IRS Plans to Double in Size - What That Means for Investors

IRS Plans to Double in Size - What That Means for Investors

Joe SplitrockPro Member
Moderator
Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes

More tax news out of Washington. The administration announced doubling the size of the IRS over ten years. This reverses the trend during the last administration of reducing IRS staff and scaling back the number of audits. They are also pushing for banks to increase transaction reporting efforts. Currently banks are only required to report suspicious activity or large cash transactions, but they are hoping for more transactional detail. The end goal is to crack down on people who are evading taxes. This covers three main areas; unclaimed income, illegitimate deductions and unpaid taxes. They are also concerned that crypto is a tax evasion vehicle. 

As with all proposals, the stated aim is "high income earners", which is an attempt to placate the masses, by convincing them that they will not be affected. In reality this is likely to affect small businesses and real estate, more than any other category. Even if you think you are doing things legitimately, it doesn't mean you can't get pulled into an audit or have your business questioned. Legitimate things can appear sketchy or you could be accidentally making errors. Here are a few ways it could affect real estate investors:

1. There are countless contractors out there offering "cash discounts", which is secret code for I don't pay taxes. You may pay with cash or with a check. Often those transactions go unreported to the IRS, because the investor doesn't send a 1099 and the bank has no reporting requirement due to the amount or type of payment. When more returns are audited and more bank information is available, it is easier to identify the fraud. A landlord could get pulled into an investigation. One way landlords can protect themselves is always send a 1099 when required. Avoid ever paying cash because it is not traceable and hard to prove you actually paid the money. If you believe the contractor is asking for cash to avoid taxes, make it clear you want the transaction legitimate. A landlord may say, "not my problem", but in some circumstances the IRS can collect taxes from you or fine you if the receiving party didn't pay them. There can be an argument if a rental business is passive or active and if 1099 is required, but why fight that fight?

2. Real estate has as many or more deductions as any other business. Landlords don't always know the difference between legitimate and illegitimate deductions. It is sometimes a grey area, so people use the rationale, "how can the IRS prove it isn't legitimate?" The answer is simple. The IRS has access to every return filed from every landlord. They know what deductions are typical based on size and type of property. For example, you may be house hacking and renting out rooms. You claim your cell phone, home office deduction and 100% of your utilities. The IRS knows that is not reasonable. You can't justify needing a dedicated office for one property. You can't justify the full expense of a cell phone when tenants live down the hall. You can't expense all your utilities, when you enjoy personal use of the space. New investors get excited about "all the deductions", but forget you must have legitimate business need before you claim something. Anything you use for personal use must have expense split with personal. If you are claiming mileage or car expenses, you need to have travel logs that show miles driven and business use. Document the purpose of every expense. Remember that the expense needs to be necessary and reasonable. Hiring a tax professional to guide you is an absolute must, because software like Turbotax only tells you HOW to claim the expense, not IF you actually should. 

3. Bank reporting could be used as a way to trigger audits in the future. As a landlord, make sure your business uses separate accounts from personal. Make sure every deposit is logged, stating which tenant, which property and the purpose of the payment like "June Rent". Make sure every payment logs the business use, not only in your check book log, but in your accounting software. All expenses should have a matching receipt. Keeping good records is the best way defuse any questions in an audit. Consider sending 1099 to contractors as a way to substantiate your expenses.

4. How you claim expenses could be scrutinized too. Be aware what expenses need to be depreciated, versus expensed. Follow bonus depreciation rules. If using cost segregation, make sure you have good documentation to support your claims (work with a professional). I have seen people claim massive first year losses by accelerating depreciation. When done legally, it is fine. Just realize any tax returns with high income, heavy expenses that result in low to no tax burden may stand out. The IRS isn't interested in scrutinizing people who pay taxes, just those who don't. 

5. Be careful of edgy strategies. This could be things like excessive deductions or I have heard people claim they did a 1031 exchange after only three months of owning a property. They say that their tax professional tells them they could "defend it and win in court". I would argue a better tax strategy would avoid the need to defend yourself. If you end up in court, you have already lost. If you are working extra hard to defend what you are doing as legitimate, that is an indicator you may be pushing it too far. 

