Covid times: Section 8 tanant missed their portion of rent

Covid times: Section 8 tanant missed their portion of rent

Member since 2018 · 43 posts · 15 votes

I have one property that being rented out to section 8. This march i noticed that they missed their portion of the rent and I got charged with their utility bill.

I contacted my PM in regards to these concerns

1. PM told me that I “don’t have a ton of legal standing”since most of the rent has been paid (paid by section 8) and only a small portion is outstanding (which is the tenants portion of the rent)

I am not sure why I don’t have a ton of legal standing... from what i’ve read, I am still owed the tenant portion of the rent and late fees.

Am i missing something or changed because of covid?

I am not sure if i can start the eviction process due to covid,

But I don’t want to get played by professional renters. What can I do other than working with my PM to follow up on the rents?

(I might be giving the wrong impression that I am heartless, i do believe in helping people and i do that through charity not through my business.)

As far as the unexpected utility bill

As it turned out they never switch the utility bill under their name. (This what i was told by the PM; which is weird because they’ve been paying their utilities since they moved in October up until 12/31.)

I shouldn’t be liable for their utility bill as far as i am concerned because it was rented out as the tenant should be responsible for their utilities.

I believe that they owe me for the utility bill that was deducted from my account (through the property management).

What to do here if the tenants won’t transfer it to their name? Is it legal for me to not pay it and they would lose their utility service?

Or the property management company should be responsible for the bill since it’s their responsibility to make sure that the utilities were switched to the tenants name?

I Appreciate your thoughts and advice in this matter.

1Reply
57 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · St. Louis, MO · Member since 2014 · 741 posts · 424 votes
5y

@Tim Siocheng They are in breach of their lease agreement, like anyone else, and would loose their voucher if you wanted to press the point. Work with them to catch up. One never wants to evict, work with them. Covid has hit hard but stimulus checks have been mailed from Washington. Ask for it. Yes, bill back the utilities and have them take over the account, if that is what the lease agreement says. We don't give keys to our tenants until they tell us their account numbers, as a verification system.

See this reply in the discussion

16 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    5y

    I haven’t rented to section 8 but can you contact a section 8 “case worker” or agent, or whatever they’re called? Certainly you are owed full rent. HOPEFULLY your pm meant you didn’t have a reason to evict during covid and simply misspoke when they said you didn’t have legal standing. 

    I’ve heard they can lose their section 8 voucher if they don’t carry their portion. 

    How did the utilities get in to the PM’s name? When my properties are vacant they revert back to my name automatically and I pay them. The new tenants aren’t given keys until the PM confirms the utilities have been transferred to their name. But they are never in the PM’s name. 

    It might be time to shop a couple other PMs in your area. Tell her what happened and ask how A) they would prevent it from happening, and B) if it happened how they would solve it. 

  • Deland, FL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y

    $100 to a real estate Atty is very well spent in my opinion. 

    Life is too short to get myself all worked up about things like this like I used to 

    You are already using a PM so you are already delegating some of the hassles 

  • Rental Property Investor · St. Louis, MO · Member since 2014 · 741 posts · 424 votes
    5y

    @Tim Siocheng They are in breach of their lease agreement, like anyone else, and would loose their voucher if you wanted to press the point. Work with them to catch up. One never wants to evict, work with them. Covid has hit hard but stimulus checks have been mailed from Washington. Ask for it. Yes, bill back the utilities and have them take over the account, if that is what the lease agreement says. We don't give keys to our tenants until they tell us their account numbers, as a verification system.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Michael Plante:

    $100 to a real estate Atty is very well spent in my opinion. 

    Life is too short to get myself all worked up about things like this like I used to 

    You are already using a PM so you are already delegating some of the hassles

    what attorney will talk to you for 100.00  ?   LOL

  • Investor · Toledo, OH · Member since 2017 · 24 posts · 5 votes
    5y

    @Tim Siocheng this issue is totally not yours it is the management company. You pay them to manage your property they failed to make sure the bills were transferred to the tenant. They should had called the utility company gave them a date to transfer or turn off.

    You can contact sec8 let them know your tenant is not in compliance they could possibly loose their voucher. I had a similar problem but the tenant decided to pay up or loose out.

    You can start the eviction process because rent was not paid in its entirety per rental agreement.

    Hope this helps.

    Sounds like you need a new management company.

  • Deland, FL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Michael Plante:

    $100 to a real estate Atty is very well spent in my opinion. 

    Life is too short to get myself all worked up about things like this like I used to 

    You are already using a PM so you are already delegating some of the hassles

    what attorney will talk to you for 100.00  ?   LOL

    Dana Anderson Eustis FL 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Michael Plante:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Michael Plante:

    $100 to a real estate Atty is very well spent in my opinion. 

