Underwriting a flip before a partner's dollar moves: the numbers we share up front

Underwriting a flip before a partner's dollar moves: the numbers we share up front

Member since 2026 · 21 posts · 4 votes

Before a partner's dollar moves on one of my flips, I want them to see the same numbers I am looking at. That is the whole point of underwriting, and it is where most partnerships either build trust or quietly fall apart.

I start with purchase price versus ARV, and I do not take either number on faith. The ARV has to be backed by recent comps — same kind of house, same neighborhood, sold in the last few months — not the nicest sale in the county. Then I walk the rehab scope line by line with a real budget, not a round number, because a $35,000 to $45,000 gap per property can appear or disappear in the details: roof, HVAC, kitchen, baths, and the surprises you find once walls open up.

Next come the financing, holding, and selling costs. Interest, taxes, insurance, utilities, and commissions all eat into the margin, and I model them on a six-month term so nobody is surprised if the sale takes longer than the optimistic case. From there I work backward to my max offer: ARV minus rehab, minus carrying and selling costs, minus the margin the deal has to carry.

I also lay out the exit timeline and how the partner is protected. In the structure I use at Anchor Point Development, a partner's capital is documented and secured by a second-position lien, and that capital is returned first before any profit is split — in our co-flip model, remaining net profit splits 50/50. I have done 75 flips as an operator, and the habit has not changed: share the full numbers up front, and let the deal speak for itself. Returns are never guaranteed, and anyone considering a flip partnership should underwrite it that way.

What numbers do you insist on seeing before you commit to a deal?

1Reply
391 views

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Delray Beach, FL · Member since 2024 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    2d

    One thing I'd add is stress-testing the numbers before committing. I always like to see what happens if rehab costs come in 15–20% higher, the project takes an extra 2–3 months, or the property sells for 5% below the expected ARV. A deal might look great on paper, but understanding how much room you have for unexpected costs is just as important.

    I'm also curious about your second-position lien structure. How do you typically handle situations where the final profit is significantly lower than projected? Does the partner still receive their full capital back before any operator compensation?

    Always interesting to hear how structure these partnerships!

  • Investor · Cuyahoga Falls, OH · Member since 2026 · 27 posts · 4 votes
    1d

    Raul, thank you for putting this out there so plainly. Sharing the numbers up front, before a partner's dollar moves, is exactly the kind of honesty that keeps a partnership strong. It says a lot about how you work.

    What I have learned to pay attention to is the numbers that protect the relationship, not just the deal.

    The purchase price against ARV built from recent sold comps, the rehab budget line by line with a little room for surprises, the full cash picture including holding and selling costs, and the exit timeline with what happens if it slips.

    When a partner can see all of that before they commit, they are deciding with a clear picture, not a hope.

    The second-position lien is a thoughtful piece of protection too. When the numbers and the story match from the start, everyone at the table can breathe a little easier, and the funding side tends to follow more smoothly.

  • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 197 posts · 42 votes
    21h

    @Raul Valdivia, good day. The numbers matter most in the middle of the rehab. When each line moves from budget to actual at every draw, an overrun behind a wall becomes a call that week, not a surprise at the sale.

    Do your partners get that budget-to-actual view at each draw, or only at the exit?

  • Jim BlackburnBusiness Member
    Lender · Florida Based (48 states Puerto Rico) · Member since 2017 · 344 posts · 130 votes
    21h

    Coming at this from the lending side, three numbers I'd add to the partner packet:

    1. The first-lien loan terms in writing. Points, interest reserve, draw schedule, maturity date and extension fees. A 2-month slip on a short-term loan can cost more than the extra interest people model.

    2. Whether the first-lien lender allows a second lien at all. Many fix-and-flip lenders prohibit subordinate financing or require written consent. If the partner's second-position lien isn't approved, the protection may not hold up.

    3. The exit buyer's financing. If the likely buyer uses FHA, a resale within 90 days of acquisition isn't eligible, and a resale between 91 and 180 days at double the purchase price or more needs a second appraisal. That can push the exit later than the rehab timeline suggests.

    Do you share the first-lien loan docs with your partners, or just a summary?

    — Jim Blackburn, NMLS #1072866

    Stairway Mortgage, a Division of NEXA Mortgage LLC598 Reviews
  • Erik EstradaBusiness Member
    Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    17h

    One number I'd add to the packet: what the first-lien lender will actually fund versus your max offer.

    Most fix-and-flip lenders size the loan three ways at once: a percent of purchase, a percent of rehab, and a cap at roughly 70-75% of ARV. Whichever comes in lowest wins, and the gap between that and your all-in cost is the partner's real exposure. Showing that gap in dollars tells a partner more than the profit projection does.

    I'd also show:

    - How the rehab holdback is released (inspection timing and who pays the inspection fee). Slow draws stretch the timeline more than most surprises behind the walls.

    - The interest reserve, if any, and what happens when it runs out.

    - The as-is appraisal next to your purchase price. If the lender's appraiser comes in low, the loan shrinks and the partner covers the difference at closing.

    LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
  • Lender · Tampa, FL · Member since 2018 · 28 posts · 5 votes
    7h

    Raul, good list. From the first-lien side I'd add two things that lenders and partners both want to see: a draw schedule tied to the line-item budget, so everyone knows when money moves, and a downside check on the ARV, meaning what the deal looks like at 5% to 10% below your comps.

    One more worth spelling out for partners: a second-position lien only protects them if the first lender allows subordinate financing and the terms between the two are in writing. Plenty of first-lien loan documents prohibit it. At 75 flips you probably have that handled, but newer operators miss it.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.