The first state in the nation to make solar mandatory for new builds starting in 2020 . Pros? Cons?
Hi @Account Closed I'm happy to run numbers with you in AZ, because what you have posted is certainly no reflection of the reality I work with there. My latest customer, for example in Prescott Valley had a utility bill averaging $183. We eliminated that bill with a solar system that costs him $149/month for 20 years with no increase. If you factor in inflation on the utility at 4% annually then he will save tens of thousands over 20 years. He did not come out of pocket one cent to do that with the zero down loan.
For sure batteries are the next massive step that is and will happen in solar and renewable, but for now the utility is the "battery" through net metering. The over-production from solar is purchased by the utility. At night power is purchased back from the utility. The goal to offset that overall bill to zero - depending on the roof space etc.
There are some small utilities in AZ that have punitive conditions for solar, but for the overwhelming majority, the numbers for solar in AZ are excellent. Batteries are already economically viable in CA because of the cost of utility power. It will be around 24 months before that's the case in AZ
Sure, it's annoying to have to be forced into using solar. But I believe in 20 years we'll look back and ask ourselves, "Why didn't we make that switch sooner?" That's all CA is trying to do.
Perhaps photovoltaic solar is as good as it gets, but I believe that the best is yet to come. What it will be, I can't say. Someday fusion but that always seems to be a couple of decades away. China actually has 58 nuclear reactors in the works. Those include thorium MSR reactors which are much safer and create safer waste compared to uranium reactors. Bill Gates and Jeff Bezos are investing heavily in forth-generation nuclear reactors. They do not want to see the United States fall behind China as the leader in nuclear power because they believe that nuclear is an important component of a low carbon energy future.
Honestly, I don't know if MSR, forth-generation or fusion will be major energy sources in 20 years. Twenty years ago I might have guessed that natural gas or bio-diesel cars might have replaced a lot of our gasoline cars by now since peak oil seemed like a sure thing. That didn't happen. Let's admit that none of us knows and not lock ourselves in to a single technology.
Agreed. If somebody perfects the Mr. Fusion Home Energy Reactor coupled with a flux capacitor I can use to power my DeLorean, I'm all for it.
If only there were some kind of massive fusion reactor that was accessible to us on a daily basis, perhaps in the sky. Imagine if we could just harness the power of that fusion reactor and get endless renewable energy!
They are building quite a large fusion reactor in France. I'm not holding my breath though. I've had high hopes before.
That’s crazy Andrew, we should just keep digging up fossils and burning them until we completely smoke ourselves out. Because, you know, market forces and windmills and China.
Anytime California does a stunt like this it means some politician has a cousin, uncle or spouse benefiting.
This will just give California more regulatory powers and let socialism continue to metastasize in state government. Nothing like solar should be “mandatory”.
@Steve K. More regulation! Yuck. Look at the items you wrote. That’s probably 20,000 pages of regulations.
@Steven Picker that state is screwed.
@Christopher Lombardi Says the guy from New Jersey. Haven’t you guys been in danger of defaulting on your massive debt for years? What is it up to now, $150B? I just read today everybody is dumping NJ bonds, again. It seems like every week the S&P is downgrading New Jersey. But yeah CA sure has it rough.
@Steve K. I agree, NJ is screwed as well. CA, IL, NY and NJ, the 4 states that have a mass exodus happening right now. These politicians are idiots. As for the solar panel thing, financially, solar panels never make sense. They cost much more than getting your electricity the traditional way from the power companies. I'm not sure how CA plans to pay for it or specifically what the law said, but I'm sure its going to hurt everyone. As far as how good they are for the environment, solar panels dont last very long and when disposed of, the toxic metals that they contain are very harmful to the environment. Right now they dont have enough solar panel recycling facilities to have them recycled so the way it is now, instead of polluting with fossil fuels, its polluting grounds and water with toxic metals.
Actually, isnt CA almost exclusively nuclear power anyway right now?
