CASE STUDIES part 1: expected vs actual savings from cost segregation
Occasional spats between CPAs and cost segregators boil down to one word. Cost segregators say “always” where CPAs say “sometimes.” I wrote an entire post about this disconnect between two groups of tax professionals who both are trying hard to help you.
Here I present to you a few case studies that support my insistence on saying sometimes instead of always. I assume you are familiar with depreciation and cost segregation. If not, then please start with my introductory post.
And if you find this post worth your time, please also review Part 2:
CASE STUDIES part 2: cost segregation saves you money with rate arbitrage
Case Study 1. Fiona, a high earner with a traditional rental.
Fiona is a senior manager in Denver, making $250k. Single, as she does not have time for dating, constantly being on call for every problem. Over $50k of her salary goes to the IRS, plus another $10k to the State of Colorado, making her even more stressed.
After a real estate podcast gave her hope for some much-welcome tax relief, she buys a $500k house in Aurora and puts a tenant there. Cost segregators pursue her, suggesting that they can easily find $100k worth of bonus depreciation in this house.
To her question, "Why do I want it?", Dave - who goes by TBD, Tax Buster Dave - explains that the top federal tax bracket is 37%, and the new Colorado law has doubled the maximum state bracket to above 8%. Together it is 45%. 45% of $100k is $45k - tax savings she can't afford to ignore.
Fiona works in finance and gets suspicious that she can so easily save $45k of her $60k tax burden, especially hearing it from someone named TBD. She seeks a second opinion from Ian who goes by CSI, Cost Segregation Ian. CSI is more careful than Dave. While confirming that Fiona's house brings $100k worth of bonus depreciation, Ian points out that Fiona does not yet reach the highest tax brackets. Her actual tax brackets are 32% Federal and 4.4% Colorado. Therefore, her true savings are a little over $36k. Not quite $45k, but still a heck of a savings, totally worth the $4k fee for the cost seg study. Fiona likes Ian's diligence and gives him the job.
Next March, her CPA, Isaac (everybody calls him FBI - Fun-Busting Isaac) solemnly informs her that she owes just as much in taxes as the year before. "How come?" Fiona exclaims in disbelief and anger. The answer is PAL - Passive Activity Loss rules of Section 469, explained in this post of mine. PAL is no pal of yours: the extra $100k depreciation uncovered by cost seg does exist, but it cannot be applied to Fiona's taxes in the current year.
Ian's assurances that this extra $100k tax loss does not disappear and can be applied at some future point are not much comfort to Fiona. She is bummed. She would've been even more distressed if I told her that this future tax benefit is not guaranteed, but we will save this for another case study.
Result: Expected tax savings: $36k. Real current tax savings: $0.
Case Study 2. Fiona, round 2, now with an STR.
Fiona would not have reached her current high-level position if she were easily deterred by setbacks. With more research, assisted by Mr. ChatGPT and Mrs. Claude, she realizes that she simply acquired the wrong kind of rental. Instead, she needed an STR - short-term rental. Her existing suburban property would not work as an STR. Fiona soon finds another $500k property, this time a small cabin near a skiing area, perfect for an STR.
Having been burned once, she checks with FBI (her CPA, remember?) before buying. [Side note: you should, too!] Isaac assures her that, while bonus depreciation on her first property will remain locked up, this new STR cabin will indeed allow additional losses to offset taxes on Fiona's salary. Finally, $36k less in taxes!
Isaac was not nicknamed FBI for no reason. Turns out, Fiona's savings were not $36k, after all. Colorado savings were, as expected , exactly 4.4%, or $4,400. However, Federal savings were only $27k instead of $32k. Who stole Fiona's $5k?
The tax bracket system did. As Fiona's $100k bonus depreciation was successfully pushing her taxable income down, somewhere along the way it crossed from the 32% bracket into the 24% bracket. Part of Fiona's savings was applied to the 32% bracket, and the rest was applied against the 24% bracket, for a combined effect of 27%.
But ultimately, $31k in combined Federal + Colorado tax savings was not something for Fiona to complain about. You know what? This chunk of cash was enough to make a down payment on at least one more property! The game gets exciting!
Result: Expected tax savings: $36k. Real tax savings: $31k.
Case Study 3. Fiona, round 3, raising the stakes.
