[Calc Review] Would you take a lower ROI for an A-Class Turn Key?

[Calc Review] Would you take a lower ROI for an A-Class Turn Key?

Rental Property Investor · Staten Island, NY · Member since 2018 · 124 posts · 50 votes

View report

*This link comes directly from our calculators, based on information input by the member who posted.

Greetings Again BP Community,

Here's my dilemma. In my valiant quest for a good value add property as a long distance investor, I've learned some stuff. 

  • Stuff 1: Putting together a good and reliable team for your first out of state purchase is daunting.
  • Stuff 2: Most turn key providers are sucking up every bit of equity in exchange for a break-even property at best that will still likely need some help in the near future because of rehab shortcuts and location. 
  • Stuff 3: If I had the team in place and the deal ready, I'd bank all the equity and cash flow but would have to endure the process of getting to that point.

So here's my issue. I have actually found a good, trustworthy, and highly recommended turnkey provider who works with Investors and ARE investors themselves. I communicate directly with head of the outfit which is nice. They cover the property management in house. Only rehab in A & B Class neighborhoods. And have an average tenant vacancy of 3.4% over the last 10 years. The rehab itself is a bit above average but for good reason. They update all the bathrooms, kitchen, plumbing, electrical, and replace the roof. All hard surface floors and counters are installed for ease of maintenance. Their whole goal is to front load the property with all these updates so that the investor can ACTUALLY cash-flow. BTW, this is my review not a regurgitation of some advertisement from them.

So the question is, until I can get a good and reliable team of people in place that can execute the deals for me, Would a low purchase price turn-key property in a Class-A neighborhood that cash flows $150-$200 with lower CAPX, Vacancy, and MX costs really be such a bad idea? At least until I get some more experience and connections.

Anxiously awaiting your thoughts!

-Adam Scheetz

2Reply
130 views

Most Popular Reply

Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
7y

this subject has been talked about a bunch on BP.. why do people sell cash flow assets.

the argument that they must be selling the dogs and keeping the good ones is not reality.

I have been funding turn key companies for going on 20 years now.. they sell almost all their properties.

they are in the business of buy rehab and sell.. they are not in the landlord business per se.. now some will have some properties but its not their goal to own hundreds of homes.. 

its hard to finance all of those first off.

just like me who builds new homes why don't I keep them all.. well because I want to sell them that's my inventory to sell just like anyone else and I make more on one sale of a new home than I would with 20 years of cash flow at 200 a month.. so its what I choose to do.. Same with those whose business is flipping they just happen to concentrate on investors instead of home owners.

Keep in mind in many of these neighborhoods.. there is no retail sales to homeowners there is only sales to investors.. this is quite common in any area were 20% down gives you positive 200 a month.. 

I tried the big landlord gig I did not care for it.. I had over 300 SFRs the happiest day of my life was when I sold that portfolio so now its only build or rehab for retail or we sell a lot of product to investors as well. I have no personal interest in owning rentals..  so that's why I don't care how good they are I don't like it.. LOL  But that does not mean I cant provide a product make a profit when I sell for those that want to own cash flow rentals. 

See this reply in the discussion

59 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Adam Scheetz:

    @Michael P.

    I've said it's Memphis. It's @James Wachob and his team at Memphis Investment Properties. He has a lot of free content and knowledge on the web. He's been timely and professional every time we speak. He's forth coming with his criteria for property selection and has answerd in detail every question I've had. Additionally you find a lot of reviews online and BP about how he does business.

    James had some new construction a few years back that looked like pretty good deals to me for long term landlord.. at least your starting out with everything brand new..  

  • Rental Property Investor · Brooke Park Drive · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    Buying would be fun and easy.  Exit strategy is the harder part.

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y

    @Adam Scheetz I agree. Memphis doesn't have high operating costs which is why it's a popular cash flow market. What I was saying is that the better the class of property, the higher your rent will be. That will always be the case. Due to higher rents, A and B class properties will have more cash flow although the cash on cash ROI might be lower. Often times people don't realize that you can have higher cash flow and lower ROI and that's usually the case with higher rent properties. Based on your numbers, I think you're cash flow will be higher than you're estimating which is good. When I do a quick calculation I'm seeing around $250/mth cash flow rather than $150-$200. Also, when factoring in your long term CAP EX, don't forget to include the offsetting deprecation tax benefit that pays for those future expenses over the long term. That's often overlooked when analyzing a properties return. This sounds like a solid investment. Good luck!

