Is rent by the room worth it?

Question

Hello everybody, I am looking into buying a home and using it as a rent by the room property/househack. I am 21 years old and have just completed my first BRRRR project and have found that the cashflow is not something that would set me financially free as quickly as I would want it to in todays real estate environment. Since I am young and have the time to manage something like this I wanted to hear from people who have done it.

How much cashflow can I expect?

What kind of challenges have you faced?

Is management really difficult?

Have you found it to be worth it?

What kind of things to do you look for in a rent by the room property?

How much cashflow can I expect?

What kind of challenges have you faced?

Is management really difficult?

Have you found it to be worth it?

What kind of things to do you look for in a rent by the room property?

Danielle Daly · Answer

Hey Jack! I may be a little biased because this is exactly how I got started, but I think rent-by-the-room is one of the fastest ways to build cash flow if you're willing to be more hands-on.

And kudos to you for starting at 21 years old! Wish I started that young.

I bought my first house hack 4 years ago and have since done multiple co-living/rent-by-the-room properties. Compared to traditional rentals, the cash flow difference has been significant.

A few thoughts based on your questions:

Cash flow: It varies a lot by market and the house itself, but the biggest advantage is that you're monetizing each bedroom instead of the property as a whole. In many cases, that's the difference between breaking even on a traditional rental and generating meaningful monthly cash flow.

Challenges: Tenant compatibility is probably the biggest one. You're managing people living together, not just renting a property. Having clear expectations, solid screening, and house rules from day one makes a huge difference. Turnover is definitely higher, so having systems in place is important.

Management: It's definitely more active than a standard rental, especially at first. That said, I think people often overestimate how difficult it is. Once you have good processes for screening, onboarding, and communication, it becomes much more manageable.

Was it worth it? Absolutely. For me, it accelerated my investing journey far more than a traditional rental would have. Not only did it produce stronger cash flow, but it also allowed me to save and reinvest into future properties faster.

What I look for:

• - 4-6+ bedrooms (or a layout with the ability to add one legally)
• - 2+ bathrooms
• - Strong job market and demand from young professionals
• - Plenty of parking
• - A functional layout that gives tenants some privacy
• - A neighborhood where I'd actually feel comfortable living myself

Since you're 21 and already completed a BRRRR, I'd also think about your goals. If your priority is maximizing monthly cash flow and you're okay being more involved, rent-by-the-room can be a fantastic strategy. If your goal is completely passive investing, it's probably not the best fit.

I'd encourage you to run the numbers both ways: traditional rental vs. renting each bedroom individually. Seeing that difference on paper is what convinced me to go all in on co-living.

Best of luck to you!! And feel free to reach out if any more questions come up :)

Ed Barone · Answer

Hi Jack,First off, congrats on completing your first BRRRR project.

I wouldn’t let the management side scare you away. Renting by the room and managing the property yourself can be quite simple with good systems in place, whether the property is local or remote, and especially if you’re house hacking.

There are inexpensive platforms that can help with rent collection, screening, maintenance, communication, leases, and finances. In full transparency, I’m a co-founder of RentRedi, and BiggerPockets Pro members already have RentRedi included with their membership.

I’d also strongly recommend coming to BPCON in Orlando if you can swing it. One of the best things you can do early on is meet and learn from people who are already doing what you want to do and have scaled to the level of cash flow you are trying to hit. You’ll have plenty of opportunities to talk one-on-one with experienced investors.

We’ll be there too, so please stop by and say hello. Hope to see you in Orlando!

Matthew Paul · Answer

First at 21 years old , 1 rental property isnt gonna make financially free , not even close . It takes more than one and it takes time .

Second , renting by the room , what could go wrong ?   You put 4 people in a house that dont know each other and have to get along . Who cleand the bathroom , the kitchen , whos tv is in the living room , does one play their music too loud ? Does someone work night shift , who gets the driveway to park ?  How long can a boyfriend / girlfriend stay and how often ?

MOST OF ALL who is the referee ?   Are you going to live there ?

