I've always heard about arbitrage and never really given it much thought, but it seems easier to get Packers season tickets than a tier 4 STR permit in SD. Arbitrage could be a good way to overcome barriers to entry in this market and build some knowledge (and hopefully make some money).
Anyone pursue this strategy before in San Diego or elsewhere? Any tips from personal experience that I might be surprised to hear, other than the obvious challenges?
Appreciate the insight,
Lucas
Hey Lucas, rental arbitrage is how I got my start in the furnished rental space. My business does property management now, but it still holds a place in my heart for my origin story.
I'm in Los Angeles, so it may be similar to your market, in that long-term rents are high. What I've found in L.A. is that the delta between long-term and mid-term rent is not enough to make MTR arbitrage worthwhile here. I do know other arbitrage operators who do MTR specifically in other markets where it is definitely a viable business model, and I believe that's because their long-term rents are lower and there's more margin there for MTR arbitrage.
You're on the right track with your thinking. Short-term arbitrage will make a lot more sense here in LA and probably in San Diego as well, except for regulations. So, you have to kind of pick which path you want to take, and I agree with you that the arbitrage is a great way to get started at building cash flow. Remember, arbitrage is a business, not investing; it is a real estate business similar to property management as a real estate business but it is not real estate investing. So, you are creating a job for yourself if that's what you want - that's awesome. If it's not what you want, then just keep that in mind.
Hey @Lucas Bernard - a lot of people will say arbitrage is risky and not real investing, and there’s some truth to that. But we do a little of it (about 10% of our portfolio) when it makes sense.
Pros: low cost to get in, more control vs. managing for someone else, and in our case, maintenance is handled by the building, along some utilities and amenities included. Cons: you’re on the hook for rent no matter what.
It’s not a goldmine, or a way to get rich quick, but the cash-on-cash returns can be solid. We started with buying property years ago, and only added arbitrage later. If you’re smart about the deal and the market, it can absolutely work.
I've always heard about arbitrage and never really given it much thought, but it seems easier to get Packers season tickets than a tier 4 STR permit in SD. Arbitrage could be a good way to overcome barriers to entry in this market and build some knowledge (and hopefully make some money).
Anyone pursue this strategy before in San Diego or elsewhere? Any tips from personal experience that I might be surprised to hear, other than the obvious challenges?
Appreciate the insight,
Lucas
Tier 4 is mission beach and is the only license that has hit the quota. Wait list is currently 55. In year 1, ~90 came off the waitlist.
This means
1) you can get a STR license for anywhere in the city of San Diego except mission beach. If you do not own the unit, you can choose somewhere besides Mission beach.
2) that there is a decent/good chance if you are on the mission beach waitlist you will get off the waitlist within a year. Note the packers waitlist is estimated to be between 30 and 50 years.
I know someone that has been doing MTR arbitage in Dan Diego county for ~5 years. She has a lot of RE experience and does turn a profit. I have had STRs, MTRs, and LTRs in San Diego. My primary source of return from any of these is not the cash flow, but the appreciation. My appreciation has ranged from $2700/month to over $10k/month over the hold. To miss out on this appreciation would greatly affect my return.
In addition, I do not understand why an owner would choose to let an unlicensed, under capitalized person arbitrage their high value unit. Note they can profit share with a licensed and insured property manager keeping a significant majority of the income.
Good luck
I've always heard about arbitrage and never really given it much thought, but it seems easier to get Packers season tickets than a tier 4 STR permit in SD. Arbitrage could be a good way to overcome barriers to entry in this market and build some knowledge (and hopefully make some money).
Anyone pursue this strategy before in San Diego or elsewhere? Any tips from personal experience that I might be surprised to hear, other than the obvious challenges?
Appreciate the insight,
Lucas
Tier 4 is mission beach and is the only license that has hit the quota. Wait list is currently 55. In year 1, ~90 came off the waitlist.
This means
1) you can get a STR license for anywhere in the city of San Diego except mission beach. If you do not own the unit, you can choose somewhere besides Mission beach.
2) that there is a decent/good chance if you are on the mission beach waitlist you will get off the waitlist within a year. Note the packers waitlist is estimated to be between 30 and 50 years.
I know someone that has been doing MTR arbitage in Dan Diego county for ~5 years. She has a lot of RE experience and does turn a profit. I have had STRs, MTRs, and LTRs in San Diego. My primary source of return from any of these is not the cash flow, but the appreciation. My appreciation has ranged from $2700/month to over $10k/month over the hold. To miss out on this appreciation would greatly affect my return.
In addition, I do not understand why an owner would choose to let an unlicensed, under capitalized person arbitrage their high value unit. Note they can profit share with a licensed and insured property manager keeping a significant majority of the income.
Good luck
Thank you for the detailed info Dan!
Hey Lucas, rental arbitrage is how I got my start in the furnished rental space. My business does property management now, but it still holds a place in my heart for my origin story.
I'm in Los Angeles, so it may be similar to your market, in that long-term rents are high. What I've found in L.A. is that the delta between long-term and mid-term rent is not enough to make MTR arbitrage worthwhile here. I do know other arbitrage operators who do MTR specifically in other markets where it is definitely a viable business model, and I believe that's because their long-term rents are lower and there's more margin there for MTR arbitrage.
You're on the right track with your thinking. Short-term arbitrage will make a lot more sense here in LA and probably in San Diego as well, except for regulations. So, you have to kind of pick which path you want to take, and I agree with you that the arbitrage is a great way to get started at building cash flow. Remember, arbitrage is a business, not investing; it is a real estate business similar to property management as a real estate business but it is not real estate investing. So, you are creating a job for yourself if that's what you want - that's awesome. If it's not what you want, then just keep that in mind.
Hey Lucas, rental arbitrage is how I got my start in the furnished rental space. My business does property management now, but it still holds a place in my heart for my origin story.
I'm in Los Angeles, so it may be similar to your market, in that long-term rents are high. What I've found in L.A. is that the delta between long-term and mid-term rent is not enough to make MTR arbitrage worthwhile here. I do know other arbitrage operators who do MTR specifically in other markets where it is definitely a viable business model, and I believe that's because their long-term rents are lower and there's more margin there for MTR arbitrage.
You're on the right track with your thinking. Short-term arbitrage will make a lot more sense here in LA and probably in San Diego as well, except for regulations. So, you have to kind of pick which path you want to take, and I agree with you that the arbitrage is a great way to get started at building cash flow. Remember, arbitrage is a business, not investing; it is a real estate business similar to property management as a real estate business but it is not real estate investing. So, you are creating a job for yourself if that's what you want - that's awesome. If it's not what you want, then just keep that in mind.
Well said Allen, still weighing options on my end and appreciate the insight.