Texas vs Midwest for buy and hold investing

Texas vs Midwest for buy and hold investing

Member since 2019 · 222 posts · 104 votes

Hey BP,

I'm in my 20's and have 200k to invest. I want to make the investment that will give the best returns over my lifetime, so 50+ years. 

I already own a house in Cleveland, OH which cashflows well at close to 2%. I am considering going and buying a ton of more properties in Cleveland, but I am concerned about it in the long term, as it is losing population and home prices are more or less stagnant.

Enter Texas. There is a lot of growth happening in the 4 big cities, and they appear to have a much more solid future than Cleveland at the moment. The downside is that the cashflow is much lower than Cleveland, and most of my gains would be locked into equity which is harder to access.

You're probably wondering why I put "midwest" in my title, and so far have only mentioned Cleveland. I will mention a few others. Chicago appears to have some potential, as it is such a large city with much cheaper houses relative to NY/LA, etc. Indiana(polis) in theory has some good deals, but it has been super competitive and I haven't been able to land any, and Cleveland has better cashflow. Columbus looks excellent, but I've heard it is insanely competitive right now. I won't touch Detroit. 

For Texas, all of the big 4 cities minus Austin look appealing as a mixed csahflow/appreciation play. In Dallas, San Antonio, Houston, you can get deals pretty close to 1%, most of what I'm finding is 0.8-0.9%. Most of the properties I've checked either break even or lightly cashflow with conservative numbers. Like I said before, this would be a play betting on Texas' future, as in the present the midwest offers much higher returns.

I'm probably going to embarrass myself here by showing some theoretical math. I'm going to compare my preferred midwest cashflow city (Cleveland) with my preferred Texas future growth city (Dallas) for turnkey properties:

I'll be estimating 15% maintenance, 10% vacancy, 8% property management, 20% down @ 3.6% mortgage costs for both properties*

Cleveland SFH, B neighborhood:

Purchase Price 65k (15k down)

Rent 1050

Cashflow after all costs: $320/ mo

CoC Return: 25.5%

Cashflow pays purchase costs in 4 years. 

1500% ROI after 30 years (186k Cashflow, 0% appreciation of house)

Dallas SFH:

Purchase price 170k (39k down)

Rent 1600

Cashflow after all costs: $100/mo

CoC Return: 3%

Cashflow pays purchase price in ~13 years

1220% ROI after 30 years (127k cashflow and 412k equity. 3% appreciation per year for 240% total appreciation)

It seems like Cleveland beats Texas even in the long-term, unless there is something that I am missing. I would prefer to go with a better long-term option, and Cleveland, my representative for the midwest, appears to have the best returns both in the long term and the short term.

There are a few variables that could change these calculations quite a bit, and feel free to let me know your thoughts on them. 

1) There may be better deals available in each market than those I listed, which were just what was readily available on the MLS. Better number could easily sway things in Texas' favor.

2) Texas may grow better than expected, and beat that 3%/yr appreciation number. It may also underperform that number.

3) Cleveland's population loss could cause decreased demand/ rental prices which eventually sway things in Texas' favor.

4) Repairs on the cheaper Cleveland houses will cost the same as the more expensive Dallas ones. Assuming same cost of repairs for both houses makes the 30yr ROI about the same for both.

5) Cleveland/ midwest will run into traditional loan limits faster than Texas.

Either way, the best option appears to be investing in the high cashflow, midwest markets. Not only do the returns appear to be better in the long term, they are much better in the short-term which will allow me to acquire more cashflowing properties faster. I'd like this to be an open discussion, please let me know if there is anything I missed in my analysis. I'd love to hear the opinions from both sides.

7Reply
380 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Brooke Park Drive · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
6y

I’m like you, many doors in Ohio, so to balance it out I added A class in OKC to my portfolio. It doesn’t have to be 100% one way or another.

Most want strong cash flow to replace a W2. Buying for appreciation is more “long term wealth building “. Both are good goals, but if you have a job you want to quit cash flow is the way to go.

P.S. Don’t write off a whole city (Columbus) because you heard it’s too competitive. Plenty of great deals in Columbus come across my desk
(mostly from @Remington Lyman)

See this reply in the discussion

29 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Erik B.:
    How do you find current population statistics? I can only seem to find data that's 2 years old

    Originally posted by @Mike D'Arrigo:

    @Tyler D. I think your concerns about Cleveland with a declining population are valid, there are other alternatives besides TX which has high property taxes and insurance rates. I recommend taking a good look at Indianapolis and Kansas City. Both cash flow well but both also have good economic and demographic fundamentals. 

    The U.S. Census Bureau does population projections every year based on the last dicenial full count which the last one was 2010. 2020 data isn't out yet. You should be able to find the 2019 projections on their website.

  • Real Estate Agent · Temple, TX · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 700 votes
    7mo

     I invest in Temple TX (I-35 corridor between Austin and Waco) and the math is different than what most people assume about Texas. Median home here is $255K with 3BR rents at $1,750. That's a gross yield around 8.2% — comparable to a lot of Midwest markets but with actual population growth (24.1% projected) and employer diversification (Fort Hood + BSW Health System + growing university).

     The property tax argument is valid — Bell County effective rate is about 2.18%. But the appreciation kicker offsets it. Temple's still priced 40-45% below Austin for similar square footage with the same I-35 access. The real risk in Midwest markets that doesn't show up in the spreadsheet is tenant quality and vacancy duration. Military bases and hospital systems create a tenant pool that's employed, credit-checked, and rotating on predictable timelines. My military tenant turnover averages 2-3 years with zero evictions.Both strategies work. Just depends whether you want pure cash flow (Midwest) or cash flow + appreciation + demand floor (Central TX).

  • Michigan, USA · Member since 2026 · 22 posts · 13 votes
    7mo

    Breaks my heart you won't touch Detroit. I, however, see this was posted 5 years ago. The city had a poor reputation back then, but a lot has changed in those five years. I hope you've been able to reconsider your position on the city, haha. 

    I think you answered your question. Cleveland is a safer investment long-term with stronger cash flow. The city is betting big on its future and has recently embarked on a major revitalization project, which you should check out if you haven't yet. The city is projected to grow significantly in the next few years. I can't say the same for Texas. Growth in Texas has plateaued around the pandemic time. 

    If you read this, I'd be interested to know where you finally landed. And if you are ever in need of architecture design services, hit me up!

  • Garrett CrosbyPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Los Angeles, United States · Member since 2021 · 392 posts · 163 votes
    5mo

    Five years later this debate looks very different in hindsight. The Texas appreciation play worked for people who bought in 2018-2021 but those who got in at peak 2022 pricing are dealing with a market that got hit by high insurance costs, HOA fee increases, overbuilding in certain submarkets, and price corrections in Austin especially. The cash flow numbers at those peak purchase prices never quite worked, and the appreciation that was supposed to make up for it didn't come through.

    Meanwhile the cash flow-first Midwest markets you analyzed — especially Columbus and Indianapolis which you mentioned — have both appreciated meaningfully AND maintained decent cash flow. The boring strategy outperformed. Cleveland is debatable depending on neighborhoods, but the point stands that buying for yield and holding gives you optionality that appreciation-only plays don't.

    My take from experience: buy where the numbers work TODAY, and treat appreciation as a bonus not a plan. If the deal needs appreciation to justify the purchase, you're taking on more risk than the yield reflects. Feel free to reach out if you want to compare notes on what's working in specific markets right now.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.