Home Warranty Decision(s) for entire portfolio

Home Warranty Decision(s) for entire portfolio

Real Estate Investor · Des Moines, IA · Member since 2016 · 922 posts · 533 votes

We were just yesterday looking at some options for home warranty type of services and I think crowd-sourcing this one may help:

The provider we were looking at specifically was HomeServe, however there are numerous other companies.  Details in the fine print do matter, for instance a typically large and padded, profitable expense for HVAC companies is their crazy markups on their refrigerant, and there's a max of 1lb of charge that would be covered under the HVAC portion of the plan.

Our biggest pain points given where we are (7 rentals currently) has been finding competent and trustworthy people in the HVAC and plumbing fields.  We are in that middle ground where we don't have enough stuff come in where we can keep the good people locked in/engaged, but we've got enough stuff that we need help.

The two strategies that we think are most viable are to evaluate doing a piecemeal (a la carte) approach to the use of these warranties, or to just pay for all for all properties.  For instance, of our 7 rentals perhaps the ones with 10+ year old water heaters, we pay the $7/mo or so for the water heater repair/replace plan.  The available options for warranties break down into things like:

  1. exterior main water line coverage
  2. exterior main sewer line coverage
  3. interior plumbing line coverage
  4. HVAC (cooling system) coverage
  5. HVAC (heating system) coverage
  6. hot water heater coverage
  7. electrical system coverage

We broke down two viable options:

Option 1:  Evaluate Risk/reward likelihood on each property as to whether we get individual coverage, total yearly cost of this is ~$2100/yr which comes to approximately ~2% of our gross rents

Option 2: Go with full coverage on every property we own, total yearly cost of this is ~$5100/yr, which comes to approximately 4.5% of our gross rents.

We usually work off a 15% goal/assumption (of gross rents) that allows for costs tied to vacancy/maintenance/capEx items, which so far (been operating for 3-4 years) we have been significantly under that. Barring a few major CapEx items like new furnace/ACs, we have been fortunate and doing well based on this. Our rents are towards the top of market.

I'm often cranking on actively managing a project, as I am now - the cost/hit to profitability is big but it does feel like we are at a point to absorb it and it makes business sense.  I'm getting pulled in enough directions that evaluating options for property management has already been 

We enjoy the tenant management side of things, think that the rent pricing is absolutely critical to keeping things on the up-and-up, and we also think managing the turns is something that makes sense for us over time - so I think getting the help per the above makes some sense.  I would say I'm leaning towards pulling the trigger on the Option 2, but I wanted to crowd-source other thoughts from the community.

Going this route wouldn't completely excuse us from the 'hands on' management, however things like roofs, wrapping windows, and other maintenance items I've found the ability to provide a lot of value between using our bucket truck and metal break.  Other past maintenance items that may come up that we've had would include things like:

  1. Garage doors/opener issues
  2. Bugs
  3. Roofs
  4. Exterior maintenance items (gutters, fascia, soffit, etc)

I'd be really interested in any thoughts from the community from going down this road. To me this seems like a reasonable other option for the current point in time given that we are in the area and still actively manage our properties. It seems that retail rates for property managers have us give up too much - we usually are looking at terms like : 6% of gross rent, 1st month rent for tenant placements, and that's not even counting costs and markups from the actual work (ie: Capex, maintenance etc)

Thanks in advance!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Jim

0Reply
189 views

Most Popular Reply

Realtor and Investor · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
8y

It appears as though you have put alot of thought into this.  However, picking apart a warranty for ala carte items may prove to be more expensive in the end.  Look into Old Republic Home Protection, or maybe Fidelity.  They both offer basic to premiere coverages with add ons for things like appliances, roof leaks, pools, etc.

And don't be tricked by that 1 lb refigerant coverage.  It usually takes more than that when an HVAC guy comes out.  They can have 1 lb just sitting in their hose while evaluating your system.  So, that line item is like, "thanks, but really?".  You would be better suited to find a company that LIMITS the amount they can charge for the coolant, rather than covering a minimal amount.

I understand your dilema.  My husband and I had similar conversations.  It seems like once you go over 8-9 properties, the annual fee is so expensive that you are tempted to just put that money in an account as a reserve for something going wrong.  The problem is that if all 8-9 HVACs go out, you're stuck.  What's the likelihood of that happening?...probably MINIMAL, but like ANY type of insurance, do you want to take that chance?

