Is there a way to defer some rental income into some kind of retirement account when retired?
Lets say someone was able to live entirely off savings for a year, could they somehow put their rental income into a deferred (not annuity) retirement account and pay no taxes?
The simplest thing is just to use the income from your rentals to fund your contribution to your IRA. Unfortunately, that's only a few grand per year and is subject to income limitations.
You might look into a Solo 401K and see if you could set up a company that owns rentals and using the income to fund the 401K. The contribution limits are much higher. You do need to watch out for the self-dealing rules. Those probably mean you can't put current rentals into this deal. You already own those, so selling them to a qualified plan of any sort isn't allowed. Solo 401k's don't work for me because I have a regular job, so I've not looked at them in detail.
Tom C. I have to disagree with the taxed at effective rate statement. My top income which I was contemplating deferring is taxed at the marginal rate of 25% this year, and who knows going forward. While my effective rate is 15%, the question was originally revolving around the possibility of lowering that marginal rate to 15%.
I am not much of a stock person believing that sooner or later you will lose a significant % (like 40%) if you buy and hold.
At the same time when returns are minimal the expenses of a mutual fund eat away at precious little returns the fund earns. All in all I believe owning a company (like RE ) should be offset with liquid reserves, not stocks. Whatever stocks I own will be in their pure form.
The original discussion morphed into a new question of whether converting deferred income into after tax ROTH makes sense. It appears the accountants say yes and the financial advisers say no.
Jeff S. You are correct, I should have used the "term marginal tax rate", rather than effective tax rate. I guess even CPAs use the wrong lingo at times when quickly dropping a post on a blog. :-)
If, as you suggest, you are at a 25% marginal rate with only passive rental income and without working or drawing on your retirement and are suggesting your marginal rate will go down in retirement after you begin to draw, I certainly would love to see how that works. Best of luck with it all this!
Tom C. Most people have more than 1 source of income and I am no different in retirement. There is rental income, interest income, pension income, capital gains income (sometimes) and there was job income part of the year this year, maybe some business income next year, maybe not.
If, the rental income is not entirely needed to live, the original question was can I defer some. I have since given up on that idea. It is possible but would require an elaborate plan of creating a rental business that funded a retirement account.
All in all keeping things simple is my motto.
It could be possible IMO (not accountant but believe) by buying more properties with leverage, and starting businesses, that the marginal rate could be brought down to 15.
Jeff S. Depreciation is the key. Buying often and using cost segregation is one of the biggest ways to save.
Jeff S. Yeah, I suspect you are correct. My assumption was that you were nearing retirement rather than merely being unemployed with some rentals on the side planning to go start a new career starting businesses that only generate tax losses. Who knew... silly me, right? :-)
My point remains that you should consider both deferring your income in strictly enforced IRS restricted funds as well as consider the tax and save approach if you are approaching liquidation events in retirement accounts. If this is your situation... you can play it by ear or really sit down and evaluate your options. After all, we all know that real estate outside of retirement accounts can be managed in a manner to keep the earnings largely tax deferred for many years as it is sheiled by depreciation.
Tom C. it is hard to jump into a post and make much sense when having not taken the time to read it. We on here are all guilty of that from time to time.
Being unemployed is an interesting way of thinking about. That would imply that one is looking for a job and might even qualify for unemployment insurance. I think the last time I was eligible for unemployment was 35 years ago but I never did file.
What I am doing at this point is exploring options. Exploring ways to reduce taxes is one exercise in the exploration of those options. But, tax reduction will be the icing on the cake of 1) doing something business wise that is enjoyable. If there is a tax loss, then great, if it makes taxable income that much better. 2) my places have been depreciated for almost 21 years and are based on small purchase prices. My depreciation is negligible. IF investing in more RE can fit into a lifestyle that is pleasing (not looking for more work) then the tax benefit would be most welcome. I will do very little just for the tax benefit. 3) being merely unemployed and doing nothing more than hanging out is better than working my *** off as I have done for many years. The nice thing is I don't have to do anything and if staying merely unemployed continues to be as enjoyable as it is now then nothing much will change.
I guess buying mutual funds will help the financial industry and we all know how people that are attracted to money have our best interests at heart.
