Is it just me, or has BP changed over the past few years?

Is it just me, or has BP changed over the past few years?

Flipper/Rehabber · Hazlet, NJ · Member since 2017 · 61 posts · 110 votes

It seems to me that BP has changed. I can't put my finger on exactly when - but, I think it started about 3-5 years ago. Up until then, BP was filled with good stuff, real value, from real REI at all levels. The content was gritty and real, and came from actual hands on successes and failures. Now, it seems like a social media platform to just "talk" about theories and possibilities. If I had to guess, I'd say that BP got big and the founders handed the day to day operations over to people that know how to market, but have no experience with the actual subject matter. It's probably a natural transition, and I'm just whining about it. Maybe it's just that I miss how it was, and I'm resistant to change.

27Reply
241 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
4y

I think there is some truth to it, but also you have changed - you know more now, so things get repetitive and less interesting.

Subjectivly I feel real estate investing has become more mainstream compared to 2010-2015. Back then it was hard core RE enthusiasts who did not mind to swim against the current. After 2015 REI became a mainstream idea, competition and prices have risen. So the filter is no longer market sentiment, but the actual financial barrier entry.

Josh Dorkin has been hammering cash flow as the main criteria, if not the only criteria, based on his own experiences in CA. This has really influenced a generation of investors, who took it way to far and started looking at REI as an ATM. Now the market is correcting that; cash flow expectations are starting to reduce and a lot of people will leave the space before they bought their first one, just because its getting too hard.

As a young agent I have worked with a lot of investors. 80% bought just one property, never a second one. A few bought 2 or 3. Only 2 guys have kept going as far as I know with small MF and SF. Only one person I have ever met made it from zero when we first spoke to 1400 units and built an actual business.

I think the next 5 to 10 years will be interesting; I expect prices to keep rising to unexpected levels along with the dollar (and debt) loosing value - until legislation and builders can ramp up production to fill the backlog and match demand.

See this reply in the discussion

69 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2021 · 237 posts · 153 votes
    4y

    @Kevin Zhang

    Yep. & BP money just grabbed some contributors that I’ve seen first hand are advocating only budgeting 20% of rents on sfh for ALL of the following:

    - Vacancy

    - professional management

    - utilities

    - repairs and maintenance

    - future improvements

    This, is a pipe dream. Always has been, and always will be. From all the numbers I’ve seen posted by those particular contributors, every single sfh they own will be cashflow negative over a 10+ year hold. But these “experts” have a following, and that’s the currency that matters here in 2022.

  • Member since 2021 · 237 posts · 153 votes
    4y

    @Mary M.

    Noticing the change a few years ago was possible because folks like your or I or Marcus were fairly regular here prior to that.

    As you’ve said, monetization (maximizing it) lead to the book drive, membership push hard and continuously, instafeeds, that are all the top of the funnel for multi millions in syndications. It’s marketing into real estate syndication, all of it. No other way to explain a $200M fund raise for storage for someone who’s never done it before (or similar).

    We’ve all gotta keep in mind too that there are seasons to investing. You start out absorbing everything. Try some stuff. Make some mistakes. Learn some stuff. And eventually you’re either giving back or else this place is pretty useless to you. Fundamentals haven’t changed, just experience.

  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    4y

    I've been on BP since 2010 and have definitely seen changes. Some good and some bad. I'm not a fan of all the facebook pages that tend to draw people away from this site and they are full of junk.

    On the other hand, BP provides a TON of information for free if you're willing to sift through it.

    I like to see how many posts/votes a user has, but would really like to see how many properties or units they own/manage! I can't tell you how many times I've seen someone give advice only to find out they bought their first duplex last month with money borrowed from their dad. Now they're passing themselves off as experts? Or I get someone arguing with me about how to manage rentals, only to find out they only have six (I manage 33 of my own, 350 for others, and 300 storage units). It's important to know the experience level of the person talking.

    I like to see real people that started small and built success. Grant Cardone is an anomoly and the advice he gives may be motivating but it's not practical to 99.9999% of the population. There are a lot of investors on this site that built a successful business, but then they kind of disappear once they're successful. Instead of mentoring the beginners, they're only focused on networking for their next big deal.

