. He told me that Mechanical Engineering is the same stuff taught at Berkeley or San Diego State.
I just learned this RE stuff a little too late at 45 years of age I purchased my first little rental property. If I would have learned this RE stuff back when I was in my early to late 30's, I would have had $500,000-$750,000 cash flow per year, instead of $160,000 right now.
Dave Ramsey is right to get America out of debt for liabilities and of course he is not correct in saying we should not get good leveraged RE that puts cash flow in our pockets month after month after month. Dave Ramsey is like the Kindergarten of financial planning. What I am speaking of hear is like a college degree. When you move to the apartment complex business model and follow proven methods like David Lindahl's Multifamily Millions strategy of repositioning value plays on your way to financial freedom, then you are in the PHD type education or level of financial planning. The power of the 1031 exchange or refinancing and buying more is the best way to defer taxes.
The Trumps of the world have always done this. They defer, defer, defer, defer, defer, and then they die. Their heirs or their kids then inherit at a stepped up basis and that is how multigenerational wealth is created. Depreciation starts all over again and right now I have 122 front doors and counting. If I die with 1000 front doors, then my son can continue this pattern, keeping good leveraged debt on his front doors, until he has maybe 5000 front doors when he dies.
This all was made possible by living like no one else for a 10 year period and now I can live like no one else the rest of my life. I am 52 right now. You people in your late 20's, 30's and 40's can do what I did too. Especially, if your W2 combined family income is well above $100,000 or greater. Many people contact me and make over $200,000 a year and tell me they can't do what I do. How is that possible?
Again, Napolean Hill in his THINK AND GROW RICH has the secret. "whatever the mind can conceive and believe, it will achieve." That goes the same for negative thoughts and ideas too. You will have set backs, but if you keep your eyes on the prize, staying focused on your one thing each day that gets you closer to those goals, you will do it!!!
@Michael Swan The Dave Ramsey approach before getting into real estate is the best. I am paying down my SL debt now but at least i will have financial foundations to help me get into real estate without having to worry about a stupid SL payment!
You said it. You need to get as far away from zero as possible. That is Dave Ramsey style!! Plus, invest in assets (RE) with good leveraged debt to get that cash flow and catapult your net worth and then after 7-10 years you are free!!!
@Steve Walko I encourage you to objectively look at your posts and you will see that you suffer from confirmation bias. Everything you say indicates you have already made your decision.
That is ok as long as you are not fooling yourself into believing you are carefully considering all your options. You are running into this full blaze.
Just be careful to make sure your future wife is OK with holding this debt and buying rental property. I fear you may be steam rolling over her and not even know it.
As far as your decision, I have never talked to someone who paid off debt who said years later, "I wish I never paid off those student loans." I have heard MANY people say, "I wish I never got into rental properties."
Everyone who enters rental properties is 100% confident they will succeed. The point is people taking risk never think the bad stuff will happen to them. The safe choice here is paying off your student debt first.
@Steve Walko I'm all for real estate investing as you have the chance to tap into exponential financial growth, and set yourself up nicely for the future.
Only thing I would consider is make sure you have enough income to account for taxes, maintenance, PMI, etc
Clear all debt while living below your means now. Build up your emergency fund of 3-6 months of expenses after that. THEN start to look at your investment strategy. Without the student loan debt, you will have many more options to invest and build wealth WITHOUT the high risk of simple “what-if” scenarios. This is ultimately what the majority of wealthy people do to become wealthy in the shortest amount of time.
Count me in with those that advocate with investing now and not worrying about your student loan debt. This is kind of personal for me because I consider myself a hybrid Dave Ramsey'er and struggled with the same question back in 2011 when I bought my first property. I decided against paying off/down my student loans on Dave's advice and the advice of my Financial Peace University graduate close friends.
I strongly disagree with Dave Ramsey's prescription for cash investing. I went to a seminar of his back in 2007 and it changed my life. I love "Total Money Makeover". However, in my opinion he is way off base on leverage. In fact Proverbs 14:4 says, "Where there are no oxen, the manger is empty, but from the strength of an ox come abundant harvests." I believe the ONLY way to get rich is to leverage time, talent, or money.
He said at the beginning a phrase which has stuck with me, "If you only take one thing away from today it is; don't buy things you can't afford". I agree. If you are wanting to get involved in investing and have a huge car note hanging around your neck then I would advocate selling that sucker and getting an affordable car.
Take this with as much salt as necessary ;) Dave is wayyyy richer than I am. Your mileage may vary but I am much better off financially for the decision I made back in 2011 to purchase instead of keeping on renting and paying off my student debt.
I'd get married, househack together, then pay off at least the $40k.