I wonder if any of these home warranty companies have a blanket policy for multiple units...??  May be a good question when you do your evaluating.

One last thought.... insurance is just that.  I have paid my car insurance for almost 30 years, and I have been in only 2 accidents where I was at fault.  It sucks to pay that every year, but I wouldn't be caught without it!  I feel like home warranties are the same way.

See this reply in the discussion

29 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Investor · Des Moines, IA · Member since 2016 · 922 posts · 533 votes
    8y

    @James Wise

    We'll go in circles on this one to be honest.  It's not my job/responsibility to convince you.  We live with the results of our decisions. 

    However - if you're lumping insurance into your same bucket of needless expenses would it be safe to assume you go without health insurance then?  Because they make profit?  Because their outflows are less than their inflows?

    Also, there is a service provided by AHS.  Yes, maybe it's not high value but dispatching companies to a site is SOMETHING.  

    I've also suggested that I feel I have a high opportunity cost of my TIME which is another major factor to consider.  No one can consider that quite in the way I can.

    Further, there are situations where other companies (for instance a supplier) may have a different cost than I might.  In theory, if that company can pass along some cost savings our way then there may be a win-win.  At the end of it all they do have to decide if they want to retain us as customers in terms of how they handle various things that come up.

    In practice, we will see.  But it is possible under the right circumstances.  

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    8y

    @Jim Goebel

    However - if you're lumping insurance into your same bucket of needless expenses would it be safe to assume you go without health insurance then? Because they make profit? Because their outflows are less than their inflows?

    Again. Apples & Oranges.  As I am a healthy individual who was self employed and in my 20's during much of that period, yes I would have. However the Obama administration forced us to buy insurance.

    Today, I am on my wife's insurance because her employer covers the majority of that cost. Doesn't mean that the cost between what I pay & what her employer pays is cheaper than not having it tho.

  • Real Estate Investor · Des Moines, IA · Member since 2016 · 922 posts · 533 votes
    8y

    @James Wise

    You're not speaking to the intent of my questions James.

    You're the one that came in with a one size fits all (DONT USE HOME WARRANTY COMPANIES) statement.

    The point here is that under some circumstances is makes sense to buy insurance.  So your reasoning is not apt in making that recommendation.  The conclusion might serve, but we will see.  Sounds like you've got it figured out.

  • Realtor and Investor · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Jim Goebel:

    @Robert Gilstrap
    @Joni Chin

    @Cara Lonsdale
    @Mike McCarthy
    @Fred Heller

    OK sorry for the many tags if any of you are NOT interested in following this, please let me know.  I for one have gotten a great deal of value on threads that follow up and provide info over time.  So here goes....

    About 3 months ago we converted our ENTIRE portfolio (we're at 9 units, with 10 doors - one is a duplex and the rest are SFHs) to a complete Home Warranty - and went with American Home Shield, with supplemental coverage for the main sewer and main water lines offered through Des Moines Water Works (they work through a company called HomeServe).  Our 'typical' or 'model' affords some nice cash flow and for the most part we are VERY happy with our tenant mix so I think this may be relevant for our decision justification.  I have some friends where they are operating a 'different' rental business where their margins are a lot thinner so that roughly $60/mo added cost per property would not be tenable.  Note: the duplex they hit us for the premium on a per unit basis.

    So, it's not an insubstantial cost going out the window every month - roughly $500 let's call it.  We're 3 months in and have initiated 4 calls (work orders etc) to date.

    Here have been our data points, with both financials and some more 'color' on how they've gone:

    Early April 2018: First Call in was a Stop Box failure where it failed in the open position and tenant had not been paying Water Bill for entire tenacy.  I was disappointed in the responsiveness of DMWW with regards to providing us notice of the situation.  It wasn't until 5 months after this all started (and they tried to shut off the tenants' water) that we got a letter letting us know the situation.  (by the way, this is our last BAD tenant and he's out now).  Anyways, this was a HomeServe call and they initially indicated that they were unsure/doubtful they needed to respond to the situation because it was non-emergency.  We had some back and forth about what constitutes an emergency, and she did relent and agree to dispatch someone.  The company they dispatched it also mentioned the word emergency and I again had to push back and state our case that it WAS in fact an emergency.  They did do it, however, and they did a great and quick job.  I don't know how much stop box replacement projects cost and we typically don't pay retail prices for anything.  However, there was NO deductible on this and they did a great job.  I'm guessing we would have been out $500 and 2 days of my time to manage this project, or average (just got that from an article from Des Moines Register) labor cost of $1183 if we were to do it more 'turnkey'.  In either case especially given the timing of this item I'm thrilled with how it went.