    BP has a lot of posers, sharks, used-car salesmen, braggarts, and outright liars. But there's also a large number of people that figured it out, built a successful business, and then stuck around to share with others. It's worth digging until you find them.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
  • Flipper/Rehabber · Hazlet, NJ · Member since 2017 · 61 posts · 110 votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Nathan Gesner:

    I've been on BP since 2010 and have definitely seen changes. Some good and some bad. I'm not a fan of all the facebook pages that tend to draw people away from this site and they are full of junk.

    On the other hand, BP provides a TON of information for free if you're willing to sift through it.

    I like to see how many posts/votes a user has, but would really like to see how many properties or units they own/manage! I can't tell you how many times I've seen someone give advice only to find out they bought their first duplex last month with money borrowed from their dad. Now they're passing themselves off as experts? Or I get someone arguing with me about how to manage rentals, only to find out they only have six (I manage 33 of my own, 350 for others, and 300 storage units). It's important to know the experience level of the person talking.

    I like to see real people that started small and built success. Grant Cardone is an anomoly and the advice he gives may be motivating but it's not practical to 99.9999% of the population. There are a lot of investors on this site that built a successful business, but then they kind of disappear once they're successful. Instead of mentoring the beginners, they're only focused on networking for their next big deal.

    BP has a lot of posers, sharks, used-car salesmen, braggarts, and outright liars. But there's also a large number of people that figured it out, built a successful business, and then stuck around to share with others. It's worth digging until you find them.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Hazlet, NJ · Member since 2017 · 61 posts · 110 votes
    4y

    Good stuff Nathan. Never been to WY - but, I didn’t think the whole state had 33 rentals! Lol. That was a Jersey joke! Wow, you must have your hands full. I quit my W2 job 3 years, 6 months and 4 days ago (who’s counting!), to do this full time. I’ve bought 10 sfr and hold 7 as rentals. I feel so blessed to be in the position I’m in. Money wise? Went from negative $30k to just going over $1M net worth. I’m so grateful for do-overs!

  • Coupeville, WA · Member since 2016 · 93 posts · 73 votes
    4y

    @Mary M.

    One of those great generic truisms " So i guess it's all in where you are in your life cycle, being an investor, being on BP, etc."

    I joined BP in 2016 when my siblings and I inherited a small apartment building that I and a sister were to determine what to do with it. We also bought a house as an investment with our son then. Over the years I have found much useful information on the forums from reading forum posts. Over time things change and I discovered other real estate related things like syndications and note investing simply from exposure to bigger pockets. I found an out of state to me lawyer through the forums by just seeing her trying to help folks with questions or references to lawyers and CPA's in her area and she helped us with some things we needed to put in place in order to sell the apartments this year. As we look at when to sell the house with our son and what to do with the money I still find value in reading what people are thinking about the real estate market in general. In terms of a life cycle adjustment do I want to be a passive or active investor is a question I go back and forth on. One of the things I was taught about training materials was to try and find 1 to 3 things that you could walk away with and use from the training. Is there a lot to sort through before you find a nugget or two you can use, yes there is but at least for me on this journey I find it worthwhile. Much thanks to all those who contribute their time, knowledge and experiences to the rest of us. I help if I can but still consider myself a newbie. 

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    4y

    This kind of conversation seems to come up every few months...

    Everything in life is what you make of it. It really does no good lamenting the way forums change and evolve because no amount of pining for days gone by is going to change the trajectory of anything. My thoughts:

    1. Interest in investing in RE has exploded in the 8 or so years I've been hanging around here. That is going to attract a lot of newbies with the same questions, dreamers and tire kickers who will never do anything, scammers looking to take advantage of the naive, etc. 

    2. It's pretty easy to follow people you're interested in - they'll even show up on your first page. That may beat digging through the forums for topics of interest, since topics go by pretty fast.

    3. The RE cycle has reached a point where getting a reasonable return is getting very difficult, which brings about a whole different set of forum topics and members - things that may not be of interest to those already "in the game". 