You yourself seem to benefit from business losses if you are a CPA and a RE agent. Being an agent can produce losses both tax wise and for real too. Been there. Do you do the agent thing for the tax benefits?
Have not heard about any new options. What am I missing?
I did not take the time to read all (but most) of the replies so forgive me if I'm repeating.
This is not qualified advice, but I think my accountant would give me a "semi" thumbs up.
rental profit is not considered "earned income" and cannot be used as retirement contribution "officially". However, you can open a "management" company, which your buildings then pay a management fee to. The "profit" from that management company then becomes earned income and can be used to fund retirement account. Keep in mind though that every dollar you "convert" from rental income to earned income is now subject to SS/MED of 15.3%.
Now "unofficially" you can do anything you want with your rental income. By that I mean, let's say you work a job and your earned income is 40K. But you spend it all on mostly non-deductible living expenses. You then have 10K in passive rental income. you can put that into at least a ROTH or regular IRA. Because the IRS doesn't know "which" dollars you put in. IRS knows you made 40K from another job, and it's all "earned income" so you can put 5500 or so into ROTH. Period. It doesn't matter where it comes from. Does that make sense?
I have a lawn care company LLC that takes a management fee from my buildings. I use that to fund a SIMPLE retirement account. I'm 50 now so I can put in 15,500 of my earnings PLUS the "company" kicks in 3% of net earnings as well. I also made my wife an employee of that lawn care company so she gets a wage equal to what I can put into a SIMPLE for her.
I considered switching to a solo 401k but my accountant reminded me that, although that allows for bigger contribution, again, every dollar I move from rental income to earned income costs me 15.3% off the top!
The following IRS page covers self-employment income topic.
https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/self-employed-individuals-tax-center
Here's what my understanding is, and what I do:
1. Rental income is NOT "earned" income so not one dollar of it can be used to fund retirement plan, so it has to be "converted" into schedule C or wage income of some sort that qualifies.
2. My wife and I each have a solo 401K. I also own a schedule C web business, (LLC) she owns a schedule C RE management business (LLC). We're each sole owner of these two LLCs which has a benefit I'll get to in a minute.
3. Our rentals are owned by a 3rd LLC (schedule E's).
4. The properties pay my web business x dollars per year for web design, hosting, consultation, etc. The properties pay my wife's LLC x dollars per year for RE management. Then we fund our SOLO 401ks from this schedule C "income".
So the benefit to owning TWO LLCs is just that we don't have to do any payroll stuff. If we owned just the ONE, and I owned it, then we'd have extra work to do (941's, withholding, etc.) because my wife would be an employee.
We did consult with John Hyre in Ohio who just warned us to be within the generally accepted amounts (i.e. don't pay my web business $50,000 for web hosting when the local market rate is $9.99 per month)
This is especially helpful when we sell a building. We sold 4 units this year and have a pretty sizeable cap gain and depreciation recap. By plowing most of it into our 401ks we avoid the big caveat: Going over x dollars per year in AGI and having to pay back $18,000 in ACA health insurance subsidies. Ouch. This brings tax planning to an entirely new level.
PS: Keep in mind RE income is NOT subject to self employment tax but earned / wage / schedule C income IS. So depending on your tax situation you might not want to convert too much. We're literally doing it to avoid a ridiculous and unjust ACA penalty, which I'm hoping gets some rule changes next year. But for every dollar we convert into earned income, we have to pay 15.3% for SS/FICA.
@Kenneth LaVoie I see now that I did not understand the basics that it is not worth it to try and shelter rental income in any other way than to buy more property to shelter income through additional depreciation. A 22% tax bracket is very livable and not worth buying just for the write-off IMO.
@Jeff S. - Thanks for reminding me! My wife and I are sort of scaling down, to leave a little more room in our lives but it does bring a host of tax issues, whereas if we stayed "aloft" a little more (i.e. kept our mortgages as long as possible, bought and renovated more properties) we would reduce that tax issue. It's a big decision reversing course but your short comment gave me something to think about.
@Kenneth LaVoie attended a RE conference in CA last year and the big idea there was the biggest returns were coming from upgrading existing properties. That is where I am at and can up depreciation that way. They were saying a 20% return on upgrades made more sense than buying at a 5 cap.