I support everyone paying their taxes, but there are countless examples of the IRS bullying legitimate businesses. Throughout history the IRS has even been weaponized for political reasons, targeting specific groups for audits. Call me paranoid, but there is a high level of "real estate loophole" frenzy and "landlord hate" going on right now. Just be careful, because as much as tax strategies can help your business, it is not worth pushing the boundary to attract unwanted attention. 

20Reply
39 views

Most Popular Reply

Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
5y
Originally posted by @Christopher Smith:
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
Joe..  just went through the Bully session and the arbitrary disallowing of write offs .. very frustrating. 


Just wondering what specific deductions / areas did they appear to target most heavily?

my travel  they wanted actual receipts of my plane tickets  from 2016.  airlines don't keep them.. and of course my credit card proved it but that was not enough.. even though I matched the credit card to hotel stays in the cities i do business and then matched that up to huds and all sorts of business contacts.. power points of presentations i made at reias around the country etc etc..

and other stuff like soft staging my wife buys for her listings..  IE  bed bath beyond.. they said was for our personal homes .. I had a business trip to London and one to Tel a viv and one to singapore all denied  .. even with supporting documents.

See this reply in the discussion

17 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Aaron ZimmermanBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y

    Very nice commentary on this. I agree with everything stated above. It's always essential to dot your i's and cross your t's when taking deductions and preparing your taxes. You don't want loose ends out there that could come back to bite you. With that being said, I support more resources for the primary revenue generating body of the United States. This should bring in some additional tax revenue and as real estate investors, we should appreciate good investments. My tax professor said a couple years back that for every dollar that's allocated to the IRS, it can bring back $4. Not a bad ROI.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    5y
    Joe..  just went through the Bully session and the arbitrary disallowing of write offs .. very frustrating. 
  • Greg H.Pro Member
    Moderator
    Broker/Flipper · Austin, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    I am shooting the messenger!  No upvote for you Joe!

  • Investor · brentwood, CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 730 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Joe..  just went through the Bully session and the arbitrary disallowing of write offs .. very frustrating. 


    Just wondering what specific deductions / areas did they appear to target most heavily?

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Christopher Smith:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Joe..  just went through the Bully session and the arbitrary disallowing of write offs .. very frustrating. 


    Just wondering what specific deductions / areas did they appear to target most heavily?

    my travel  they wanted actual receipts of my plane tickets  from 2016.  airlines don't keep them.. and of course my credit card proved it but that was not enough.. even though I matched the credit card to hotel stays in the cities i do business and then matched that up to huds and all sorts of business contacts.. power points of presentations i made at reias around the country etc etc..

    and other stuff like soft staging my wife buys for her listings..  IE  bed bath beyond.. they said was for our personal homes .. I had a business trip to London and one to Tel a viv and one to singapore all denied  .. even with supporting documents.

  • Greg O'BrienBusiness Member
    Accountant · Boston, MA · Member since 2019 · 386 posts · 336 votes
    5y

    @Jay Hinrichs unfortunately it largely depends on the actual auditor (which shouldnt be the case)

  • Greg O'BrienBusiness Member
    Accountant · Boston, MA · Member since 2019 · 386 posts · 336 votes
    5y

    @Aaron Zimmerman right but thats also been questioned by others. There are 5000 OPEN jobs in customer service at the IRS which have been sitting for months. I believe ww should focus on taxpayer service first then figure out how to close the tax gap (starting with nonfilers). I have a tough time believing the IRS can hire 70k qualified lawyers, accountants or trained pros to actually generate an ROI but who knows

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Greg O'Brien:

    @Jay Hinrichs unfortunately it largely depends on the actual auditor (which shouldnt be the case)

    no kidding this one also audited two of my employees  ruthless is how i would call it we had to appeal so we got some changes in that ..

  • Investor · Malakoff, TX · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5y

    Thanks for the info. I've seen some people recommending really stupid things. Like buying Home Depot gift cards and claiming them as deductions. But using the gift cards to buy personal use items. Like the IRS wouldn't catch that in an audit.

  • Rental Property Investor · TN · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5y

    I have been audited twice.  Neither time was I at fault for anything, but both were a painful experience.