    4. If you track post counts and upvotes, it's a fairly reliable way of finding people to listen to. @Jay Hinrichs has the most upvotes on BP, and they're well-deserved. I like to look at the ratio of posts to upvotes; people that are one to one, with over a thousand votes, tend to be pretty reliable indicators of quality advice. Nothing is foolproof, of course, and that's not to say someone with a ton of votes or posts can't/won't be wrong on some issues, but in a virtual world where vetting is difficult it's as close to a sure thing as you can get. I also like to compare vote totals/post totals to time on BP total; I might be more suspicious of a very high post count from someone who is relatively brand new vs. something from someone like @Steve Vaughan or @Joe Splitrock. 

    5. Be the change you want to see. If you're looking for intelligent, worthwhile discussions, get them started. If you're just waiting to see what everyone else has to say, you may just be part of the problem you're describing. 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Harry Arnold:

    Good stuff Nathan. Never been to WY - but, I didn’t think the whole state had 33 rentals! Lol. That was a Jersey joke! Wow, you must have your hands full. I quit my W2 job 3 years, 6 months and 4 days ago (who’s counting!), to do this full time. I’ve bought 10 sfr and hold 7 as rentals. I feel so blessed to be in the position I’m in. Money wise? Went from negative $30k to just going over $1M net worth. I’m so grateful for do-overs!

    Nice! I didn't start investing until 2016 with a savings of $15,000 and a net worth of about $50,000. I now have 33 rentals, 150 storage units, a very successful property management company providing eight jobs to the local community, and a net worth of over $2M. My management company provides a very comfortable living and our sales commission is "play" money for investing. Thanks to my upbringing and some internal limiting beliefs, I never thought I would own more than a few rentals. A couple years ago my eyes were opened and I set a goal of $300,000 annual rental income with at least $100,000 of that going to charity. It's only been six years since I started investing and I'm already 2/3 of the way there!

    A lot of what I learned came from BiggerPockets users. I'm doing my best to give back.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y

    @Nathan Gesner@JD Martin   I think an important distinction to make on BP is you have a few class of investors or BP members.

    1. the business owner who is already in RE business in some manner be it PM RE brokerage Lending  etc etc and their interest In BP would be to further their already established business models.

    2. you have the W 2 / or self-employed but in a business that has nothing to do with real estate and they come here to learn how to be a landlord.  and in a Far lessor degree maybe now to safely lend money or buy notes or invest in syndications or buy from Turnkey operators etc. 

    3. Then you have the young folks who are really starting out and have some big plans and dreams which is really cool. 

    4. Then you have the really successful business person that simply trolls BP and is interested in investing in RE but does not have the time to do it themselves and they troll the forums and then reach out to someone they like etc. 

    So in my mind there are varying different reasons why folks are on BP.. and based on the rules of the open forum were you can't do haves or wants or open solicitation those in the RE business that are looking for clients etc. If they don't want to put in the work to help others answer questions etc .  they don't get very far on BP  it's all take and no give back.

    Then you have others that just like the social aspect and to talk about their lives and what they have done that relates to the real estate industry. I think that's kind of my personal situation.  Just been in it forever and done a lot of things with real estate seems like every decade and i am going on 5 of those I am doing something different .. so for me I like to share the different things I have done in real estate some pretty darn neat some I got my butt kicked. . does not make me the be all end all to real estate that's for sure.  And we all have our motivations and thought process.  One of them we see on BP that can go from one extreme to the other is the use of debt.  you have the refi till you die have no money into the deal you have middle of the road and then you have Hey i want to own them outright.  So this leads to spirited math debates LOL. 

    And there is no question, and it took me a few years to realize that some of the folks on this site just cut and paste for the pure reason to run up post counts you can identify them by 1k posts and 32 votes LOL.. then U have others that have 1k posts and 3k votes that's quality content in my mind.