@Steve K. I agree, NJ is screwed as well. CA, IL, NY and NJ, the 4 states that have a mass exodus happening right now. These politicians are idiots. As for the solar panel thing, financially, solar panels never make sense. They cost much more than getting your electricity the traditional way from the power companies. I'm not sure how CA plans to pay for it or specifically what the law said, but I'm sure its going to hurt everyone. As far as how good they are for the environment, solar panels dont last very long and when disposed of, the toxic metals that they contain are very harmful to the environment. Right now they dont have enough solar panel recycling facilities to have them recycled so the way it is now, instead of polluting with fossil fuels, its polluting grounds and water with toxic metals.
Actually, isnt CA almost exclusively nuclear power anyway right now?
This must be a record for the most factual inaccuracies and false statements in one paragraph.
1) Solar achieved grid parity with fossil fuel power almost a decade ago. In many States - especially CA - it is far less expensive for homeowners to produce their own power from solar than purchase from utilities.
2) Solar panels typically have production guarantees for 25 years with 0.5% degradation/yr max. That means that they are guaranteed to produce 87.5% AT LEAST in 25 years of what they start out life producing. That means they will likely continue producing for decades more. That does vary by manufacturer, but that is typical for reputable solar.
3) Because of the lifespan there are simply not enough degraded panels to make recycling economical. If you have no raw materials i.e. degraded panels, it's pretty hard to recycle them. NO DOUBT panels will be recycled as more degrade and recycling becomes economically viable. Combine this with manufacturing and recycling using solar power as their own power source and it's pretty obvious that solar is massively less impactful than fossil fuels.
4) In 8 seconds on Google, the data appeared as if by magic showing nuclear being 9% of CA's production https://www.energy.ca.gov/almanac/electricity_data/total_system_power.html
5) As a sidebar on nuclear, people need to become educated on San Onofre. SoCal's Fukushima in-waiting. The lies told about nuclear are horrific. I't's my son's generation and beyond that will have that to deal with though so no issue for short-termists I suppose. https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-chapple-san-onofre-20180815-story.html
To dispel an other couple of myths and falsehoods:
6) Dirty panels do not produce significantly less power than clean ones. Unless you live next to a guano mine then power production is reduced by less than 1% with typical dirt. Panels clean easily with one decent rainfall. The maintenance costs then should be $0. There are industries being spawned like solar panel cleaning companies. While these are unnecessary, it is for the greater economic good I suppose.
7) Tariffs, while ludicrous, have not significantly increased costs. Roughly 65% of the cost of a system is in human beings rather than the equipment. That's another reason not to wait to go solar if considering it on the basis that costs will fall. Even if panels reduce some relative to cost/KwH that will be offset by labor cost increase and certainly by the scheduled reduction in tax credits starting this year.
8) Not every home can go solar. Roof aspect/shading etc mean that not every home qualifies. This is factored into the mandate.
9) A lot of myths would be dispelled if people consider the underlying grid right now. Right now we dig, mine or drill for fossil fuels. We transport them all across the planet burning more fossil fuels to do it, and requiring massive human and economic costs in protecting the supply lines. We then burn them to boil water to turn turbines. Literally steam engine technology. Energy loss in power plants averages 65%. Add a further 10-20% in losses on the grid transportation and it's around 23 quadrillion BTU of loss. Solar panels sit in place on your roof producing power. It is converted in an inverter on your garage wall and brought into your house. Which do you think is more efficient? Seriously. Which requires trillions of dollars of maintenance and which does not?
10) CO2 has been known as a heat trapping environmental gas for over a century. Adding trillions of tons of CO2 to the atmosphere is impacting the climate. We can see it in real time right now. One residential solar system offsets the same CO2 as planting around 5000 trees that grow for 10 years. Sometimes we have to cut down a tree or a few trees to make solar work on a home. We sacrifice one or a few for 5000. If you visualize a BMW X5. Now think what that weighs. That weight of CO2 is saved from the atmosphere EVERY MONTH because a home goes solar.
