@John Underwood has the correct answer as usual. The ONLY way to know what your house, in your area, against your competition will actually do is to run your own numbers from doing your own comps taken from their sites.
Sorry, I know most people nowadays want an easy and quick online tool, and there are a few, but none of them will be a substitute for doing your own research.....!
AirDNA is a great platform for that but I generally take the average rate and multiply it by 15x, if that number covers all the PITI and operating costs I will think about it. You have to consider 50% vacancy for this type of rental product.
Best way to estimate income is to manually check properties on Vrbo and Airbnb to see what similar comps are getting per night and estimate occupancy based in these calendars.
If you have a true vacation rental in a good area you should be able to get better than 80% occupancy if you self manage.
I look at the rates of local motels. They are my competition. I ran off everyone else that tried to do an STR in this town. Some people don't think I'm very friendly. I don't care what other people think.
@John Underwood has the correct answer as usual. The ONLY way to know what your house, in your area, against your competition will actually do is to run your own numbers from doing your own comps taken from their sites.
Sorry, I know most people nowadays want an easy and quick online tool, and there are a few, but none of them will be a substitute for doing your own research.....!
@Shane R Williamson use Airdna and Rabbu. You don't need to manually check rates and occupancy for every single listing on Airbnb, that's what these tools do for you. What you should do is study the top-producing rentals in the area to see what separates them. Do they have a killer location? What amenities do they offer? What do the reviews say they're missing? How can you be different without breaking the bank?
Do you have an agent in the area you are looking to invest that has helped others do what you are trying to do? They should be able to help point you in the right direction and give you a good idea if the income estimate from Airdna/rabbu are accurate for their market. Sometimes I have found those estimates to be very high.