    Once when adopting a child, during the time the child was in my home before the adoption, the board that was paid by the county/state for the child was miscategorized by the county employee as a salary for me.  Eventually a person working for the state was able to send in a correction form to the IRS to fix that problem...but it took a lot of effort on my part to work through the system to see who and how the monthly board payments could be changed from salary which is taxable to board which is not.

    The other time some folks that I never met, have no idea who they are, or anything about them, used my SSN as theirs for work they did at several chicken processing plants.  So along with my one salary from my one job, there were about a dozen different salaries paid out under my SSN and taxes were withheld.  So when I filed my taxes for the only job I held or even knew was under my SSN, they sent a form letter saying I did not claim all my W-2 income.  They figured out I could not be in all those places, and that I actually worked for the federal government and was pretty much way too far from any of the chicken jobs to work 2 jobs even, let alone a dozen.  So I did not have to do anything but sign paperwork saying what job/W-2 income I claimed and that the rest were not me.  And, well, that was already what I did when I signed my tax form...  Then I had to wait until they did what they did for the chicken jobs/company/people.  That took nearly 2 years, but eventually I did get my return processed and got my refund.  

    And now, well, this years taxes were processed, but for some reason, last years is still being done, not sure why....

    They have no sense of humor, are very slow, and even when they can see its their issue, not mine, it becomes mine...

  • Real Estate Broker · Pueblo, CO · Member since 2013 · 368 posts · 303 votes
    5y

    Great reminders. Tortoise vs the hare.  Be the tortoise.

  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Aaron Zimmerman:

    Very nice commentary on this. I agree with everything stated above. It's always essential to dot your i's and cross your t's when taking deductions and preparing your taxes. You don't want loose ends out there that could come back to bite you. With that being said, I support more resources for the primary revenue generating body of the United States. This should bring in some additional tax revenue and as real estate investors, we should appreciate good investments. My tax professor said a couple years back that for every dollar that's allocated to the IRS, it can bring back $4. Not a bad ROI.

     It will bring in extra revenue, but it is like hiring more state troopers for speed enforcement to generate ticket revenue. We all agree nobody should be speeding, but when you get pulled over for going 8 miles over as you exit a higher speed zone, it feels a little like targeting. Or when you get a parking ticket two minutes after the meter expired. 

    Audits can take months or even years. Arguing with an auditor is often a loosing proposition. If they think they found something, it is guilty until proven innocent. 

    I just don't trust that the process is fair, based on historic performance. I guess it has to be a balance. When they are short staffed, they focus on major offenders only. When they have extra staff, they will start going after smaller fish. 

  • Greg O'BrienBusiness Member
    Accountant · Boston, MA · Member since 2019 · 386 posts · 336 votes
    5y

    @Joe Splitrock well said. Training 70k to audit complex multi national passthroughs will take a decade plus. By the time they are trained theyll get a better offer in industry. Small fish are easier targets

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Greg O'Brien:

    @Joe Splitrock well said. Training 70k to audit complex multi national passthroughs will take a decade plus. By the time they are trained theyll get a better offer in industry. Small fish are easier targets

    Also I wanted to throw this in there about my audit..  I took my Vendor from London to lunch at Harrods  And that just threw her for a loop ya know tourist spot..  Also we stayed at the Marina Sands in Singapore the one with the big ship like pool on top of it  probably one of the coolest hotels in the World she no like that.. I was like we what are we suppose to go to motel 6 or something.  Its almost like you need to video tape your meetings. 

  • Daniel SmythPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Rockford, IL · Member since 2019 · 471 posts · 342 votes
    5y

    @Joe Splitrock

    Nice article!

    My last speeding ticket was at a really bad time.

    No money, layed off, late for an appointment to get a job, and just did not think I was going THAT fast! Ugh!

    After I was handed the ticket, the officer saw that I was distressed. He offered me some advice in a really nice way. He told me that if I was not speeding and zipping across traffic, that there would be no ticket.

    He was correct. Lots of people speed, but its the speeders that draw attention that get looked at.

    I don't care if you declare every earned buck to the government. I don't care if you are a non filer. But, if you commit fraud, or just go out of your way to violate laws, I can't say I care that you get caught.

