Where's My Money?

Where's My Money?

Investor · Midwest · Member since 2019 · 384 posts · 254 votes

How do you handle deposit refunds? Last month, two tenants disputed their deposit refunds.

Tenant #1: The Heavy Smoker

After four years, this tenant moved out. During my video walkthrough, I commented how hard it was to breathe. The walls were yellow with nicotine, and you could see exactly where pictures had hung. The bedroom carpet looked like someone had changed an engine on it.

This unit was completely remodeled before she moved in.

We sent her an accounting of damages above normal wear and tear. She argued for two days.

Then we shared the video.

Tenant #2: The Revisionist Historian

After eight months, this tenant moved out under a mutual lease-break agreement. Another story for another time.

She requested a joint walkthrough, which I declined. After 20-plus years in this business, I've learned those rarely end well.

We refunded 35% of her security deposit.

She argued that her move-out video showed the apartment was clean and in good condition. I agreed it was in good condition and you can see she cleaned, but that doesn't mean damage-free.

We compared her move-in inspection report, which SHE completed, against our documented move-out damages.

She then claimed the damage was preexisting and insisted we use her move-out video instead.

Talk about revisionist history!

The lesson:

  • Document the property's condition before move-in.

  • Give tenants 72 hours to submit their move-in inspection. Your lease should establish your condition report as the baseline if they fail to submit theirs, subject to applicable law.

  • Record your move-out inspection and provide an itemized accounting within your state's required timeline.

Without documentation, you're arguing opinions. With documentation, you're discussing evidence.

What's your process for handling security deposit disputes?

Do you conduct joint move-out walkthroughs or let your documentation do the talking?

2Reply
375 views

Most Popular Reply

Leo SteinBusiness Member
Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 328 posts · 79 votes
23h

Carl, the move-in report the tenant completes themselves is the piece that bites most people, so I treat it as the foundation of every deposit decision. Not legal advice, and deposit rules vary by state.

Here's the routine I'd suggest. Do the move-in condition report together or with dated photos from the manager, and have the tenant sign off on it. At move-out, do the same set of photos room by room, same angles, so the comparison is easy to line up. Keep a written damage list with a repair estimate or invoice behind each line, and separate normal wear from damage. Long tenancies like your four-year smoker case generally mean the age of carpet and paint matters when you decide what is fair to charge.

On the joint walkthrough, declining isn't unreasonable, but offering a short video call or sending your photos first can take the heat out of a dispute before it starts.

Happy to compare notes by message.

Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

15 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 766 votes
    1d

    Your process is the right one — documentation does the talking. I run 236 single-family rentals in Memphis, mostly Section 8, and I don't do joint move-out walkthroughs to argue in person. I document, in writing, with video and photos.

    Move-in condition, tenant's own move-in report, move-out video, and an itemized accounting. That file is what protects you when a tenant rewrites history. Clean does not mean damage-free, and a tenant's move-out video doesn't replace the move-in baseline they signed.

    The number that matters: on a 3-bedroom at $1,395-$1,950 a month, a disputed deposit that turns into a vacant, unrented house costs far more than the deposit itself. Get the accounting out on time, keep it plain and itemized, and get the house turned and rented again. Don't let a deposit fight keep a house empty.

  • Member since 2026 · 46 posts · 14 votes
    1d

    Carl, both cases show the same lesson: the dispute is usually won or lost at move-in, not at move-out. The move-in condition report is the baseline everything else is measured against, so it pays to make it thorough, dated, and signed by both sides, with photos for every room.

    What experienced landlords recommend is a simple three-part file for each deposit: the signed move-in report, dated move-out photos or video taken in the same order, and an itemized list where each charge names the item, the cost, and the evidence for it. Keeping the deposit in a separate account and recording it as money held for the tenant, not as income, also makes the accounting much easier to defend.

    On joint walkthroughs, a short one can help if the checklist is followed and notes are signed on the spot, but it is not a substitute for the written record. A calm, factual reply that points to the specific photo, report line, and receipt for each charge usually ends the argument faster than debating cleanliness in general terms. The state deadline for sending that accounting is the part to check first, since missing it can matter more than any single charge.

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 328 posts · 79 votes
    23h

    Carl, the move-in report the tenant completes themselves is the piece that bites most people, so I treat it as the foundation of every deposit decision. Not legal advice, and deposit rules vary by state.

