Rental Property Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2016 · 61 posts · 18 votes
How can I protect my assets, I am owner occupying a duplex in Middletown, Connecticut. I currently live in the first unit with a roommate and have tenants upstairs, Unit 2. I plan to officially move out so my roommate will be taking on the entirety of the tenant responsibilities in Unit 1 (lease already in place), thereby will no longer be living here. I have heard many differing opinions on what to do with my asset protection in the landlord unfriendly state of Connecticut so I am worried I have no protections in place other than home insurance. How can I protect my other assets (401k, savings, Florida single family rental part of a 50/50 partnership LLC) with intentions to grow the portfolio.
Is it advisable to purchase an umbrella policy or form an LLC for my business here in Connecticut? Any suggestions on what I can do?
@Christopher Kolasa, just so you know most forms of formal retirement plans are exempt from attachment including bankruptcy. In Wyoming the annual cost of an LLC is about $50 per year until you get over a million in value.
Thank you @Jaysen Medhurst for your feedback, at what point would additional properties require additional protection (obviously a very subjective question).
@Christopher Kolasa, certainly any partnership is best held in a LLC. If you're doing SFR or smaller MFR, I would think every 6-10 doors or $500k of value should be in a separate LLC. It is very subjective, as you wrote. Anything larger than that should be in it's own entity, IMO.
I am no attorney, but if you go find one, they will probably have you put each property where you have some kind of ownership into a individual LLC.
The appropriate response for these kinds of questions is totally dependent on the type of investor you are. Some are very risk averse, some are not.
Generally speaking, most investors in the small multi-family space agree that a umbrella policy of one or two million will suffice for most people who do not have a large target on their back. A large target can be created by having multiple properties with high equity, or a high net worth/savings.
Keep in mind that in the state of CT, if you're going to own real estate in a LLC, some things will change - i.e. evictions.
If you are still going to be actively managing the property once you move out, a LLC may not be the best route for you, as any good attorney will be able to pierce the corporate viel afforded by an LLC in the event that something goes wrong.
@Filipe Pereira yes, the recommendation of my attorney is LLC (no surprise)! Regarding LLC's in CT, I believe they have an annual renewal fee of $150-$200, similar to Connecticut's handling of other professional licenses (expensive to maintain). This is a cost I would rather not incur and I believe an umbrella policy should be sufficient in my current case.
Filipe, how do things change in Connecticut under and LLC, specifically evictions? Also, you comment about a good attorney piercing an LLC, are you suggesting a different corporate structure may be appropriate upon property managing?
@Christopher Kolasa let me know what you wind up deciding. I'm in a very similar situation right now. I was leaning going umbrella but I would love to hear your pros & cons.
@Ryan Allison , I am heeding the advice of @Jaysen Medhurst & @Filipe Pereira, I will likely go forward with an umbrella policy to protect my owner-occupied duplex (soon to be non-owner-occupied) and likely go without LLC protection at this juncture. This decision is location dependent due to the fact the property is in Connecticut and LLC's are expensive to maintain. I received a quote from my insurance broker for a $1 million dollar umbrella policy for +/- $160 for the year (tied in with my car and home insurance), all in all seems like a pretty good deal. This will also provide some coverage for my single family rental in Florida which is in an LLC with a partner as well as general lawsuit protections. My knowledge with these asset protection structures is limited (not a lawyer) but will probably pick up the rich dad LLC book to learn more. Anyway, they will probably suggest I create a 'parent' LLC in Wyoming and eventually put all other LLC's into this LLC for the best protection considering Wyoming has strong protections far greater than Connecticut which will help de-incentivize any lawyers from pursuing lawsuits. At this juncture my assets are limited and should be well enough protected under the umbrella. I think if I were to have 3+ properties in Connecticut (total value over $500k) I would revisit the LLC creation discussion.
@Christopher Kolasa I'm not an attorney but I have been in the game for quite a while. I would suggest the LLC and the umbrella policy. Maybe that is overkill but if you are ever sued you will be happy you have both. Just my two cents worth. Good luck.
@Christopher Kolasa, just so you know most forms of formal retirement plans are exempt from attachment including bankruptcy. In Wyoming the annual cost of an LLC is about $50 per year until you get over a million in value.
@Filipe Pereira yes, the recommendation of my attorney is LLC (no surprise)! Regarding LLC's in CT, I believe they have an annual renewal fee of $150-$200, similar to Connecticut's handling of other professional licenses (expensive to maintain). This is a cost I would rather not incur and I believe an umbrella policy should be sufficient in my current case.
Filipe, how do things change in Connecticut under and LLC, specifically evictions? Also, you comment about a good attorney piercing an LLC, are you suggesting a different corporate structure may be appropriate upon property managing?
