It seems to me that BP has changed. I can't put my finger on exactly when - but, I think it started about 3-5 years ago. Up until then, BP was filled with good stuff, real value, from real REI at all levels. The content was gritty and real, and came from actual hands on successes and failures. Now, it seems like a social media platform to just "talk" about theories and possibilities. If I had to guess, I'd say that BP got big and the founders handed the day to day operations over to people that know how to market, but have no experience with the actual subject matter. It's probably a natural transition, and I'm just whining about it. Maybe it's just that I miss how it was, and I'm resistant to change.
I think there is some truth to it, but also you have changed - you know more now, so things get repetitive and less interesting.
Subjectivly I feel real estate investing has become more mainstream compared to 2010-2015. Back then it was hard core RE enthusiasts who did not mind to swim against the current. After 2015 REI became a mainstream idea, competition and prices have risen. So the filter is no longer market sentiment, but the actual financial barrier entry.
Josh Dorkin has been hammering cash flow as the main criteria, if not the only criteria, based on his own experiences in CA. This has really influenced a generation of investors, who took it way to far and started looking at REI as an ATM. Now the market is correcting that; cash flow expectations are starting to reduce and a lot of people will leave the space before they bought their first one, just because its getting too hard.
As a young agent I have worked with a lot of investors. 80% bought just one property, never a second one. A few bought 2 or 3. Only 2 guys have kept going as far as I know with small MF and SF. Only one person I have ever met made it from zero when we first spoke to 1400 units and built an actual business.
I think the next 5 to 10 years will be interesting; I expect prices to keep rising to unexpected levels along with the dollar (and debt) loosing value - until legislation and builders can ramp up production to fill the backlog and match demand.
I think there is some truth to it, but also you have changed - you know more now, so things get repetitive and less interesting.
Subjectivly I feel real estate investing has become more mainstream compared to 2010-2015. Back then it was hard core RE enthusiasts who did not mind to swim against the current. After 2015 REI became a mainstream idea, competition and prices have risen. So the filter is no longer market sentiment, but the actual financial barrier entry.
Josh Dorkin has been hammering cash flow as the main criteria, if not the only criteria, based on his own experiences in CA. This has really influenced a generation of investors, who took it way to far and started looking at REI as an ATM. Now the market is correcting that; cash flow expectations are starting to reduce and a lot of people will leave the space before they bought their first one, just because its getting too hard.
As a young agent I have worked with a lot of investors. 80% bought just one property, never a second one. A few bought 2 or 3. Only 2 guys have kept going as far as I know with small MF and SF. Only one person I have ever met made it from zero when we first spoke to 1400 units and built an actual business.
I think the next 5 to 10 years will be interesting; I expect prices to keep rising to unexpected levels along with the dollar (and debt) loosing value - until legislation and builders can ramp up production to fill the backlog and match demand.
True - good points.
I think there is some truth to it, but also you have changed - you know more now, so things get repetitive and less interesting.
Subjectivly I feel real estate investing has become more mainstream compared to 2010-2015. Back then it was hard core RE enthusiasts who did not mind to swim against the current. After 2015 REI became a mainstream idea, competition and prices have risen. So the filter is no longer market sentiment, but the actual financial barrier entry.
Josh Dorkin has been hammering cash flow as the main criteria, if not the only criteria, based on his own experiences in CA. This has really influenced a generation of investors, who took it way to far and started looking at REI as an ATM. Now the market is correcting that; cash flow expectations are starting to reduce and a lot of people will leave the space before they bought their first one, just because its getting too hard.
As a young agent I have worked with a lot of investors. 80% bought just one property, never a second one. A few bought 2 or 3. Only 2 guys have kept going as far as I know with small MF and SF. Only one person I have ever met made it from zero when we first spoke to 1400 units and built an actual business.
I think the next 5 to 10 years will be interesting; I expect prices to keep rising to unexpected levels along with the dollar (and debt) loosing value - until legislation and builders can ramp up production to fill the backlog and match demand.
Agreed BP is cash flow is everything anything else is gambling so we all have that pounded into our bp posts.