  • Chris ClothierBusiness Member
    Rental Property Investor · memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y

    @Adam Scheetz - 

    I've read through your thread and some of the discussion and I want to answer the question you posed in the title.  

    Yes. I have taken a lower ROI on a better property in return for a higher IRR in the future.

    I hate the classification of properties by the way, especially for out of state buyers.  It is too easy to call a property an "A" property and spin answers and the buyer never knows the difference.

    Essentially, this area is a C+ to B area at best.  An "A" class property will never have a car port.  Ever.

    A quick way to determine the alphabet class of a property is to look at median home prices for the area.  You are basically buying a home for roughly median price in Memphis.  That tells you that half are above and half are below.  That means you are not in an "A" area no matter how you define it.

    I would say homes in the 190k to 300k range are going to be closer to what you are discussing and thinking as top class investments.  They may or may not cash flow much, but that is where the appreciation is happening in Memphis.

    Now, that does not mean this is not a good investment or that you wouldn't want to make the purchase. That is up to your preference as an investor and your comfort level with whom you are working with. But, your question was about taking lower ROI for "A" class Turnkey property. I don't think you have to as usually a better property performs better according to many data points. This is just a regular turnkey property like a vast majority of other turnkey properties in an area popular for rentals. Nothing really special here to make it be considered an A-class turnkey property nor is there necessarily anything wrong with it.

    Best of luck to you 

  • Developer · NY/NJ/PA · Member since 2018 · 758 posts · 935 votes
    7y

    There’s nothing wrong with these turnkey providers. People are saying “they keep the best ones, and sell the dogs”, which is not true for the most part. 

    These guys are in the business to flip. Flip to investors. They make more money overall flipping than cash flowing the asset. 

    Also, everyone has their limitations. No one can buy every property that crosses your table. I personally will wholesale out deals when my liquidity or other priorities stop me from personally keeping a property. 

    Now the returns you should require depend on what your buyer profile is. Are you a passive investor? Can you put in some real hours managing this?

    I personally require a 15+% COC, $200/door (after capex; etc etc), and a couple of other metrics. I don't buy turnkey. I'd rather buy a POS and turn it myself.

    But I am a full time investor. I am self-employed with multiple other businesses and a flipping business. I have flexibility. Most people don’t.

    If you have another full time job, a turnkey property might be perfect for you. For secondary and tertiary markets I would look for a 9-12% coc @ 20-25% down with realistic vacancy/mgmt/capex #'s. The nicer the area, the more rent appreciation that is predicated; etc, the lower my acceptable COC would be.

    I'm buying a small building in NYC, I can't reasonably expect a 10-15% COC there. But my MIRR will be decently high bc of appreciation.

  • Rental Property Investor · Brooke Park Drive · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    Best quote in BP history 

  • Rental Property Investor · Staten Island, NY · Member since 2018 · 124 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Syed H. I am 100% on board with flipping and holding a property myself, even partnering, Refi'ing, and paying out if there's enough meat. Problem being, as I mentioned initially is that the process of putting together an out of state team is doable, just not quickly. And in the interest of experiential value and soliciting financial partners, a couple cash flowing properties and a couple of local flips looks better than a bunch of analysis charts and inaction. I am a full time military officer and will be for the next 10 years. My target is actually as you said 9-12% @ 20% down. I typically do 8% CapX, 5% Mx, 10% PM, and 6% Vacancy. The reason why I went lower on some of those is because of the nature of the Turnkey property and the level of rehab and updating that- to me- allows for a reduction in those areas. Could I be mistaken by doing that, maybe...likely...but that's where my thought process was. Additionally, I never bank on appreciation unless I build it into the deal. As in, a foreclosure + Rehab that puts my ARV at or above market so I have a nice cushion of equity built in. Forced appreciation is the only appreciation I think you can trust with some certainty.

    Much Appreciated,

    Adam

  • Real Estate Agent · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2017 · 814 posts · 466 votes
    7y

    @Adam Scheetz

    These are good questions.  I invest in Class A/B properties-neighborhoods.  

