Hi everyone,
My name is Celine, and I live in Los Angeles. I've been learning about real estate investing and am ready to take action on my first out-of-state property using the BRRRR method (with plans for short-term rentals). I have enough cash to invest and am considering cities like Indianapolis, IN; Cincinnati, OH; Cleveland, OH; Atlanta, GA; and Charlotte, NC.
I’m looking to purchase houses around $300K, with the intention of fixing them up. For experienced out-of-state investors, where have you invested? Which cities and areas do you think have the greatest potential for appreciation?
Thanks in advance for sharing your insights!
@Celine Li I am curious if, before posting this, you clicked on the search function in top right, and tried looking up this subject/ answer/ question????
I truly feel a need to understand your process, because this question seems to get asked almost hourly. And yes, that's a rather accurate measure.
The question comes with various customized details but it's the same answer over-n-over again, to such a degree that answer-burn becomes a very real thing.
Which means for those later asking, they won't get the kind of care of answer the earlier persons get.
So I gotta know, did you try that? If not, why not? Maybe you were not even aware of the function? Or was it too complicated or frustrating to complete a search that way?
Or did you just directly go to posting? If so, I am curious the thoughts and drives behind that, like, maybe really wanted exact answers to you so thought posting on your specifics was best approach?
I just want to understand.
Because a flood of the 1 same question does not do anyone a service on BP. It floods out variety of content, makes for answer burn-out, etc etc..
--------------------------------------------------------
To answer your question, fact and reality is there is no such thing as a "golden ticket" market. The best market for YOU, is the market that fit's YOU; you're situation, your preferences, you're resources, your knowledge level, you're risk aversion and about 40 other personalized factors to you.
So start with STRATEGY.
Develop YOU'RE strategy.
Than, once you have that, the strategy will describe exactly what market it works in and which it doesnt.
From there it's just math, the metrics of where best fit's for that strategy deployment. Next is getting to the work of researching that market to confirm viability, building the TEAM, the How-To for strategy.
If you ask others you will only find out what's best FOR THEM.
We don't know you, we have no idea how you act under pressure, how much hair a sec8 tenant will have you pulling out or how thick you skin is. It's a very personal thing, it really is.
If your asking where the profit is: EVERYWHERE. It's literally everywhere, 98.7% of places. All that changes is how to profit and how much.
Perfection is not a place, it's a process.
I would trend toward the first two on your list, but all have potential. Just know that when you make a post like this, the agents are all going to come and say their area is the best. How did you come up with these markets? Lists?
Do you know anyone in those areas or have you been to or lived in any of those areas? If so, that's your prime market to start in because you have a competitive advantage of boots on the ground you trust of personal knowledge.
If I were you, and new, I would not do fixers, I would buy turnkey or rent-ready properties or you are going to have to trust a whole lot more people to do what you want to be done.
Hi Jonathan, Thank you for your thoughtful reply and advice! You're absolutely right—agents will always say their area is the best, which is why I appreciate hearing different perspectives and the reasoning behind them.
I came up with these markets based on research into affordability and population growth trends. I don’t personally know anyone in these areas, nor have I lived there, but I’m open to visiting to get a better feel for the markets and make connections.
Hi, the Ohio market is a great place to invest in real estate. Please reach out with any questions. Good Luck!
@Celine Li
I also agree with @Jonathan Greene. Doing a BRRRR that you plan on turning into an air bnb would not be the best as a beginner out of state. Regardless of the market I would buy something more turnkey and get familiar with your PM, agent, and team then look at branching out and buying a BRRRR after the first one is stabilized. People have a hard enough time doing a BRRRR minus the air bnb portion and vice versa doing an air bnb minus the value add. On top of that, add being out of state and that just adds more complexity to it. Start simple
Hi everyone,
My name is Celine, and I live in Los Angeles. I've been learning about real estate investing and am ready to take action on my first out-of-state property using the BRRRR method (with plans for short-term rentals). I have enough cash to invest and am considering cities like Indianapolis, IN; Cincinnati, OH; Cleveland, OH; Atlanta, GA; and Charlotte, NC.
I’m looking to purchase houses around $300K, with the intention of fixing them up. For experienced out-of-state investors, where have you invested? Which cities and areas do you think have the greatest potential for appreciation?
Thanks in advance for sharing your insights!
I suggest interviewing teams of realtors, contractors, lenders, and property managers in each market. Additionally, set up home searches in each market. Finally, select the market that best aligns with your goals.
Hey Celine, great questions.