    For me personally bottom line it's a social thing and I guess I am one of the ones that like to talk. Plus, I type fast LOL . And I work from my home office so those things allow me to be more active on the site..  I don't do Facebook linkdin insta whatever that is or any of those other things that are so popular with many.. so it all gets funneled to bp..   Bottom line BP for sure has helped me immensely in many avenues since I joined

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles · Member since 2018 · 844 posts · 1k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Nathan Gesner@JD Martin   I think an important distinction to make on BP is you have a few class of ivestors or BP members.

    1. the business owner who is already in RE business in some manner  be it PM  RE brokerage Lending  etc etc and their interest In BP  would be to further their already established business models.

    2. you have the W 2 / or self employed but in a business that has nothing to do with real estate and they come here to learn how to be a landlord .  and in a Far lessor degree maybe now to safely lend money or buy notes  or invest in syndications or buy from Turnkey operators etc. 

    3. Then you have the young folks who are really starting out and have some big plans and dreams which is really cool. 

    So in my mind there are varying different reasons why folks are on BP.. and based on the rules of the open forum were you cant do haves or wants or open solicitation those in the RE business that are looking for clients etc. If they dont want to put in the work to help others answer questions etc .  they dont get very far on BP  its all take and no give back.

    Then you have others that just like the social aspect and to talk about their lives and what they have done that relates to the real estate industry.. I think thats kind of my personal situation.  Just been in it forever and done a lot of things with real estate seems like every decade and i am going on 5 of those I am doing something different .. so for me i like to share the different things I have done in real estate some pretty darn neat some got my butt kicked. . does not make the  be all end all to real estate thats for sure.  And we all have our motivations and thought process..  ONe of them we see on BP that can go from one extreme to the other is the use of debt..  you have the refi till you die have no money into the deal  you have middle of the road and then you have Hey i want to own them outright.  So this leads to spirited math debates LOL. 

    And there is no question and it took me a few years to realize that some of the folks on this site just cut and paste for the pure reason to run up post counts you can identify them by 1k posts and 32 votes LOL.. then U have others that have 1k posts and 3k votes thats quality content in my mind.

    For me personally bottom line its a social thing and i guess I am one of the ones that like to talk.. Plus I type fast LOL .. And i work from my home office so those things allow me to be more active on the site..  I dont do facebook linkdin insta what ever that is or any of those other things that are so popular with many.. so it all gets funneled to bp.. 

    I'm kind of in the same boat as you.. well, can't say same boat as your boat is a lot larger than mine. But I log on mainly for enjoyment...and once in a while, I'll make a connection that pertains directly to business, such as locating @Dave Foster as my QI. The first few years were about learning, but for me now, it's more about finding an interesting thread and following the discussion and once in a while, trying to make an interesting contribution.

    I do LinkedIn as well, but definitely not FB...though LinkedIn is slowly starting to feel like FB.

    I think one of the interesting dynamics that occurs when folks first starting getting hooked on this site (and this site is very addicting!) is how they've been using leverage all wrong. The max-leverage folks here tend to be a bit more outspoken and so when I first joined this site, I thought I was doing it all wrong and was determined to extract every last bit of dead equity from my properties. After all, it's the best way to grow your assets, right? Max out your leverage and cash flow about 100 to 150 per door, right?

    I also find interesting how newbies get all excited about TK's because I went through the exact same thing. Nothing wrong with it...but after a few years, many of them will realize that there are many other ways to be successful in RE. Newbie posts about how they're looking to invest in real estate and then all the usual suspects start chiming in about how TK's in the Midwest or South are the way to go.

    Also, it's been a while since we've had a long thread of wholesaling. Those are pretty entertaining as well....

  • Joe S.Pro Member
    Investor · San Antonio · Member since 2020 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Mary M.:
    Originally posted by @Marcus Auerbach:

    BP used to display #of votes and #of posts under the name.  While that is not always a gurantee for quality, it was at lease some indication who you should listen to a little more.

    its still there if you use the old forum interface...

    As for the topic at hand - businesses and ideas go thru life cycles just like people do. We are at the monetization phase of BP where content is driven to the newbie who will buy books etc etc. (and if you think about us "experienced folks' are contributing for free to this monetization) 

    What I find interesting is folks saying that they have seen a change since 2015.... well hate to tell you but BP has been around a lot longer than that and REI has been a fundamental wealth builder for over 100 years. It just got popular when the gut and cheaply reno shows took off (to the detriment of thousands of amazing old houses that were gutted and ruined) .....