    What I can tell from your analysis is that you are missing some % on CapEX. These stuff often do not depend on the neighborhood Class, but the construction and materials used, and the already used life span of the systems/components itself. On maintenance, you can sometimes get away with 3%, but to be safe I always put this at 5% minimum (even with a rent of $2000/month) and fairly new (2005+). So adding this costs to your analysis may drop substantially your ROI.

    Not sure in NY where you live.  I can only tell you what I know where I invest (San Antonio TX).  One thing I have learned on Class A properties, cash flow is very thin.  Appreciation and upcoming neighborhoods, while the city expands towards that location I'm looking for property plays an important factor and things I consider when investing (future highway projects, future shopping centers, overall city or federal funds invested in that location, etc).  

    In my opinion it doesn't matter if is a turn-key or in the MLS, you should do the analysis and invest in something that best works for you.

  • Investor · Saint Joseph, MO · Member since 2016 · 44 posts · 15 votes
    7y

    @Adam Scheetz

    150-200 net is pretty low. 2400 a year? It would not take much of an innocent human error (overlooking some roffing/plumbing/electric problem) to eat that up quick.

    Taking appreciation out of the equation (cause that is educated speculatiin and I do not know your market), I dont thinking tying up the down payment is worth it. Even though the numbers and reputation of turn key deal sound good.

    With that said...you asked responses so I gave my thoughts. But you may have other goals or standards with which you will have to measure this deal.

    150 a door? Not worth the potential financial or even emotional hiccups that may occur.

    Talk with the same company, tell them you need 350 a door (or whatever your number is) with the same other general parameters being equal and wait.

    Good luck to you whatever you decide! I am glad you are making a move and looking for opinions to help the process.

    Cheers

  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    The turnkey operators in my market have been selling properties to out of state investors, primarily from California.  These investments, for the most part were overpriced.  I suggest a different investment vehicle.

  • Developer · NY/NJ/PA · Member since 2018 · 758 posts · 935 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Michael Sontheimer:

    @Adam Scheetz

    150-200 net is pretty low. 2400 a year? It would not take much of an innocent human error (overlooking some roffing/plumbing/electric problem) to eat that up quick.

    Taking appreciation out of the equation (cause that is educated speculatiin and I do not know your market), I dont thinking tying up the down payment is worth it. Even though the numbers and reputation of turn key deal sound good.

    With that said...you asked responses so I gave my thoughts. But you may have other goals or standards with which you will have to measure this deal.

    150 a door? Not worth the potential financial or even emotional hiccups that may occur.

    Talk with the same company, tell them you need 350 a door (or whatever your number is) with the same other general parameters being equal and wait.

    Good luck to you whatever you decide! I am glad you are making a move and looking for opinions to help the process.

    Cheers

     $150-250 a door is not too low IMO, if you are taking adequate reserves, maintenance, and other expenses into account with leverage of course. 

    $350/door+ is near impossible to find in a decent area after you appropriately account for all the expenses people forget. 

  • WorldWide · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    $100+sq. ft? I suggest you look into Oklahoma RE market. You can get new builds here for that much that will also cash flow similarly (and meet the 1% "rule" also). have you looked at homes sold in that area to see how much premium you're paying?

  • James WachobBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Memphis, TN · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 897 votes
    7y

    If a property burned to the ground and you were left with a vacant lot, what would the value of that lot dictate that you rebuild?

    In a C class neighborhood, you may NOT rebuild because the cost to build new would supersede the comparable sales in that neighborhood.

    In a B class neighborhood, you may rebuild the exact floorplan, sqft, and included features as the previous house. 

    In an A class neighborhood, the land value is greater and you would have the option to build bigger and better than what was there previously because of the average price per sqft in the immediate vicinity and high demand (combined with low supply) from homeowners in the area, would allow the new bigger/better property to appraise. In real estate, this is called the highest and best use.  Perhaps a two or even three car garage would be appropriate, in some cases. 

    An A class neighborhood would have a higher than average income. This data can be found on several public websites like city-data.com 

    Crime would be an important factor in determining the A,B, or C class of a community, as well. Trulia.com offers a helpful map that you can use to evaluate each opportunity. 