    Here's the routine I'd suggest. Do the move-in condition report together or with dated photos from the manager, and have the tenant sign off on it. At move-out, do the same set of photos room by room, same angles, so the comparison is easy to line up. Keep a written damage list with a repair estimate or invoice behind each line, and separate normal wear from damage. Long tenancies like your four-year smoker case generally mean the age of carpet and paint matters when you decide what is fair to charge.

    On the joint walkthrough, declining isn't unreasonable, but offering a short video call or sending your photos first can take the heat out of a dispute before it starts.

    Happy to compare notes by message.

    Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews
    • Investor · Midwest · Member since 2019 · 384 posts · 254 votes
      5h

      @Leo Stein good point. Depreciation should be factored into the age of carpet, paint etc.

  • Property Manager · Denver, CO · Member since 2026 · 27 posts · 12 votes
    23h

    Sounds like the documentation did its job, both of those ended once the evidence came out. The part I'd add happens before move-out, since that's where a lot of these arguments can get headed off.

    When a tenant gives notice, send a move-out letter with:

    - the cleaning checklist you'll inspect against

    - a price sheet for the common charges (carpet cleaning, paint per wall, blinds, hauling)

    - a reminder that their signed move-in report is what you'll compare to

    Then the itemized statement is just that price sheet filled in, and clean vs damage-free has already been explained in writing before any money moves.

    On the four-year tenant, I'd show the age of the carpet and paint in the itemization and charge a prorated amount, not full replacement. That's usually the line tenants push back on hardest and some states expect it. On walkthroughs, some landlords offer an optional pre-move-out inspection a week or two before the last day in place of a joint one. The tenant gets a list of what to fix while there's still time, and there's nothing to argue about yet.

    • Investor · Midwest · Member since 2019 · 384 posts · 254 votes
      5h

      @Jaimee LaTorra I like this suggestion. While we do provide the move out checklist, we don't provide the price sheet or a copy of their move in sheet. Thanks

  • Mike FisherBusiness Member
    New Lenox, IL · Member since 2024 · 151 posts · 78 votes
    23h

    Carl, I'm with you on skipping the joint walkthrough. For us the move-in condition report is the baseline: done in the first week, dated photos of every room, and the tenant gets a short window to note anything we missed. Everything at move-out gets measured against that file.

    The part that gets overlooked is the clock. A deposit dispute is rarely about the deposit, it is about the days the unit sits empty while the argument plays out. On most of our south suburb rentals, a month of vacancy costs several times the typical disputed charge. So we send the itemized accounting early, each line naming the item, the cost and the photo, and start the turn in parallel instead of waiting for the tenant to agree.

    One habit that saves a lot of back and forth: shoot the move-out photos in the same room order as the move-in set. Side by side, it stops being a debate about clean versus damaged.

    I've been doing this personally since 1991, and the owners who document the same way every single time spend the least time arguing. Mike, M Property Group LLC, managing in Chicago's south and southwest suburbs.

    M Property Group LLC | MF Cashflow Property Management4.997 Reviews
  • Ryan BrownPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2022 · 133 posts · 45 votes
    22h

    Carl, documentation is the right lesson, but honestly what jumped out at me was that you refunded 35% to the second tenant at all. I'm not sure how there's anything left after almost any repair.

    Take a unit renting for $1,500 with a $1,500 deposit. One room of paint, labor included, can easily run a few hundred dollars. Add a few patched drywall holes, a carpet cleaning or a single replaced section, a missing blind and a trip charge from the handyman, and the deposit is close to gone. After four years of heavy smoking like the first tenant, you're looking at priming and repainting the whole unit and probably replacing carpet, which can cost more than the deposit on its own. I've rarely seen a move-out with real damage where the deposit covered everything.

    That's why I think of the deposit as a minimum, not a cap. If the documented damage goes over it, send the tenant an itemized bill for the balance, the same way you did the accounting. Some will pay, some won't. If it's a large amount, small claims or a collections agency is an option, and a good file like yours is exactly what makes that work. You do have to charge fairly. A carpet that's eight years old was near the end of its life anyway, so you can generally only charge for the remaining value, not the full cost of new carpet.

    The other side is the amount you collect up front. Where your state allows it, a deposit higher than one month's rent for higher-risk applicants, or a separate nonrefundable pet fee, gives you more of a cushion before a turnover starts costing you out of pocket.