    Life is too short to get myself all worked up about things like this like I used to 

    You are already using a PM so you are already delegating some of the hassles

    what attorney will talk to you for 100.00  ?   LOL

    Dana Anderson Eustis FL 

    thanks I happen to have a matter that is located in Deland will touch base on Monday with them.. out this way attorney is 300 to 500 an hour with a one hour minimum

  • Deland, FL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Michael Plante:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Michael Plante:

    $100 to a real estate Atty is very well spent in my opinion. 

    Life is too short to get myself all worked up about things like this like I used to 

    You are already using a PM so you are already delegating some of the hassles

    what attorney will talk to you for 100.00  ?   LOL

    Dana Anderson Eustis FL 

    thanks I happen to have a matter that is located in Deland will touch base on Monday with them.. out this way attorney is 300 to 500 an hour with a one hour minimum

    I’m in Deland
    happy to help however I can   I have too much free time on my hands 

    send me a message if you like 

  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    5y

    If the utilities are not tied to the unit (ie if they go unpaid, it follows the tenant); let the PM know the tenant needs to switch it to their name and you are having it moved out of your name.  I'd also talk to their case worker.  how much money are we talking about for their portion?  If it is a small amount, are they not getting money through the govt (assuming the tenant lost their job or their hours were cut).  Losing their job or losing hours are the two reasons they can claim not to be able to pay rent, but if they are still working their regular hours...they need to pay.

  • Broker · DeLand, FL · Member since 2017 · 19 posts · 6 votes
    5y

    It is possible the PM was saying that filing an eviction is not the most financially smart thing to do at this moment. For example, if the portion tenant owes is $100 and an eviction costs $400 to file (uncontested) and $1000 or more (contested), and could take a month or more, it may make more sense to work with them on a payment plan to catch up. Also, the COVID moratorium is still in place, which means a tenant can halt the eviction by filing a one page form with the court claiming they had a loss of income due to COVID. Many tenants are not aware of this, but it is a possibility (I just completed an eviction in DeLand and luckily tenant did not try this defense).

    As far as utilities, yes the PM should have verified all accounts were switched prior to giving keys. That is our policy. But, if the tenant was allowed to move into the property with the utilities already on in the owners name, it is against Florida law to turn them off. You are entitled to recover the amount owed, but again this requires legal action if deposit does not cover what is owed.

    I always try to avoid eviction if at all possible. Any the majority of the time we can get a tenant back on track. If not, having an agreement with the tenant to voluntarily vacate by X date to avoid eviction, then recouping as much as possible from security deposits is often the cheapest and fastest solution.  Landlords (and I own 17 in DeLand, so I include myself) often want to pursue a money judgement against tenants for what is owed, and I understand that. But a judgement against a section 8 tenant is most likely worthless, as they wouldn’t be on section 8 if they had adequate income or assets to go after. The court/attorney fees will most likely be unrecoverable.

  • Member since 2018 · 43 posts · 15 votes
    5y

    I appreciate everyone’s input and I am taking notes as I communicate with my PM in handling this matter.

    @ Bill Brandt:

    After digging around I finally able to get a copy of the bill, and it shows that the bill is under my name, not the PM.

    *I’m going to have to talk to the PM because it shows that she’s not on top of things here.

    But I am still not out of the woods since why is the bill under my name when it should be under the tenants name.

    @ Kathy Henley

    I agree, I don’t want to evict unless I don’t have a choice. I’ll also check with the PM on what their protocol is in regards to utilities accounts before handing the keys. I expected that this is standard operating procedure for them as they manage a lot of properties. Thank you

    @ Cynthia G.

    I’ll look it up if I can use this to bypass the eviction moratorium. I will try and work with the tenant but definitely if they continue not paying then I will opt for the eviction.

    @ Theresa Harris

    Their portion is $215. I don’t know if they have lose their job or hours cut, but between unemployment and stimulus checks they should have some money to pay their rent and utilities.

    Overall It would cost me a lot of money to evict them but it will cost me more if they stay. But during these covid times I don’t know if I can start the eviction process.

    I highly appreciate all the advice and my plan A is work with the tenant and transfer the utilities to their name; especially April is coming up, I’ll keep an eye on their portion if they pay or not. Plan B call the section 8 case worker and start the eviction process if Plan A doesn’t work. To be honest though that I have a bad feeling that they will not act on this very quickly.

    @solomon greene

    Thanks for the tip,

    Hopefully the tenant doesn’t know neither about contesting the eviction.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    5y

    Couple of things to check on before jumping to conclusions:

    UTILITIES: you stated the tenants were paying them until recently. So, has the bill always been in your name and the tenants paying it or was it recently just switched to your name because the tenants STOPPED paying it?

