I just closed escrow for our first short term vacation rental property. Should I set up an LLC or do I just operate as a Sole Proprietorships? Need your expert advise please. Thank you.
@Lindley Garcia, it's a good question and one that is often asked. Ken and Michael are spot on as it really depends on your business model and your risk/value matrix and should be vetting out by your attorney/CPA.
In general however, you are usually fine with no LLC and good insurance ($1-$2Million in liability protection if possible) with a single property.
If you have a mortgage, I’m not sure you’d be able to transfer title without bank approval. Check your loan documents to see if there is a provision for “permissible transfers” and simply call the bank to confirm.
Most large banks don't allow you to transfer title to LLC for conventional loan - it will trigger forced pay off for the whole loan. Call the bank directly and ask.
Make sure to get enough liability insurance no matter if held in LLC or not.
@Jon Crosby when you say good insurance, what does that mean. I have one rental property back in WV which used to be my primary residence until I moved to WA state. The only insurance I’ve on that property is landlord policy from State Farm that covers property.
@Manmath D. and @Beau Pearson Yes, I'm referring to a liability umbrella policy to reach the $1-$2M. I use Foremost insurance for my STR policies. I have a $1M with them plus standard home owners coverage and then I use Evolve for booking and payments and they add an additional $1M in coverage.
Thank you to all your responses. I consulted a CPA and Lawyer today and both said for single property, i dont need an LLC at this time but to purchase a good liability insurance. I currently have 1M coverage + the regular home insurance. Should I get additional unbrella insurance? Thanks
@Beau Pearson you can increase base liability coverage up to $1 million and then usually if you need more than that, you would need to add an umbrella policy.
@Manmath D. Property coverage is only one part of a good policy. I’m an insurance agent and in my professional opinion having the correct amount of liability coverage on your policy is more important than the correct amount of property coverage.
I don't think there's a right or wrong way to answer this question. I think the question you need to ask yourself is what is your exit strategy , what is your hold time and how are you planning to keep the asset protected meaning in an LLC for anonymity, multiple owners, do you plan on getting umbrella policy ?things such as that
I just closed escrow for our first short term vacation rental property. Should I set up an LLC or do I just operate as a Sole Proprietorships? Need your expert advise please. Thank you.
I think the most important Q is: do you have a lot of other assets you need to protect? If something awful happens in your rental & you got sued big-time, an LLC would protect your personal assets (personal home, 401k, etc). If you don't have personal assets that need protecting, then you may not care about having an LLC
Whether you decide to or not make get like 1 million liability on the property and a 2 million umbrella policy. Even your lawyer will tell you llc’s are not guaranteed. Especially if you dip into the funds for personal reasons. Talk to your lawyer and tell him your goals. If your goal is to buy 5+ unit commercial props or a bunch maybe the way to go.
Regular umbrella may not extend to business activity. Some people tend to be naive here. Easier and maybe cheaper to get additional coverage from your policy, such as upping to 2 million
Thank you to all your responses. I consulted a CPA and Lawyer today and both said for single property, i dont need an LLC at this time but to purchase a good liability insurance. I currently have 1M coverage + the regular home insurance. Should I get additional unbrella insurance? Thanks
I agree with @Ken Latchers. This isn't a question for forums. Only a [hopefully investor-friendly] accountant or entity specialist should answer this if you want a solid answer. Every situation is different and they are the only ones who can advise appropriately for your situation.
It is scary how readily newbies ask questions fraught with peril and how quickly some questionables here spoon out simplistic, one size fits all answers.
Do they even know what country/state/judiciary the questioner is in??
I agree with @Ken Latchers. This isn't a question for forums. Only a [hopefully investor-friendly] accountant or entity specialist should answer this if you want a solid answer. Every situation is different and they are the only ones who can advise appropriately for your situation.
@Michael Baum. Talk to your tax guy. I have talked to many many investors and tax people and they say just get umbrella insurance. Your LLC doesn't protect ****. It just makes tax time more expensive. LLC is only important if you have another partner. This sets clear guidelines of what gets what. (Day you bought with a girlfriend or buddy)
Umbrella insurance protects you in great ways. Talk to your tax guy/gal and consult an attorney and I am confident they will reaffirm what I shared above
I use Proper Insurance to cover my vacation rental. It is designed specifically for vacation rentals and it cover anything that can happen. It includes 40k revenue coverage due to it being out of service as well as covering guests when they are off property.
It has 1m with 2m umbrella.
If you are using plain landlord insurance or just an umbrella on top of standard, you are undercovered IMHO.
We are lakefront so I have coverage for that (including dock insurance even though we don't have one). It is very comprehensive but expensive.
Also, don't rely on AirBNB/VRBO/HomeAway/Evolve coverage. It rarely pays out. Too many stories from other owners about it. I am not saying try, but be prepared for them to deny and leave you hanging.