Go property by property, and treat a percent of rent as the floor only. A percentage scales with rent, but a roof or HVAC unit fails on age, so two houses with the same rent can need very different reserves. For each big system, take its replacement cost, divide by the years it likely has left, and that's the monthly number for that system. Add a flat amount per door for the small stuff, and keep vacancy as its own line so it doesn't drain the repair money. Pool it in one account across the portfolio, since failures never arrive evenly, but track it per property so you can see which ones keep eating the reserve. Older, cheaper stock usually eats the most.
Go property by property, and treat a percent of rent as the floor only. A percentage scales with rent, but a roof or HVAC unit fails on age, so two houses with the same rent can need very different reserves. For each big system, take its replacement cost, divide by the years it likely has left, and that's the monthly number for that system. Add a flat amount per door for the small stuff, and keep vacancy as its own line so it doesn't drain the repair money. Pool it in one account across the portfolio, since failures never arrive evenly, but track it per property so you can see which ones keep eating the reserve. Older, cheaper stock usually eats the most.
You should always have a 25k-35k per property emergency fund for huge repairs. Just build it up over time and you will be happy in the long run. Expensive turn-overs, roof replacements/repairs, HVAC, siding, etc. Alternatively, you can also just obtain lines of credit and HELOC's to use as your rainy day fund. However, I always recommend a huge safety net for what if scenarios.
The REAL answer is...it depends! It depends on how deep your pockets are, and/or how much ready access you have to credit or cash over and above your personal "living" requirements. It primarily depends on the age and condition of the various elements today, based on a competent review or inspection of each element.
I recommend at least having accurate calculations for each property, and adjust your actual pool of funds according to the above factors.
I just this week released a new book available on Amazon, Nuts and Bolts Rental Management Secrets, which includes a companion resource website with a free reserve calculator and useful life tables to help determine your actual needs.
@Linda Murray I like a hybrid. Start with a percent of rent as a floor, then adjust for each house based on age and condition. Generally, I keep 5% per property unless I know there is a higher likelihood of maintenance items - you always want to get those resolved for the residents, quickly.
Age matters more than rent. A lot of our rentals here in San Antonio are new builds, and their first few years look very different from a 1970s house with an original roof and a 15-year-old AC. Down here the HVAC works hard most of the year, so on older homes I'd look at that system first.
What's worked for the owners we manage at Portfolio Management Group: keep reserves in one pooled account, track spending per property so you can spot the money pits, and keep vacancy and turnover as their own line so a slow lease-up doesn't eat the repair fund. I have a client with 8 properties and we had to swap the water heater last month, that one properties reserves would have been able to cover, but since maintenance is pooled across the multiple properties, I was able to cover it and not have to bug him (which is always my goal for my owners).
Linda, @Noah Wright and @Michael Gonzales laid it out well, and it's how I handled reserves on my long-term rentals in Orlando before I moved into mid-term and short-term. Use a percentage of rent as the floor, then adjust each property for the age and condition of the big systems. Keep the money pooled so one bad month doesn't sink a single property, but track spending per property so you can see which ones keep eating the reserve.
Linda, I like a mix of both. A percent of rent is a fine floor for routine stuff, but the big-ticket items are easier to plan per property.
A simple method for self-managers is a one-page capital list per house: roof, HVAC, water heater, appliances, flooring, and paint. For each item, note its age, a rough replacement cost from a local quote, and the years left. Cost divided by years left gives you a monthly set-aside for that item. Add those up, then add a turnover line (cleaning, paint touch-ups, a vacant month) based on how often that unit turns.
Keep it in its own savings bucket or ledger tab so it doesn't get mixed in with operating cash. Then review it once a year, or after any big repair, and adjust the numbers. Older houses will need more than a flat % suggests.
The replacement cost divided by years left math only works if you actually know the ages, and a lot of people are guessing. Water heaters and HVAC units have the manufacture date on the data plate or coded into the serial number, so one walk-through snapping photos gets you real install years.
I track reserves per property even when the cash sits pooled, and I tag every transfer with the property it belongs to so I always know whose money it is. On the books that transfer isn't an expense, the expense only hits when the HVAC or roof bill actually gets paid. I size it system by system based on age, and when a big one does go, I log it as a replacement, not a repair, so my CPA can depreciate it at year-end.
Property by property is how I'd do it too. Around north Houston I'd set aside extra for HVAC and roofs, since the AC runs hard most of the year and a lot of policies here carry a percentage wind/hail deductible. Older homes on slab need a little cushion for foundation and under-slab plumbing too. A percent of rent is a fine floor, but the age of the big systems matters more.
Hi Linda, I use the hybrid most replies here describe. I set aside an amount per unit each month for repairs, so small jobs do not come as a surprise. Then I keep a list for the big items on each house: roof, furnace, water heater, and appliances, with the age of each one noted.
That list is what keeps me from being caught short. A percent of rent is a useful floor, but it does not know whether the roof is five years old or twenty-five. When I know what is likely to need replacing in the next few years, I can build the reserve toward that, rather than guessing after a failure.
I keep the reserve in a separate account, so it does not get spent on operating costs. If I have to dip into it, I top it up before I take money out for anything.
My rule of thumb is $150/month ($1,800/year). Ultimately it comes down to the unit specifics.
I keep a 'reserve' fund similar to Daniel and try to keep it stocked with 3-4 months of annual expenses per unit.
So 10 units with annual expenses (including mtg payments) at $20k means I have approx $50k in a reserve account and I've got an $18k yearly budget for regular maintenance.
I budget 5% of the gross scheduled rent for repairs and 5% of the same for cap ex. If the property is generally lower quality, these percentages should increase.
It helps to split reserves into building-level and unit-level. Roofs, parking lots, and sewer lines get planned for the whole building, while appliances and flooring get tracked by unit. That way, a big shared repair doesn’t wipe out the money meant for turns.
I keep approximately 3 months of expenses. For my properties, I estimate 5-10% in maintenance costs per month based on the rental income. Of course, some months are higher than others.