    So i guess it's all in where you are in your life cycle,  being an investor, being on BP, etc. 

    But as I have said more times that I remember BP is full of sharks ready to eat all the guppies....  that is the ENTIRE point of it. 

    Well Mary are you trying to tell us that a lot of the success stories aren’t  real or indirect ways self marketing??? Do you mean that the 25-year-old young man that claims to have over 5000 units is simply a part of a Syndication And trying to solicit limited partners? I could go on and on of course. 🤭

  • Michael E.Pro Member
    New to Real Estate · Saginaw, MI · Member since 2021 · 99 posts · 115 votes
    4y

    Well I hope my "no experience" "new to to real estate" 2¢ doesn't offend anyone but I think this goes to exactly one of the things the David Greene talks about. "Managing expectations".

    I have watched dozens of hours of BP content on Youtube and read lots of posts and articles. Everything I need to know to be a real estate millionaire is available on BiggerPockets.com for free or be learned by following the BP process. So why don't more people actually become successful in real estate (or any other endeavor for that matter)? In one of the podcasts that I watched Brandon said they found the thing that stops most people is mindset. Posts in this thread have said very few people actually buy more then 1 property and even less buy more then 3 properties. That doesn't sound like a lack of knowledge or skills, it sounds like a lack of true investor mindset. So is it any surprise that they are pushing more and more content that is aimed at mindset?

    However, having said that, I want more nitty-gritty stuff too, but I'm always thirsting for more BP knowledge.

    But again, I'm just a no experience, new to to real estate, investor and this is just my 2¢.

    "But the biggest enemy you will have to deal with is yourself" -Les Brown

    P.S. BiggerPockets... I LOVE YOU!

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Tony Kim:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Nathan Gesner@JD Martin   I think an important distinction to make on BP is you have a few class of ivestors or BP members.

    1. the business owner who is already in RE business in some manner  be it PM  RE brokerage Lending  etc etc and their interest In BP  would be to further their already established business models.

    2. you have the W 2 / or self employed but in a business that has nothing to do with real estate and they come here to learn how to be a landlord .  and in a Far lessor degree maybe now to safely lend money or buy notes  or invest in syndications or buy from Turnkey operators etc. 

    3. Then you have the young folks who are really starting out and have some big plans and dreams which is really cool. 

    So in my mind there are varying different reasons why folks are on BP.. and based on the rules of the open forum were you cant do haves or wants or open solicitation those in the RE business that are looking for clients etc. If they dont want to put in the work to help others answer questions etc .  they dont get very far on BP  its all take and no give back.

    Then you have others that just like the social aspect and to talk about their lives and what they have done that relates to the real estate industry.. I think thats kind of my personal situation.  Just been in it forever and done a lot of things with real estate seems like every decade and i am going on 5 of those I am doing something different .. so for me i like to share the different things I have done in real estate some pretty darn neat some got my butt kicked. . does not make the  be all end all to real estate thats for sure.  And we all have our motivations and thought process..  ONe of them we see on BP that can go from one extreme to the other is the use of debt..  you have the refi till you die have no money into the deal  you have middle of the road and then you have Hey i want to own them outright.  So this leads to spirited math debates LOL. 

    And there is no question and it took me a few years to realize that some of the folks on this site just cut and paste for the pure reason to run up post counts you can identify them by 1k posts and 32 votes LOL.. then U have others that have 1k posts and 3k votes thats quality content in my mind.

    For me personally bottom line its a social thing and i guess I am one of the ones that like to talk.. Plus I type fast LOL .. And i work from my home office so those things allow me to be more active on the site..  I dont do facebook linkdin insta what ever that is or any of those other things that are so popular with many.. so it all gets funneled to bp.. 

