Hey dudes,
I've enjoyed reading all 15 pages of this convo! I think I represent a group that hasn't been heard from yet:
I started in properties around the $100k mark... and gravitated toward this market... and these are the only type of properties I'm super interested in anymore. I guess that runs completely contrary to what a lot of people feel. Let me discuss why:
1.) The properties I go for tend to have awesome features like Art Deco style built-in bookshelves, hardwood floors which are very cheap to maintain and keep looking good, higher grade building materials, and overall better craftsmanship. My first house was a cookie-cutter track home and it has had numerous problems despite my paying entirely too much. Older homes often times have more character and are in neighborhoods with other cool, older homes. Call me crazy, but I just think claw-foot bathtubs and high ceilings are awesome. Fortunately many tenants agree.
2.) Bang for the buck. @David Beard Yes, I've been doing this for well over 5 years. The ROI is insane when compared to my more expensive properties. Proper tenant screening and regular maintenance alleviate 99% of my problems.
3.) Depreciation recapture. If you're going to 1031 exchange your properties later on down the road, it's easy to point towards depreciation as a major part of your strategy. If you are buying lower-end houses, you may find that you prefer to not have as much depreciation recapture to deal with at a later point. Higher end financed houses with a lot of depreciation I consider to be almost doubly leveraged.
4.) Carrying costs. I love not having to fret about vacancies in my low-tax, low-cost insurance, high-demand rental market.
5.) Free money. The more astute BPers get into hard-money loans, big dollar deals, etc. I do a lot of small deals. For example, I bought a house for $25k with an ARV of $60k. The bathroom floor had fallen through. I had it up and running for $30k, refinanced it for $40k, took the $10k tax/interest free and the house still cash flows $460 a month plus prinicipal of $50/month (increasing month to month of course.) I like these kinds of setups.
6.) Despite being able to sometimes work deals like #5, I hate dealing with financing.
Ben