    Everyone seems to have different thoughts about the definition of an A, B, or C neighborhood. Crime, homeownership %, the possibility of appreciation (because of the demand from homeowners), are factors that attract quality tenants. Not the floor plan and amenities of a home, as much as Location, Location, Location. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Winona, MN · Member since 2018 · 87 posts · 90 votes
    7y

    @Adam Scheetz, I am an investor that is looking at long-term gains and I have purchased a nice property below the 1% rule. However, I could easily pay the mortgage/expenses should my property become vacant... if I couldn’t do that, I may not have done that deal.

  • Rental Property Investor · Staten Island, NY · Member since 2018 · 124 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Heather Schmidtknecht Where are you located? Does that mean that you break even or slightly above that every month? I'd love to know more. Thanks!

  • Rental Property Investor · Winona, MN · Member since 2018 · 87 posts · 90 votes
    7y

    @Adam Scheetz, the mortgage on my property with escrow for taxes and insurance is $749/month on a 15-year. The rent is $1000/month for a 3 (small) bedroom & 2 bath home; tenant pays all utilities. Currently I’m paying ahead on the mortgage, so I pay $900/month automatically and then I save the other $100/month for whatever might be needed in the future. Many would have turned down this deal, but because my property is nice and most of the rentals in this area are not (college town), I felt it was a good investment. Since I have a full-time W-2 job that I LOVE and don’t need the month-to-month cash flow, I am looking at this at a long-term investment to produce retirement income and diversify my investment portfolio.

  • South Holland, IL · Member since 2017 · 376 posts · 432 votes
    7y

    @Adam Scheetz

    How did you confirm the low vacancy rate yourself?

  • Rental Property Investor · Staten Island, NY · Member since 2018 · 124 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Quincy Lockett the low vacancy is a point of pride that they tout over the last 10 years. I don't know how'd I'd independently verify that number without seeing all their tenant records.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @James Wachob:

    If a property burned to the ground and you were left with a vacant lot, what would the value of that lot dictate that you rebuild?

    In a C class neighborhood, you may NOT rebuild because the cost to build new would supersede the comparable sales in that neighborhood.

    In a B class neighborhood, you may rebuild the exact floorplan, sqft, and included features as the previous house. 

    In an A class neighborhood, the land value is greater and you would have the option to build bigger and better than what was there previously because of the average price per sqft in the immediate vicinity and high demand (combined with low supply) from homeowners in the area, would allow the new bigger/better property to appraise. In real estate, this is called the highest and best use.  Perhaps a two or even three car garage would be appropriate, in some cases. 

    An A class neighborhood would have a higher than average income. This data can be found on several public websites like city-data.com 

    Crime would be an important factor in determining the A,B, or C class of a community, as well. Trulia.com offers a helpful map that you can use to evaluate each opportunity. 

    Everyone seems to have different thoughts about the definition of an A, B, or C neighborhood. Crime, homeownership %, the possibility of appreciation (because of the demand from homeowners), are factors that attract quality tenants. Not the floor plan and amenities of a home, as much as Location, Location, Location. 

    James these are excellent points..  and why new construction for infill only happens in areas were you can sell homes for closer to 200k no way you are going to rebuild in an area were not matter the age the home will only be worth 60 to 80.. better to take your insurance money and move on.. those lots have zero value..  In hot infill we pay 100  to 200k just for the lots.. 

    in the lower end price points were 95% of the sales if not 100% are to investors the values are only going to follow the 1% rule type of thing even though U dont use cap rate for SFRs the reality is the investor does.. and will only pay for a given rent.. Its only a home owner that will pay more .. and i bet when we talk about a cities appreciation its the city as a whole NOT a specific neighborhood so the high end appreciation numbers skew whats happening in the low end.. but even then 3% appreciation on a 60k house is a whopping 1,800 bucks .. so to me its a nothing metric..

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y

    @James Wachob  and further many Californians are facing this burnt out house what do i do..  I mean we lost about 20 thousand houses in Wild fires last 3 years.