    I'm kind of in the same boat as you.. well, can't say same boat as your boat is a lot larger than mine. But I log on mainly for enjoyment...and once in a while, I'll make a connection that pertains directly to business, such as locating @Dave Foster as my QI. The first few years were about learning, but for me now, it's more about finding an interesting thread and following the discussion and once in a while, trying to make an interesting contribution.

    I do LinkedIn as well, but definitely not FB...though LinkedIn is slowly starting to feel like FB.

    I think one of the interesting dynamics that occurs when folks first starting getting hooked on this site (and this site is very addicting!) is how they've been using leverage all wrong. The max-leverage folks here tend to be a bit more outspoken and so when I first joined this site, I thought I was doing it all wrong and was determined to extract every last bit of dead equity from my properties. After all, it's the best way to grow your assets, right? Max out your leverage and cash flow about 100 to 150 per door, right?

    I also find interesting how newbies get all excited about TK's because I went through the exact same thing. Nothing wrong with it...but after a few years, many of them will realize that there are many other ways to be successful in RE. Newbie posts about how they're looking to invest in real estate and then all the usual suspects start chiming in about how TK's in the Midwest or South are the way to go.

    Also, it's been a while since we've had a long thread of wholesaling. Those are pretty entertaining as well....

    I have a linkdin that my secretary put up..  Its too complicated for me to use.. so I never use it..  I guess I could learn how to use it.. but BP is hard enough for me to figure out :)

    OH and I just learned about U tube a year or so ago.. and that is one I sure missed the boat on..  I love that.. cooking recipes  how to fix things.. lots of aviation and fishing and other stuff that interest me..  also dont know how twitter works other than I hear everyone talk about it but never tried it I might have twitter account that my office set up for me but I have no clue how to access it or if I would even try it or what I would do once I was there.

  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    OH and I just learned about U tube a year or so ago.. and that is one I sure missed the boat on..  I love that.. cooking recipes  how to fix things.. lots of aviation and fishing and other stuff that interest me..  also dont know how twitter works other than I hear everyone talk about it but never tried it I might have twitter account that my office set up for me but I have no clue how to access it or if I would even try it or what I would do once I was there.

    Jay, I can't believe you only learned about YouTube last year!!! 

    In Twitter's first year, I said it was a cesspool. It's only gotten worse since then. I swear it's responsible for at least 1/4 of the partisanship and hate in this country. Bad, bad stuff and I wish it a speedy, horrible death.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Nathan Gesner:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    OH and I just learned about U tube a year or so ago.. and that is one I sure missed the boat on..  I love that.. cooking recipes  how to fix things.. lots of aviation and fishing and other stuff that interest me..  also dont know how twitter works other than I hear everyone talk about it but never tried it I might have twitter account that my office set up for me but I have no clue how to access it or if I would even try it or what I would do once I was there.

    Jay, I can't believe you only learned about YouTube last year!!! 

    In Twitter's first year, I said it was a cesspool. It's only gotten worse since then. I swear it's responsible for at least 1/4 of the partisanship and hate in this country. Bad, bad stuff and I wish it a speedy, horrible death.

    LOL  I know U tube is great I dont like all the commercials that you have to sit through but they work I just bought one thing I saw on there and then promptly tried it and threw it away..  

    from the little i understand about twitter ( mainly because of trump and media say trump just tweeted this)  its short little statements with no real context I can see what you mean how its create such bad crap.. 

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    4y

    BP needs a FAQ area that members can add to when they reach some "giving back to the community" thresholds. 

    Get so tired of newbies asking the same questions, day after day! But, wait - BP has a VERY crappy search feature, so the newbies find junk when they do try to search - hence the member supported FAQ idea. We seem to care more about the community than the powers in the ivory towers:(

  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    4y

    Here's a great explanation of what's wrong with Twitter: https://medium.com/illuminatio...