11) Globally, around 1 in every 4 deaths are related to the environment. From extraction to transportation to burning and disposal, to climate change, fossil fuels are a huge factor. Their use and the grid we know got us to being the greatest nation on earth and all developed societies have energy in common. It has come at a massive price, we know it. We can and must do better. CA leads the World in being proactive.
https://www.acsh.org/news/2016/09/21/globally-about-1-4-human-deaths-are-due-environmental-factors-10198
As someone who lives in CA, and is burdened by high taxes and high cost of living. This doesn't make me happy. I tried to push for solar panels to the HOA so we can reduce the price of our electricity and when I found out high expensive it was, it didn't make sense. Yes you DO save money in the long run but most people don't live in their house for 20 or 30 years.
The technology will get more and more affordable but right now the price is too high.
As someone who lives in CA, and is burdened by high taxes and high cost of living. This doesn't make me happy. I tried to push for solar panels to the HOA so we can reduce the price of our electricity and when I found out high expensive it was, it didn't make sense. Yes you DO save money in the long run but most people don't live in their house for 20 or 30 years.
The technology will get more and more affordable but right now the price is too high.
If you are paying cash for a system, there is a period before you get an ROI. Typically 7-11 years depending on a number of factors. If you are financing - as most people do - the goal of a system would be at worst to replace your spend with utility and in CA more likely save money monthly out of the gate. That is with ZERO out of pocket. Zero out and saving money means instant ROI in most peoples' minds.
Every circumstance is different. If it was the whole HOA looking at a community solar project that is a whole different world of commercial solar. It would depend on the financing and how the HOA were billing the homeowners.
All financed systems consider that homeowners move. That's why in terms of owned systems at least it is an easy transfer or simple payoff. NAR and CAR both consider systems raise the value of your home.
Did you push your HOA for a community solar project or for solar for your own home? Do you have a communal roof or is it an SFR?
@Steve K. I agree, NJ is screwed as well. CA, IL, NY and NJ, the 4 states that have a mass exodus happening right now. These politicians are idiots. As for the solar panel thing, financially, solar panels never make sense. They cost much more than getting your electricity the traditional way from the power companies. I'm not sure how CA plans to pay for it or specifically what the law said, but I'm sure its going to hurt everyone. As far as how good they are for the environment, solar panels dont last very long and when disposed of, the toxic metals that they contain are very harmful to the environment. Right now they dont have enough solar panel recycling facilities to have them recycled so the way it is now, instead of polluting with fossil fuels, its polluting grounds and water with toxic metals.
Actually, isnt CA almost exclusively nuclear power anyway right now?
California's population is growing consistently by 300-400,000 people each year over the last 10 years. Some residents are leaving, but more are moving in. They definitely don't have a problem with a "mass exodus", if anything the opposite is true, they're struggling with ways to accommodate their growing population. That's why it makes sense to include a power plant with every new home. Build a new roof, power the home with that roof.
Financially solar panels make a ton of sense. There's an upfront cost but over time the power they produce is far less expensive than traditional energy sources.
Solar panels don't last very long? That's utter hogwash. Down the street from me is NREL, where they test new technology. They have an array consisting of solar panels from the 70's and guess what? Still producing power. Why would we recycle them when they still generate valuable electricity? Modern solar panels are even better, they come with 20-25 year warranties, degrade less than 1% per year, and will still be producing valuable electricity in 30-40 years at least. If you want to "recycle" some panels, just bring them over my house, I'll plug them in and sell the electricity.
Also not sure what "toxic metals" you think solar panels are made of. They're made mostly of silicon which is the eighth most common element in the universe that is non toxic and easily recycled. The embodied energy in a solar panel, the amount of energy it took to produce it including mining the aluminum for the frame, all the materials in it, assembly, shipping and everything, is offset by the production from the panel in 1-4 years, so they pay for themselves in terms of energy return on energy invested many times over during their useful life, that's why they make so much sense environmentally.
"Actually, isnt CA almost exclusively nuclear power anyway right now?"
