Investor · Wynantskill, NY · Member since 2013 · 180 posts · 77 votes
I own a 3 bed/2 bath condo in Myrtle Beach and I’m using it as a vacation rental and it is doing very well. The unit next to me has recently gone on the market and it is laid out exactly the same and priced similarly to mine. I obviously know the positives of mine but what are your thoughts of owning 2 pretty identical units side by side?
Why not? You know what works there, easy for you, easy for everyone; in that kind of market it makes sense. Also, if you wanted you could even create a listing with the side-by-side condos and larger groups could book them together. I know my family's loved having options like that on ski trips.
In a market like yours I think it would be a good thing. It will make it more convenient for you cleaners and other vendors. Others may disagree and argue the "eggs in one basket" approach, and they won't be wrong. It might not be the best idea in a metro market, but in a VR market like this I'd probably go for it in your shoes.
Why not? You know what works there, easy for you, easy for everyone; in that kind of market it makes sense. Also, if you wanted you could even create a listing with the side-by-side condos and larger groups could book them together. I know my family's loved having options like that on ski trips.
Good: You could create some management efficiencies. You've also done the research already and know the numbers first-hand. Bad: Less diversity in your portfolio. If something goes wrong, such as a major hurricane or special assessment from the condo, you get hit double.
As others have mentioned, as long as the demand is strong (which it seems like it is), I wouldn't hesitate. You know pretty much exactly how it will perform.
I own a 3 bed/2 bath condo in Myrtle Beach and I’m using it as a vacation rental and it is doing very well. The unit next to me has recently gone on the market and it is laid out exactly the same and priced similarly to mine. I obviously know the positives of mine but what are your thoughts of owning 2 pretty identical units side by side?
100% you should do this. For two reasons:
1) because of the synergies: you already have a cleaning crew, handyman, you know how to furnish these units, you know how much to charge, you know how to market them, etc. If something works once, scale up and duplicate. Easy money
2) because you can use the three in one technique: you can list each unit separately and then you can create a third listing that includes both units combined. That way, as Julie said, larger groups will stumble upon your combined listing, whereas smaller groups will Book the listings individually, I would jump on this in a heartbeat!
@Avery Carl the eggs in one basket has been mentioned and is a slight concern but I definitely saw the same positives you mentioned. Thanks for your feedback.
How much are the HOA fees? Im assuming if you bought the second unit, you would have to pay two sets of HOA fees. Seeing as the numbers work out with your first unit, I guess its not the end of the world, but condo HOAs annoy me. Especially if they decide to not allow STRs in the future.
We have this in the Keys. Three separate four bedroom rentals, a eight bedroom side by side, or 12 bedroom tic tac toe. The only negative is that when you get the really big groups they can be more destructive. The main positive is that we are able to offer the number of beds/baths "essentially" under one roof.