Also Mr. Dorkin sold the business a few years back. So new ownership that needs to monetize their investment to to a far greater degree than the original owner who had sweat equity. Although I am not privy to how it started or who funded the startup but from what I read and see it started small then did very well. Also, As Marcus alluded to it started coming out of the GFC where deals were once in a lifetime type pricing
I don't see builders ever catching up at least not in the short term what's happened with covid was not a real estate crash but a huge crash to the supply chain and price of components which has risen the cost to build a home significantly and land prices keep rising. Rents are going up but, in most places, NOT anywhere high enough to keep returns like they were 10 years ago. Returns keep going down on cash flow rentals across the board a solid 5 to 7% return is the norm on a stabilized quality asset.
Unfortunately its the sign of the times. Hope grant Cardon hasent influenced this platform. anyone Watch the recent Rich dad poor dad podcast with Robert Kyosaki and Grant Cardon. It was suppose to be about real estate investing for begginers and ended up being a promotion and marketing for grant and his property. what a disaster.
Sign of the Times
I have the tendency to try and say things as kind as possible. That creates confusion, and is definitely something I have to work on. What I meant to say in my original post is this.
It seems that BP is no longer a forum where people help each other. Where the atmosphere isn't "self help", but an equal giving and receiving community. Now, there are people that are giving advice, that never even pulled the trigger in one deal. It's filled with people that have a "passion" about REI, but only talk about it. There seems to be a lot of people that want to "get rich quick" and never do any work to get there. In other words, BP seems to be a great place for "dreamers" that like to talk theory and "what ifs." BP used to be a place to come to for encouragement and fellowship, around a common subject - Real Estate Investing. Now, it's a social forum for people to hear themselves talk.
@Marcus Auerbach touched on a lot of great points. A lot more hyped up REI enthusiasts now than back in 2017/18 when I started on BP. Energy is super charged but deals are harder to come by and the questions that people raise also evolved as a result.
I sit here as a newer member and one of the first things I was told on the forums was "be aware of the blind leading the blind". I thought nothing of it until time went on. Now I can see it though. I am far from experienced, so at a entry level, I feel the information talked about is much of the same. I use to think people like Jim K, Joe V., and Jerryll N were jaded and brash, but now they are the posts and discussions I enjoy they most because they tend to contain REAL knowledge. When I see things from Marcus A and Jay H, I know they did their research. Most things now feel like copy and paste responses to the same topics worded different ways. there are very few thought provoking and informative posts left that actually provide helpful information to the general readers.
That being said, what is the new investor to do in times like these? Like Marcus A. said, RE is mainstream and over saturated. I just recently closed on my first property. Am I 100% sure that I did everything right? Nope. Am I excited for everything I have and I am going to learn? Yep. Am I already looking into acquiring another property? Yep. Do I recognize that it will take years if not decades to establish a portfolio while also taking the risk of going bankrupt along the way? Of course. If I listened to everyone on BP, I would have bought nothing and learned little. Which I feel has strayed from the original intent.
I now crave the in person, hands-on learning from a trusted source. The question is whether BP still provides that.
It seems to me that BP has changed. I can't put my finger on exactly when - but, I think it started about 3-5 years ago. Up until then, BP was filled with good stuff, real value, from real REI at all levels. The content was gritty and real, and came from actual hands on successes and failures. Now, it seems like a social media platform to just "talk" about theories and possibilities. If I had to guess, I'd say that BP got big and the founders handed the day to day operations over to people that know how to market, but have no experience with the actual subject matter. It's probably a natural transition, and I'm just whining about it. Maybe it's just that I miss how it was, and I'm resistant to change.
Hi Harry,
. I'm the Community Engagement Specialist here at BiggerPockets. I really appreciate your thoughts and feedback. Part of my job is to communicate the member concerns or ideas to our team at large. I can attest we have a number of investors that are employees here, and we are passionate about creating new opportunities to learn at any level. There are so many excellent contributors here that have decades of experience, much of which I've used as an investor myself. I'd love to chat with you on any specific things you're wanting to see offered or ways you feel we can improve. I can tell you that I am actively working on strategies to create a positive and accurate experience for a member at any level of experience. Feel free to message me directly, or shoot me an email at [email protected].