Our firm invests in Michigan and Ohio, with 90% of our holdings in southeast Michigan. We have found that the Midwest offers an attractive price per door that cannot be matched in any other region. If you are predominantly looking to flip these homes, someone else may be able to provide more-specific advice for your situation. More directly related to your area of interest - I suggest concentrating in 1 market out of your list at first, and build a system (vendors, property manager, etc). Once it's really running well, take on another city on your list. If they're in the same state, that will make your legal team more streamlined, but otherwise, you have to form all new vendor teams when assets are scattered across multiple MSAs & states. If you work a day job in addition to your plans to pursue real estate in this way, then focusing in 1 city/MSA will drastically reduce your time spent focused outside your job, allowing you to keep your income high, your job safe, and your problems simpler. Best of luck!
Hey Celine,
When looking into Cleveland, I would take a look on the west side. Look into neighborhoods like Clark Fulton, Jefferson, West Park and Boulevard, Brooklyn Center, Old Brooklyn, and Newburgh Heights.
If you're looking for cities with the greatest potential of appreciation, I also suggest putting Columbus, Ohio, on your list, as there's a ton of growth happening in the city.
No matter where you chose to invest, it will be crucial to work with an investor friendly agent so you're able to gain the right insight on the different areas and the risks involved.
Hi everyone,
My name is Celine, and I live in Los Angeles. I've been learning about real estate investing and am ready to take action on my first out-of-state property using the BRRRR method (with plans for short-term rentals). I have enough cash to invest and am considering cities like Indianapolis, IN; Cincinnati, OH; Cleveland, OH; Atlanta, GA; and Charlotte, NC.
I’m looking to purchase houses around $300K, with the intention of fixing them up. For experienced out-of-state investors, where have you invested? Which cities and areas do you think have the greatest potential for appreciation?
Thanks in advance for sharing your insights!
Agree with Patrick here on how you should look at starting out. There are opportunities to start investing in all the areas you said, fixing them up may not be the best route to go at first just because that takes a lot more getting used to in the market (in my opinion), not that it is impossible, just a better route to take for your first property. Then after that, you have more trusted contacts, then diving into world is more possible
To me the biggest issue with out of state investing and long term rentals is that you have to deal with property damages and/or evictions. Depending on the state and even the county, the eviction process can be a nightmare. And typically long term rentals don't make it easy to include property management fees into the numbers and have them still work well.
I would consider looking into STR type areas where you can avoid the risk of property damages (str and pm insurance covers almost everything that they might damage) and evictions/collections. If you have a tenant that doesn't pay and you have to evict, you might lose 3 to 5 months of rent payments plus have make ready costs of 5k to 6k depending on what they do. That house won't have a profit for 3 or 4 years now.
As an out of state investor, I think STRs are now the way to go. Built in property managent. Less risks of significant cash outlays and/or collections defaults. And you still get the same benefits in terms of tax benefits (depreciation is a beautiful thing), rental profits, principal paydown and appreciation.
Hi everyone,
My name is Celine, and I live in Los Angeles. I've been learning about real estate investing and am ready to take action on my first out-of-state property using the BRRRR method (with plans for short-term rentals). I have enough cash to invest and am considering cities like Indianapolis, IN; Cincinnati, OH; Cleveland, OH; Atlanta, GA; and Charlotte, NC.
I’m looking to purchase houses around $300K, with the intention of fixing them up. For experienced out-of-state investors, where have you invested? Which cities and areas do you think have the greatest potential for appreciation?
Thanks in advance for sharing your insights!
Hi Celine! If you're looking for appreciation potential, I personally suggest checking the Columbus OH market. Lots of major companies developing and moving here like Intel, Meta, Amazon, Google, etc. The tech scene is booming, population and the job market are growing. I've done a lot of BRRRR deals here myself as an investor. Happy to send over some resources on why Columbus is a great real estate market to invest in.
To me this is a combination of things. Main things being population growth and landlording laws. If those two things are in your favor, you will do well.
Hi Celine, I can't really speak to the midwest as I just don't understand the area as well. I live on the East Coast and I too am an out of state investor primarily since Long Island is a particularly expensive area as a whole to invest in. I invest in Pennsylvania where I find to be some opportunity there in terms of cash-flow particularly with multi-family within the $300,000 range and even lower. As a first time out of state investor, I would not do a BRRRR to start until you build your contacts and systems there. There is a lot of risk involved with that and it could turn out to be a problem with the wrong people in place. Feel Free to reach out if you have any questions.
out of state BRRRR is a difficult way to get started. in state BRRRR is tough! I did one last year that was an hour away from me, and it was a huge, huge pain. to do an out of state BRRRR you have to do the following remotely (somehow):
-find a deal that is exactly the right amount of distressed - needs a big rehab, but can be salvaged and fixed up. these deals aren't on Zillow - they're usually off market.
