Much more important topics to discuss in my opinion. I get disgusted each time two non-relevant (in my opinion) topics get brought up in elections. One is gay rights or gay marriage and the other is abortion. What the heck does that have to do with how one person runs the country over another?!?!?
Just my opinion though.
Why do people have such a problem with this issue?
I have looked at peoples arguments over the years, and this is what I have observed.
We need to protect the sanctity of marriage? A young couple marrying for the first time has a lifetime divorce risk factor of 40% using current trends. 31% of your friends, aged 35 to 54, who are married, engaged, or cohabitation have already been previously divorced. (as per Dr. Scott M. Stanley)
This goes against what our Founding Fathers intended? I was taught by my first government teacher that the *Declaration of Independence stated:
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness.
Then my parents took me to Washington D.C to read it myself. So I can confirm that this phrase above is accurate.
Well, you do have the "endowed by their Creator" line to base a religious argument, but I also believe that women and those of African descent were excluded from this in 1776. So I am not clear as to where this argument leads and/or can be validated.
Religious Issue? If you are basing your judgment on the bible, then you might as well fight to ban inter-racial marriages as well. (Reference Genesis, Ezra, Deuteronomy, Acts and Leviticus.
It will be a drain on our economy with these folks having access to health care, ect. It might actually save money. Since the gay lifestyle makes it difficult to reproduce, will that not save on the medical expense of having those 2.3 babies that an average American couple has? Would it be a safe assumption that less Maternity leave would be taken? Would that not lead to more production in the workplace with less time off?
I would probably save this argument for the immigration issue?
Bottom line:
It does not matter if I agree with the lifestyle or not. I do not see how this has any negative impact on my life as an American. If two people want to live a happy life together, then so be it.
I was raised in the Midwest, went to a Christian school, still go to church, and tend to be a Conservative. However, I do not feel it is the Governments role to stop a couple from being together and enjoying the rights and freedoms that America provides.
We have so many other issues that we need to fight for, and this just seems like a waste of resources that could be used for much more important issues.
I am not sure if this is politically correct to say, as it is confusing anymore, but I have seen that when gay couples move into a neighborhood, property values tend to go up. Seems that this would be good for a struggling real estate market!
Here's a newsflash! Gays already have the same right to marriage as everyone else. The definition if marriage is the union of one man and one woman. Gay men are free to marry one woman and gay women are free to marry one man.
If they don't want to be married (to one member of the opposite sex), then they are free to shack up in any combination that they like: two men; two women; three men and a parrot - I couldn't care less!
Isn't it amazing how the liberal left are always trumpeting the "will of the people" until the results are not to their liking?
Maybe we should be protesting the election of Obama or the magical votes now appearing in the MN Senate race.
BTW, this whole mess exists because government stuck its nose into the issue of marriage so they could tax it through licenses and then give tax benefits in the interest of promoting "family".
This is all just so silly. Marriage is a religious covenant, government should get their nose out of it all the way around.
Now, the issue of whether the government should "recognize" any kind of union is a whole different question.
Having said all of that, I have a question to those who oppose gay "marriage" ... What does it take away from you if they are allowed to marry?
Now, to those supporting it ... Other than the "feel good" position of having society recognize your "marriage" what does this do for you?
The reality is all of the issues raised in favor of "gay marriage", save two, are easily addressed through contract law and good estate planning. The two that aren't addressed that way are related to the emotional aspect of calling a union a "marriage" and taxation related to a marriage.
On the taxation side, the biggest one is in estate taxation and inheritance. Get the government out of the redistribution of wealth upon death, and the taxation issues go away.
Some wise person said: Marriage is a religious covenant, government should get their nose out of it all the way around.
That's the answer. All this "gay" nonsense is nothing more than an effort by the wacko Godless left to destroy religion and faith in our country.
I've always found it ironic that gays walk around touting their sexual preference while normal people don't go around talking constantly about their sex lives. Additionally, normally people don't dress up in freaky costumes and parade around chanting rhymes about their sexuality.
"Having said all of that, I have a question to those who oppose gay "marriage" ... What does it take away from you if they are allowed to marry?"
