Exit strategy for commercial loans

Exit strategy for commercial loans

Chicago IL · Member since 2017 · 43 posts · 11 votes

I have a few commercial real estate loans which are fixed rate for 5 years on a 20 year amortization schedule.

My lenders assure me that at the end of each 5 years, I can get another similar loan with the prevailing rates.

The problem is that I would be on the first 5 years of a 20 year amortization schedule every time- which means that I’d be paying mostly interest. It would take forever to pay off this mortgage.

What should be  the general strategy here?

 These properties are meant to be my retirement. Should I aim to get Enough cash to pay them off? Or should I sell them at some point?
Unclear what the best exit strategy is, or whether I should think of it as cash flow and not worry about the fact that I will barely ever touch the principal?

0Reply
181 views

Most Popular Reply

Lender · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2014 · 250 posts · 133 votes
4y

Chris a quick story. That says it all. First, I am not selling anything. Most people who say they are real estate experts, have not survived challenging times. The last 10 years or so has made everyone a hero. Most have not survived the global melt down of 2008-2011. I have and like everyone else who survived I was beaten up bad. 

To put thinks in prospective I just turned 60, when I was much younger I am guessing 30 years or so ago I met someone who I think was 70 at the time who started investing with me, after some time, it was clear he had real wealth. One day I asked him how did you accumulate so much money and cash flow. He said it very simply, I started buying real estate when i was young, before you new it if was paid off and I was wealthy. He told me what I said, buy good real estate, let the tenants pay it off and dont die. If you do this, you dont have to get fancy or complicated but be steady and if you dont die you will become wealthy.  

I can tell you story after story of what happened to me and how this effected me. Some seems nuts, but real. 

See this reply in the discussion

15 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    4y

    If you want to pay them off in 20 years, calculate a 15 year amortization schedule at the 5 year point and pay more than the stated payment amount.  Things change over a 5 year period too; so, just roll with the punches and adjust at that point.  You may want to purchase more properties rather than prepay the loan...who knows.

  • Lender · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2014 · 250 posts · 133 votes
    4y

    Its really a strategy issue. I am a big fan of buy and hold and dont die. I would pay off over the amortized period, with rates being so low I would not make extra paydown payments, But use that money to invest and buy more. Every month your building equity, if you payoff the loan in 20 years and do that on several, you will be a very rich man. 

  • Chicago IL · Member since 2017 · 43 posts · 11 votes
    4y
    Quote from @H. Jack Miller:

    Its really a strategy issue. I am a big fan of buy and hold and dont die. I would pay off over the amortized period, with rates being so low I would not make extra paydown payments, But use that money to invest and buy more. Every month your building equity, if you payoff the loan in 20 years and do that on several, you will be a very rich man. 

    The problem is that due to the loan “resetting” every 5 years, it will take much longer than 20 years to pay .

  • Lender · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2014 · 250 posts · 133 votes
    4y

    Yes I understand, as I said a critical part of my strategy is dont die. Think of it this way, if you borrower 500k every year and pay if off over 30 years, Time goes by very fast and you will be wealthy. I made a YouTube on this subject. 

  • Member since 2020 · 671 posts · 937 votes
    4y

    @H. Jack Miller

    There's a lot of hucksters out there, but I think I've finally found someone who's selling something that I can get behind.  I just might try your new "dont die" strategy out because it sounds like it's just right for me!

  • Lender · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2014 · 250 posts · 133 votes
    4y

    Chris a quick story. That says it all. First, I am not selling anything. Most people who say they are real estate experts, have not survived challenging times. The last 10 years or so has made everyone a hero. Most have not survived the global melt down of 2008-2011. I have and like everyone else who survived I was beaten up bad. 

    To put thinks in prospective I just turned 60, when I was much younger I am guessing 30 years or so ago I met someone who I think was 70 at the time who started investing with me, after some time, it was clear he had real wealth. One day I asked him how did you accumulate so much money and cash flow. He said it very simply, I started buying real estate when i was young, before you new it if was paid off and I was wealthy. He told me what I said, buy good real estate, let the tenants pay it off and dont die. If you do this, you dont have to get fancy or complicated but be steady and if you dont die you will become wealthy.  

    I can tell you story after story of what happened to me and how this effected me. Some seems nuts, but real. 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joe T.:

    I have a few commercial real estate loans which are fixed rate for 5 years on a 20 year amortization schedule.

    My lenders assure me that at the end of each 5 years, I can get another similar loan with the prevailing rates.

    The problem is that I would be on the first 5 years of a 20 year amortization schedule every time- which means that I’d be paying mostly interest. It would take forever to pay off this mortgage.

    What should be  the general strategy here?

