No one will fill out screening form prior to showings… ideas why?

No one will fill out screening form prior to showings… ideas why?

Member since 2022 · 27 posts · 11 votes

I have recently listed my first rental unit (a LEGAL/permitted ADU in Utah.. many basement/in-law rentals here are definitely not legal/permitted) and am trying to pre-screen inquiries BEFORE scheduling showings with them. I tried to show first for a few weeks and it was simply a massive waste of time, between the no shows and unqualified applicants. But now I am unable to get any submissions after sending prospects my screening link which I created with google forms.

I know there are a lot of similar posts but I can’t get over some of the replies I’ve received after sending the form which asks (seemingly) standard/basic questions. I would greatly appreciate your feedback
-
“I see that (my google form…) is from a third party company - can you tell me more about it?”

-

”I went to fill the application but it seems a bit out of order in the steps of inquiring for an apartment (for me). I'd prefer to see if the place interests me first and have a genuine conversation. I also believe initial trust is best built and seen in person and then followed up/backed with the serious details of credit etc. to be sure someone is being authentic.“

-

”As a tenant - I would like to go and look at the property before filling out all of that information. I understand it helps deter people who aren’t serious, but for me, it isn’t worth the hassle when I found other places that were in the same price range that were willing to show me and have a conversation after, if we mesh well.”

____________________________________
My screening form questions are listed below. Would you say the form is doing its job and removing these people from the serious inquiries? Or am I missing out on potentially great renters by giving them a 2 minute “hassle” of a google form (in order to save myself hours of hassle)?

-Name/ Phone Number

-Desired Move in Date?
-Desired lease term? (6/12mo)

-Are you willing to undergo a credit and background check?

-Is there anything that may come up on these reports that we should be aware of?

-What is your estimated credit score (we have a minimum credit score limit of 620)

-Total number of occupants that will be moving in (including any children)?

-Annual Household Income (we have a minimum income limit of 3x rent)?

-Will you be able to provide proof of income for the last 2 years? (W-2,

-Have you filed for bankruptcy in the last 7 years?

-Does anyone in the household smoke? (This property does not allow smoking).

-Number of Pets (we allow a maximum of 2 pets)?

-Any additional information you'd like us to know or take into consideration about you.

3Reply
277 views

Most Popular Reply

Dan H.Pro Member
Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
3y

My experience is pre-screening questionnaires work where most LL require them and do not work where very few LL require them.  We do not require a pre-screen questionnaire because they are rate in our market.

We do not do individual showings.  We have an open house.  We send a reminder to each interested party about the open house an hour or two before the open house.  The open house creates a perceived frenzy that encourages immediate applications.  We virtually always get a qualified application in our first open house.  I will say that we are in a very low vacancy market where there are more tenants than available housing.  

During Covid we had to do individual showings.  

Our open house gets nearly everyone stating they will submit an application, but if they do not submit it immediately, I would estimate it is maybe 1 of 5 applicants get submitted.  Fortunately, about 25% submit applications immediately.  Our open houses are usually scheduled for 1.5 hours but we usually end up staying 2 hours.  We virtually always get a qualified applicant from the first open house.  Note to get a qualified applicant often requires more than applicant.  Even with charging for applying, we still have around 50% of applicants not meet out qualification standards.  Fortunately, we typically end up with 2 to 5 applications at the open house.

During the 1 on 1 showings during Covid, nearly everyone that showed up for their scheduled showing stated they would fill out an application.  About 1 in 10 filled out the application immediately.  Of those that did not submit application immediately, there was maybe 1 in 10 submitted an application later.  We confirmed with each potential applicant an hour or two before the showing and still had a high rate of no-show (maybe 30%).  It is incredible how many of the people who missed their appointment still desired to be re-scheduled for a showing.  We do not re-schedule as someone that does not make their appointment is not someone that we desire as a tenant.  I would estimate that we had 30 thirty minute scheduled showings (about 20 actual showings) to get a single qualified applicant (~50% of applicants qualify).  This amounts to 30 showings (20 who show up), 15 hours of scheduled showings (10 hours with tenant showing up), 2 applications received, one qualified application.  It is very inefficient compared to having an open house.  Without the perceived frenzy, we have a significantly lower rate of applications received.

It is critical to charge for application.  This reduces unqualified applicants.  It also reduces bogus ESA applicants if combined with an ESA policy.  Applicants do not want to spend $35 to find out that their application is rejected because they do not have a legitimate ESA.

Good luck

See this reply in the discussion

38 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Little Falls, NJ · Member since 2014 · 88 posts · 49 votes
    3y

    PS: I have their info in a sheet and after a few days do an open house with 15min blocks of time. Almost everyone shows up once they commit to a time.

  • Member since 2022 · 27 posts · 11 votes
    3y
    Yeah one person sent me a very long reply after I sent them the form, stating all the reasons their credit is low and can't show their income but how they are still a great person and they aren't going to fill out the form to just get judged on paper.
  • Little Falls, NJ · Member since 2014 · 88 posts · 49 votes
    3y

    Sure there's great people with bad credit, but to risk having an expensive eviction. Sorry on the the next... Nothing worst than a tenant with nothing to lose.

  • Lender · Washington DC · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    3y

    Change the long form to what matters

    Name/ Phone Number/email

    What is you credit like: great /good /bad

    What was your income for 2022?

    Book appointments with eight minute intervals. It doesn't matter if they see each other. Hand them printed application and credit inquiry form on that you write you need w-2 and year to date paycheck, names/ages of all occupants, breed /weight of pets, bank statement attached. IF They don't fill it all out ~ don't run the credit. When they say they can't give this or that, pass. Ask for $100 for the credit report of your top five people that says a long story- we intend to check. Look at the contents of their vehicle, is it clean? Take notes on the names and what they said as you will not remember. 