    Twitter, YouTube, and Facebook are all censoring information to protect certain political interests. They hide stories that shed a bad light on certain people, they squelch opinions (and even scientific facts) they disagree with, and then they pretend to be open platforms. Government doesn't seem willing to do anything so it may never get better.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
  • Dave FosterBusiness Member
    Qualified Intermediary for 1031 Exchanges · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2013 · 9k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    4y

    @Nathan Gesner, Every platform has  an underlining purpose.  It may not even be a conscious decision on the part of the creators.  It can simply be a byproduct of the organic growth of the platform.  The main distinction I see between a platform like Twitter and BP and say facebook is that Twitter is really more of a platform for you to share your opinion (good bad snarky or observation).  Facebook seems to be more about connecting smaller groups relationally - family or subsets of real estate investors.  And Platforms like BP are where you go to learn and listen and discern.  You won't learn anything from Twitter.  But you can vent or get yourself worked up over it.  Facebook doesn't lend itself to long dialogues but is great for establishing connections.

    BP is where you can still find an in depth discussion on just about any REI topic. And on every one of those discussions there will be posers and princes. So it also serves as the first pass on finding folks you want to work with like @Tony Kim and all the other great folks I've been privileged to work with here over the years.  

    Do they have to pivot and expand and grow to keep making money - sure.  But as long as BP allows new investors the chance to ask questions and experienced investors to explore advanced topics, And as long as markets grow die and mutate BP will be a huge resource tool for real estate investing.  

    You Tube is much the same as BP except for it is tutorials that are more one sided.  I use it to archive our information for easy access for potential clients.  But it is also my Walter Mitty muse - @Jay Hinrichs is learning how to cook and fix his airplanes.  I'm learning how to dress wild hogs and play blues guitar.  There's something for everyone!!  It's just one sided.

    But the dog videos....Oh the dog videos!!!!  Don't get me started!

    The 1031 Investor5140 Reviews
  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Dave Foster:

    @Nathan Gesner, Every platform has  an underlining purpose.  It may not even be a conscious decision on the part of the creators.  It can simply be a byproduct of the organic growth of the platform.  The main distinction I see between a platform like Twitter and BP and say facebook is that Twitter is really more of a platform for you to share your opinion (good bad snarky or observation).  Facebook seems to be more about connecting smaller groups relationally - family or subsets of real estate investors.  And Platforms like BP are where you go to learn and listen and discern.  You won't learn anything from Twitter.  But you can vent or get yourself worked up over it.  Facebook doesn't lend itself to long dialogues but is great for establishing connections.

    BP is where you can still find an in depth discussion on just about any REI topic. And on every one of those discussions there will be posers and princes. So it also serves as the first pass on finding folks you want to work with like @Tony Kim and all the other great folks I've been privileged to work with here over the years.  

    Do they have to pivot and expand and grow to keep making money - sure.  But as long as BP allows new investors the chance to ask questions and experienced investors to explore advanced topics, And as long as markets grow die and mutate BP will be a huge resource tool for real estate investing.  

    You Tube is much the same as BP except for it is tutorials that are more one sided.  I use it to archive our information for easy access for potential clients.  But it is also my Walter Mitty muse - @Jay Hinrichs is learning how to cook and fix his airplanes.  I'm learning how to dress wild hogs and play blues guitar.  There's something for everyone!!  It's just one sided.

    But the dog videos....Oh the dog videos!!!!  Don't get me started!

     Good observations Dave. 

    That's another good point that comes into focus - part of what you get out of BP depends on how you mine the relationships that you make here. I am in a mastermind group with several people that I met on BP, and that introduced me to a couple that weren't. I've been invited to speak at a couple of REI groups from my exposure here. Dave's been a guest speaker at our mastermind group discussing 1031 exchanges in greater detail - I learned more on that subject with his one hour talk than in all the years I've been on BP. Jay has been a guest at our group as well, sharing a lot of information about previous RE cycles. I've met and mentored some younger investors; appeared on a few podcasts; and grown my portfolio bigger than I thought I would, a lot of the courage to do so coming from watching and listening to those who did it before me.

    If you just come here for some entertainment on the forums, that's fine - but there's a ton more wealth to be obtained, financial and otherwise, by just digging a little beneath the surface.