Thnx!
Hi Chris,
Annual fees aren't that much. Should be around $20.
If the property is held in a LLC and you need to file an eviction, you cannot handle it yourself, you would need to hire an attorney. If you own it outside of an LLC you can handle the eviction yourself.
Unfortunately, I don't know of any other structures for asset protection. LLCs are great if they are done right. Most people don't operate within them correctly though, and that's the problem.
Christopher,
I don't think it is a question of Umbrella policy or LLC. Regardless of the form of ownership you need to decide on how much coverage you are comfortable with. The LLC is a benefit if the judgement against you exceeds your coverage. Then, if properly handled, the LLC limits the assets the claimant can go after. If you have the house under an LLC with $500,000 in Liability coverage and there is a judgement against you of $1,000,000 they are going to look to the assets of the LLC for the rest. If you have an umbrella policy with a $1,000,000 limit the claim would go into that policy for the additional $500,000.
I would suggest that you also look into the ways you need to keep the LLC separated from your transactions. If there are things like co-mingling of funds the claimant may be able to pierce the veil of the LLC and go after your other assets anyway.
Quitclaiming from your name to an LLC I don't think will do anything for protection, but could compromise your title insurance, hazard insurance and open you up to DOS risk with your lender. Changing the hazard insurance notifies your mortgagee.
Since we're talking about a primary residence , you could also mess up your 121 capital gains exclusion if you sell within 3 years of making it a full rental.
Quitclaiming from your name to an LLC I don't think will do anything for protection, but could compromise your title insurance, hazard insurance and open you up to DOS risk with your lender. Changing the hazard insurance notifies your mortgagee.
Since we're talking about a primary residence , you could also mess up your 121 capital gains exclusion if you sell within 3 years of making it a full rental.
More risks than potential rewards IMO.
As long as the Grantee entity strictly meets the definition of Insured as shown in your title policy you should not impair the coverage.
As long as the Grantee entity strictly meets the definition of Insured as shown in your title policy you should not impair the coverage.
Thanks. So we should review our title policy for that. I just don't see title insurance coverage risk discussed much. Lots about due on sale, but not title or hazard insurance.
Would a quitclaim deed affect title insurance more than a warranty deed do you know? Oh excuse me- quick claim. LOL Often quoted as quick on here displaying the experience with conveyance we are dealing with
As long as the Grantee entity strictly meets the definition of Insured as shown in your title policy you should not impair the coverage.
Thanks. So we should review our title policy for that. I just don't see title insurance coverage risk discussed much. Lots about due on sale, but not title or hazard insurance.
Would a quitclaim deed affect title insurance more than a warranty deed do you know? Oh excuse me- quick claim. LOL Often quoted as quick on here displaying the experience with conveyance we are dealing with
You were correct the first time, it's called a quit claim deed and no, in my experience the type of deed doesn't matter, only that the Grantee strictly meets the policy definition. Take a look at Conditions And Stipulations 1 for the definition of Insured.
When I say strictly I mean strictly. For example, I once had a claim from a gentlemen who purchased property in his individually name. He then conveyed it, by quit claim deed, to an LLC he set up. When I reviewed the Articles of Organization and found his son was a member also. I denied the claim because Conditions & Stips 1(d)(i)(D)(1) provides the term Insured also includes a Grantee that doesn't pay value for the deed and, more importantly, the Grantee is wholly owned by the Grantor. Since the son held an interest, the LLC was not an insured under the policy. Good luck
As long as the Grantee entity strictly meets the definition of Insured as shown in your title policy you should not impair the coverage.
Thanks. So we should review our title policy for that. I just don't see title insurance coverage risk discussed much. Lots about due on sale, but not title or hazard insurance.
Would a quitclaim deed affect title insurance more than a warranty deed do you know? Oh excuse me- quick claim. LOL Often quoted as quick on here displaying the experience with conveyance we are dealing with
You were correct the first time, it's called a quit claim deed and no, in my experience the type of deed doesn't matter, only that the Grantee strictly meets the policy definition. Take a look at Conditions And Stipulations 1 for the definition of Insured.
When I say strictly I mean strictly. For example, I once had a claim from a gentlemen who purchased property in his individually name. He then conveyed it, by quit claim deed, to an LLC he set up. When I reviewed the Articles of Organization and found his son was a member also. I denied the claim because Conditions & Stips 1(d)(i)(D)(1) provides the term Insured also includes a Grantee that doesn't pay value for the deed and, more importantly, the Grantee is wholly owned by the Grantor. Since the son held an interest, the LLC was not an insured under the policy. Good luck
Ok great. So the deed type - quitclaim vs warranty doesn't matter but the vesting continuity does. Thank you👍