CASE STUDIES part 2: cost segregation saves you money with rate arbitrage

CASE STUDIES part 2: cost segregation saves you money with rate arbitrage

Michael PlaksPro Member
Tax Accountant / Enrolled Agent · Houston, TX · Member since 2014 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes

Occasional spats between CPAs and cost segregators boil down to one word. Cost segregators say “always” where CPAs say “sometimes.” I wrote an entire post about this disconnect between two groups of tax professionals who both are trying hard to help you.

Here I present to you a few case studies that support my insistence on saying sometimes instead of always. However, this is Part 2, and I strongly suggest that you first read and study Part 1:

CASE STUDIES part 1: expected vs actual savings from cost segregation

For this part 2, we need to know a little bit about depreciation recapture. The concept of depreciation recapture, if you need an intro, is explained in this post. I always use a loan analogy: first you receive tax benefits from depreciation, and then later you return these tax benefits via depreciation recapture when you sell. Like a loan. A mandatory loan which you cannot refuse: you must take it, and you must return it.

Common pushbacks to my loan analogy are:

  1. this so-called loan is interest-free (time value of money)

  2. there is no repayment schedule or maturity date (you choose when/if to sell)

  3. you return less principal than what you borrowed (rate arbitrage)

  4. you can keep "refinancing" it (1031 exchanges)

  5. the loan is forgiven when you die (basis step-up at death)

No argument against the first two points or the last one. I discussed some issues related to combining cost segregation with 1031 exchanges in this post. This leaves us with #3: rate arbitrage.

The rate arbitrage argument is based on the assumption that your depreciation benefits are applied against a high tax bracket of 32-37% while your depreciation recapture tax rate is capped at 25%. Thus, you save 8-12% of your "borrowed principal." Sweet deal, I agree.

For Frank from Case studies 4 and 5 (see Part 1), that indeed would be the case. However, not for Fiona's parents from Case study 6. They take depreciation at their ordinary tax rate, and they take depreciation recapture at the exact same ordinary rate. It's a wash. Why? Because they are in the 24% tax bracket. Until you cross into the 32% tax bracket, rate arbitrage does not kick in. A married couple will need to make over $440k to get there.

Not that I enjoy breaking bad news to you, but yes, it can get worse.

Case Study 8. Backwards rate arbitrage.

Fiona's assistant Brad, lovingly called SOB (Super Organized Brad), house-hacks his redneck-grade duplex. He realizes that cost segregation would be an overkill for a cheap one-bedroom unit, particularly with his salary being an unimpressive $40k.

Nevertheless, regular slow depreciation is not optional, so Brad deducts $2k of depreciation every year. At his 12% bracket, this saves SOB $240 per year. Enough for a few Happy Hour Tinder dates.

Who knew? One of his casual dates turned into something serious, and two years later Brad is married to a young ambitious lawyer, Grace (OMG - Obsessively Methodical Grace). Grace makes $200k, lives in an upscale area, and she wants Brad to sell his dingy duplex. He likes being married, so he won't argue with OMG.

Brad's depreciation recapture happens at the newlywed couple's tax bracket rate - which is 24%. Twice that of SOB while he was single and broke. So much for rate arbitrage, huh?

Result: Depreciation benefits, total: $240 x 5 yrs = $1,200. Depreciation recapture tax: $2,400.

Conclusion:

Rate arbitrage is a real benefit, but it is NOT guaranteed and can even work against you. As with almost any tax benefit, your mileage will vary.

Case Study 9. Cost segregation makes depreciation recapture somewhat worse.

For this example, I will set aside my silly stories, since we will have quite a few numbers to process. You're welcome.

The STR was bought 7/01/2022 for $500k and sold 7/01/2025 for $800k. $100k of the $500k was allocated to land. Of the remaining $400k, cost segregation identified $125k of 5-yr property. We will ignore any 15-yr property for the sake of simplicity. And we will assume a 32% tax bracket.

Without cost segregation, $400k would've been depreciated under a 39-yr straight line schedule. (Side note: yes, I'm very aware of the 27.5 vs 39 debate in the STR context, and I made my informed choice.) So, what do we have? ~$31k worth of depreciation. ~$10k tax savings at a 32% rate. The entire $31k depreciation will be recaptured, at the maximum 25% recapture rate, coming close to ~$8k tax. Our $2k in savings is courtesy of rate arbitrage.