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Contractor · Grand Marais, MN · Member since 2016 · 249 posts · 417 votes
    4y

    @Jay Hinrichs builder here, and I agree. I live in a small town, but the number of kids entering the trades is virtually 0. We simply don't have enough labor. I'm booked 2 years out, got another call last night wanting to give a down-payment just to be on a list. I'm not a permabull, but I don't see a reversal anytime soon

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Matt Groth:

    @Jay Hinrichs builder here, and I agree. I live in a small town, but the number of kids entering the trades is virtually 0. We simply don't have enough labor. I'm booked 2 years out, got another call last night wanting to give a down-payment just to be on a list. I'm not a permabull, but I don't see a reversal anytime soon

    frankly in our area if we did not have Hispanic tradesmen/women we would be dead in the water.  We do have a lot of eastern block non English speakers that are great at hard surfaces and paint . but they will also hire hispanic labor.  I cant imagine how you would do it if your labor pool did not include those folks.  I know when i was in Jackson Mississippi I advertised over in Texas and imported Hispanic GC/ labor and housed them the local labor pool was unbelievably poor. 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Drew Sygit:

    BP needs a FAQ area that members can add to when they reach some "giving back to the community" thresholds. 

    Get so tired of newbies asking the same questions, day after day! But, wait - BP has a VERY crappy search feature, so the newbies find junk when they do try to search - hence the member supported FAQ idea. We seem to care more about the community than the powers in the ivory towers:(

    I agree i cant find anything on BP search function it simply does not work.. especially other members if you cant recall the exact spelling of their name your toast..  Like If wanted to find Drew  Sygit  and for the life of me could not remember how to spell the last name IE Seygit or some variation your not going to find it.. 

  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Matt Groth:

    @Jay Hinrichs builder here, and I agree. I live in a small town, but the number of kids entering the trades is virtually 0. We simply don't have enough labor. I'm booked 2 years out, got another call last night wanting to give a down-payment just to be on a list. I'm not a permabull, but I don't see a reversal anytime soon

    How long before the shortage of tradesman drives prices up and makes homeownership unaffordable? That's what I'm waiting for. 

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
  • Contractor · Grand Marais, MN · Member since 2016 · 249 posts · 417 votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Nathan Gesner:
    Originally posted by @Matt Groth:

    @Jay Hinrichs builder here, and I agree. I live in a small town, but the number of kids entering the trades is virtually 0. We simply don't have enough labor. I'm booked 2 years out, got another call last night wanting to give a down-payment just to be on a list. I'm not a permabull, but I don't see a reversal anytime soon

    How long before the shortage of tradesman drives prices up and makes homeownership unaffordable? That's what I'm waiting for. 

    I don't know that,  but feel that we are close. I don't think that means prices drop, it just means fewer people will own more assets. We haven't had a new listing in market in over a month. Come to town with unlimited cash, there is nothing to buy. Waiting lists for rentals...I hear similar stories from other areas. Just got back from Quebec, similar stories there. There is simply not enough supply, and not enough people that know how to make more. I have had people argue "bubble", but I disagree. Lots of cash buyers, 0 sellers. I have no idea how this looks 10 years from now, but 20 years ago, I was one of the young guys, and at 48, I still am. 

  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Marcus Auerbach:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Marcus Auerbach:

    I think we need to have some perspective.  Large funds and very well to do investors are very happy with 4 to 7 caps on quality stabilized assets.  its primarily the beginner or smaller mom and pop land lord that seems to have this criteria of ( and I love it when they say my criteria LOL) of needing a 10 cap or at least 10% coc so this moves them into assets the bigger investors by and large wont buy. Except for the hedge funds that went around the country scooping up a bunch of the C and D class sfrs and are still doing it.. WHY I don't understand personally .. I think you nailed it when you said most buy one or two homes and then stop. 

    More D than C, which really surprises me! Why not go into quality neighborhoods? 

    Just had a deal with Vinebrookhomes; they are not too picky with where they buy. 20,000 SF homes under management, relativley low rents, I can only guess their turnover and eviction ratios - but save to assume higher than what I would tolerate. According to their website they have currently 129 open jobs. I would love to see their P&L and balance sheet! With some rough math I get 2-3 billion dollars in assets and 300 million in annual rent. They make it up with volume - 5% to 7% is still a nice return.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.