    Late April 2018: We initiated a call also to HomeServe when we had a severe (nasty) backup with a lateral floor drain on one of our rentals.  We aren't sure of the cause but suspect one possibility was a day laborer from Ghana (really nice young man) that just didn't know what was appropriate to go down the toilet.  This was during a turn period and we actually let a new tenant for another house stay in the house for a week while we completed updates on their permanent home, when this happened.  Again, HomeServe this time on the sewer side, dispatched (with no fighting this time) a Drain type plumber.  They came in, did a great job, and we haven't had any more issues.  No deductible there.  Guessing this would have been a $150-250 type call if going with a Roto Rooter (don't ever hire them by the way) and I can't trust them as far as I can spit so who knows it may have turned into a disastrous main sewer line replacement if my one experience with them was representative...  

    Early May 2018: Got an AC call on a house owned under an IRA. Called AHS and they dispatched local company. Diagnosis was that the compressor was gone, in the condensing unit. After a couple frustrating conversations with AHS trying to explain the difference between a diagnosis and prognosis (I was frustrated they just wanted to replace the compressor or rather that's all they would pay for - when because this is an R22 unit and older unit, we felt it was about time to replace the coil and condensing unit). As a side note, the 'trump card' for the companies that work through AHS is their crazy markup on refrigerant. AHS only covers $10/lb of this stuff and that gets you like 5% of what these companies charge... At something like 400-500% markup, by the way... Anyways, we had to learn a bit more about AHS's process and we learned you can request what's called a cash in lieu amount. The catch is that they apparently want to 'kind of' stay involved in the project at least in terms of verifying something was done and they have communicated they want someone licensed and insured to do it. Largely because of all this we decided to go with the company they originally dispatched. They came in at $3700 less the cash in lieu amount of $775 so just under $3k for this project. Sucks paying retail and I feel.. Middle of the road when just looking at this project in terms of AHS. I feel confident I could get the project done for closer to $2000 total if I was managing it, however both because this house is under IRA and there's additional rules and possible scrutiny there, but because AHS was insisting on essentially verifying the licensed/insured part, we pulled the trigger on this one.

    Yesterday: Initial call from tenant was AC not working.  We had it charged recently so that's peculiar.  Upon further examination, something weird is happening electrically on condenser unit circuit.  Like, something I've never seen before - it makes a violent rattling sound when the AC condenser is running, and that circuit breaker (a 30A/2P) is closed.  Sound is right above the panel.  This work order is in process and they dispatched a company that has experience/licenses on both the AC and the electrical side.  My suspicion is that the panel 'should' be replaced as it is a Federal Pacific and such... We will see on this one.

    In total I feel with this pretty steady outflow of $500 / mo we are at roughly $1500 cost for these services.

    My analysis on this decision goes something like this:

    Let's sum our costs, and compare to our benefits.. Which consist both of money saved, and time saved (I have to put some assumption of what my opportunity cost of time is)

    On the Cost side, we're at the $1500 total roughly.

    On the benefit side, we'd be at $1183 + $200 + $0 (I think this outflow is pretty 'in line' with a turnkey AC replacement option given the above constaints...  + (not sure we'll see how the most recent electrical / AC one turns out) + my time saved which I'm estimating would be at maybe 2 days total to deal with these items one way or another (either actively manage or vet/bid stuff etc)...  Which I'd put my time at invaluable :)  Maybe $300/day, I don't know....  

    So I'm getting something like a $1500 cost vs a $2000 benefit.  With HomeServe really being the star of the show mostly just because of the data points we've had so far.   Yes, I'd do it again, as of right now.  Will try to follow up every so often.

     Thanks for the update Jim!

    This all sounds about right.  Regarding the HVAC "settlement", I am surprised that AHS wanted to stay involved in the replacement.  That is usually what "settlement" means.  They want to know it was completed in order to further cover the item, but they don't have any input in the fix.  So, this surprised me.

    We took one of these type of settlements from Old Republic for our pool filter.  They wanted to repair the equipment that we knew was needing replacement, so we initiated the settlement.  All we needed to do was submit our receipt of completion from our installer to prove that it was done, and keep it covered under the home warranty.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.