What can be better than one windfall? Two windfalls, of course! The year after, Fiona added two more STRs to her portfolio.
Not so fast, dear Fiona. While Colorado tax savings stay at 4.4%, Federal tax savings on your second property dropped further from 27% to 21%. Why? Tax brackets at play.
Result: Expected tax savings: $36k. Real tax savings: $25k.
Case Study 4. Frank, max level game.
At one of their corporate retreats at the company's California HQ, Fiona mentioned her discovery to her boss, Big Finance Frank, aka BFF. Frank receives the news at the best possible time in his career. This year, his stock options get vested, and his W-2 will show a staggering $1.2MM. The money is nice, but he certainly hits the maximum 37% bracket plus another 13% from California. Combined, this is a totally insane 50% tax rate, half of his money! Ouch.
But, thanks to Fiona, Frank now has a plan. He will buy a nice condo, rent it as an STR on Airbnb, and maybe enjoy a weekend or two there with his girlfriend. A $5MM Santa Monica mid-rise condo would give him $1MM of bonus depreciation, enough to offset most of his gigantic $1.2MM W-2 for this year.
Quick math. 37% + 13% = 50%. 50% of $1MM bonus depreciation = $500k in tax savings. Yeah baby, we're talking now! Eat this, Uncle Sam!
And now, some reality check. Sorry, BFF. Sorry, BFF's girlfriend.
First, forget California savings. California does not allow bonus depreciation on state tax returns. Why, you may ask? Because California. Actually, it is not alone. Many other high-tax states, including New York and Massachusetts, do not allow state-level bonus depreciation.
Second, you cannot take a $1MM loss on the Federal side, either. Why?!? There is a sneaky (and fairly recent) tax trap known as EBL (Excess Business Loss) limitation. You are allowed a maximum loss of about $250k per year for a single person. Married couples could double it, but Frank's wife divorced him a while back, thanks to his regular beach weekends with girlfriends.
For all his troubles, Frank can only deduct $250k, and only on the Federal side. Yes, still at the maximum 37%, but $92k in tax savings is a far cry from $500k.
What happens to the other $750k of Frank's tax loss? It gets pushed forward and can be used in future years.
So, Frank still gets the exact same tax benefit, just has to wait? Not really. This was one unique year for him, with an inflated W-2. Next year, Frank is back to his usual $300k salary and, consequently, to a mixture of lower tax brackets. Therefore, it will take BFF three more years to deplete his reserve of losses, and he will get a lot less bang for his buck: around $335k total over 4 years instead of a $500k lump-sum.
Result: Expected current tax savings: $500k. Real current tax savings: $92k. Real overall tax savings: $335k.
Case Study 5. Frank's fortunes reverse a little.
As it turns out, BFF did not fully understand how his company's complicated stock plan worked. His W-2 showed only $900k. The other $300k came to Frank as long-term capital gain on a portion of his stock. Still $1.2MM in combined income, but a far better taxation than if his entire $1.2MM was included on his W-2.
Frank was not sure of anything anymore, including his 37% Federal savings on the $250k maximum allowed loss. He asked his CPA to calculate his tax liability both ways: with and without this $250k loss, so he could compare. The difference was $102k in tax savings. Could be better, but at least his current girlfriend gets herself the long-promised Porsche.
Now, wait a minute. $102k from a $250k loss is 41%. The highest tax bracket is 37%. How come Frank suddenly received an extra 4% in tax savings? Answer for tax geeks: NIIT, Net Investment Income Tax. Comment for extreme tax geeks: yes, gray area.
Result: Expected tax savings: $92k. Real tax savings: $102k.
Case Study 6. Sometimes less is more.
Fiona's parents are retired. I respect their age and will spare them from my 3-letter mocking. Between their pensions and IRA withdrawals, they live comfortably on $150k per year in the serenity of Texas Hill Country. They would be even more comfortable if they did not have to give $12.5k of their retirement income to the IRS. This could buy them two more cruises, and they never tire of cruises.
As luck would have it, their smart and successful daughter had the answer: buy STRs. City folks love to kick it back in the country for the weekend. And for Mom and Dad, it's a perfect mixture of having something to stay busy with while sticking it to the tax man. More luck: they quickly found a perfect cozy house for sale on a ranch just a few miles down the road.
