My Tenant chopped down my tree and removed my bushes!

My Tenant chopped down my tree and removed my bushes!

Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 2 votes

I am taking over management of my property beginning July 13 - reading "The Book on Managing Rental Properties now. Current property management company has no response to my alarm upon seeing that new tenants have chopped down a (small) tree, removed established bushes in front of the porch, and removed landscaping plants in one area of the yard. Current lease only says they are responsible for lawn maintenance. What should I do? What recourse do I have?

Thanks. I'm a total beginner.

1Reply
217 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Broker · Northeast PA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
8y

May I suggest, It might be better for you, as owner, to have a landscaper put in what you want, (as close as possible to original shrubbery) and charge the tenants for the bill, assuming they were not given permission, and have in fact, damaged your property.

Do NOT let them do it themselves, and do NOT let them suggest you take it out of their security.

Either of those cases:  got to court, get judgment for damages and lost rent (if any) and get them out.

People, especially some tenants, are just plain weird.  And they say and do the darndest things.  Welcome aboard.

See this reply in the discussion

43 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 2 votes
    8y

    Met with tenants Saturday. Went over new Tenant Orientation and Rules & Regulations for my taking over management. They were very friendly, made direct eye contact, followed well, and spoke in complete sentences. When I asked about the front yard (which is now completely razed), they said the property management company gave them verbal permission to remove plants (they deny it, and the person who was in charge of that (asset management) has now left the company.

    They are 2 months into their tenancy. They seem to live paycheck-to-paycheck (they are used to paying rent via Pay Near Me). I told them I am thinking about what to do about the landscaping. It should have not been removed, and will need to be replaced in some way or another. They said they removed it to have 100% grass because they are afraid of bugs and snakes.

    So far this year, the house has had a slab leak, replaced 50% of the flooring (due to the slab leak, covered by homeowners insurance), replaced entire HVAC system (went out, it was old), a clogged laundry line drain with flooding and water damage. I am out of money, and need rental income to build cushion.

    If I had to re-list, I would have turnover/make ready costs, loss of rent, and would need to put in a sorely-lacking fence. Also, previous shoppers complained of the dated look of the paneling in this 1973 house's living room. I can't afford all this without a loan.

    Thanks for your wisdom and thoughts.

    Again, I'm in Dallas, TX. 

    Margaret Bean

  • Real Estate Broker · Windsor, CT · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 268 votes
    8y

    @Margaret Bean I would start by contacting the tenant to see what happened at the property? Also when you say lawn maintenance maybe in the future outline and be very specific as to what the tenant should be doing to maintain the lawn. I typically walk the whole property during Lease signing and discuss with the tenant any specific information about the property.  Have you had any other issues with the tenant? If not you may have to take the cost of the bushes and trees that were cut out of their deposit when they move out. I would definitely start by discussing the issue maybe you can come to a resolution with the tenant where they either pay you for the plants to have them replanted or you agree on a dollar amount that will be help from their deposit when they move out.

  • Property Manager · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2015 · 36 posts · 38 votes
    8y

    (retracted - I read OP's most recent update, and what I had to say no longer seems relevant)

  • Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 2 votes
    8y

    We did do a walk-through Saturday. Everything clean, sparse, and in order. Tenants not using oak kitchen cabinets because they're germophobic about wood(!). HVAC is only 1 month old.

    Why should they think I'm not the owner. I told them a lot about the history of the house when I was there, what things were and how they worked and why things were the way they are (e.g. grass can't grow in certain areas of the yard; thus planting beds). They know my children grew up there.

  • Rental Property Investor · Haverhill, MA · Member since 2017 · 290 posts · 185 votes
    8y

    Why did you keep the property as a rental when you moved out instead of just selling it?  What are your goals?  How much are you clearing each month?  How much equity is in the property?  Answers to these questions will enable you to determine if it’s even a viable rental property.

  • Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 2 votes
    8y

    @Dick Stevens - I'm not questioning whether to keep the house or not. It has done very well for me over many years; this year, however, has been a nightmare.

  • Aurora, CO · Member since 2018 · 180 posts · 166 votes
    8y

    I'd treat this much like you would if someone painted a bedroom chartruse, they have to repaint to your satisfaction or lose deposit. Paycheck to paycheck, they can't afford to pay you for a landscaper, nor does it sound like you need additional bills.  

    As a gardener-a-holic and former landscaper, grass is cheap.  Watering it isn't.  If they have scraped clean the yard, have them heavily seed it, at THEIR expense, and water.  Under no circumstances should you suppliment the water.  If you're in Dallas, I probably wouldn't try this until fall.    IF they don't want bushes, then I wouldn't force them to put them in now.  I'd wait and deduct the  cost of the shrubs from their deposit. You can do the same with the tree, but you can't really estimate "value based on age".  All you can do is get a replace ement cost. 

    Not using wood cabinets due to wood....I'm a little concerned about this group.  Why did they rent your place if they didn't like the landscaping, or kitchen?   


    I think if you are now the PM, and you keep them, you need to do weekly drive bys and monthly inspections of interior.  Who knows what else they will decide to rip out for fear of a germ?  The rule of thumb when installing landscaping is that it should be 10% of the value of the house.  They need to understand what they have done financially.  

  • Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
    8y

    My advice is to sell. The first quoted sentence is key.  Counting on tenants to pay their rent in order to make your payments is not a good plan. 

