I was listening to some old podcasts from "The Real Estate Guys" today. They had a special guest speaking about using life insurance as a better bank account for REI's.
Has anyone used Whole Life Insurance as a bank account? What has your experience been? Any lessons learned?
He probably sold life insurance....
Advantages...can't be attached by creditors, exempt from bankruptcy, proceeds tax free if properly drawn, loans from cash value at low rates but reduce death benfits, can be pledged and assigned .
Cons, dificult to add additional amounts to account, premiums required to keep current, low very low ROI, but OK if you need life insurance too, might be hard to get to cash quickly, fees for transactions may apply.
Off the top....don't think it's a good idea just for a bank account....IMO.
Prudential had a policy, paid up at 65, that generated CV at 4 years that could buy additional paid up coverage, interest use to be deductible, it was rather a perpetually increasing policy and then CV could be borrowed without repayment and the interest deducted, in the 8th year.
What you're speaking of is the Variable Outlay Premium (VOP) program that I helped institute in 82 with Prudential. Many companies had early paid up policies that could be used. A straight WL to 100 won't be too effective. Not new. Not doable for individuals with consumer interest.
I'm not against life insurance, but it's not a bank! It's marketing, just as using the highest tax rate in your attempt at an example.
Instead of asking your "in office tax expert" you might pull interest tracing rules and show the auditing required to accomplish that with a business policy and its purpose. I won't be reading it, I'm familiar with auditing.
While you may try to promote this angle, my bet is that there are only about a dozen people on this site that would be able to set this up, in a business, have the funds for premiums, have the validated insurable interest to acquire a high coverage policy, account for proceeds without issues and use this method economically. Your rendition is off as interest isn't paid on CV that is borrowed out.
Now, insurance companies do lend money and they will use CV as collateral, totally a different borrowing out of the policy, made to a business interest could be deducted. This is much like getting a loan and using a CD as collateral. :)
Perhaps tax rates are less expensive in Missouri but, after 49,800 or so in CA we are taxed 9.3% on all earned income up to about 1 million (as high as 13.3%) just for state. If you wanted to be technical then I was using the 28% tax bracket for fed which is 87k-183k income brackets. The technical marginal rate would be 37.3% fed/state combined. To make it easier for discussion purposes I used 40%.
This is definitely not the "highest," marginal bracket. If I wanted that I would use 39.6% fed, 13.3 CA state% = 52.9%, and depending if you add the medicare hospital sur tax of .9%, or the 3.9% Obummer investment income tax for earners over 250k you could be upwards of near 58-59% before even considering payroll/self employment taxes.
" Interest is not paid on CV that is borrowed out," not sure what policy you're referring to and that may be right in the past. However on an indexed universal policies all of the CV gets the interest credit and the loan taken out "against," the CV is separate and it gets charged at its own rate. So within the policy the CV is unaffected by loan taken against the CV as collateral however it does affect the net surrender value and death benefit because at death or surrender the the policy owner would receive the net between CV - loan balance remaining - surrender cost (if any). Usually after year 10 there is no surrender cost so it would just be CV - loan balance = proceeds to beneficiary.
When I first heard about life insurance I was just feeling negative stigma but became interested when I learned you could use the policy to have your money work in multiple places at one time and have the additional benefits (liquidity, reserves, collateral, asset protection, etc).
In theory you could borrow money from the policy at a lower rate like 5%, earn a higher rate of return like 10-15% and pay it back to your policy and keep some for yourself. This would in turn build the policy larger and rinse/repeat.
Not to bring a dead thread back to life, but I'm on board with whole life dividend paying life insurance. It's a topic fresh in my head as I went through many different options. I actually hammered this down last year and started a policy a few months back. It's not a get rich quick thing nor will it give you much cash in the early years, but after several years the sails seem to blow off of it. It's your own banking system and it needs a few years of capitalization. Even with a quick few thousand available that I have right now I can take small loans to beef up my rehabs, or use them as float money for rehab draws, etc. I will pay back, plus add % to my payback, plus the money that is in my account gets it's regular interest plus dividends (dividends aren't guaranteed, but they have basically always been paid). *You don't actually take your own money out, you get loans from the insurance company directly and your cash value is the collateral. I'm using a dividend paying mutual insurance company, and there are definitely various products out there, some linked to the stock market. Mine is not.
The other factor for me was the legacy effect. The death benefit is great and increases each year. In 30 yr's if I don't do anything else than the bare minimum, I'll have a significant chunk of cash, and a much more significant death benefit which will go to my family and they can continue it - all tax free and very private. Using certain real estate and other strategies with the cash value (take it out and lend it, lend to your self and pay yourself back what you'd pay a lender, buy cars or items you would normally get financing on, have an emergency fund, etc etc), the velocity of the practically 5% a year you'll get if you do absolutely nothing in it will greatly increase its velocity. And plus I still use SD IRA's, SD 401K's and all that.
Since the last 5 yrs of this thread, has anyone started a whole life policy and used it with real estate, etc.?
My whole business is geared toward teaching this strategy to real estate investors. I've sold dozens of policies specifically for real estate investing and I do it myself. It doesn't have to take years to build up cash value. Only if you are starting with nothing. I try to get a client's savings/working capital all into life insurance premium in 5 years. If I put $50K into premium, I have about $42,500 of cash value immediately. In a few more years I'll have my $250,000 of working capital held in cash value.
For the "funding" years, your investing has to be balanced between policy loans and outside funds, but after 5 years, ALL of your working capital will be leveraged cash. I call it the "magic checking account"