Rental Property Investor · Member since 2023 · 2 posts · 2 votes
Looking for some advice….We have one unit with no pets but the second unit we are testing the waters and allowing one small dog. Anyone have experience with pets in their rentals? Is it a bad idea?
Looking for some advice….We have one unit with no pets but the second unit we are testing the waters and allowing one small dog. Anyone have experience with pets in their rentals? Is it a bad idea?
Majority of tenants have pets these days, so you may be significantly shrinking your tenant pool.
Also, you may be setting yourself up to have tenants sneak pets in.
I'm Mo, a real estate broker based in NYC and Long Island. I’ve read and heard from other landlords that having a clear pet policy and addendum is crucial. Things like size limits, behavioral expectations, and responsibilities for damage can help protect your property and set clear expectations for tenants. Many landlords also charge a pet deposit or monthly pet rent, which can help cover wear and tear or potential extra maintenance.
Hi Gia, I allow pets in my rentals and have a pet addendum that my real estate attorney provided me. I think in A or B class usually owners take care of their pets. I would be more hesitant to allow in C or D class. You want to limit your personal liability so I would recommend requiring them to have renters insurance covering their pet. Unfortunately, some insurances have breed restrictions, so it might be more expensive than regular renters insurance to cover breeds like pit bulls. I don’t take a separate pet deposit because it is sometimes hard to tell if damage was done by pet or human. Hope this helps.
Hi Gia, Research shows that you cut your tenant pool by close to 60% if you don't allow pets. Also, with ESA and service animals being allowed anyway, there are many ways to get pets in. Weight limits or breed restrictions are common and can add a bit of control on your end.
As a property management company, we have seen a lot of homes that go wither way. We have never had pet damage to the point that we could not fix it, and have had more success renting the home with allowing pets.
Looking for some advice….We have one unit with no pets but the second unit we are testing the waters and allowing one small dog. Anyone have experience with pets in their rentals? Is it a bad idea?
Majority of tenants have pets these days, so you may be significantly shrinking your tenant pool.
Also, you may be setting yourself up to have tenants sneak pets in.
Pets for sure can be bad and they can be good.. So the example I can give, one lady moved in a year ago to one of our properties (moved out after a year). There were some blinds missing and that was about it. So minimal damage, and I have had one guy move in for 7 months, his dog pulled up all the grass in the backyard and some other stuff which cost us the full security deposit $3,600.00. So it really depends on the size, breed and other factors.
Pets aren’t automatically a bad idea but they do require tighter controls. Many landlords successfully allow small dogs with clear pet policies, pet screening, additional deposit or pet rent and regular inspections. The key is proper screening and written expectations. Done right, pets can increase demand without significantly increasing risk.
Done right pets will increase your tenant pool and keep tenants staying longer. Use petscreening.com to screen all pets. You can use them for assistance animals as well - they will do all the vetting.
From a property management perspective, pets aren’t automatically a bad idea, but they do need to be handled intentionally. A strict no-pet policy definitely shrinks the tenant pool and can lead to longer vacancy times, since many otherwise qualified renters have pets.
The key is having a clear pet policy in place. Screening, a pet addendum, limits on size or number, and proper fees or pet rent go a long way. Some owners also use pet programs that include additional damage protection beyond the security deposit, which helps manage risk.
In our experience, responsible pet owners often stay longer because their housing options are more limited.
When I first started investing in real estate, I was pretty against pets, but as time went on, I found myself limiting a large amount of tenant pool. Truth is a lot of people nowadays are actually preferring to have pets instead of kids, and the truth about pets is that it's not the pet that's the problem - 99% of the time it's the owner. if the owner is clean organized and takes care of their things their pet will not affect the condition of the property. That being said, I usually try to aim for animals under 20 to 30 pounds because having two large German Shepherd's in a 1 to 2 bedroom apartment - It's just not a good idea. That already tells me something about the person because in my opinion, it's not responsible to have such a large animal in such a small space that type of animal needs a large indoor space as well as access to large outdoor space. in many cases, I actually now request property walk-through of their current property. I will ask the prospective tenant if I can do a quick walk-through of their current place and that will tell me the entire story and everything I need to know. If they are hesitant and are uncomfortable and don't want me to do a walkthrough - usually that is a huge red flag and I move on. The people who are super responsive to this and even ask me to do it the same day are usually not hiding anything.
Everyone talks about 'reducing the tenant pool' and they are absolutely correct. It does.
BUT - I would rather work with a smaller pool of possible renters, and know that the odds of a huge animal repair problem are not going to be there. I have rehabbed houses that had animal urine and there is no end to the problem. Once I even had to re-mud drywall in the entire house to get rid of the problem....after sanding wood floors 3 times! If you only have to re-finish floors, prime and paint...you are getting of easy.....
As far as sneaking animals in, more frequent inspections will take care of that. You should be doing these anyway.
I have always allowed pets and always will. The reward far outweighs the risk - added income, filling vacancies sooner, and better-quality tenants. You just need to make the property as close to indestructible as possible. We manage a portfolio of 400+ and 98% of them now allow pets. The 2% that do not are in HOA's that do not allow them.
Agree with @Adam Bartomeo. Most of the homes we manage allow pets and we make sure homes are built for it and also that our leases are strong and structured to protect our owners. Additional pet deposit and pet rent are great ways to offset any possible damage.
Pets can sometimes cause odors and lead to higher maintenance costs in rental properties. However, based on my experience with more than 20 tenants, about one-third of them have pets. Especially when the rental market is slow, a strict no-pet policy can significantly extend vacancy time.
When pets are medium or small in size and the proper pet deposit and fees are collected, most tenants with pets tend to be very responsible and take extra care of the property. So far, I haven’t encountered any cases where pets caused major damage to a rental unit.
Pets aren’t automatically a problem, but they do change the risk profile of the unit. A lot of it comes down to screening and structure rather than just “yes or no.”
Some owners find that allowing pets widens the applicant pool and can lead to longer tenancies, but wear and tear, odors, and potential damage are real considerations. Clear pet policies, limits on size/breed, and making sure expectations are documented upfront tend to matter more than the pet itself.
The bigger issues usually come from poor screening or unclear rules, not the animal alone. Consistency in enforcement is key once you decide your policy.