Write your tenant screening criteria down before you list the unit
A lot of screening problems start before the first application shows up. When the criteria live in someone's head, they drift from one applicant to the next, and that's where inconsistent decisions and fair housing risk come from. Whether the owner screens or a property manager does, it's worth having the criteria written down and shared with the listing.
What a written screening policy usually covers:
Income standard (for example, a rent-to-income multiple) and which income sources count, including how vouchers and other lawful income are handled under local rules.
Credit: what gets reviewed, and what isn't automatically disqualifying, such as medical debt.
Rental history: how far back references are verified and what counts as a negative one.
Eviction and criminal history: lookback periods and an individualized review instead of blanket bans, consistent with fair housing guidance.
Occupancy standard, application fee, and processing order (for example, first complete application first).
How denials are communicated, including adverse action notices when a credit report was used.
Then apply it the same way to every applicant and keep the file.
This is timely in Ohio: HB 368, as introduced in the Ohio House, would require eviction records to be sealed after three years, which would change what some screening reports show.
What's on your written criteria that you wish you'd added sooner?
BJ Everson