Marketing- SEO or Direct Mail

Marketing- SEO or Direct Mail

Rental Property Investor · Lancaster, CA · Member since 2023 · 9 posts · 4 votes

Hello Everyone!

Marketing Strategies -

Hope everyone is doing well, I have a (quick) question to ask ! So I have recently come into a little money, about $700. Not a lot I know but I am a hard-working guy who just moved out at 18 and I am trying my best to get to where I want to be. I have tried Direct Mail before and received about two calls back and spent about $400 on materials. I made and mailed all my yellow letters by hand to cut and save on costs.


From this, I realized two things-

1. I need to make my mailing lists smaller because I sent out one big thing of mail only one time. When I could've lowered coverage and sent it multiple times to a smaller lead group.

2. Direct Mail is expensive, time-consuming, and doesn't have a high conversion rate based on the amount of money I'm spending as well as the amount of time I am spending sitting on Property Radar hunting for the leads. 

So I am thinking my next move since I don't like how well the mail performed,  is to try SEO. I have a website built already and it's been up just floating about in the space of the internet with no organic searches. I spent the time making the website and I pay to keep it running. So why not pay and have my SEO optimized, to try and generate organic leads?

I'm not simply just gonna put down direct mail either. I know in the future I should be mailing to get and yield the most leads possible. It would be nice to have my back-burner website cooking away a few deals though. I know setting up and getting my SEO done on Fiver won't cost a lot of money, so with whatever is left I am most likely going on a few paths.

My Strategies and plan with what I am gonna do- 

1. SEO- spend money on SEO to get the back burner deals cooking away. Try to get the website at least ranked 3rd in my area.

2.  Dirt cheap bandit signs around town about 150 placed and dotted around local zip codes with hot spots of interest/traffic.

3. The rest of the money will be put away and saved for a 5-time mailing direct mail campaign. Property Radar just released a new dirt mail system for the program offering postcards at .48 per and it's already linked to all my lead lists and properties I have found. I am going to shrink them all down into what I think are the best homes out of the lot and mail to them consistently.

That most likely limits all that money. I want to ask is this the best use of that money? Should I go all into direct mail or should I go my 25/25/50 on SEO, Bandit signs, and mail? As well I do know I need a way to handle lead flow. If leads start to come in and I am at work how do I handle them? I heard people say to use Google Voice and set up a mailbox to get back to the motivated sellers, but is there a better way to handle leads when they start to come in? If Google Voice is the way how would I set the mailbox up to handle the leads other than leave a message and I will get back to you? That seems very unprofessional like I'm not with my phone ready to help them with their home sale. It also seems like the leads may pile up too high for me to handle sorting out the bad from the good leads.  Any help on the subject would be very helpful :)!

Bottom Line-

I am a young guy and the first deal really will change everything for me. I am still super excited even after about a year now of learning and entering into the community, yet to achieve a wholesale deal. Please any advice on my ideas or changes that may benefit them would be greatly appreciated and I appreciate the time you took to read this.

2Reply
526 views

Most Popular Reply

Flipper/Rehabber · Bakersfield, CA · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
2y

People on BP are too nice.  

Please stop.   For your own sake.  

SEO is at least a 6 month project that will cost a minimum of 2k a month and it will never get you top 3 results.  

Mail isn’t expensive done right. Done wrong absolutely a waste of money.  

Bandit signs are not legal in most areas.  So I’m not going to suggest that you break the law for your own gain.  

Your best hope if you have any is to network.   Pass out business cards to strangers and call friends.   Tell everyone you know and don’t know that you’re a real estate investor.  

The HUGE question I have is what happens when or if you get a deal?   Do you even know what a deal is?  Do you have an agreement to use?  Do you understand the laws surrounding purchase contracts?  

Real estate isn’t a get rich quick industry.  

See this reply in the discussion

17 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Minneapolis · Member since 2023 · 265 posts · 162 votes
    2y

    So lots of good ideas here.  I have some favorite marketing tips that might help you.  The best way to improve your SEO and Google performance is to study the hottest keywords for your business at trends.google.com - then load your website with the highest ranking keywords. Google only recognizes a word after 5 impressions... this is why websites are so repetitive, especially blogs. 


    To load up on the right keywords, add a simple blog page to your website. 

    To capture and nurture leads on a budget, look for free alternatives to ClickFunnels.  

    This should be a good start.

  • Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2017 · 109 posts · 30 votes
    2y

    I think you are throwing money at trying to generate leads which is fine but not with your limited budget.  I feel you would be better served by driving for dollars and putting together a small but targeted list of distressed properties that you can skip trace, call or mail the homeowner.  I never stop driving for dollars.  I have at least 1-2 times a month that I dedicate 3-4 hours of driving.  I always come back to the office with at least 15-20 homes to put on my list.  This is the most cost effective strategy if you have a limited budget.  Then when you close on your first deal, I would parlay the entire profits back into the business.  In fact I'd do this with the first 2-3 flips and schedule out your budget for the next 2-3 years using that money.  This way you don't have to think about how or if you can generate leads.  The system will be in place for at least a little while.  Then get busy getting busy flipping properties.

  • Investor · Tampa, FL · Member since 2015 · 63 posts · 59 votes
    2y

    $700 isn’t enough for direct mail - you need to budget for 6 months of direct mail before you start. 

    SEO is a long term game that will take 12 months minimum to see any benefit.

    If I were you, I would do driving for dollars and use the money to buy the deal machine app and mojo dialer and coke call your leads. I have heard that Deal machine now includes Skip tracing so you don’t need that (assuming the data is there and is good). If you find the data is not good, you’ll need to pay for skip tracing.

    Go to YouTube and find Zach Boothe. Watch his 40 day challenge. 

    Once you start doing deals, you can roll the profits back in to the business and start doing direct mail - I’d start with your D4$ list and then add other niche lists as your budget grows.

    Open a separate checking account dedicated to marketing and budget 6 months of mail, so if you have $6k, you would do $1k per month with 1/4 of that dropping every week. You want to hit the same people every 30-45 days. With postcard rates at roughly $0.50 each that would get you 500 postcards per week.

  • Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2023 · 6 posts · 4 votes
    2y

    Congrats on the 700 bucks but that's not going to get you anything for marketing. I would actually suggest you spend that money to get your real estate license and hang your license with an e-brokerage. You need to be building capital and to do that you need to do deals that don't cost you any money. MLS should be your best friend for the next 18 months. Wholesale some deals, build capital, learn the business, and then move into paid marketing campaigns.

  • Rental Property Investor · Lancaster, CA · Member since 2023 · 9 posts · 4 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Adrian Pedraza:

    Congrats on the 700 bucks but that's not going to get you anything for marketing. I would actually suggest you spend that money to get your real estate license and hang your license with an e-brokerage. You need to be building capital and to do that you need to do deals that don't cost you any money. MLS should be your best friend for the next 18 months. Wholesale some deals, build capital, learn the business, and then move into paid marketing campaigns.


     Great advice :). I’ll finish up my license asap that’s been on my list as well I started taking marketing and business classes at my local college. 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · CA · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Brandon Flores:
    Quote from @Adrian Pedraza:

    Congrats on the 700 bucks but that's not going to get you anything for marketing. I would actually suggest you spend that money to get your real estate license and hang your license with an e-brokerage. You need to be building capital and to do that you need to do deals that don't cost you any money. MLS should be your best friend for the next 18 months. Wholesale some deals, build capital, learn the business, and then move into paid marketing campaigns.


     Great advice :). I’ll finish up my license asap that’s been on my list as well I started taking marketing and business classes at my local college. 


     D. All of the above.

    Grind culture dude, run a tight budget & cast a wide net. That's how most small businesses are built. Very best of luck to you!

  • Investor · Tacoma, WA · Member since 2021 · 97 posts · 28 votes
    2y

    I'd say email marketing is one of the best ways to reach people, especially in this niche. You just need to know how to do it.

    For example, I use this email checker and finder: https://mailtester.ninja/. It costs $10/month, but I can check up to 100k emails per day. I do this because if you send emails to the wrong recipients (like the ones that don't exist anymore), then it affects your sender's reputation.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Bakersfield, CA · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y

    People on BP are too nice.  

    Please stop.   For your own sake.  

    SEO is at least a 6 month project that will cost a minimum of 2k a month and it will never get you top 3 results.  

    Mail isn’t expensive done right. Done wrong absolutely a waste of money.  

    Bandit signs are not legal in most areas.  So I’m not going to suggest that you break the law for your own gain.  

    Your best hope if you have any is to network.   Pass out business cards to strangers and call friends.   Tell everyone you know and don’t know that you’re a real estate investor.  

    The HUGE question I have is what happens when or if you get a deal?   Do you even know what a deal is?  Do you have an agreement to use?  Do you understand the laws surrounding purchase contracts?  

    Real estate isn’t a get rich quick industry.  

  • Specialist · Krakow, Europe · Member since 2019 · 87 posts · 25 votes
    2y

    Over the past three years, I’ve been using most of the major off-market techniques.