Nope. Currently about 14% of CA energy comes from Nuclear, compared to 19% from solar. California is not big on nuclear. They’re shutting down the last remaining nuclear plant and not building new ones. Fukushima was the last nail in the coffin for nuclear. We realized having these facilities was too much liability, especially next to the ocean and on top of major fault lines. Side note: Did you know there’s a nuclear plant in NJ that's the same dangerous design (Mark 1 by GE, 1960's technology that we've known was faulty since 1972) as Fukushima? The biggest job maker in nuclear currently is the decommissioning industry. It takes over ten years and costs billions of dollars to take these things apart. Guess who pays for that? Taxes. Meanwhile people think recycling solar panels is a problem SMH.
@Andrew Smith My HOA has a communal roof. And from my understanding there would have to be a lease on it. That's what I was told by the board members. It makes sense to me to have all the homeowners get a solar grid and share the costs. Not sure if it makes sense financially when you're in an HOA and you have a gazillion rules to abide to. My circumstance is different in general.
@Andrew Smith you beat me AGAIN! And you even had more updated info than me... I stand corrected, nuclear is down to 9% of the CA energy mix, I'll have to update my number of 14% from a few years ago. It's quickly on its way to zero.
Whatever question is being asked about energy, nuclear is never the answer. How did we forget to account for the cost of managing the nuclear waste for literally 100,000 years? Taxes pay for that, and if we don't protect it, it can be made into dirty bombs. Great idea indeed but solar "doesn't make sense".... ok.
I hope this is OK to do. I figured something from the "Real World" would be more meaningful.
Attached is a redacted actual solar proposal. This homeowner is in Southern CA and contracted this system. They are in an HOA and we had zero challenges or issues with them.
The salient points are:
https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/betterideasteam/Resources/Redacted+-+9.4+kW+-+20+Yr+Dividend.pdf
Hopefully that at least adds real world numbers and happy to answer questions.
@Andrew Smith My HOA has a communal roof. And from my understanding there would have to be a lease on it. That's what I was told by the board members. It makes sense to me to have all the homeowners get a solar grid and share the costs. Not sure if it makes sense financially when you're in an HOA and you have a gazillion rules to abide to. My circumstance is different in general.
Definitely different circumstances as the roof then would be owned by HOA. It's very difficult then to slice off "footprints" of roof space for resale and avoid someone else's panels being on your part of the roof. We do install community solar for entire communities and entire HOAs and they are excellent typically for ROI for the HOAs/Communities but are not working in the same way for the homeowners withing those HOAs/communities
Steven Picker
I do commercial construction for a living. One of my current clients is a leader in the state of California for Zero Net Energy (ZNE) and LEED Gold new construction projects. It’s only a matter of time (maybe a decade or two) where the California Building Code will require a combination of photovoltaic (PV) systems with battery walls and building system submetering on all new construction.
What most people don't realize is that PV solar panels have what is called a degradation factor. The panels' energy output reduces by 0.25% - 3% per year depending on the make/model. The panels also must be cleaned regularly. Between these two things the advertised energy cost offsets for the property owner slowly decreases year after year, reducing the ROI.
Also, recent tariffs on PV panels and inverters has driven costs up lately.
Current price points are not where they need to be to make this economical statewide yet.
Of course the degradation factor is taken into account when we do energy forecasts. It's less than 1% on avg., high quality panels less than .5%.
I have never cleaned my panels nor do many of my 1,000's of customers (only the really anal ones, or the large scale bank-owned ones required to do so by investors). All of these systems are producing better than forecasted, dirty or meticulously cared for, basically same end result. If there's a dust storm or something, they can easily be cleaned or you can just wait for it to rain like I do. If you clean them daily you might make a few extra pennies a day. Or if you think it's necessary, as some managers of large scale arrays lead us to believe (mostly to justify their position "managing" and array with no moving parts, or to appease investors who have little solar knowledge and just like to have something to point out and think it's important), then paying some guys to run around with spray bottles and squeegees for a few hours isn't going to be a deal breaker on a multimillion dollar system. Soiling is a non-issue in my experience. In areas with heavy dust like the Mojave or the Gobi where the largest solar arrays are, cleaning them is a teeny tiny expense compared to the many millions of dollars worth of electricity those large arrays produce.