    EVICTION: ask your PMC what the state and local laws are. States and courts all seem to be intrepreting the CDC moratorium differently, so you can't assume anything other then you can't physically remove tenants due to nonpayment of rent.

    SECTION 8: your PMC should be complaining to the S8 caseworker, who should put pressure on the tennat to pay their portion of the rent and utilities or possibly lose their voucher. We use the word SHOULD because many caseworkers are over-worked and under-paid and often fail to perform this.

    If rentals ran perfectly, there'd be much lower returns corresponding to that lower risk.

    Do you know who really makes money in real estate? Problem solvers!

    So, go figure out how to work with your PMC to solve this problem, instead of jumping to assumptions:)

  • Rental Property Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2018 · 229 posts · 279 votes
    5y

    I have a portfolio of Section 8 rentals.  Here's what I (or maybe in your case, your PM, up to you) would do.

    Contact the tenant to inquire about happened.

    If their income has changed, they can & should contact their caseworker to submit new income docs.  Section 8 may (in my experience, they almost always will) change their rent portion.  They might even back date it depending on when the income change happened.

    If it didn't change, let the tenant know that my process is to file for eviction when 30 days late. Then I'd say - I don't want to do that and I don't want to put your voucher at risk (if they get evicted and as long as you notify the caseworker/Housing Authority, they should lose their voucher until you're paid).  So what's your plan to pay?  I suspect this will get them to pay.

    As long as they have a plan, it's short time-wise and they stick to it, I wouldn't notify the caseworker.

    I would enforce whatever late fees are in my lease.

    If they say they can't or won't pay, send a statement by email to tenant and caseworker ASAP and let them know I plan to send to the attorney for eviction on XXX date.  I would request a response/receipt from caseworker and would email or call daily until I get one (politely, of course).

    As for utilities, notify the tenant that these utilities should have been in their name from day 1, and I will be billing the utility charges to them (as long as that's what the lease says).  Add the utilities to the tenant ledger, send copies of the statements to the tenants and caseworker.

    Finally, if a tenant leaves a subsidized unit still owing $ to the landlord, they shouldn't be able to move elsewhere until they've paid the landlord in full.  But this requires communication to the caseworker/Housing Authority on the landlords part.

    I find good Section 8 tenants pay their portion religiously because they value that voucher.  Almost all of my tenants pay a portion of their rent and I don't have trouble collecting.  But I make clear from move in that the lease will be enforced, including payment policy, late fees and evictions.  

  • Member since 2018 · 43 posts · 15 votes
    5y

    @Jennifer Donley

    @Drew Sygit

    I appreciate your inputs and I am willing to workout with the tenants if they would communicate with the PM.

    The current status: the PM made several attempts to contact the tenants but so far there are no response. The PM will give them couple days to respond, then they’ll start talking to the case worker. So far this where i am at. I am very hopeful that the tenants will do their part and this will be resolved quickly. But until then we’ll refer to section 8 and get into the eviction process.

    As far as the utility bill, the PM worked with the utility company and they were able to straighten out the situation. The bill was added to the tenant and I should get reimbursed for the utility bill in april. According to the property management they’ll handle the money and cover the expenses if needed.

    So now I’m just left with the tenants that needs to oay their portion.

  • Member since 2018 · 43 posts · 15 votes
    5y

    @Jennifer Donley

    I appreciate all the information, i will certainly put this in my notes. This is my first section 8 and as you can tell i’m not getting a very good experience.

    I understand that you have a lot of section 8 experience, do you mind if i message you privately if i have more questions about section 8?

    Thank you for your help.

  • Rental Property Investor · Centreville, VA · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 799 votes
    5y

    If they are not paying rent, you should be taking the action listed in your lease. Also, your PM should be on top of this. They should be the 1st ones to track if the tenant is paying or not and they should follow up with a NOTICE to the tenant. 

    If the tenant is not paying citing COVID reasons, they have to document it in this form below. You are eligible to get rent assistance if the tenant qualifies. 

    https://www.cdc.gov/coronaviru...

    Utilities are always tricky. My tenant never transferred the utilities under their name even after they promised to do so so its always best practice to hand the keys after the utilities are switched to the tenant's name. In this case, you can certainly ask the tenant to pay you the utilities since they should be paying that in the 1st place per your lease. If it gets worse, you can always deduct that from the security deposit. Again, your PM should be doing all this. You can tell them you won't be paying them the PM fees for this month since they messed up twice. I would even find a new PM because these are elementary mistakes and PMs should know better. 

    Good luck!! Real estate investing is all about solving problems so treat this another hurdle and push through. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.