     These properties are meant to be my retirement. Should I aim to get Enough cash to pay them off? Or should I sell them at some point?
    Unclear what the best exit strategy is, or whether I should think of it as cash flow and not worry about the fact that I will barely ever touch the principal?


    am i missing something your paying principal down day one. so at the end of 5 years you owe less than you started the 5 year is usually just to adjust interest rates up or down.  But if your saying they then take the loan and recalculate at 20 years all over again I see that.  Most folks wont own a property more than 5 to 8 years before they move on. if your goal is to pay it off then add to your monthly payment each time and keep doing that.
  • PA · Member since 2010 · 339 posts · 168 votes
    4y

    I'm in a similar position. Spreadsheets indicate that you would be crazy not to leverage everything to the hilt because to the whole ROI/CoC return thing. But when you do this, half of your NOI goes toward paying off your mortgage and your cash flow (retirement income) is what's left over. As you say, most of the mortgage payments go toward interest. This is everything you said.

    Here's my position: there's no difference between principle and interest if you plan to live off the property's cash flow--its just a mortgage payment subtracted from your NOI. Even though my spreadsheets will be very upset with me, I might sell one of my properties to make the others debt free. The advantages to me are: I would get the same retirement income, reduce work associated with ownership, eliminate vulnerability to changing market and interest rates and eliminate the emotional pain associated with giving so much money (especially interest) to the bank.

    I've given enough to my kids, so who cares about them :) so my perfect scenario would be to do the above and, at some point, to sell everything so that I can live off the equity. I would time this so that the last bit of equity would be spent the day I die. It would kind of mess everything up if I didn't die, though. Then, I would have angry kids who would abandon me and I would end out homeless and living in the streets.

  • Investor · Malakoff, TX · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joe T.:
    Quote from @H. Jack Miller:

    Its really a strategy issue. I am a big fan of buy and hold and dont die. I would pay off over the amortized period, with rates being so low I would not make extra paydown payments, But use that money to invest and buy more. Every month your building equity, if you payoff the loan in 20 years and do that on several, you will be a very rich man. 

    The problem is that due to the loan “resetting” every 5 years, it will take much longer than 20 years to pay .


     As Mike said, if you want to pay them off in 20 years, just calculate what you would need to pay monthly, and then do that.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Eric James:
    Quote from @Joe T.:
    Quote from @H. Jack Miller:

    Its really a strategy issue. I am a big fan of buy and hold and dont die. I would pay off over the amortized period, with rates being so low I would not make extra paydown payments, But use that money to invest and buy more. Every month your building equity, if you payoff the loan in 20 years and do that on several, you will be a very rich man. 

    The problem is that due to the loan “resetting” every 5 years, it will take much longer than 20 years to pay .


     As Mike said, if you want to pay them off in 20 years, just calculate what you would need to pay monthly, and then do that.


     unless I am missing something ( which is totally possible) the loan is a 20 year am so long as the interest rate does not go higher the starting monthly payment will pay it off in 20 years..  the 20 due in 5 am familiar with is just an interest rate reset or you pay it off .. If you took the unpaid balance and re did it at 20 year am and interest was the same your monthly payment would go down .. since there is less principal than what you started with..  am i getting this correct :)

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2018 · 829 posts · 811 votes
    4y

    @Joe T. There are commercial lenders that have 15 yr and 30 yr fixed rate loans that are competitive with agency or other commercial loan products. There are many threads on this forum that provide lists of these lenders.

  • Rental Property Investor · NY · Member since 2017 · 132 posts · 90 votes
    4y

    @Joe T.

    Most lenders offer shorter terms

    5 year

    10 year

    15

    20

    25

    30

    If the properties are large enough you can get a 30 year Fannie/Freddie commercial loan. Pretty much the last loan you’ll ever get on it.

    I’d take a 100 year loan leveraged and never pay it off.

    When you sell 1031 and buy something “cash” if not having a mortgage is your worry

  • Member since 2018 · 563 posts · 562 votes
    4y
    TAXES...

    Loans are non taxable large cash infusion events, AND their interest payments are fully deductible.

    IMHO, the strategy for commercial lending is either have a disposition strategy(exit) that is based on the loan term OR at the end of the term refinance/cashout any of the equity you have accumulated(assuming appreciation) and reinvest it in other properties, in order to diversify the built up equity from the original investment with the intention of growing a portfolio, OR have the equity cash out to buy expensive things with(stocks, yacht, beach house, RR, Gulfstream jet, etc) and let the investment property cover the debt service on that thing purchased with the cashout, depending on the greater economic conditions. Of course, more income producing RE would be my first choice and probably most on this site.

    ...... all of that can go seriously sideways if you have to large LTV, and your loans mature from very low interest rate to much higher and go from black ink to red accordingly because rents didn't keep pace with the difference in new higher interest loan payment.