Yes, the recent tariffs increased the cost of imported panels by 30%, and the same president signed off on extending the 30% tax credit. So now we mark them up 30% and then down 30%. Makes sense to me... free market! Interesting fact: both policies were signed into law by the party of "less government"; the 30% tax credit in 2005, extended in 2017, and the 30% tariff in 2017. Less government achieved by more government? Energy subsidies are extremely complex, and solar isn't unique in that regard. If you look into subsidies for any form of energy it's migraine-inducing. Despite the tariffs panel prices have dropped by 75% since 2009 and will continue to drop as they are increasingly mass produced.
Current prices have been more than economical for renewables in CA for quite some time that's why almost all new generation is coming from solar and wind.
You seem very defensive. You need to do some more research though. Maybe posting questions here isn't a good way to do it since you clearly have issues with the responses.
Steven Picker
I do commercial construction for a living. One of my current clients is a leader in the state of California for Zero Net Energy (ZNE) and LEED Gold new construction projects. It’s only a matter of time (maybe a decade or two) where the California Building Code will require a combination of photovoltaic (PV) systems with battery walls and building system submetering on all new construction.
What most people don't realize is that PV solar panels have what is called a degradation factor. The panels' energy output reduces by 0.25% - 3% per year depending on the make/model. The panels also must be cleaned regularly. Between these two things the advertised energy cost offsets for the property owner slowly decreases year after year, reducing the ROI.
Also, recent tariffs on PV panels and inverters has driven costs up lately.
Current price points are not where they need to be to make this economical statewide yet.
Of course the degradation factor is taken into account when we do energy forecasts. It's less than 1% on avg., high quality panels less than .5%.
I have never cleaned my panels nor do many of my 1,000's of customers (only the really anal ones, or the large scale bank-owned ones required to do so by investors). All of these systems are producing better than forecasted, dirty or meticulously cared for, basically same end result. If there's a dust storm or something, they can easily be cleaned or you can just wait for it to rain like I do. If you clean them daily you might make a few extra pennies a day. Or if you think it's necessary, as some managers of large scale arrays lead us to believe (mostly to justify their position "managing" and array with no moving parts, or to appease investors who have little solar knowledge and just like to have something to point out and think it's important), then paying some guys to run around with spray bottles and squeegees for a few hours isn't going to be a deal breaker on a multimillion dollar system. Soiling is a non-issue in my experience. In areas with heavy dust like the Mojave or the Gobi where the largest solar arrays are, cleaning them is a teeny tiny expense compared to the many millions of dollars worth of electricity those large arrays produce.
Yes, the recent tariffs increased the cost of imported panels by 30%, and the same president signed off on extending the 30% tax credit. So now we mark them up 30% and then down 30%. Makes sense to me... free market! Interesting fact: both policies were signed into law by the party of "less government"; the 30% tax credit in 2005, extended in 2017, and the 30% tariff in 2017. Less government achieved by more government? Energy subsidies are extremely complex, and solar isn't unique in that regard. If you look into subsidies for any form of energy it's migraine-inducing. Despite the tariffs panel prices have dropped by 75% since 2009 and will continue to drop as they are increasingly mass produced.
Current prices have been more than economical for renewables in CA for quite some time that's why almost all new generation is coming from solar and wind.
With regard to the tariffs though the 30% tariffs is on the components. The 30% tax credit is on the entire system. So on a $21K system it would be 30% on $7K in tariffs but 30% tax credit on $21K in rough numbers so the tax credit is worth a lot more than the tariff.
100% concur in wondering what happened to less Govt, free market and free trade too. Tariffs are taxes.
You seem very defensive. You need to do some more research though. Maybe posting questions here isn't a good way to do it since you clearly have issues with the responses.
Nobodies defensive, it’s sad your opinion is formed with false or outdated information, that’s all.