@Harry Arnold there are heavyweights in the forums with thousands and thousands of votes, who give really, really great advice, including frank, unvarnished, solid advice to newbies who don't want to hear it. So, I think you're right that there are lots of people that are all talk, but it's not accurate to say that there isn't help being given. The advice from those folks (including @Jay Hinrichs) is invaluable. I am amazed at the time that they dedicate to the forums. I particularly benefit from Joe Splitrock, Russell Brazil, Jonathan Greene and many others.
I think your first post had some truth to it too, the early podcasts have a lot of "nitty gritty" and now some of the newer podcasts are more business and lifestyle focused. But the newer podcasts - Rookie and Money - still have stories of beginners and intermediates with more detail.
Good topic of discussion.
@Adam Chmielewski
@Harry Arnold
I agree with you both-joined the community probably mid 2017.
However, since then the Bigger Pockets Money podcast has built its own following that feels like the Mrmoneymustache group or Bogleheads, and they’ve started a Rookie and Business podcast.
In early 2020 I didn’t meet anyone at REIAs that weren’t newbs who didn’t know about BP.
With that said, my 2 cents is the content is there, you just have to look at the specific spots to find what you’re looking for, and ignore the spots that don’t apply.
Great discussion, thanks for starting it
@Harry Arnold there are heavyweights in the forums with thousands and thousands of votes, who give really, really great advice, including frank, unvarnished, solid advice to newbies who don't want to hear it. So, I think you're right that there are lots of people that are all talk, but it's not accurate to say that there isn't help being given. The advice from those folks (including @Jay Hinrichs) is invaluable. I am amazed at the time that they dedicate to the forums. I particularly benefit from Joe Splitrock, Russell Brazil, Jonathan Greene and many others.
I think your first post had some truth to it too, the early podcasts have a lot of "nitty gritty" and now some of the newer podcasts are more business and lifestyle focused. But the newer podcasts - Rookie and Money - still have stories of beginners and intermediates with more detail.
Good topic of discussion.
Thanks for the shoutout! It always helps to hear that people are finding value in the content we offer.
Ive been around BP a long time, and I still garner a lot of value from the forums. The podcasts, I really just listen when it is a topic or person I am interested in, and dont listen to every episode any more. I still check out the blogs....but for me it is the forums where I get the most value, and feel like I can also provide the most value. Podcasts and blogs speak to topics in very broad terms....while the forums allow us to get much more specific, whether with a specific problem or a specific neighborhood.
@Harry Arnold I completely get both sides of what you’re saying. At times when I post a question, instead of help I get rude know it all answers. However, the other 85% of the time I feel there are genuine people who like to help each other out. I think it’s just the sign of the times with social media these days. There’s a lot of keyboard warriors. Being smalltime myself it’s easy to get overwhelmed by the millionaires on the podcasts but I just keep investing knowing I’m better off than most my neighbors.
@Harry Arnold agreed Harry. The content isn’t as good.
@Harry Arnold it has gone from startup to corporate. Also even when Josh was here he moved things towards the newbies and so many of the more sophisticated got tired of the same questions and have stopped contributing.
Newbies buy books and help the business grow so the source of business is bigger with the influx of new people all the time.
It is still a great resource and I have benefitted from questions where people come out of nowhere and contribute, some very qualified attorneys, accountants and high level investors with very valuable information. And of course @Jay Hinrichs being one of the top of the list. All and all still an excellent source of information.
One of the things I've noticed, especially with the podcast is that a lot of the content seems more "rah rah!" than nitty gritty investment talk. I can imagine why, I would *guess* that some disproportionate number (80%?) of folks on here are either working on getting their first deal, or have one rental and are dreaming of number 2.
I constantly hear trailer parks being plugged, various books being plugged, and more shows on generic "How I went from 0 to 1400 units in ONE YEAR!". Bring back the talk about the middle, bring back guys who don't have entire teams working for them but are out there hustling trying to turn 6 units into 10, or buy a small complex that may or may not work. It seems a lot of the technical talk has been lost, and that's what I always look to bigger pockets for.
Every time I come here it seems like someone is trying to convince me real estate is a good investment. I figured that part out already, now I want to know how to make my business better.
