Eviction News Update - finally some Good News

Eviction News Update - finally some Good News

Investor · Member since 2021 · 265 posts · 305 votes

Oops, my mistake. I thought they were going to give Landlords a break . . . Instead of easing the Eviction Moratorium to help Landlords, Instead of Providing Landlords with financial assistance, WA State and soon others, are going to Provide Free Legal Service to tenants to Fight the Landlords when evictions start up again.  

Washington state lawmakers push to provide lawyers for residents facing eviction

A bill up for final approval by the Washington state Senate aims to provide attorneys for some low-income residents facing eviction, which would make it the first state to enact such a measure.

text, qr code: Washington state lawmakers push to provide lawyers for residents facing eviction

© Getty Images Washington state lawmakers push to provide lawyers for residents facing eviction

The bill, a draft of which was initially passed in the state Senate and was approved with amendments by the House on Thursday, would provide lawyers for tenants who meet certain qualifying conditions.

Those eligible to receive legal representation from the state include residents receiving certain public assistance, individuals who have been committed to a mental health facility, those who can't afford an attorney or those who have incomes at 125 percent or below the federal poverty level, according to The Seattle Times.

Jim Bamberger, director of the state's Office of Civil Legal Aid, praised the legislation, telling the Times that it "is a powerful statement on the part of the legislature in terms of balancing power in the justice system between tenants and landlords."

"And I think it will work, honestly, in favor of both," he added.

However, an amendment added to the bill Thursday night has prompted concern from housing advocates, as it would end Washington state's eviction moratorium on June 30, the same day the federal order halting the practice amid the pandemic is set to expire.

Bamberger told the Times that if passed, the bill would require his office to hire 58 additional state attorneys, which he said may not be logistically possible in less than three months.

However, some state lawmakers have pointed out that the amendment would temporarily require the state to provide rental assistance directly to a person's landlord if a program qualified tenant does not have access to a lawyer starting July 1.

"The argument that the day the moratorium ends people are going to be on the street is just false," state Rep. Andrew Barkis (R) told the Times. "It takes months to go through the eviction process."

"We believe there will be plenty of time for these things to get set up," he added.

Bamberger noted that the legal representation program will likely cost his office an estimated $11.4 million in the first year.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) announced late last month, three days before the existing federal eviction moratorium was set to expire, that it would be extending the temporary ban on coronavirus-related evictions through the end of June.

CDC Director Rochelle Walensky said in a statement at the time, "The COVID-19 pandemic has presented a historic threat to the nation's public health. Keeping people in their homes and out of crowded or congregate settings - like homeless shelters - by preventing evictions is a key step in helping to stop the spread of COVID-19."

However, concerns have erupted in recent days after a new guidance issued by a Texas judicial advisory panel gave the green light for state courts to openly defy the CDC moratorium, putting hundreds of thousands of Texans at risk of being removed from their homes.

0Reply
166 views

Most Popular Reply

Jerry W.Pro Member
Moderator
Investor · Thermopolis, WY · Member since 2012 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
5y

@Eric Weldon-Schilling, your statement is wrong on so many levels that it is scary. Please read Atlas Shrugged, which was written by a woman who was forced to grow up in communism and escaped. If landlords cannot evict for failure to pay rent, how long before that housing falls apart? No money to paint, replace flooring, replace broken windows, fix roof leaks, broken toilets, repair electrical issues? If car companies could collect payments for selling cars or repair costs, how long would it be before they quit making cars and parts? If grocery stores could not stop shoplifters from taking all the food they want and not pay, how long until grocery stores quit selling groceries? If medical institutions could not collect for delivering babies, doing surgery, or even just seeing sick kids, in a few years people would quit being doctors and nurses. Imagine a world where kids die from the flu, ear infections, or where kidney stones, bad gall bladders and appendicitis are death penalties? If you don't pay people for the fruits of their labor they quit working. No one will ever buy a run down house and fix it up to rent if tenants don't have to pay rent. Would you allow someone to move into your house free of charge and live there forever? Would you allow people to take your vehicle and leave you with no way to go to work because you seem rich to them? How about eat your food if they are hungrier than you? How long will power plants run if no one pays for electricity? I could go on forever.

