New to Real Estate · Northeast USA · Member since 2021 · 17 posts · 7 votes
Hello, Single STR owner/operator newbie. My wife & I own and operate one STR in the Finger Lakes area of upstate NY. Purchased in 2021, went live January 2022, and we are pleasantly pleased, and blessed with how good the the investment is performing to date.
We are starting to look forward to 2023 and currently planning for the next STR. I am starting to research these 4 areas as my next STR market. Poconos PA, Finger Lakes Region NY, (something on the lakes or with a great lake view), Windham NY, & Niagara Falls NY. I'm fairly familiar with the Finger Lakes region so I feel as though I have a good grasp of the seasonality and profitability in this area. I don't know a ton about the other markets aside from them being vacation destination.
I know the Pocono's and Niagara require STR permits. I've pulled offline the Niagara permit application. I assume the Poconos will be similar. Seems like most states copy each other on the usual requirements and the fee's don't appear too bad to push me away from these markets.
I'm hoping to network with anyone in the BP family that is already operating in these areas, knows about the permitting process's, seasonality of these specific markets, Pro's & Con's, and any additional general knowledge you'd be willing to share.
Also I saw you're looking at the Poconos region. Let me know if you need an agent recommendation. I've met a couple through clients and can share their names if it's helpful.
Also I saw you're looking at the Poconos region. Let me know if you need an agent recommendation. I've met a couple through clients and can share their names if it's helpful.
We LOVE the Finger Lakes and I have considered this as an STR market, as well. Where is yours located?
Lyndsay,
Are you in any of the 4 markets I'm looking at? Any pro's or Conn's if you are?
Hey Jay!! Our STRs are in TN and we had one in Gulf Shores, AL that we just sold for a 1031x and we are now buying in FL (under contract) and TX I believe. Our TN property went live in April and is doing well. The Gulf Shores property was crushing it! YTD gross was $67k when we sold end of July and I had purchased it for $475k with 10% down. I sold because we didn't like the lack of control w/ HOA, potential for assessments, hurricanes, etc. Plus I wanted to sell that one to turn it into two.
I like the idea of NY because it doesn't seem so saturated. We personally love the Finger Lakes region and part of our strategy is buying in places that we would enjoy long term. I have a lot of clients that buy in PA. I am not as familiar with the market but there are interesting forum posts on here about some of the challenges. But it's always what you make of it!
We LOVE the Finger Lakes and I have considered this as an STR market, as well. Where is yours located?
Lyndsay,
Are you in any of the 4 markets I'm looking at? Any pro's or Conn's if you are?
Hey Jay!! Our STRs are in TN and we had one in Gulf Shores, AL that we just sold for a 1031x and we are now buying in FL (under contract) and TX I believe. Our TN property went live in April and is doing well. The Gulf Shores property was crushing it! YTD gross was $67k when we sold end of July and I had purchased it for $475k with 10% down. I sold because we didn't like the lack of control w/ HOA, potential for assessments, hurricanes, etc. Plus I wanted to sell that one to turn it into two.
I like the idea of NY because it doesn't seem so saturated. We personally love the Finger Lakes region and part of our strategy is buying in places that we would enjoy long term. I have a lot of clients that buy in PA. I am not as familiar with the market but there are interesting forum posts on here about some of the challenges. But it's always what you make of it!
Congrats on your sale and 1031 exchange to FL and TX.
TX and TN are both on our list someday once we get rolling. My wife and my plan is to one day have STR's in places we want to vacation and then drop our W2 and move to each in the slow seasons for each market.
Is your TN in the Gatlinburg area? Hot market but pricing is really high. Just wondering.
@Jason Bozek Did you use a STR savvy Realtor? If so, can I have their name? We are eyeing one in that area. Thx!
Unfortunately we did not have an STR savvy Realtor. He was a great guy, but I was the one sending him all the houses I wanted to view and he just lined them up. I'm hoping to find a Realtor this time that has a good understanding of the STR market they are in.
If you have an STR in the Finger Lakes region and it's doing well and you have a good understanding of the area, why not stick to that area and purchase another property. Plus, you'll have the contacts like cleaner/handyman etc. I read a few negative posts relating to the Poconos on BP but some say they're doing well. I have an STR in Niagara Falls and it does pretty well especially based on the purchase price. Niagara Falls does require a permit and license. Recently, they also restricted the areas where STRs can operate. Luckily, I got in before that restriction so my property is grandfathered in, but if I lose my permit/license...I'd be in trouble. I don't know the exact areas where they allow it but I think it's closer to the downtown area where a lot of houses are blighted and neighborhoods aren't the greatest. I've noticed many guests mention not feeling safe in properties in those areas.
If you have an STR in the Finger Lakes region and it's doing well and you have a good understanding of the area, why not stick to that area and purchase another property. Plus, you'll have the contacts like cleaner/handyman etc. I read a few negative posts relating to the Poconos on BP but some say they're doing well. I have an STR in Niagara Falls and it does pretty well especially based on the purchase price. Niagara Falls does require a permit and license. Recently, they also restricted the areas where STRs can operate. Luckily, I got in before that restriction so my property is grandfathered in, but if I lose my permit/license...I'd be in trouble. I don't know the exact areas where they allow it but I think it's closer to the downtown area where a lot of houses are blighted and neighborhoods aren't the greatest. I've noticed many guests mention not feeling safe in properties in those areas.
Thank you Andrew for the comment an d info regarding the Niagara area. I have read reviews of active listings and seen several note the guests feeling uneasy and unsafe at some listings. Definitely something I will consider if I choose that area. Glad to hear your listing is doing well. The properties are cheap and the tourism is extremely high thus why I am doing some research of the area. As far as not staying in my area. If the right deal comes around, I fully plan on staying around the Finger Lakes area. I would like to use the Vacation home loan again so to meet one of the criteria's I need to be 50 miles away which puts me more to the western side of the lakes area, and I feel like I will loose some seasonality because there is only one ski resort to the west. Currently I feel like I benefit from the 3 ski resorts near me in my winter months and get the full benefits of the lakes in the warmer months. Plus I believe Ithaca has now implemented permits and restrictions within the city limits. Thank you again for your comments and info. Like I mentioned, I'm just starting my search and due diligence for property #2 which I hope to have under contract Mid Summer 2023