    The point is.... that if you have a completely paid off, fully depreciated asset, you don't have tax depreciation expense incentives, but if you redeploy the equity from the refinance loan into another asset, you have a larger fully deductible loan payment, untaxed inflow of cash from the refinance, and new asset with a new depreciation schedule that shelters some amount of the equity in your RE portfolio, instead of no depreciation on the initial paid off primary asset.

    When done correctly you minimize tax liability, maximize diversification, maximize appreciation, maximize portfolio growth and maintain a stable cash flow with occasional large infusions.

    Unless, I am missing something?



  • Chicago IL · Member since 2017 · 43 posts · 11 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Isaac S.:
    TAXES...

    Loans are non taxable large cash infusion events, AND their interest payments are fully deductible.

    IMHO, the strategy for commercial lending is either have a disposition strategy(exit) that is based on the loan term OR at the end of the term refinance/cashout any of the equity you have accumulated(assuming appreciation) and reinvest it in other properties, in order to diversify the built up equity from the original investment with the intention of growing a portfolio, OR have the equity cash out to buy expensive things with(stocks, yacht, beach house, RR, Gulfstream jet, etc) and let the investment property cover the debt service on that thing purchased with the cashout, depending on the greater economic conditions. Of course, more income producing RE would be my first choice and probably most on this site.

    ...... all of that can go seriously sideways if you have to large LTV, and your loans mature from very low interest rate to much higher and go from black ink to red accordingly because rents didn't keep pace with the difference in new higher interest loan payment.

    The point is.... that if you have a completely paid off, fully depreciated asset, you don't have tax depreciation expense incentives, but if you redeploy the equity from the refinance loan into another asset, you have a larger fully deductible loan payment, untaxed inflow of cash from the refinance, and new asset with a new depreciation schedule that shelters some amount of the equity in your RE portfolio, instead of no depreciation on the initial paid off primary asset.

    When done correctly you minimize tax liability, maximize diversification, maximize appreciation, maximize portfolio growth and maintain a stable cash flow with occasional large infusions.

    Unless, I am missing something?




    Thank you explaining the approach in this much detail. It makes a ton of sense. One question- when you say the new depreciation schedule that shelters some amount of equity in your current RE portfolio, don’t you mean shelters some of the income?
    As I understand it, the depreciation helps with additional deductions from your RE income.  

    If not, please clarify what you meant by sheltering equity.

    Thanks!

  • Member since 2018 · 563 posts · 562 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joe T.:
    Quote from @Isaac S.:
    TAXES...

    Loans are non taxable large cash infusion events, AND their interest payments are fully deductible.

    IMHO, the strategy for commercial lending is either have a disposition strategy(exit) that is based on the loan term OR at the end of the term refinance/cashout any of the equity you have accumulated(assuming appreciation) and reinvest it in other properties, in order to diversify the built up equity from the original investment with the intention of growing a portfolio, OR have the equity cash out to buy expensive things with(stocks, yacht, beach house, RR, Gulfstream jet, etc) and let the investment property cover the debt service on that thing purchased with the cashout, depending on the greater economic conditions. Of course, more income producing RE would be my first choice and probably most on this site.

    ...... all of that can go seriously sideways if you have to large LTV, and your loans mature from very low interest rate to much higher and go from black ink to red accordingly because rents didn't keep pace with the difference in new higher interest loan payment.

    The point is.... that if you have a completely paid off, fully depreciated asset, you don't have tax depreciation expense incentives, but if you redeploy the equity from the refinance loan into another asset, you have a larger fully deductible loan payment, untaxed inflow of cash from the refinance, and new asset with a new depreciation schedule that shelters some amount of the equity in your RE portfolio, instead of no depreciation on the initial paid off primary asset.

    When done correctly you minimize tax liability, maximize diversification, maximize appreciation, maximize portfolio growth and maintain a stable cash flow with occasional large infusions.

    Unless, I am missing something?




    Thank you explaining the approach in this much detail. It makes a ton of sense. One question- when you say the new depreciation schedule that shelters some amount of equity in your current RE portfolio, don’t you mean shelters some of the income?
    As I understand it, the depreciation helps with additional deductions from your RE income.  

    If not, please clarify what you meant by sheltering equity.

    Thanks!


    Yes, that's correct, I meant to say " shelters some amount of your portfolio income from immediate tax liability"... and it is especially important when you plan on holding an asset for longer than 27 years(depreciation schedule), and you want all the other aforementioned strategic growth benefits.

    Paying off the asset totally, IMO, is meant for your primary residence or very small portfolio and/or the personal satisfaction of not being indebted to anyone, should not be completely dismissed.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.