@Harry Arnold well clearly you need to buy a pro membership and then you’d understand lol. The podcasts are filled with adds and it seems like I skip more than I listen to these days. The constant come to BP Con, buy our best selling books, and use the pro calculator because we are sure you can’t handle building a simple spreadsheet without screwing it up is getting annoying for sure!
It seems to me that BP has changed. I can't put my finger on exactly when - but, I think it started about 3-5 years ago. Up until then, BP was filled with good stuff, real value, from real REI at all levels. The content was gritty and real, and came from actual hands on successes and failures.
I agree and always liked a discussion with some grit and gravel in it. Funny how grit-wanters from back in the day can have posted less than 50 times. LOL
We used to did. Heated technical discussions about creative strategies and finding off-market deals.
Now the questions are just repetitive and we get answer fatigue. Trending discussions about blinds or a ceiling fan or some other nuance that lasts for days along with 'it depends on how you feel and what your goals are' yawner answers.
But I still check in to see what my colleagues are posting. If I can see their posts buried inside a crowded dashboard full of stuff I couldn't care less about. 10 month old blog posts, huge picture things of the podcasts, the webinar or a random post. I asked about cleaning up our dashboards months ago. I come here to see what my people are talking about. If I can't see that, you won't see me.
The Creative and more interesting forum topics shouldn't be so buried at the bottom of the choices. Might see something besides Starting Out, Buying and Selling or generic Landlord forum topics.
It seems to me that BP has changed. I can't put my finger on exactly when - but, I think it started about 3-5 years ago. Up until then, BP was filled with good stuff, real value, from real REI at all levels. The content was gritty and real, and came from actual hands on successes and failures.
I agree and always liked a discussion with some grit and gravel in it. Funny how grit-wanters from back in the day can have posted less than 50 times. LOL
We used to did. Heated technical discussions about creative strategies and finding off-market deals.
Now the questions are just repetitive and we get answer fatigue. Trending discussions about blinds or a ceiling fan or some other nuance that lasts for days along with 'it depends on how you feel and what your goals are' yawner answers.
But I still check in to see what my colleagues are posting. If I can see their posts buried inside a crowded dashboard full of stuff I couldn't care less about. 10 month old blog posts, huge picture things of the podcasts, the webinar or a random post. I asked about cleaning up our dashboards months ago. I come here to see what my people are talking about. If I can't see that, you won't see me.
The Creative and more interesting forum topics shouldn't be so buried at the bottom of the choices. Might see something besides Starting Out, Buying and Selling or generic Landlord forum topics.
I completely agree with this. Why is it so difficult to set BP up so that I see what the twenty or so regular posters with opinions that matter have posted recently? Instead, I get discussions by landlords on how their five-year tenant with the 200 lb. St. Bernard that the LL originally signed off on should best be charged $12K after moveout to redo the parquet floors.
In how many nuanced ways can I be expected to express, "You're just a blind sack of stupid, Bubba" before I write something that gets me banned?
@Jim K.
This started likely 5 ish years ago when the amateur “developers” were given the go ahead (budget) to redesign the platform. … they’ve failed at beta testing ever since. Remember the “oops we forgot about a search button!” crap from about 5 years back? That’s when I started to see a major slide with both UX & UI.
But wrt to the original topic, we live in a world now where people send hundreds of thousands of dollars to Instagram marketers who have never purchased a multi/ self storage/ commercial etc style property but have 200k followers from repairing doors without priming/ prepping them… so it’s definitely no surprise that this place is full of folks who want to talk a lot… if you’re good at the talk, or making a unit look good in photos for 30 days, that’s all it takes to grift people these days.
Some great and prolific contributors here still, and I used to give a crap about wanting to be one.. but once BP became focussed on the pump n dump/ business plan that fits on a cracker (or Instagram post) style content I just started deleting my account whenever the bumper sticker wisdom got too annoying. Now I’m gone for 6m at a time, minimum, before I even want to return.
Now, there are people that are giving advice, that never even pulled the trigger in one deal. It's filled with people that have a "passion" about REI, but only talk about it.
BP always had it's share of dreamers, but with the expolosion of BP memberships their share has exploded as well. There are a fair number of posts where one blind is leading another.
