Real Estate Broker · Austin, TX · Member since 2022 · 30 posts · 24 votes
Curious how other investors sequence diligence on short-term rental purchases.
I work with a lot of buyers who start at revenue (comps, ADR, occupancy) and only later dig into whether the property can actually operate the way they intend. Sometimes that still works. Sometimes they find out the hard way that seller history, HOA/condo docs, or jurisdiction details change the whole thesis.
My bias is to confirm the use-case path earlier—public rules and private restrictions—before spending too much emotional energy on the pro forma. Revenue still matters. I just do not want it in first position if the operating right is unclear.
How are you handling this in your market?
• Rules/jurisdiction first?
• HOA docs before offer?
• Comfortable underwriting off seller operating history?
Genuinely interested in what's working for people outside my area too.
HOAs are a non-starter for me. There is almost no legal or democratic process that can help you. Exception would be a building that is mostly owned by other STR owners, although even then you aren't 100% safe, and you are competing with a bunch of other units that look exactly the same. Would have to be an A+ location (beach or mountainside, view, walkable etc) where a SFH is nonexistent or too expensive to cash flow.
City/County regulations can also be dealbreakers. If there is a process with a clear yes/no set of qualifications that's fine. If it is subject to the whims of a government employee then no.
So yes, I start with rules, then move to revenue. I also find that the revenue to price needs to be higher with smaller units because so many expenses are the same whether you are 1 or 5 bedroom.
I represent a lot of buyers in my area, so I already know where is and is not legal here. If I were exploring a new area, I would start rules first then revenue, I would not want to waste time if its not legal.
Curious how other investors sequence diligence on short-term rental purchases.
I work with a lot of buyers who start at revenue (comps, ADR, occupancy) and only later dig into whether the property can actually operate the way they intend. Sometimes that still works. Sometimes they find out the hard way that seller history, HOA/condo docs, or jurisdiction details change the whole thesis.
My bias is to confirm the use-case path earlier—public rules and private restrictions—before spending too much emotional energy on the pro forma. Revenue still matters. I just do not want it in first position if the operating right is unclear.
How are you handling this in your market?
• Rules/jurisdiction first?
• HOA docs before offer?
• Comfortable underwriting off seller operating history?
Genuinely interested in what's working for people outside my area too.
@Erika Albert, I'm with you on checking the use first. From working with property owners and investors, one thing I've learned is that I would not rely too heavily on the seller's STR history by itself. I would want to know whether any permit or license stays with the property, whether it has to be renewed under the new owner, and whether an HOA or local rule could change what the buyer is allowed to do after closing.
I usually think of it in this order: first, can I legally operate the property the way I want to, second, will that right still be there after I buy it, and then third, do the revenue numbers work. That keeps me from spending too much time on a deal that may never work the way it was underwritten. I'd be glad to stay connected too. I like the way you're looking at the deal from the use side before getting too attached to the revenue. Since you're in Texas, I'd still have local counsel confirm anything specific to the property or local STR rules.
Revenue can make a deal look great on paper, but if the property can't legally operate the way you're underwriting it, the rest of the analysis doesn't matter much. I'd want to understand both the public side — zoning, STR regulations, licensing, occupancy limits, etc. — and the private side,
especially HOA or condo restrictions, before leaning too heavily on seller history.
My wife Melinda and I are building REInMakers around this exact idea: verify the property-specific facts early, then evaluate the opportunity with clearer eyes.
Seller operating history is useful, but I’d treat it as evidence of past performance, not proof of future operating rights.
Same order as you, and I'd add that I sequence by what's cheap and fast to check, because the point is to kill the bad ones before you've spent money or time on them.
Before I write an offer, three things, all free. Zoning for the parcel, pulled by parcel ID off the property appraiser, not by the mailing address. Whether the jurisdiction registers or permits STRs at all, and whether there's a cap, a waitlist or a lottery. And whether an existing permit actually transfers on sale. That last one catches people. A nonconforming or grandfathered use can die at closing and the seller is often genuinely unaware.
On HOA docs before offer, I'd like to but usually can't get the full set until after contract. So rather than fight for them early, I write the contract so the document review is the exit. In Florida the resale contract has to either acknowledge you already received the declaration, articles, bylaws, rules and recent financials, or give you a window to cancel after you receive them (718.503). Plenty of buyers sign the acknowledgment without having read a page of it.
When you do get them, read the board minutes and not just the declaration. The declaration tells you today's rule. The minutes tell you what the board is arguing about. A rental restriction that's been on the agenda twice isn't recorded yet but it's coming. Worth looking at the reserve position for the same reason, because an association under funding pressure tends to look harder at rental activity.
Seller operating history I'll underwrite off, but I adjust it down and I ask for the payout export rather than a dashboard screenshot. Things that quietly inflate it: discounted launch pricing to build up reviews, cleaning fees sitting inside the gross, owner-blocked dates making occupancy look better than it was. The bigger issue is that the reviews don't come with the unit. You're buying the property, not the listing, and you relaunch from zero. That's the exact situation where AirDNA and Rabbu run most optimistic.
Last one, and it's the thing that most changed how I do this. Underwrite the downside where nightly goes away. Most people assume the fallback is a long-term tenant. Not always. Myrtle Beach adopted a short-term rental conversion overlay in December 2024, ordinance 2024-69, that blocks converting buildings of more than two units between Kings Highway and the ocean over to long-term use. Single-family and duplexes are exempt and owners with existing long-term licenses were grandfathered if they keep them current. The specifics don't matter outside Myrtle Beach. The principle does: the fallback can be legislated away too.
Confirm any of that with the city yourself, including what I've just written. That ordinance already had exceptions added once and it may have moved again since.