With cost segregation, we bonus-depreciate $125k (100% of 5-yr property) and slowly depreciate the remaining $275k over 39 years. Our depreciation deductions are $125k + ~$21k = ~$146k. And yes, we now recapture $146k. Here's the real bummer: bonus depreciation on 5-yr property is not capped by 25% and must be recaptured at the ordinary rate, aka tax bracket, 32% in our case. No rate arbitrage here. Rate arbitrage only applies to the building depreciation portion, which is $21k. A 7% arbitrage rate applied to $21k gives us less than $1,500. Not much really. Notice that we have less rate arbitrage benefit with cost segregation than without. Unexpected, isn't it?

In fact, maybe we did not "win" even this $1,500. Maybe we even lost money, mathematically speaking. $125k bonus depreciation could have pulled us partially into the lower 24% bracket. If so, then we received some of our depreciation deductions at 24% and are now returning/recapturing these benefits at 32%. Reverse rate arbitrage at its ugliest.

Did cost seg fail us? Not really, if you consider the other benefits. In 2022, $125k bonus depreciation saved us somewhere close to $40k in taxes, and we had 3 years to deploy this money towards growing our portfolio. Kind of an interest-free $40k loan. Probably worth the $3k-4k cost seg fee.

Conclusion:

Even when in high tax brackets, rate arbitrage does not move the needle much, if at all. Cost segregation can still make sense.

Will you believe me if I say that I have good news for a change? But I do! Cost segregation has a trump card (not to be confused with Trump), and we saved it for dessert. Albeit there's a catch: you will need a very sharp CPA and likely pay him accordingly.

Case Study 10. Cost segregation redeems itself with the help of an astute CPA.

Our previous case study was based on a very substantial and very flawed assumption. Specifically, we were recapturing depreciation on the 5-yr property all the way up to its original value of $125k.

We don't have to. We can stop at the current FMV of the property. FMV is a real abbreviation, standing for Fair Market Value. It basically means the price that an unrelated buyer would be willing to pay on an open market. We're looking at carpet, appliances, furniture and cabinetry that together were worth $125k three years ago. What is it worth today? Certainly not $125k anymore. And not $0, either.

Well, let's say that my research pegs the current FMV at $45k. Now we have to recapture $125k of bonus depreciation only up to $45k. What happens to the remaining $80k? It ends up being taxed at the long-term capital gains tax rates - the best possible rates that you could ask for! Depending on your overall income, the rate is either 15% or 20%. Now this is real rate arbitrage, baby! From 32% down to 20% or even 15%!

A calculator, please. $80k arbitraged down to a 20% rate is almost $10k in savings. If you are still in the 15% rate zone, your savings are closer to $14k. And even if you have to add the 3.8% NIIT tax (a complex topic for a different discussion), you are still way ahead mathematically. Plus, remember, 3 years of an interest-free $40k loan? Plus flexing on social media - priceless! Sign me up!

Let's close on this positive note. And remember the little catch I mentioned: don't expect this kind of fancy tax work from your bread-and-butter CPA. Need a high-level pro for this.

Final conclusion:

You need two tax professionals working together: a great cost segregator and a great CPA. And now you know one of those CPAs. :)

2Reply
194 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2017 · 142 posts · 35 votes
    5d

    The part that deserves more attention is the sale year itself. Rate arbitrage is not just about which bracket you are in when you take the bonus, it is about which bracket you are in when you sell. If the sale lands in a low-income year, or a retirement year, the recapture math looks very different than if you sell in your peak earning year. Same study, same property, very different outcome depending on when you exit. That is another reason a study done in isolation, without a rough exit plan, can mislead.

  • Aaron ZimmermanBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3d

    This is fantastic! If I was looking at doing cost seg, this is the post I’d save.

    FMV in your last example is a bit subjective but point well taken. You shouldn't be picking up the full gain on 5 yr property especially if you're selling multiple years later. It's not the same value.

    • Michael PlaksPro Member
      OP
      Tax Accountant / Enrolled Agent · Houston, TX · Member since 2014 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
      2d

      FMV is subjective by definition. I mean, it has the word "fair" in it, and what is more subjective than fairness? ;)

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.