BP used to display #of votes and #of posts under the name. While that is not always a gurantee for quality, it was at lease some indication who you should listen to a little more.
I don't see builders ever catching up at least not in the short term what's happened with covid was not a real estate crash but a huge crash to the supply chain and price of components which has risen the cost to build a home significantly and land prices keep rising. Rents are going up but, in most places, NOT anywhere high enough to keep returns like they were 10 years ago. Returns keep going down on cash flow rentals across the board a solid 5 to 7% return is the norm on a stabilized quality asset.
I feel there is a wave of enthusiasm towards REI in the general public, which is lagging a few years after the period 10 years ago, where opportunities were abundent, but everyone was scared. With 5% to 7% returns public interest (the outer shell of the BP comunity) might shrink again over the next years. I wonder what that will do to BP as a business...
I don't see builders ever catching up at least not in the short term what's happened with covid was not a real estate crash but a huge crash to the supply chain and price of components which has risen the cost to build a home significantly and land prices keep rising. Rents are going up but, in most places, NOT anywhere high enough to keep returns like they were 10 years ago. Returns keep going down on cash flow rentals across the board a solid 5 to 7% return is the norm on a stabilized quality asset.
I feel there is a wave of enthusiasm towards REI in the general public, which is lagging a few years after the period 10 years ago, where opportunities were abundent, but everyone was scared. With 5% to 7% returns public interest (the outer shell of the BP comunity) might shrink again over the next years. I wonder what that will do to BP as a business...
I think we need to have some perspective. Large funds and very well to do investors are very happy with 4 to 7 caps on quality stabilized assets. its primarily the beginner or smaller mom and pop land lord that seems to have this criteria of ( and I love it when they say my criteria LOL) of needing a 10 cap or at least 10% coc so this moves them into assets the bigger investors by and large wont buy. Except for the hedge funds that went around the country scooping up a bunch of the C and D class sfrs and are still doing it.. WHY I don't understand personally .. I think you nailed it when you said most buy one or two homes and then stop.
I can see your votes and posts....
@Harry Arnold
I totally echo. Thanks for expressing things that I've been wanting to say for a long time. I often see posts or podcasts tilted as "millions of assets, $20K / month cash flow, hundred units at age 25" or "xxxxx within 2 years". It made people believe that real state investment is so easy and achieving financial freedom is a "low hanging fruit" which could happen over night. Definitely it's not. Those are "other people's stories" - they are not necessarily the truth just because they say so on BiggerPockets forum. REI is capital intense and how would a newbie investor invest in a buy and hold deal without steadily W2 income…(I often see posts reaction like "oh I'm 18 years old I want to get into real estate or I want to drop out college into REI). It takes a lot of efforts, education, failures, trial runs, and funds to get to one deal, then to second, then scaling to bigger deals…I always have my grain of salt on those success stories - the strategies they said in those stories in my opinions are mostly very high level, repetitive on the same thing over and over with little enlightening content to me (maybe it's not to others). Their real "know-how" may not be willing to share with others as to how they scale up. To those newbie investors - don't be fooled by those "successful stories" to believe that becoming financial freedom can take place within a few years. There is no quick money in this world. And you don't know their failures, caveats or risks involved behind their successful stories which they won't talk about.
BP used to display #of votes and #of posts under the name. While that is not always a gurantee for quality, it was at lease some indication who you should listen to a little more.
its still there if you use the old forum interface...
As for the topic at hand - businesses and ideas go thru life cycles just like people do. We are at the monetization phase of BP where content is driven to the newbie who will buy books etc etc. (and if you think about us "experienced folks' are contributing for free to this monetization)
What I find interesting is folks saying that they have seen a change since 2015.... well hate to tell you but BP has been around a lot longer than that and REI has been a fundamental wealth builder for over 100 years. It just got popular when the gut and cheaply reno shows took off (to the detriment of thousands of amazing old houses that were gutted and ruined) .....
So i guess it's all in where you are in your life cycle, being an investor, being on BP, etc.
But as I have said more times that I remember BP is full of sharks ready to eat all the guppies.... that is the ENTIRE point of it.