15 or 30 year mortgage on 1st rental?

15 or 30 year mortgage on 1st rental?

Rental Property Investor · Washington, DC · Member since 2019 · 28 posts · 21 votes

I’m in the process of buying my first rental property. My credit union is offering 3.1% on an15 year while another lender is offering 4.87% on an 30 year for investment properties. I’m 46 and aim to retire by 65. With only 20 years on the retirement horizon, do I go with a 15 year or 30 year mortgage?

A couple considerations:

-my goal now is but and hold. in retirement it would make sense to have all the rent come on as cash flow and not have to pay down a mortgage.

-in my area, prices are expensive, so I my rent would not quite cover the Monthiy expense even for a 30 year mortgage. This means even more out of pocket for a 15 year!

Any help would be appreciated!!

0Reply
126 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Agent · El Dorado Hills · Member since 2018 · 32 posts · 41 votes
6y

I made a mistake doing a 15 year on one of my rentals.  The reality is you will have a little bit higher rate doing a 30 BUT you can always pay at a 15 year rate.  When market went down and oil went to $25  a barrel my unit went unrented for 3 months.  I ate 2,100 month being on a 15 year.  That was the time I wished I was on a 30 year paying $1400 or so while times weren't so good.  Take what your 15 year payment would be and pay it on a 30 and you'll have it paid off in 15 BUT if for some reason your vacant or a big repair comes you aren't tied to a higher mortgage.

See this reply in the discussion

31 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · Henderson, NV · Member since 2011 · 1k+ posts · 550 votes
    6y

    @Masud Khan You asked about DTI calculations on future loans. If you're worried about that, then you should probably stick with the 30 year to keep your DTI down while accumulating the additional properties.

  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, NC · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    @Joe Villeneuve @Bill B. You guys make my head hurt, but in a good way lol. Two well reasoned perspectives that are both right. If I were 25, I think I would opt for 30 year leverage on smart buys and turn a 50% ROI. However, I'm 61 with debt free rentals that cash flow life but only a 10% ROI.

    Generally speaking, the optimal path may be smart leverage to maybe 45 or 50, then debt free by 65 and love life. Thanks for you perspectives.

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Terrell Garren:

    @Joe Villeneuve @Bill B. You guys make my head hurt, but in a good way lol. Two well reasoned perspectives that are both right. If I were 25, I think I would opt for 30 year leverage on smart buys and turn a 50% ROI. However, I'm 61 with debt free rentals that cash flow life but only a 10% ROI.

    Generally speaking, the optimal path may be smart leverage to maybe 45 or 50, then debt free by 65 and love life. Thanks for you perspectives.

     I'm 63 and if I could get a 60 year mortgage, and lower the MP, I would do it.

  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, NC · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
    Originally posted by @Terrell Garren:

    @Joe Villeneuve @Bill B. You guys make my head hurt, but in a good way lol. Two well reasoned perspectives that are both right. If I were 25, I think I would opt for 30 year leverage on smart buys and turn a 50% ROI. However, I'm 61 with debt free rentals that cash flow life but only a 10% ROI.

    Generally speaking, the optimal path may be smart leverage to maybe 45 or 50, then debt free by 65 and love life. Thanks for you perspectives.

     I'm 63 and if I could get a 60 year mortgage, and lower the MP, I would do it.

    Joe, I have a feeling the first question you ask St Peter in heaven is "So what interest rate are you guys offering up here..."

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Terrell Garren:
    Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
    Originally posted by @Terrell Garren:

    @Joe Villeneuve @Bill B. You guys make my head hurt, but in a good way lol. Two well reasoned perspectives that are both right. If I were 25, I think I would opt for 30 year leverage on smart buys and turn a 50% ROI. However, I'm 61 with debt free rentals that cash flow life but only a 10% ROI.

    Generally speaking, the optimal path may be smart leverage to maybe 45 or 50, then debt free by 65 and love life. Thanks for you perspectives.

     I'm 63 and if I could get a 60 year mortgage, and lower the MP, I would do it.

    Joe, I have a feeling the first question you ask St Peter in heaven is "So what interest rate are you guys offering up here..."

    Actually, that depends on whether St Peter is a traditional lender ( and this would also depend on the product being sold,...ie...HELOC, REIF, BUY/Hold, etc...), the seller of the property, a private lender offering a collateralized loan, or a private lender offering a non-collateralized loan.

  • Lender · San Diego, CA · Member since 2019 · 874 posts · 355 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Masud Khan:

    I’m in the process of buying my first rental property. My credit union is offering 3.1% on an15 year while another lender is offering 4.87% on an 30 year for investment properties. I’m 46 and aim to retire by 65. With only 20 years on the retirement horizon, do I go with a 15 year or 30 year mortgage?

    A couple considerations:

    -my goal now is but and hold. in retirement it would make sense to have all the rent come on as cash flow and not have to pay down a mortgage.

    -in my area, prices are expensive, so I my rent would not quite cover the Monthiy expense even for a 30 year mortgage. This means even more out of pocket for a 15 year!

    Any help would be appreciated!!

    Hi Masud, I would get a 30 year and pay in 18 years. If your goal is to retire in 20, your cash flow should go to paying all your RE investments. If you get a 15 year you lose the flexibility if the market turns and for unexpected things in life. The 15 year loans are high on the payments. Even with 1.77% extra on rate and with 3 years more than the 15-year mark you would save 7K in interest. At the 15 year mark, your balance on the example below would be 23.5K

    Look at this simple comparison. I used 100K to make it easy to follow. 

    Home Mortgage Calculator:

    $100,000 

    15-year @ 3.1% = PITI payment of $959. in 15 years the interest paid would have been $57,882. Pay off 15 years

    30-year @ 4.87% = PITI payment of $793. in 15 years the interest paid would have been $48,651 and an outstanding balance of $22,585.

    If you use the difference $166 and apply it to the monthly payment the Pay off would be in 18.08 years. Interest paid $50,491 saving you $7,391.

    Any year you can back off the extra payment for repairs etc. Or you can save the amount and pay a lump sum yearly. The month you apply the lump sum will either add a few months or subtract.

    Don't be fooled by the RATE.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.