Occasional spats between CPAs and cost segregators boil down to one word

Occasional spats between CPAs and cost segregators boil down to one word

Michael PlaksPro Member
Tax Accountant / Enrolled Agent · Houston, TX · Member since 2014 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes

What word, you ask? Cost segregators say “always” where CPAs say “sometimes.” And I finally found a good analogy.

When you see CPAs debating cost segregators (CS), think of a conversation between drivers (D) and freeway builders (FB). It goes like this:

  • FB: freeways are an amazing way to travel faster and easier!

  • D: yes, but not for every trip

  • FB: so, you hate our wonderful freeways?

  • D: not at all, I love them, and I take them myself almost daily

  • FB: then you simply don’t understand how great they are!

  • D: I do! I’m only saying that sometimes it’s better to not take a freeway

  • FB: aha, so you do hate freeways!

and so on…

Cost seg translation:

  • CS: cost seg is an amazing way to save a fortune on taxes and propel your business forward

  • CPA: yes, just not for every situation

  • CS: so, you hate cost segregation?

  • CPA: not at all, I love it, and I recommend it to many of my clients

  • CS: then you must not understand all the amazing benefits of cost seg

  • CPA: I’m only saying that sometimes cost segregation is not sensible

  • CS: aha, so you do hate cost seg!


And even if you somehow get a freeway builder to concede that yes, sometimes (but VERY rarely, as they will stress) freeways are NOT the fastest route, they will insist that you anyway take the freeway, for all its other benefits:

  • You will avoid potholes and other road hazards

  • Nobody will ask you for donations or offer to wash your windshield with a dirty rag

  • You will be far less likely to hit a drunk person or someone’s wandering pet

  • You don’t have to worry about an errant car suddenly pulling in from a hidden driveway

  • Building freeways provides employment to many good people

  • Pigeons do not target cars on freeways


Maybe we can stop all this silliness and have a real discussion of pros and cons? Sadly, a mere mention that cost segregation has its pitfalls can make the daring CPA persona non grata on this forum.

Listen here, buddy: highways will get you there faster!


Yes, but not always. For instance:

  • If your start or end point are far from the freeway ramps and exits, getting to and from the freeway may negate the speed advantage of the freeway itself

  • The freeway can have construction creating a congestion (some areas like my Houston adopted never ending construction as a way of life)

  • Accidents can put a freeway at standstill

  • In bad weather with limited visibility, a freeway can be more dangerous and slower than a side road


This list could continue, but does it need to?


Some long distance trips are unthinkable without freeways. Some short distance trips would make taking freeways utterly impractical. Is this really debatable? Apparently, yes, it is debatable for some cost seg promoters. To them, every depreciation should be done with cost segregation, and never without.

For those who are curious, I recommend my two follow-up posts:

CASE STUDIES part 1: expected vs actual savings from cost segregation
CASE STUDIES part 2: cost segregation saves you money with rate arbitrage


But who needs case studies when it’s much easier to proclaim (and believe) that cost segregation is a universal magic wand that never fails. Just take the freeway, dude!

Wait, one more thing. I used a freeway analogy, but it is actually a toll road.

Most people would gladly pay $3 if a toll road saves them an hour of sitting in traffic. I would. But what if it only saves me 5 minutes? Now I have to think. If I'm running late to the airport risking missing my flight, every minute counts, and I'm taking the toll road. In contrast, arriving 5 minutes earlier to a casual party with my friends may not be worth the rush and the fee.

Cost segregation studies are not free. Just like with toll roads, customers naturally consider the cost. It's called CBA, cost-benefit analysis. Or, less formally, common sense.

1Reply
180 views

1 Reply

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2017 · 142 posts · 35 votes
    5d

    Good analogy, and the toll is only half the math. The other half is whether the owner can actually use the loss the study creates this year. The same front-loaded deduction is worth a lot more to someone who can offset active income, say through STR material participation, than to someone whose losses are passive and just carry forward. Hold period matters the same way — sell soon and recapture eats into it. That is why the same study can pencil on one property and not on the identical one next door.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.