See this reply in the discussion

59 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    @Greg M. i have been a LL for years and own 6.5M in RE 
    i do however understand what it is like to live in a property owned by a slumlord or bully LL with no education. 

  • Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y

    "It should be an equal playing field. If the landlord has a lawyer the renter should be provided one."

    -----------------------------------------------------------

    The landlord has to pay for his lawyer, so who is "providing" the lawyer to the tenant?

    Also, you overlook the fact that legal aid societies help tenants, as do law school legal clinics.

    Finally, you overlook the cases -- legion -- where the tenant simply refuses to pay anything simply because he cannot be evicted.

    We may pass over in silence the fact that government partial payment programs require the landlords to release the unpaid portion of the rent. The economic model of rentals doesn't work that way.

  • Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    "Ended up raising his rent $75 at renewal and let him know that $72 was my increase in costs."
    ---------------------------------------
    Sounds like you squeezed your own return on investment. Are rental prices in your area that keenly set?

  • Member since 2020 · 671 posts · 937 votes
    5y

    @Mary M.

    That's sweet of you.

  • Handyman · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    5y

    It seems as if we keep shouting past each other about this. On the one side of this you have landlords crying for justice, justice under the law and on the other side of this you have tenants crying for mercy and equality under the law.

    I personally believe the US Constitution is largely a sham, patriotism is often the last refuge of scoundrels, and there is no fairness in this broken world except between parties of equal power: the normal order of things is that the strong do whatever they want and the weak suffer whatever they must. I did not always feel this way but I learned better.

    So I would advise all parties to stop pretending justice is blind and to stop looking to the law to save you except as an institution to be manipulated if you have enough money, influence, or votes in your pocket to do it. Call it cynicism or realism, take your pick.

    On a practical basis, I am a small landlord in C-class. In my world, if you need the threat of immediate legal eviction to keep your tenants paying rent you've screwed up somewhere along the line. You didn't play your cards right. Your business model sucks. I have yet to lose Dime One in rent on this pandemic. My tenants know that I'm one of the best deals in this town, and to be perfectly honest it doesn't take much to be one of the best deals in this town. The industry as a whole in Pittsburgh is rife with incompetence, naked greed, bloated overleveraged expansion, shortsightedness, and drooling stupidity.

    -----

    There's an old joke about two guys walking through the jungle. They hear a roar of a nearby tiger. One immediately drops and opens his backpack, takes out a pair of light running shoes, and tosses his backpack away. The other laughs and asks him scornfully: "What, do you think you can outrun the tiger?"

    "I don't have to outrun the tighter. I just have to outrun you."

    -----

    So lace 'em up, kids.

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @John Clark:
    "Ended up raising his rent $75 at renewal and let him know that $72 was my increase in costs."
    ---------------------------------------
    Sounds like you squeezed your own return on investment. Are rental prices in your area that keenly set?

    Overall, a great tenant so I kept rent increases to a minimum. I raised the unit $300 when he left and had it rented with zero days vacant. 

  • Member since 2019 · 2 posts · 3 votes
    5y

    I have three tenants in one house.  One rent is paid by the state and she is the best tenant.  Another is/was self employed with a great business watching dogs as their people commute.  No commuting, her business shut down.  I worked with her as she received PPP, unemployment bonusus (her and her husband), stimulus checks, etc.  She did apply for rent relief but last I heard the application was incomplete.  She had all of these programs but I still lost three months rent.  Luckily she moved out.

    The third tenant is a dirtbag.  I have texts saying how hard he was working, three jobs, etc.  Then one day we have words and he stops paying rent, period.  Finally get a court date for a pre-trial hearing and he gets a free lawyer.  He sends a picture of his unemployment benefits, turns out he was working off the books.  Immediately its delayed until May.  He did not file for rent relief, he did not file the CDC hardship form.  So all in, I'm out about $20k.

    How is that fair?  Why is the burden on the landlord?  Where is my rent relief package?  

  • Investor · Millburn, NJ · Member since 2018 · 141 posts · 100 votes
    5y

    @Eric Weldon-Schilling

    Hmm. My TX property costs me 4K a year in taxes and the monthly rent is nowhere close to 4K.

    If you truly want to own, save each month to have some down payment, most people can afford to own in TX.