    I say we because I was born and raised in Northern CA and Silverado Country club got hit and lived there for 10 years 30 to 40 of my fellow club members lost their homes these are all 2 to 8 million dollar homes.

    they are now left with lots that take thousands to clean as they are toxic hazards.. and what i see is many even though well insured and many had their homes paid for.. they are just taking the insurance money and put the lot up for sale.. so we made an offer on a few lots in the 500 to 600k range with the idea to build a 3k sq house that will sell for 1000 a foot. so 3 million.. over in Coffee Park in Santa Rosa were 6k houses burnt down.. same thing many are not rebuilding this is basic starter housing in N Ca at 650 to 850k.. so lots there are selling in the 150k range.. although we believe there is going to be a flood of lots since many are taking their money and moving on..  So lot values could actually drop.

    What happens is insurance money comes in subs raise their prices out of this world and its 200 a foot to rebuild or more on the high end ones we are trying to do at Silverado our bids are coming in at 400 to 500 a foot just to build.

    I have been building luxury in Charleston SC and paying 300 a foot to build.. just got one 2600 sq ft done for 750 k but i sold it for 2.2 mil in Jan..  paid 570k for the lot.. 

    So your points are very well taken.. plus can you imagine trying to build new construction in the C and D areas.. your materials would get stolen as quickly as they are taken to the site.. you dump your lumber pac and you cant secure the house .. you would need 24 hour security in those areas..

  • Rental Property Investor · Staten Island, NY · Member since 2018 · 124 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @James Wachob thanks for the response. I'm loving this thread and the dialogue it's generated!

  • James WachobBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Memphis, TN · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 897 votes
    7y

    @Jay Hinrichs well said.

  • Chris ClothierBusiness Member
    Rental Property Investor · memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Adam Scheetz:

    @Quincy Lockett the low vacancy is a point of pride that they tout over the last 10 years. I don't know how'd I'd independently verify that number without seeing all their tenant records.

    Adam,

    A great way to confirm numbers, especially when companies are touting very specific and very hard to corroborate numbers is to do the math yourself.  Ask the provider how many properties they manage.  I'm sure you've already done that.  Then go to the website where they list their properties for rent.  Do the math.  

    Say they advertise that they manage 2000 properties and their website lists 200+ rental properties.  That is a 10% plus vacancy.  No getting around that fact.

    You can also ask how they rent the properties and when they tell you that they run newspaper ads, ask for one.  See how many properties they advertise as available in their ads.  Do the math.  These techniques will work for most companies.  If they dont have this kind of data readily available for you then you just keep asking specific questions and often mirror questions.  Whats the vacancy rate, whats the occupancy rate, how many are you managing, how many are for rent right this minute, etc...  Then again, you do the math yourself.  

    It's a pretty good way to separate the bs from reality.   I have been in this industry for a long time and helped a lot of turnkey companies with best practices.  What i have found is that most guess at their numbers and if they're not guessing, they are telling the best story they can because they think it's what the buyer wants to hear.  Again, you just have to know how to do your best due diligence.  

    I can tell you from experience, it is extremely, extremely difficult to have that low of a vacancy.  Good thing for you, the data you need is right there in plain sight.  This technique works with any provider in any city you review as you're doing due diligence.

  • Rental Property Investor · Durham, NC · Member since 2016 · 7k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    7y

    @Chris Clothier @Adam Scheetz. I just did what Chris recommended. Took me 30 seconds.

    According to the PM website for the provider you listed they have 244 current available listings. It says on their website they manage

    Over 2000 rentals. So 244/2000 is 12.4 percent and 244/3000 is .08 percent. I am assuming if t was over 3000 rentals they’d have said that.

    So right this minute you can likely safely assume the actual vacancy rate is between 8 and 12 percent for that company.

    I just did this same thing for my PM company (in memphis) and I got 7.8 percent. They manage less propeties though. In my experience in memphis, if you have a vacancy, it’ll take about a month (8 percent rate) to get it filled again. I imagine this would be longer in higher rent propeties because less tenants qualify for your rental.

    I always advise people in memphis to stay between 750 and 1100 in rent. Much above and it’ll be harder to fill, much below that and tenant class won’t be great.

    Hope this helps.

  • Rental Property Investor · Staten Island, NY · Member since 2018 · 124 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Caleb Heimsoth You're Awesome! You beat me to it. I like your analysis on rent. Ironically, late last year I was looking in Cary, NC. I used to live in Raleigh in the early 2000's and remembered that Cary was expanding rapidly. What made you leave that market?

    Thanks so much for your response!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.