Write your tenant screening criteria down before you list the unit

Write your tenant screening criteria down before you list the unit

Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 201 posts · 75 votes

A lot of screening problems start before the first application shows up. When the criteria live in someone's head, they drift from one applicant to the next, and that's where inconsistent decisions and fair housing risk come from. Whether the owner screens or a property manager does, it's worth having the criteria written down and shared with the listing.

What a written screening policy usually covers:

  1. Income standard (for example, a rent-to-income multiple) and which income sources count, including how vouchers and other lawful income are handled under local rules.

  2. Credit: what gets reviewed, and what isn't automatically disqualifying, such as medical debt.

  3. Rental history: how far back references are verified and what counts as a negative one.

  4. Eviction and criminal history: lookback periods and an individualized review instead of blanket bans, consistent with fair housing guidance.

  5. Occupancy standard, application fee, and processing order (for example, first complete application first).

  6. How denials are communicated, including adverse action notices when a credit report was used.

Then apply it the same way to every applicant and keep the file.

This is timely in Ohio: HB 368, as introduced in the Ohio House, would require eviction records to be sealed after three years, which would change what some screening reports show.

What's on your written criteria that you wish you'd added sooner?

BJ Everson

3Reply
314 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · San Francisco · Member since 2026 · 73 posts · 36 votes
21h

This is exactly right, and the written part matters more than most landlords think. Once criteria live only in your head, every applicant conversation becomes a negotiation, and that is where inconsistent decisions and fair housing risk creep in.

My written policy covers the same buckets you listed: gross income at 3x rent, a credit floor, verified rental history with prior landlord calls, eviction and criminal lookbacks with defined time windows, occupancy limits, and the fees for application and holding. I also write down the automatic disqualifiers and the judgment calls, so I know in advance which ones are truly non-negotiable.

Two things I would add. First, write the denial reasons in the same document, so a denial letter is just filling in the blanks. Second, apply the same criteria to every applicant for the same unit, no exceptions for a good story or a referral. The policy protects you most when it is boring and consistent.

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Broker · Northeast PA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1d

    @BJ Everson absolutely spot on advice in providing a written set of screening standards and documentation needed for an applicant approval. It saves time, helps the prospect, lightens the burden on the processor, and protects the owner/manager from 'tester' HUD applicants and complaints. In other words, written criteria helps you remain compliant with the law.

    We provide every applicant a list of our written criteria and necessary documentation prior showing or application. They are also posted prominently in the office and on the website for all to see.

    Once that's done, make sure to FOLLOW YOUR WRITTEN CRITERIA during the application processing, for every single application.

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 83 votes
    1d

    One thing I'd add is a short line on how you handle reasonable accommodation requests, like an assistance animal, so the process is the same every time a request comes in. I also like keeping a dated checklist in each applicant file showing which criteria were checked and when. Happy to compare notes by message. General info only.

    Real Property Management Optimal 525 Reviews
  • Member since 2025 · 21 posts · 6 votes
    1d

    Good thread. A few items that tend to get left off written criteria:

    • How income is calculated: gross vs. net, whether roommates' incomes combine, and what counts as proof (pay stubs, offer letter, bank statements, benefits letters). This is where "case by case" sneaks back in.

    • Guarantor rules: allowed or not, and what a guarantor has to meet (often a higher income multiple).

    • Pets vs. assistance animals as separate sections, since assistance animals aren't pets under fair housing rules and pet fees don't apply to them.

    • What makes an application "complete," and when the first-come processing clock starts.

    • Application fee and holding deposit: amount, what's refundable, and how long an approved applicant has to sign.

    • A version date on the sheet, so you can show which criteria applied to which applicant.

    Then hand the approved applicant straight into the same lease-signing and move-in condition report process every time. Educational only; check your state and city rules.

    • Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 201 posts · 75 votes
      23h

      Great list!

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 621 posts · 177 votes
    23h

    The line most written criteria are missing is what happens when an applicant has no credit score at all. A thin file isn't a bad file. Plenty of solid applicants are young, new to the country, or have paid cash for years, and without a written rule that's exactly where the drift you describe creeps back in. Spell out what stands in for the score, like a qualified guarantor, verified rent payment history, or a larger deposit where local law allows it, and write down the guarantor's own income standard too.