  • Rental Property Investor · Henrico, VA · Member since 2019 · 265 posts · 155 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Joe Splitrock:

    Zillow was sending emails to tenants during the pandemic advising them of their right to not pay rent. Seriously, you pay to list your property with ZIllow, they collect email addresses of renters and then tell them they don't need to pay you!


    Seriously?  I wasnt aware of that. Do you know if they send it to only those that use the rental manager portion (who become tenants) or to anybody that responded to an inquiry when the property was listed (but with no subsequent interaction once the advertisement is taken down)?  I have used two accounts for this type of reason to see the types of communications sent to both Landlord and Tenant, but either missed this or maybe failed to with this site.  I was annoyed with many other sites that will turn around and advertise to the tenants trying to get them to move on to their next place soon after establishing interaction (the business model seems to clearly include increasing the volume of transactions).

  • Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Mary M.:

    150/month is a very slim margin and one large expense will wipe out any profit - possibly for many years.....  there is the maxim that we all should have one years worth of expenses (or income) set aside as reserves....  but at 100-150/mo that is not much of a cushion...  a new HVAC system and that money is gone So yeah, its a risky model...  however, it is how many folks get into investing and ultimately and hopefully they provide safe, clean and affordable housing for folks.....

    Also, fed tax rate increases as ones income increases....  so lots of folks pay less than 30%....  

    @Account Closedhopefully you will pick up enough info on this site so that you will be able to buy a place in the near future. 

    Part of the issue is the various definitions of cash flow. Some use rent - P&I. Others use rent - PITI. My preference is rent - all expected expenses over the long term. So my cash flow numbers includes PITI, maintenance/cap ex allocation, vacancy, PM, misc. I therefore like the 50% rule and believe it to be slightly conservative in my high rent market.

    Now to provide some numbers assuming the 50% rule...

    $2K rent - $1K (50% rule) would imply the P&I is less than $850 to have $150/month cash flow. ($200K at 3%, 100% LTV, 30 year is $843 (so a 1% property using the 50% rule at 100% LTV makes $7/month) or $250K at 3%, 80% LTV, 30 year is $843).

    $1K rent - $500 (50% rule) would imply P&I is less than $350/month to have $150/month cash flow.

    I question what percentage of financed low unit count units (excluding commercial MF) actually have better than $150/month cash flow using the 50% rule???  My expectation is that it is not a high percentage.  To put the numbers to impact from tenant not paying, one month of non payment would consume 6.6 months of cash flow at $150/month for the $1K unit and twice that for the $2K unit.  

    The cash flow, when properly allocating for all expenses, is not great per unit.  In my market most newbie RE investors start with negative cash flow as reflected by the 50% rule.  I recognize that cash flow is not the only way to make money from RE, but it is the way that is easiest to pay the bills.

    I do believe that all LL should have had a reserve that could bridge at least 1 year.  However, I do not believe it is right to have the government force the use of the reserves due to no eviction policies that many non-impacted tenants took advantage of.  I state this even though I am on record as stating that I would cover any/all of my tenants for at least 1 year that truly could not pay rent due to impact from Covid (so I did not need an eviction moratorium to not evict tenants that were truly impacted by COVID (not including those taking advantage of the situation with little or no impact)).

    Eric, research the 50% rule and learn the true expenses of having small unit count rentals. RE buy n hold renting can be great, but 1) it is not passive, it requires work 2) the cash flow is much less than most tenants (and many inexperienced LLs) believe. 3) the risks are significant. They include tenants trashing units, accidents (natural and caused by people: I had 2 units off market for a year due to a tenant caused fire, I have had a branch take out a unit, I have had hurricanes take out 2 units twice within a year (Gulf Shores, Alabama)), tenants not paying rent (squatting), and, the new ones, the government not allowing evictions or the government not allowing me to rent units (we had 2 STRs that we were banned from renting for ~4 months in 2020). Note most investment properties are purchased at 80% LTV or 75% LTV. The owner has a lot of capital invested in the RE. I like how you present yourself (you state your opinion but do not take great offense when it is not shared by many on this site), but it sometimes reflects some naïvety. Like many things in life, enlightenment comes when you understand the others' perspective (works both ways). I hope you have success as an RE investor.