    Finding great tenants is WORK. Due diligence is vital to your survival. Call the prior landlord, go drive by if you must and check the stories.

  • Bjorn AhlbladPro Member
    Investor · Shelton, WA · Member since 2017 · 6k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    3y

    My form is very similar to that. It is what I want it to be, a traffic cop!

  • Rental Property Investor · East Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 10k+ posts · 16k+ votes
    3y

    I pre-screen level 1 by asking questions in the for rent ad that must be answered.

    if those answers look OK, I go to level 2.  

    if that goes ok, I reply.

    They shouldn't even know your contact info or the property address (just cross streets) at all prior to 2 levels of pre-screening. 

    But I don't ask for a form until I decide whether I remembered to bring an application to their showing or not. 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    3y
    Quote from @Joseph Beilke:

    I do not think your questions are out of line. But I can also see why people would not want to provide some of this material facts before seeing the property, you are putting them on the defensive. I think a slight adjustment might better suit this goal. When some one inquires about the the ADU, maybe try sending this form and giving them a showing window. Let's say Saturday Jan 14 you will being doing showing, "to lock in a time to view the property please fill out and send back with your available times and I will provide you with a 30 min slot".

    Maybe this approach will change their mind set about filling out the form. They are not being told "no" before viewing, it just becomes their ticket to a time. 

    Name/ Phone Number & Email

    Desired Move in Date?
    Desired lease term? 6 or 12 Month or other,  please specify 

    I would also maybe reduce the number of questions.  I would change most questions to statements.  For instance I would state that a bankruptcy may not disqualify you, but a credit and background checks and a min score of 620 is required.

    and/or

    A income verification will be done and minimum income requirement of 3x times rent is required.

    and/or

    This is a smoke free property.

    and/or

    We allow 2 pet on a case by case.

    and/or

    For additional consideration please free feel to tell us about yourself or anyone else in your family that will be staying on the property.

    Sometime the approach is as important as the question.  Good Luck!


    Totally agree you set the ground rules you dont ask them if they mind answering a question.. you just state.

    move in date  length of lease ..  our requirements ARE:  fico 700  no smoking two small pets etc etc. thats all you need to say.. By asking them question that they can say no to you have lost control  and good salesmen knows these rules.. Of course not all landlords are up on sales techniques but you must always stay in control.
  • Joseph BeilkeBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Palm Coast, FL · Member since 2018 · 364 posts · 244 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Malachi P.:
    Yeah one person sent me a very long reply after I sent them the form, stating all the reasons their credit is low and can't show their income but how they are still a great person and they aren't going to fill out the form to just get judged on paper.

     Last summer I had a application that was in question.  He had funds in the bank for cover two whole years( he's said the funds were from the sale of a house when he got divorced).  He offered to pay up front the whole year.  It was very tempting, but we passed on him because during his income verification we notice he went to a local gas station multiple times a day and spent 10-20$ during each visit.  His saving account had plenty of cash but no transfers or deposits in the last 3 months.  He's checking account showed his bi-weekly pay check was gone in 2 weeks.  He also said he worked from home and going to gas station that much he was not buying gas.  My guess was lottery tickets and tall boys,  After a year he would not have been able to pay rent with that type of habit.   We passed!

    Enkore Real Estate & Property Management4.836 Reviews
  • Member since 2022 · 27 posts · 11 votes
    3y

    Yikes, that is definitely a pass. Thanks for the insight to heavily consider these types of things! 

  • Real Estate Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 388 posts · 174 votes
    3y
    Here is what I do and it saves me TONS of time:
    1- I have an email template I send.
    2- The email template has this in it, " Since there is a demand for viewings, we have attached the rental application.  Please review the Typical Qualifications listed at the top.  If you meet these qualifications send your full name and phone number and we will call you to schedule a showing.  You do not need to fill out the application if you do not like the property, but we will accept any application with non-refundable application fee at the showing time. etc..."
    3-If we get this far and I call, I will usually ask qualifying questions again.
    4-Only serious people will read the email, check the typical qualifications, AND send their full name and phone number.  Really serious people, usually bring me the application ready and copies in a small folder.  They usually end up getting the property...

    Hope this helps!
  • NH · Member since 2021 · 17 posts · 11 votes
    3y

    As a Realtor, I do the exact same thing with my investor’s rental properties, Luke! I completely agree that those that are the most interested will do the legwork. It weeds out the tire kickers. And those that do the work usually end up getting the property! 

  • Real Estate Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 388 posts · 174 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Martha M.:

    As a Realtor, I do the exact same thing with my investor’s rental properties, Luke! I completely agree that those that are the most interested will do the legwork. It weeds out the tire kickers. And those that do the work usually end up getting the property! 


    Thank you for the vote!
  • Member since 2023 · 2 posts · 2 votes
    3y
    Quote from @Luke H.:
    Here is what I do and it saves me TONS of time:
    1- I have an email template I send.
    2- The email template has this in it, " Since there is a demand for viewings, we have attached the rental application.  Please review the Typical Qualifications listed at the top.  If you meet these qualifications send your full name and phone number and we will call you to schedule a showing.  You do not need to fill out the application if you do not like the property, but we will accept any application with non-refundable application fee at the showing time. etc..."
    3-If we get this far and I call, I will usually ask qualifying questions again.
    4-Only serious people will read the email, check the typical qualifications, AND send their full name and phone number.  Really serious people, usually bring me the application ready and copies in a small folder.  They usually end up getting the property...

    Hope this helps!

     Hi Luke, would you be willing to share your email in it's entirety?  I'm getting ready to list our rental and it's been 10 years since we last listed it!  I'm a little rusty on what typical qualifications I should ask for.  Thanks!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.