    One standout method has always been pulling data and feeding it into a call center to generate off-market leads. In my opinion, this is much more effective than texting, which often feels like a constant game of cat and mouse with phone carriers. It’s relatively simple and, while it does cost money, it’s one of the more cost-effective options. That said, expect to deal with a fair amount of fluff leads.

    The two best strategies I’ve found are inbound methods: direct mail and Google Ads.

    As you mentioned, direct mail can be expensive, but it can also result in highly discounted properties.

    Regarding SEO, while it’s a valuable strategy, it’s not necessarily "cheap." SEO takes several months to produce results, and the process can be slow and costly.

    Google Ads, on the other hand, doesn’t require data extraction like calls, direct mail, or texting. However, it does demand solid digital marketing expertise to see positive results. These days, I’m all in on Google Ads.

    Since it seems you are pretty new, and I saw it on the replies - finding properties by doing Drive 4 Dollars can be a great start, and then skip tracing their details and calling them directly.

  • Specialist · Bothell, WA · Member since 2014 · 269 posts · 80 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Doug Lovett:

    $700 isn’t enough for direct mail - you need to budget for 6 months of direct mail before you start. 

    SEO is a long term game that will take 12 months minimum to see any benefit.

    If I were you, I would do driving for dollars and use the money to buy the deal machine app and mojo dialer and coke call your leads. I have heard that Deal machine now includes Skip tracing so you don’t need that (assuming the data is there and is good). If you find the data is not good, you’ll need to pay for skip tracing.

    Go to YouTube and find Zach Boothe. Watch his 40 day challenge. 

    Once you start doing deals, you can roll the profits back in to the business and start doing direct mail - I’d start with your D4$ list and then add other niche lists as your budget grows.

    Open a separate checking account dedicated to marketing and budget 6 months of mail, so if you have $6k, you would do $1k per month with 1/4 of that dropping every week. You want to hit the same people every 30-45 days. With postcard rates at roughly $0.50 each that would get you 500 postcards per week.


     This is great advice. $700 is a solid budget to cold call for 3 months and try to find deals. This is what I would do + driving for dollars + networking with neighbors.

  • Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    9mo

    I’ve had the best results by pairing both. SEO takes longer but can build steady inbound leads, while direct mail brings quicker action if your list is solid. How much money were you thinking of putting into this? The budget can really change which one makes more sense to start with.

  • Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    9mo

    I’ve also tried both, and the biggest difference came from having someone help me mix short-term wins with long-term wins. 

    A marketingová agentura I worked with handled my SEO while I kept some budget for direct mail, so I wasn’t putting all my eggs in one basket. SEO took a bit to kick in, but once it did, the leads were steadier and cheaper, and the direct mail filled the gaps early on.

  • Bo SmithPro Member
    Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 1k+ posts · 378 votes
    9mo

    Honestly man, you're thinking about this backwards. $700 split three ways won't move the needle on any of them. Pick ONE channel and go deep - I'd skip SEO (takes 6-12 months) and bandit signs (compliance nightmare). That Property Radar postcard thing at 48 cents is solid though. But here's what nobody talks about - your follow-up system matters more than your marketing channel. Two calls back from $400 spend isn't bad if you actually worked those leads properly. Did you follow up 7 times over 2 weeks or just wait for them to call back?

  • Anaheim Hills, CA · Member since 2026 · 8 posts · 3 votes
    7mo

    A lot of solid advice in this thread, but I want to push back on one thing: the idea that SEO can never get you top 3 results.

    That's true for broad, high-competition terms like "houses for sale in Lancaster" or "sell my house fast California." You are not beating Zillow and Realtor.com for those. Ever.

    But that is not where the opportunity is anyway.

    Hyperlocal and long-tail keywords are a completely different story. Phrases like "sell my house fast in [neighborhood]," "we buy houses [zip code]," or even your own company name and brand terms? Those are absolutely winnable, and at a fraction of the cost people assume.

    When I google "Real Estate Investor Lancaster" here's what I see; note #1 and #3 are for regular guys just like you, Yelp is #2, definitely doable to get into the top 3 here.  

    The mistake most people make is targeting the wrong keywords from the start, getting no results, and then concluding SEO doesn't work. It works fine. You just have to pick fights you can actually win.

    For someone at Brandon's budget and stage, Michael is right that SEO is not the move right now. The timeline is too long and the budget is too thin. Driving for dollars and direct outreach will get you to your first deal faster. But don't write off SEO permanently. Once you have some capital and a little runway, a well-targeted local SEO strategy absolutely can generate consistent inbound leads without ongoing ad spend.

    I've been doing SEO for 15 years. Happy to answer any follow-up questions.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.