    I'm curious what made up the other 65% on tenant #2. If she cleaned well and still lost most of her deposit in eight months, there was real damage, and I'm surprised it didn't take all of it.

    • Investor · Midwest · Member since 2019 · 384 posts · 254 votes
      5h

      @Ryan Brown we have a $250 cleaning fee and a $50 rekey fee in our lease as standard.

      Clean is subjective, while she left the place "clean" we still had to send our team in to do a standard clean after we made repairs, painted etc.


      We rekey the locks after each tenant even if they turn in the keys. You never know who they gave a copy to.

      I tenant proof my units as much as possible so LVT is throughout some, some have ceramic tile. Carpet is in bedrooms only in some units, but when I turn those I put the LVT so carpet cleaning isn't an expense as much as it use to be. This also keeps my turn cost down.

      She repaired some holes herself that were above fair wear and tear so we only had to sand and paint. No need to charge her for a repair she made, just the part we had to fix.

      I have my own team so I generally bill based on my man hours vs. market rate. If my guys are tied up and I need to bring in one of the contractors I use then that's the rate I use.

  • Member since 2026 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    22h

    On joint walkthroughs: offer one, but don’t rely on it. What wins disputes is the same photo route at move-in and move-out (same rooms, same order, same angles, timestamped), so anyone can compare them side by side.

    For the itemized accounting, pair each deduction with its before and after photos plus a receipt or written bid. Charge long-lived items like carpet and paint on a depreciated basis, not full replacement.

    Here in California the pre-move-out inspection has to be offered in writing, landlords now have to take move-in and move-out photos, and the itemization is due within 21 days. Worth checking whether your state has similar rules before leaning on a lease clause.

  • Member since 2026 · 93 posts · 31 votes
    22h

    Carl, you handled both of these well, and the video walkthrough is what saves you here. On the smoker, nicotine staining and odor after four years is damage, not wear, and your before-and-after video plus the itemized accounting is exactly the record that holds up when a tenant pushes back. On the second tenant, comparing her own move-in report against your documented move-out damages was the right move, and a clean-looking video does not erase damage that is underneath it. Two habits that have kept us out of these fights: a detailed move-in inspection with photos that the tenant signs, and a written deposit statement sent promptly with receipts and photos attached, line by line. Most disputes fade once the tenant sees the paperwork is complete and consistent. Keep the video, keep the signed inspection, and do not let a tenant swap in their own video for your records.

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    20h

    Afternoon @Carl Millsap,

    Both stories show how much easier the conversation gets once the evidence is organized. The video settled the first one in two days, and the tenant's own move-in report did most of the work on the second.

    I think the part that still takes owners the most time is turning all of it into the itemized accounting. Lining up the move-in report, the move-out video and the repair invoices room by room is slow by hand, and it's exactly the kind of reading AI handles well. It can lay them side by side and draft the list, so the owner only has to check it and decide what's fair.

    Thanks for sharing both stories,
    Lee

  • Bianca BarcelosBusiness Member
    NH · Member since 2026 · 92 posts · 51 votes
    20h

    Yikes . Definitly doccument everything upon moving in and even add some notes in the lease for "house rules". A mutual respect of the space and the living conditions is important; you own it but it's their home. So if that respect is felt, hopefully the values match on some level.

    Unfortunatly, when it comes down to it, some of these issues and expenses after someone moves out are part of your turn over fees but it seems that these were certainly above and beyond, espicially if you renovated just before that tenant moved in. It's best if the condition of the house before and after and a really clear picture of "normal" wear and tear is agreed upon in the lease so that you're not arguing opinion.

    Bianca Barcelos, Real Estate59 Reviews
    View Page
  • Member since 2026 · 1 post · 0 votes
    5h

    Same lesson here. The tenant's move-out video showing it's clean is a different question from whether it's damaged, and the only thing that settles it is the same spot photographed at move-in and move-out.

    My process: I take move-in photos myself (same corners every room, close-ups of anything existing), send them to the tenant the same day, and give them 72 hours to add anything, like you do. At move-out I take the same shots and send an itemized list with the matching before/after pair for every charge. No joint walkthrough either. The photos do the talking.

    The one thing I added after a "those photos could be from anywhere" argument: every photo has the date, time and address stamped on it. I use an app called Lokmi for that.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    4h

    Biggest takeaway for everyone reading this have a system that properly documents what you need!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.