I am from a family of 7 , five kids , 2 adults and it was fun , constant crazyness . Someone used all the hot water , this one didnt clean the bathroom , why are there dirty clothes piled over there . We had 2 referees , full time Mom and Dad . And we learned . you know what FAFO means .

Good luck if you go that route

James Jones · Answer

Rent-by-the-room can absolutely work, but it’s a different business model than traditional rentals. Think of it like running a mini-dorm or co-living setup, higher cash flow, higher touch.

Here’s what you should expect:

1. Cash flow (the real numbers)

Most rent-by-room investors I know (myself included) see 2–3x the cash flow of renting the house as a single unit when the property is set up correctly.

Example:

$1,800/month as a standard rental

$3,000–$3,600/month renting by room (4–5 rooms)

But it only works if:

Bedrooms are good size

Common areas are functional

Layout supports privacy

You’re 21 with time to manage it, that’s an advantage. Most older investors don’t want the work.

2. Challenges (the stuff nobody tells you)

Rent-by-room has amazing upside but comes with tradeoffs:

• Tenant turnover is higher.

Expect 2–3x the turnover of a normal rental, but vacancies are shorter since rooms rent fast.

• More personality management.

You’re not managing units, you’re managing people sharing a home.

House rules matter. Screening matters even more.

• More wear and tear.

Common areas get used harder. Budget for more frequent cleaning and maintenance.

3. Is it hard to manage?

It’s not hard, but it’s more hands-on unless you build systems:

Automated rent collection

Pre-set house rules

Weekly cleaning (either you or a cleaner)

Clear communication expectations

Once the systems are in place, it’s not bad. Some investors even scale it using cleaners and a VA.

4. Is it worth it?

If your goal is maximum cash flow early in your journey, 100 percent yes.

Rent-by-room is one of the few strategies where a young investor with limited capital can generate:

high cash flow

low personal living expenses

faster savings for the next deal

It’s one of the best stepping stones to building wealth.

5. What to look for in a good rent-by-room property

Look for these features:

4–5 bedroom layout (or ability to add bedrooms)

Big living room / dining room

At least 2 bathrooms

Parking for multiple cars

Safe area (huge for co-living)

Split floor plan or good separation

Low HOA restrictions

Ability to add locks to bedroom doors

The layout is way more important than fancy finishes.

Denis Um · Answer

Hey Jack,

Congratulations on completing your first brrr.

Rent by the room can be a nightmare to manage but in today's environment you need to come up with something more than the traditional long term rental to be able to find good cash flow.

Ther are plenty of people using this strategy today and it is definitely doable if you have the time and energy to figure out how to manage.

At your age I would say go ahead and try it out.

Good luck

Victor So · Answer

I’m in Chicago (& Suburbs) and mostly do rent by room stuff. In my opinion, understanding your market and what drives the rent by room model are keys to making it work. In my market, I know affordable housing is an issue and folks will sacrifice a little discomfort to share common areas and rent by room in exchange for cheaper housing. Also, I know the appeal of my market. For example, for most of my properties, public transportation is easily accessible, there’s tons of hospitals nearby (which attracts many medical workers), concert venues, airport, etc. And the best way to gauge what you can get in rents is to just rent rooms in your own house. If I could go back to being 21 again, I’d do whatever I could to buy a house with the most rooms and start renting out extra rooms and spaces. Once I figure out market rents for rooms, I’d buy more properties and scale.

Alexandra Hughes Pailet · Answer

Plugging this here as well: Use code FORUMS for $100 off your BPCON ticket, which can be stacked with the Early Bird discount happening now!

BiggerPockets.com/conference

And, yes @Jack Hamm, I totally think rent by the room is worth it! I recommend checking out @Miller McSwain's guide on co-living! https://store.biggerpockets.com/products/co-living-cash-flow...

Jake Andronico · Answer

@Jack Hamm

I'm bias, but I've done this twice in Reno, NV starting 6 years ago and it's completely changed my life.

Here's what I learned, and what I regret starting at 22:

https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/922/topics/1133476-hous...

James Stark · Answer

I would say it depends on your clientel. I have a nice home. Im picky about who stays here.

Is rent by the room worth it?

Most Popular Reply