As any Texan would do, they immediately went to meet their new neighbors. Guess what? These folks decided to move closer to their grandkids and were fixin' to put their house for sale, too. A few Lone Star beers later, handshakes were exchanged, and Fiona's parents found themselves with two Airbnbs side-by-side.
This is Texas, y'all, not California, and real estate prices here are sensible. Bonus depreciation is smaller, too, as they learned from a local cost seg guy. Still, $70k of tax write-off per house ain't half bad.
Mom and Dad expected to pay less in taxes, but still they gasped when their CPA told them how much they owed for this year: $0. Yes, ZERO dollars! Their entire $12.5k tax evaporated faster than a puddle under the scorching Texas sun. Atta girl, that Fiona!
Now, I'm not going to tell a Texas cost seg guy or a Texas CPA that they did not fully take care of their client. This is how you get shot in Texas. But I can tell you.
See, next year Mom and Dad will have their $12.5k tax bill back, since there's no more bonus depreciation left. Their combined taxes for two years are $12.5k. If, however, they did cost segregation for only one of their two STRs and then added the second cost seg next year, they would have paid $3.5k in taxes each year. Combined taxes for two years are $7k now, saving Mom and Dad $18k over two years. Even in Texas, $18k is better than $12.5k.
Result: Cowboy-style tax savings for two years: $12.5k. City-style tax savings for two years: $18k.
Case Study 7. Kathy's rushed decision bites back.
Fiona continued to enlighten her circle, including her cousin Kathy, better known as IDK, Impulsive Decisions Kathy. The next week after their eye-opening "STRs and taxes" chat during Thanksgiving dinner, Kathy bought a brand-new builder's special on a lakeshore and started furnishing it for her future Airbnb guests. By Christmas, it was ready, and so was her cost segregation study.
Referred by Fiona to FBI (the CPA, of course), Kathy congratulated herself on her rapid action. Too rapid, as it turned out. Since Kathy's very first booking was for New Year's Eve, her rental property did not qualify as an STR. Unfortunately, two other tax-related things did happen in December: the property was placed in service, and her cost seg was completed.
FBI was left with only one choice: report the property as a regular non-STR rental and apply cost segregation. Sitting on a completed cost seg report pretending it didn't happen and waiting for a better moment is not a tax-compliant option, sorry. Result: IDK had a large tax loss to report, but it got locked up under PAL rules, saving Kathy nothing. No bueno.
But wait, there is more! More bad news, that is. Kathy cannot use her loss next year, either, even though next year her property will easily qualify as an STR. Carryforward PAL losses remain passive, and are only allowed against the net income from the property. Let's say IDK's property shows a $10k annual net profit after deducting all current expenses and residual slow depreciation. It would take Kathy 10 years to use up her $100k loss at this rate.
Did she have an alternative? Yes, to pause. Ask FBI before, not after, ordering a cost seg study. Hopefully, Isaac would have told her to wait until after her initial tax return was filed. Then she could order cost seg, apply it to her second year in business, and then she would have had the benefit of the entire $100k loss.
A very costly mistake. Should have waited, but IDK is not known for her patience.
Result: Expected current deduction: $100k. Real current deduction: $0. Future deductions: $10k per year over 10 years.
Conclusions:
Yes, in many cases cost segregation can bring very substantial tax savings.
Estimating these savings based on the highest possible tax bracket is irresponsible.
Estimating these savings based on the actual current tax bracket is better, but not by much.
Ultimate tax savings are very hard to predict and can sometimes even be zero.
Timing matters, and there is such a thing as doing cost segregation too soon.
In short, you won't have an accurate estimate without running your comprehensive tax situation and your actual numbers through tax software.
Wake-up call: estimates prepared by cost segregation firms are inherently unreliable, because they consider very little - if anything - besides your tax bracket.
One last conclusion:
You need two tax professionals working together: a great cost segregator and a great CPA. At least you know where to find such a CPA. ;)
Reminder: If you found this post worth your time, please proceed to Part 2:
CASE STUDIES part 2: cost segregation saves you money with rate arbitrage
PS. Shout-out to my colleague and friend, cost segregation provider @Bernard Reisz who reviewed my draft and made a very substantial technical correction to one of my examples.