New to Real Estate · Muskegon MI · Member since 2024 · 7 posts · 3 votes
Hello BP members, this next post is strictly out of curiosity and I hope it doesn't rustle any feathers. I currently do not own or invest in any STR's in Midwest Michigan. My question is, is there anyone who does invest & operate STR's in these "rural" areas of Michigan (North Muskegon, Whitehall, New Era, Shelby, Hart, Ludington, etc).
I am very familiar with these areas and hope someone can speak to:
1. The challenges of investing in this market (occupancy, legalities, management, etc)
2. The pros or wins of investing in this market.
If you also own LTR's or MTR's in these areas, I'd be interested to hear about your experiences as well.
Seasonality will be your biggest challenge. You need to make enough money to pay the bills through the winter. Price can also get high the closer you get to the lakefront or any of the well known inland lakes.
I've heard a few podcast episodes with hosts from Michigan and the township patchwork creates another layer of bureaucratic headaches. Not uncommon for a township board to outlaw STRs, or cap them at a limit that conveniently grandfathers the STR properties already owned by the board members while leaving no room for anyone else. This podcast episode has a lawyer from Michigan that covers all of that, I'd recommend reaching out to her for a consultation if you are serious about it:
As Jon mentioned seasonality will be a challenge but also overall supply and demand. You are outside of a traditional tourist hot spot so you'll really want to try to measure and understand the demand numbers to the area and what the supply looks like. This is the precursor to occupancy and ADR when you have a specific property in mind. Good luck!