Zillow-itis

Zillow-itis

Rental Property Investor · Kansas City, KS · Member since 2014 · 604 posts · 222 votes

How do you approach a potential seller when you know you have to tell them their house is only worth about 2/3 what the Zestimate is even once it's rehabbed? The guy wants "30k FIRM" for the property saying it's worth $78k on Zillow...but the few comps I've looked at in the area only support an ARV of about $45k (and even that may be a little generous). Do I just give him the straight numbers and explain to him that Zillow is NOT the best barometer for market prices then make the low-ball offer even though it may tick him off? Realistically I'd only be able to give him about half of what he's asking but it seems like they're pretty desperate to move (as in they won't even have the money to move until the property sells). Thanks.

0Reply
57 views

Most Popular Reply

Involved In Real Estate · Olathe, KS · Member since 2014 · 10 posts · 5 votes
12y

As an agent, I'm biased and recommend using one of us! :) Zillow has been significantly underestimating values in Johnson County KS all year, and my listing clients have been genuinely surprised with how much their homes actually sold for vs what they thought they could net by selling By Owner.  It's fascinating how Zillow and Trulia's accuracy, even among adjacent markets or cities within the same metro area, can vary so drastically.

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • J. MartinPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Oakland, CA · Member since 2011 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y

    @Jim Viens ,

    Do you another investor you can get a recent appraisal for another home for to show him? Or show him the comps directly around his home, instead of the probably much bigger circle that Zillow is drawing..? 

    Even my appraiser on my refi had to talk me down on my value a bit, but I was a little more understanding after he explained the distance he was looking at. And I know how this stuff works, so hopefully should help you too.. 
    Good luck!

  • Rental Property Investor · Kansas City, KS · Member since 2014 · 604 posts · 222 votes
    12y

    I actually found some good comps on the county appraiser's website and saved the PDF to provide him. Hopefully that will be sufficient.

  • Investor · Howey in the Hills, FL · Member since 2013 · 376 posts · 114 votes
    12y

    On their website, Zillow admits that their Zestimates are within 5% of market value only 50% of the time. You could direct sellers there.

    When sellers are so fixated on a number like that, I just tell them to take a week and do some research. Ask some real estate agents, etc. If they're really motivated they will, and they'll realize their property isn't worth as much as Zillow says it is.

  • Real Estate Broker · Orange, CT · Member since 2013 · 951 posts · 218 votes
    12y

    Show him MLS sales sheets and explain why Zillow is not accurate.

  • Rental Property Investor · Kansas City, KS · Member since 2014 · 604 posts · 222 votes
    12y

    Thanks for the input guys. Didn't realize Zillow had that disclaimer @Matthew B. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Kansas City, KS · Member since 2014 · 604 posts · 222 votes
    12y

    Wow...Just looked at the Zestimate accuracy page and see that the Kansas City market only has 1 out of 5 stars for accuracy. Basically going off the county appraised values, aka: "Your guess is as good as ours."

  • Residential Realtor · Leawood, KS · Member since 2014 · 47 posts · 13 votes
    12y

    Jim, are you approaching a seller to buy the house yourself and flip it? I'd be glad to look at it and give you my opinion

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    @Jim Viens if you worry about hurting peoples feelings or ticking them off, you'll never buy anything. Just document the numbers and give him a rational explanation of why the property is only worth what you are offering. He can either accept it or reject it.

  • Involved In Real Estate · Olathe, KS · Member since 2014 · 10 posts · 5 votes
    12y

    As an agent, I'm biased and recommend using one of us! :) Zillow has been significantly underestimating values in Johnson County KS all year, and my listing clients have been genuinely surprised with how much their homes actually sold for vs what they thought they could net by selling By Owner.  It's fascinating how Zillow and Trulia's accuracy, even among adjacent markets or cities within the same metro area, can vary so drastically.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Aransas Pass, TX · Member since 2014 · 21 posts · 28 votes
    12y

    JayT from Zillow here. 

    It's a Zestimate, not a Zappraisal or Zprice. ;)

    In all seriousness, the Zestimate isn't intended to, and can't, replace the opinion of a real estate professional. Here's an article I wrote on Zillow's blog on dealing with "Zestimate objections" 

    http://www.zillow.com/blog/pro/but-zillow-says-my-...

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.