    If your portfolio spans more than one state or city, keep a version for each market. Application fee caps, source of income protections and criminal history lookbacks differ from place to place. A policy is only as consistent as the cases it decided before the applicant showed up.

  • Investor · San Francisco · Member since 2026 · 73 posts · 36 votes
    21h

    This is exactly right, and the written part matters more than most landlords think. Once criteria live only in your head, every applicant conversation becomes a negotiation, and that is where inconsistent decisions and fair housing risk creep in.

    My written policy covers the same buckets you listed: gross income at 3x rent, a credit floor, verified rental history with prior landlord calls, eviction and criminal lookbacks with defined time windows, occupancy limits, and the fees for application and holding. I also write down the automatic disqualifiers and the judgment calls, so I know in advance which ones are truly non-negotiable.

    Two things I would add. First, write the denial reasons in the same document, so a denial letter is just filling in the blanks. Second, apply the same criteria to every applicant for the same unit, no exceptions for a good story or a referral. The policy protects you most when it is boring and consistent.

  • Michele FischerPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    21h

    This is great advice. I use a scoring system so that each application is scored to a number value and the highest number is offered the unit.

    I would emphasize that the criteria can change over time, but always between openings. Each advertised unit should follow the same process, with any tweaks or changing applying to the next opening.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    7h

    Good overall advice, but NOT the part about sharing with the listing.

    There are actually two separate issues here:

    1) What application & screening criteria to publish - needs to comply with Fair Housing

    2) What application & screening procedures to develop INTERNALLY - needs to consistently be applied to comply with Fair Housing

    EXAMPLE: Credit: what gets reviewed, and what isn't automatically disqualifying, such as medical debt.

    • Not aware of any federal or state regulations requiring this

    • Too much info for an average prospective tenant to actually understand

    • So, do NOT recommend publishing this, but it should be addressed in internal written procedures

    Comments on each item:

    1. Income standard (for example, a rent-to-income multiple) and which income sources count, including how vouchers and other lawful income are handled under local rules.

      • Nothing wrong with publishing this, but also add acceptable documentation of the income

    2. Credit: what gets reviewed, and what isn't automatically disqualifying, such as medical debt.

      • Recommend publishing only minimum credit score, require acceptable letter of explanation for any negative information

    3. Rental history: how far back references are verified and what counts as a negative one.

      • Technically, this is part of credit. Recommend publishing acceptable rental verification for last 2 landlords or last 2 year as needed.

    4. Eviction and criminal history: lookback periods and an individualized review instead of blanket bans, consistent with fair housing guidance.

      • Again, technically part of credit. We don't recommend blanket bans as they may be considered "indirect discrimination" by HUD. You can publish all evictions/convictions require acceptable written explanation and supporting documentation.

    5. Occupancy standard, application fee, and processing order (for example, first complete application first).

      • Publishing your Application Fee is a no-brainer. Pointless to publish processing order as you do NOT want to limit yourself unless required by statute - and then since it's required, why publish?

      • You do want internal written procedures to make sure any statutes are followed

    6. How denials are communicated, including adverse action notices when a credit report was used.

      • Federal statutes already dictate this, so no need to publish

      • You do want internal written procedures to make sure the statutes are followed

    NOTICE we underlined "acceptable". IMPORTANT to include this everywhere, even in emails & texts, because tenants and HUD will try to otherwise twist what they submit as acceptable to them.

  • Lauren CutchenBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · The Woodlands, TX · Member since 2019 · 244 posts · 92 votes
    4h

    @BJ Everson great list. For anyone in Texas, this is more than best practice. Texas law requires landlords to make their tenant selection criteria available in writing when someone applies, and if you don't, the applicant can get the application fee and deposit back after a denial. I'd keep it as a one-page sheet handed out with every application, so everyone gets the same thing.

  • Rental Property Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2024 · 27 posts · 14 votes
    3h

    One thing I'd add is written screening criteria and a simple record of how each complete application was scored. When two people apply for the same unit, we can pick the strongest applicant. There isn't a first come, first served rule, but the decision has to rest on those same non-discriminatory criteria, and the score sheet is what shows the choice was fair. We also send the written criteria to anyone who asks about the unit before they pay a fee. It cuts down on applications that were never going to pass, and nobody feels like they paid to get turned down.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.