But... we don't know what kind of car payments or credit card debt is being carried here. That will speak to your true spending style and whether or not you're ready to invest.
If you also have cc and car payments, definitely pay off the SL first. If you're not willing to get rid of that stupid debt by driivng a beater and brown bagging your lunch, just stay in the rat race forever like 90% of everybody else.
Something else to consider that no one ever mentions....the vast majority of real estate investors FAIL.
Most never get started but far too many lose money, have destructive or professional tenants or fail due to any number of other financial disasters. S**t like life happens.
The vast majority fail. No point in starting with bad debt as a strike against you.
I love Swanny’s answer - his drive and passion (I know he just wants you to have the freedom he has) but I also understand your reply - balance and not burning out is important.
Here is my opinion. Since you have to live somewhere anyways.. the question is - not make extra income and instead create equity for someone else or invest some money now and earn cashflow and build up equity.
Stop building someones else’s dreams and begin building your own.
Based on the logic above I would invest in a house hack - preferably a multi - with as many doors under one roof as possible.
At the same time I would as Swanny suggests look for ways to accelerate the debt payoff.
Also think creatively.
Maybe you can find an investor that will hold paper for you.
Can you pull some local examples and run the numbers (for real) using the BP calculators? This will give you (and everyone if you share the results) solid examples. It will show your cash on cash return as well as your longer term return and equity build up. You can then compare this to the cost of debt and any related opportunity cost.
The low money down house hack is a no-brainer. After that, looking at it from a psychological standpoint, I would say what’s going to keep you waking up every morning ready to tackle the day? Paying off student loans and ridding yourself of the heavy burden or getting into real estate more quickly and building an empire? I would say as long as you’re doing one of the two you’re on a pretty good path.
Ouch to that interest rate. First, have you verified if you can refinance? If you can get anything 3.5% or less, it's not a big deal to have this debt. If you can't, I would plan on paying down asap. If you can get a duplex property using whatever cash you have an rent out the other units to reduce your payment that would be ideal, even before you pay down the debt. You can have more deductions, appreciation etc.
Otherwise try to get rid of that in 5 years. That's 20k/yr which should be easy with that combined income.
I would however recommend you refinance your rate with a company like SoFi or similar to lower that interest rate into the 4s.
I got a quote from SoFI online, the lower interest rates were only available as low as about 5.5 for paying it off in 7 years. Not the big of an improvement. I would probably rather keep the minimum payment low so I have more options.
@Joe Splitrock I think you are misreading me, though I get how. I'm tentatively adopting the REI route to see if someone can convince me of the holes in it. I obviously lean i that direction because of the simple math of it, but my emotional side of course is worried it won't work out.
Also, I have spoken to my fiancé of course. She is almost more in favor of the REI than I. I am trying to make sure SHE knows about the risks involved.
I'd get married, househack together, then pay off at least the $40k.
But... we don't know what kind of car payments or credit card debt is being carried here. That will speak to your true spending style and whether or not you're ready to invest.
If you also have cc and car payments, definitely pay off the SL first. If you're not willing to get rid of that stupid debt by driivng a beater and brown bagging your lunch, just stay in the rat race forever like 90% of everybody else.
No credit card debt. She has about 5k in a car loan to pay off.
We actually went to the bank to day. Because we are both self-employed, but more recently, we don't have the income to get the kind of loan we hoped for, but after next year's taxes, we should be all good. We will pay off the car loan and my smallest student loan (about 2.5k left) for sure and maybe chip away at the rest of my student loan debt and then househack. We will decide then fully whether we will save for more REI or debt pay down.
I would however recommend you refinance your rate with a company like SoFi or similar to lower that interest rate into the 4s.
I got a quote from SoFI online, the lower interest rates were only available as low as about 5.5 for paying it off in 7 years. Not the big of an improvement. I would probably rather keep the minimum payment low so I have more options.
try a different company then. If you have good credit, someone will take that loan from you for in the 4s. 4 to 6s will make a huge difference over time. It's almost like getting free money.
It sounds like you may already be a few years out of school but here is a different suggestion based on being in a similar position in 2011 graduating from PT school with 130k student loans. I assume with 6.8% loans that you have federal loans and would qualify for income based repayment/repaye. Student loan payments are capped at 10% of your AGI - (1.5x poverty rate) and the loan lasts 20 years (10 years if you are non for profit) before the remainder is forgiven(ish). I estimated my figures upon finishing PT school and opted for this program which keeps my payments low and allows us to invest in flipping houses.
This approach does create a debt to income anchor for a while but only about 7.5% at your current income level. Also, if you have children and want to reduce your work hours then your decreased income will be balanced by a lower loan payment.