It does not take anything away from me personally, however, the problem I have specifically is the legal ramifications. Similar laws like this have passed in other states and have created a legal nightmare. A gay women went to her Doctor to get invitro so her and her lover could have a baby. The doctor told her she could not do it because of her religious beliefs, but her associate in the very same office would be more than happy to. The gay couple proceeded to sue this doctor for discrimination and WON the case. That to me is disgraceful and all the law really does is manufacter the possibilities for some in the gay community to file what I believe to be frivolous lawsuites. This is only one of many cases that have actually happened. This is my concern and although it does not affect me personally, it does in a way because it potentially negatively affects innocent individuals, religious organizations and non-profits.
Here is a link to back up what I have stated:
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=91486191
And any gay person who wants to get "married" come talk to me first. Let me explain what happens in a divorce.
I don't get it. Gay folks have it made! You get the sex you want, no kids, dual income household, you're both either from venus or mars, maybe less drama and you want to screw that up with marriage?!? What's the matter with you?
Funny you mention that Tim. That is exactly the conversation I had with a friend of mine.
We bet there are many in the gay community who are outraged that the rest want to make "marriage" possible.
They are thinking, "sorry honey, the state says we can't get married, I would if I could" and in the back of the mind is thinking, "great, I don't have to give my partner 1/2 in case it doesnt work out"
I've been hearing news reports of angry protests out side of and vandalism to churches as well as racial slurs being slung at african americans (brought out by Obama's campaigning efforts) who voted overwhelmingly against gay marriage.
Huh.... Aren't these people the same ones who keep preaching "tolerance"?
That's just plain wrong! Since gay marriage is so new in the US, there are no meaningful divorce statistics. However, there are meaningful statistics elsewhere. Here are some statistics from Sweden:
"The survey revealed a high rate of legal divorce among homosexual couples in Sweden. Gay male couples were 50% more likely to divorce within an eight-year period than were heterosexuals; and lesbian couples were 167% more likely to divorce than heterosexual couples."
Here's the reference: http://www.narth.com/docs/sweden.html
Funny you mention that Tim. That is exactly the conversation I had with a friend of mine.
We bet there are many in the gay community who are outraged that the rest want to make "marriage" possible.
They are thinking, "sorry honey, the state says we can't get married, I would if I could" and in the back of the mind is thinking, "great, I don't have to give my partner 1/2 in case it doesnt work out"
What partner gets 1/2 ?
It wouldn't surprise me a bit if the courts overturn a public vote.
Separation of church and state suggests that the gays should receive all the same rights as married people through the STATE. Perhaps via a civil union.
Therefore, members subscribing to any religion; whether based in Christianity, Catholicism, or a strong believe in Santa Clause, can determine whether or not same sex marriage fits into their belief systems and religious practices, without touching state given rights.
Unfortunately separation of church and state has become a convergence of church and state, and as a result we have people who believe in Santa Clause, based on books that were not even written by Santa Clause, but by men, as a means to control the populace, starting wars and controlling rights that are independent of religion.
Until we can get back to separation of church and state, I suggest banning religion, keeping spirituality, and letting the gays have all the same rights as heteros.
It wouldn't surprise me a bit if the courts overturn a public vote.
What person gets 1/2? Both of them! Each gets 1/2 in CA, unless you have a prenup.
It would not surprise me either as our public vote has been turned over several times by some liberal judges who feel they have more power and rights than the people.
Of course not. However, I would certainly not be in favor of gays having special rights. They should have the same rights as anyone else, and that does not include changing the definition of marriage!!!
At least in CA, I do not think they were/are attempting for special or extra rights. I also think that their approach to "equality" was poor.
If I were to write a proposition for the gay community, it would not reference marriage. It would simply state that ANY civil union between two "people" (any combonation of man-woman, man-man, woman-woman), would constite ALL legal rights of a heterosexual marriage. Further, it would state that religious choice take precedence to omit any potential frivolous lawsuites which have been going on, which, IMO, was the biggest problem with this prop. in CA