    Earlier I think you say the property is paid off.  And above you say "It has done very well for me over many years; this year, however, has been a nightmare."  Yeah, you've had a bunch of stuff go wrong at once, but sounds like its been hanging in there for a while.  Cash reserves are key to surviving this business.  I've had years where I collected rent and had nothing but taxes and insurance for expenses.  I've had other years where a sewer line had to be replaced for $6000.  I had a tenant move out and the estimate was $7000 in make ready costs.  But that was after seven years with no vacancy so its $83 a month.  You knew the AC was old, so replacing it should have been a planned expense.  The plumbing issue and flooring was unexpected, but that sort of thing happens, too, and you did have insurance coverage.

    Honestly I think you're out of luck on the landscaping.  They're going to insist the PM told them it was OK.  A judge might side with them.  Focus on getting them to do something so you don't have a yard full of mud.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    8y

    @Jon Holdman  YUP undercapitalized landlords are were about half the foreclosures in the US come from.

    I agree with you  if money is this tight this is a small business with out the proper capitalization for long term success sell cash out regroup and build stronger reserves and maybe owning a rental is not the wisest investment.

  • Realtor and Investor · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    This is such a frustrating topic, isn't it?  As Landlords, we want our Tenants to care for the property as though it is their own, but when they make owner decisions as a non-decision maker, it is bad news.

    Your lease language should include verbiage about obtaining permission from you before making any changes.  Cutting down trees and removing bushes are included in that.  I had a Tenant remove a mature lemon tree from my property because she didn't like picking up the lemons anymore.  WHAT?!  I couldn't believe it!

    Your PM should be able to back you up on this one.  If not, it is a good thing you are firing them.  If the PM can't enforce rules that are established in the lease language, then they aren't doing what you are paying them for.  It shouldn't be YOU that is bringing to THEIR attention any violations.

  • Rental Property Investor · OK · Member since 2015 · 316 posts · 216 votes
    8y

    The next time I hear "I want to buy nice homes in good areas so I can get quality tenants," I'll direct them to this thread.  There's always a headache lurking somewhere.  

  • Realtor · Dallas - Fort Worth Metroplex, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 925 votes
    8y
    @Margaret. What’s the update ? We are all here to support you in your journey.
  • Investor · Utica, NY · Member since 2016 · 24 posts · 26 votes
    8y
    The best thing to do is call two landscape company find out how much it will cost for you to replace the tree and what ever else they did. Sue them for it using the lessor quote. You win and may not win, maintenance of the lawn can be broad to some they can say the tree or bushes was dying etc..., you may even find it best to kick them out if you don’t like the tenant or try to work something out with personally or just let it go. Also think of the cost to get them out, empty apartment, the stress of court vs the cost of replacing the tree or maybe you might want to leave the place with out the trees and keep collecting your rent. When it’s time for them to keep the deposit for the tress.
  • Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 2 votes
    8y

    Thank you, everyone. Update, and reviews:

    1. I'm in Dallas (Duncanville).

    2. House is paid for, and has rented very successfully in the past.

    3. I could raise funds, but it would be borrowing from other accounts, and not a good financial decision.

    4. Fired previous PMs as they did a bad job over the past year (read previous posts if you want details).

    5. I'm not asking if I should sell the house or not.

    6. Would appreciate the name of a good landlord/tenant lawyer in the area, if anyone knows of one.

    7. I'm in the process of looking for landscapers to give me a couple quotes for simple landscaping, so house has some curb appeal for future leasing.

    8. I'm planning on charging tenants for landscaping. Will probably need to give them time to pay over several months - payment plan.

    9. Taking it out of their deposit wouldn't cover landscaping; anyway, it may be needed for home repairs caused by them.

    Thank you for your support and advice - even the harsh comments I learn from. I'm not offended. As I said, I'm new at this. I want to learn - and if I help others learn, so much the better.

    I would like to pass my plan past a lawyer, if I knew one. I understand I have to keep the original lease, but I had tenants sign a "Rules and Regulations" addendum last Saturday.

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 745 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Margaret Bean:

    Just read that an eviction can cost around $5,000.

     shouldnt cost you that much.  You can do it yourself.

    Be careful though, I hear (although have not experienced it personally_) that its nearly impossible to evict unless they are behind on rent,  "if" your lease states that damage is paid first, then they would be late on their rent if they dont pay for the tree damage.

    Remember, the judge, if it goes to court will be an elected official.  So they wont be overly landlord friendly.  Just have your ducks in a row.

  • Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 2 votes
    8y

    Thanks, Bart. Getting estimates on re-doing just the front yard landscaping (around $3,000). I'm planning on having tenants pay it in installments, due with rent. Will send notification to that effect in a "lease violation" letter when I decide on a company. Hopefully, they will be able to afford it, and all will be well, and they won't touch anything else (they had sprayed everything with glyphosate, and even severely trimmed back the 2 huge live oak trees in the front yard). If they complain that they got permission from the previous management company, I will suggest they try going after them - though they didn't get anything in writing.

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Chicago Suburbs, IL · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 594 votes
    8y

    We had a tenant who did that. For some reason he they thought they were dead. Ended up charging them for it out of the security deposit.

  • Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 2 votes
    8y

    Bids for simple re-landscaping coming in at twice the cost of deposit. Plus deposit is for move-out, right?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.