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    @Account Closed  You say "Hell I’d gladly pay a 30% income tax if we had universal health care, a fund for rental/ mortgage assistance and universal college."   that wouldn't be 30% it would more likely be 70% , go to a couple European countries that have some of those programs. That said no matter what % you take of 0 it is still 0.   And why should the people who didn't go to college pay for those who did?? (yes I went to college and PAID for it). You value what you pay for.  You decide if it is a worthwhile investment. 

    As for providing free lawyers for non-paying tenants the only ones who win in court are the lawyers.  Even a public defender for criminal  defense there is often some charge at least in MA, so free for eviction seems unbalanced. There are alot of sources for tenant lawyers that are already free, I can think of bigger gaps more worthy of public support then non-payers. And this is public support not government support which many don't seem to understand. It is coming out of your pocket, your childrens pocket and your grandchildren's pockets. 

    @Jerry W. that is such a good book!

  • Ronald RohdePro Member
    Attorney · Dallas, TX · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Ronald Rohde:

    Crazy out there. Invest in Texas where we can evict in 30 days!

    WA state even is limiting commercial evictions. Makes no sense to me.

    I had not heard that. Thanks for the update. I love TX. My rentals there perform well. Tenants know there are consequences if they don't take rent seriously.

    That is absolutely true. When you de-couple punishment from bad behavior, people will exploit and push the limits everytime.

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles · Member since 2018 · 844 posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Colleen F.:

    @Account Closed  You say "Hell I’d gladly pay a 30% income tax if we had universal health care, a fund for rental/ mortgage assistance and universal college."   that wouldn't be 30% it would more likely be 70% , go to a couple European countries that have some of those programs. That said no matter what % you take of 0 it is still 0.   And why should the people who didn't go to college pay for those who did?? (yes I went to college and PAID for it). You value what you pay for.  You decide if it is a worthwhile investment. 

    As for providing free lawyers for non-paying tenants the only ones who win in court are the lawyers.  Even a public defender for criminal  defense there is often some charge at least in MA, so free for eviction seems unbalanced. There are alot of sources for tenant lawyers that are already free, I can think of bigger gaps more worthy of public support then non-payers. And this is public support not government support which many don't seem to understand. It is coming out of your pocket, your childrens pocket and your grandchildren's pockets. 

    @Jerry W. that is such a good book!

    Some of the developments in WA are troubling. It's pretty bad when you think to yourself, I'm glad my properties are in Los Angeles, not Seattle...not that this isn't a preview of what might happen here also. It's truly getting out of hand. You should see some of the strong troubling movements toward Marxism we are seeing in many college kids these days also. I also remember seeing those late night marches in gentrified Seattle areas...demanding the new owners give the properties back to those who were driven out. But I guess this is the type of logic that is drives their behavior and leads to their current situations.

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    @Tony Kim  Its unfortunate, Seattle is a symptom.  There are two groups backing this, a social activist usually college educated group with strong socialist ideas and a group of people who have grown up in a subsidy environment where the people doing well are drug dealers/system gamers.  The former group thinks they are lifting up the later group by proposing all these social programs.   And both groups think some government is funding this, not them. I don't know the answer but I think all these programs do separate people from experiencing the problem for real like when money doesn't come in the door because someone is not paying you rent or when the roof over your head is gone because you didn't apply for jobs. 

    @Mary M.  those uneducated LL like my father got there first real taste of government stupidity when they saw what it took to get non-paying tenants out of his home in NJ so he could support his own family.  So yes, some small LL don't know the law because they can't believe that the government can deprive them of their property for months and months and they can't believe people will just decide to not pay. They expect the laws should make some sense.  So while they should know consider why they don't.   Yes there are bad actors on both sides but really is the grocery store forced to give you groceries without paying?   Why is housing so different?  

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    @Colleen F. Not sure where folks are getting the idea that I support bad tenants - I do not. However, I am very cognizant of the power imbalances and how many times good tenants get evicted for the "crime" of living in an old building that needs updating....  And, usually tenants are without financial means to fight in court so I have no issue with tenants unions and organizations helping tenants, 

    Also, being ignorant of the law is no defense - and I know all too well that sometimes the older generation wants to do things their won  way which can be costly for them sadly. 

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    5y

    You bet there’s a huge power Imbalance. Tenants get free lawyers, are held to a lower legal standard, are not threatened with fines, and get the benefit of the doubt “every” time. 