    The lesson for me, was to understand the penalties for getting caught, and owning up to it when caught.

    I am not a cop lover. I am not a IRS lover.

    But, we pay these people to do a job.

    Don't get your shorts in a bunch if you get caught doing wrong on purpose.

    Regulations make good reading in the restroom at my house. Just read and let stuff sink in. Each time you read them, you will retain more.

    Or get a CPA that knows real estate investing.

  • Rental Property Investor · TN · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Daniel Smyth:

    @Joe Splitrock

    Nice article!

    My last speeding ticket was at a really bad time.

    No money, layed off, late for an appointment to get a job, and just did not think I was going THAT fast! Ugh!

    After I was handed the ticket, the officer saw that I was distressed. He offered me some advice in a really nice way. He told me that if I was not speeding and zipping across traffic, that there would be no ticket.

    He was correct. Lots of people speed, but its the speeders that draw attention that get looked at.

    I don't care if you declare every earned buck to the government. I don't care if you are a non filer. But, if you commit fraud, or just go out of your way to violate laws, I can't say I care that you get caught.

    The lesson for me, was to understand the penalties for getting caught, and owning up to it when caught.

    I am not a cop lover. I am not a IRS lover.

    But, we pay these people to do a job.

    Don't get your shorts in a bunch if you get caught doing wrong on purpose.

    Regulations make good reading in the restroom at my house. Just read and let stuff sink in. Each time you read them, you will retain more.

    Or get a CPA that knows real estate investing.

     The problem is when there are too many auditors who can not do complex cases because they are new, and they have very little knowledge of anything in life, they tend to be like a pit bull--they will not let go of what they have.  And they will get little guys, not a major case because they do not know anything yet.  They will be gone before they can get a big case, they will stay with little cases.

    So if you are like my case--where some unknown people from one company used my SSN for several people at several different locations of their plants--and I knew nothing of any of it, I am still stuck trying to prove I claimed all my W-2 income.  I had no idea what other w-2s were sent in with my SSN to the IRS.  But the little chieftain was sure I had a million dollars income I did not claim.  It literally took months before he showed me the W-2s he had with my SSN, and I showed him that they were from several locations far from me and that my name was spelt incorrectly on each one of them.  STILL, he wanted to contact the companies, etc. before he 'released' me.  Still he wanted to see all my banking accounts, credit card statements, everything to show how much money I had and spent.  TWO YEARS of this mess!

    And I did nothing, no idea how they got my SSN.  The work was in 3 states I never was in for a national company I never worked for.

    If they only 'caught' guilty people, that is fine.  But a lot of their cases are not guilty and just live in he)) for a few years playing their game.

  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Greg O'Brien:

    @Joe Splitrock well said. Training 70k to audit complex multi national passthroughs will take a decade plus. By the time they are trained theyll get a better offer in industry. Small fish are easier targets

    Also I wanted to throw this in there about my audit..  I took my Vendor from London to lunch at Harrods  And that just threw her for a loop ya know tourist spot..  Also we stayed at the Marina Sands in Singapore the one with the big ship like pool on top of it  probably one of the coolest hotels in the World she no like that.. I was like we what are we suppose to go to motel 6 or something.  Its almost like you need to video tape your meetings. 

    It seems logical to me that a large developer who has done probably thousands of transactions would stay at a higher end hotel. If you are meeting clients or vendors, you are going to go to higher end places. That beings said, if someone is house hacking and decides to take a trip to explore other markets, even a Motel 6 may seem like overkill for the scale of the business. Unfortunately this stuff is highly subjective. You get some auditor who is inexperienced or even bitter towards wealthy people and they will go after you. 

    Do you mind sharing more about the audit. How long did it take from the time you got notice? When they disallowed expenses, were you responsible just for the taxes or did the add fines on top of it? Thankfully I have not been through an audit, but I know others who have. My old boss owned a small business with around $10M annual revenue, so not huge. He was audited every couple years and I would help him with documentation to support expenses. Very stressful because the auditor approaches like an enemy. At least in his case they did. Sad thing is wealthy people pay the majority of taxes and they get treated the worst.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.