    You never hear the tenant is facing triple damages, or missed a deadline or filled out the wrong form so they lose  I assume a landlord could get in trouble for lying to a tenant, how about other way around? The check is in the mail, I don’t know why the check bounced, it’s an emotional support animal, I didn’t flush that down the drain, i’m the only one living here. People love to toss around slumlord or big evil landlord  last I herd 90% of landlords own 3 or less properties? Try calling these tenants deadbeats or thieves or whatever the equivalent of slumlord is.

    I’ve been lucky enough that over a dozen properties and 20+ years I’ve only been “screwed” a few times. Always by the tenants I treated the best. (Christmas presents for children of down and out tenants or accepting late/reduced rent to help them through a problem.) only to be rewarded with a month or two of “the check is in the mail” or “2 gangs broke in while I was at work and smashed all the granite countertops.” Or “your house is flooded, the tub overflowed so we’ve moved out.”

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    @Mary M.  I think you missed the point we are talking about  state provided lawyers for eviction and primarily at this point it is for  non-payment. Not tenant organizations it's the state representing one private party against  another private party in a contract dispute. Even you admit,  when you mentioned  about older generations  wanting to do things their own way (primarily no pay, no stay) that the law will favor tenants  (because it will be costly for these LL)  so  you are basically saying when push comes to shove the imbalance IS in favor of the tenant.  The tenant has the power and they should of course be able to stay more months free while the courts hire lawyers and catch up with these cases. 

    I get your point on slumlords but how many times do  good tenants actually get evicted for the "crime" of living in an old building that needs updating (a legally uninhabitable building)?  That is not an eviction issue when I have seen it, it is a staying issue. Then the tenants may be disadvantaged  because they don't complain about essential habitability issues to keep their housing.  

    Should Seattle be hiring lawyers to defend people  against eviction who have been living without paying  for months and months against people who may have difficulty to afford lawyers themselves since they have had their savings stripped by the process of housing these tenants so long and taking them to court.  I am glad I am not in Seattle. 

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    @Account Closed  Good for you !  so let me get this right you'll pay 30 % of 0 which is zero.......   so you and other people can have health care and go to college and maybe graduate with a useless english/history degree while a welder, construction worker, or plumber pays for 4 years of your partying.  See your point now and you are only worried about todays generation .... 

    As for throwing people on the street, the profit is many peoples income,  that is what people are railing about and many could move in with family but choose  not to , or maybe you can put them up. 

  • Buy and Hold Investor · Commack, NY · Member since 2008 · 358 posts · 33 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Mary M.:

    @Account Closed I am owed rent by a tenant so I understand the frustration. Tenants DO have something to lose - having an eviction on your record makes renting very challenging. 

    There are funds available to pay back rent - as long as the tenant is still in the property - you can get 80% of back rent paid by the feds,  You might look into this. 

    Unfortunately for me I cant access those funds as my non paying tenant moved out. So I am **** out of luck sadly.  Still, I know that some people are having to make hard decisions - and hopefully you, as the LL can do your part by applying for the rental fund.....

    And, fwiw I agree that a profit of 150/mo is slim and is not enough to help a LL weather a storm like this unless they have a years worth of reserves set aside....  also  mortgages can be put on hold so you would not need to pay your mortgage payments (they will just geg put at the back) which should help.... good luck I hope you get your rent funds. 

    How do landlords apply for the government rental fund?  Is this state specific?  If so, I'm asking specifically for Missouri. TIA

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    @Dawn Vought  google can be a great resource.....   maybe start there or call your local housing authority?

    https://kcrar.com/324-million-made-available-for-missouri-landlord-and-tenant-assistance/#:~:text=Missouri%20Governor%20Mike%20Parson%20recently,for%20past%20due%20rent%20payments.

  • Buy and Hold Investor · Commack, NY · Member since 2008 · 358 posts · 33 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Mary M.:

    @Dawn Vought  google can be a great resource.....   maybe start there or call your local housing authority?

    https://kcrar.com/324-million-made-available-for-missouri-landlord-and-tenant-assistance/#:~:text=Missouri%20Governor%20Mike%20Parson%20recently,for%20past%20due%20rent%20payments.

    Thanks.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.