-find a contractor that is high quality, willing to take on your rehab, not booked up for the next year but also not available right away. then manage them remotely.
you also noted you want an STR, which is going to shrink the inventory that is viable for you and also increase the amount of competition you have.
you may want to read these threads:
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/12/topics/1215726-break...
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/48/topics/1159104-overl...
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/963/topics/1195280-expe...
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/48/topics/1160450-run-i...
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/48/topics/1137397-balti...
i invest in Pittsburgh, and I would tell you: DON'T invest in Pittsburgh unless you're willing to come here in person and build your network. buy on the wrong street and you'll lose money.
hope this helps - have done some BRRRRs here and happy to help further. nothing to sell - not an agent - not an anything
Hi everyone,
My name is Celine, and I live in Los Angeles. I've been learning about real estate investing and am ready to take action on my first out-of-state property using the BRRRR method (with plans for short-term rentals). I have enough cash to invest and am considering cities like Indianapolis, IN; Cincinnati, OH; Cleveland, OH; Atlanta, GA; and Charlotte, NC.
I’m looking to purchase houses around $300K, with the intention of fixing them up. For experienced out-of-state investors, where have you invested? Which cities and areas do you think have the greatest potential for appreciation?
Thanks in advance for sharing your insights!
Hey Celine, from my understanding its very difficult to grow a portfolio of short term rentals using the BRRRR method as an out of state investor. The biggest challenge is finding a team you can trust that will run the business for you because its not passive at all. I haven't heard of any property managers in any market that will manage your short term rentals but I could be wrong. Let me know if you have any interest in LTRs and I could help you find plenty of BRRRR deals with under $100K in Memphis, TN. Best of luck to you!
Hello @Celine Li I was just researching the same areas that you mentioned. I’m also considering out of state investing as the entry price point in my local market is really high. Speaking from past experiences vetting the real estate professionals that you chose is paramount. I’ve been concentrating more on the Indy market and I’m happy to compare notes if you’d like. Best of luck to you.
As someone who lived in Los Angeles and also needed to invest out of state, I've dedicated my career to market analysis and selection, and I personally think you've chosen pretty good markets. I'm currently biased towards Indianapolis based on its job growth and affordability, but you could honestly find deals in any of the markets you mentioned (and if your heart is set on the Atlanta metro area, I'd strongly suggest the towns Union City and Fairburn based on their growth, appreciation, and price -- I almost closed on a good BRRRR deal in Fairburn but the rehab was just out of my budget).
My suggestion is to start looking for on-market deals immediately to get a better feel for the price points and rents for each market. Then, narrow down from there and reach out to an investor-friendly agent you can find on the BP agent finder.
Recommend you first figure out the property Class you want to invest in, THEN figure out the corresponding location to invest in.
Property Class will typically dictate the Class of tenant you get, which greatly IMPACTS rental income stability and property maintenance/damage by tenants.
If you apply Class A assumptions to a Class B or C purchase, your expectations won’t be met and it may be a financial disaster.
If you buy/renovate a property in Class D area to Class A standards, what quality of tenant will you get?
Similarly, if you put several Class D tenants in a Class A 4-plex, what do you think will happen to the property?
So, when investing in areas they don’t really know, investors should research the different property Class submarkets.
Here’s our OPINION for the Metro Detroit market (use as a template for your target area!) that we’ve learned in our 24 years, managing almost 700 doors across the Metro Detroit area, including almost 100 S8 leases.:
Class A Properties:
Cashflow vs Appreciation: Typically, 3-5 years for positive cashflow, but you get highest relative rent & value appreciation.
Vacancy Est: Historically 10%, 5% the more recent norm.
Tenant Pool: Majority will have FICO scores of 680+ (roughly 5% probability of default), zero evictions in last 7 years.
Class B Properties:
Cashflow vs Appreciation: Typically, decent amount of relative rent & value appreciation.
Vacancy Est: Historically 10%, 5% should be applied only if proper research done to support.
Tenant Pool: Majority will have FICO scores of 620-680 (around 10% probability of default), some blemishes, but should have no evictions in last 5 years
Class C Properties:
Cashflow vs Appreciation: Typically, high cashflow and at the lower end of relative rent & value appreciation. Can try to reposition to Class B, but neighborhood may impede these efforts.
Vacancy Est: Historically 10%, but 15-20% should be used to also cover tenant nonpayment, eviction costs & damages.
Tenant Pool: majority will have FICO scores of 560-620 (approaching 22% probability of default), many blemishes, but should have no evictions in last 2 years. Verifying last 2 years of rental history very important! Also, focus on 2 years of job/income stability.
Class D Properties:
Cashflow vs Appreciation: Typically, all cashflow with little, maybe even negative, relative rent & value appreciation
Vacancy Est: 20%+ should be used to cover nonpayment, evictions & damages.
Tenant Pool: majority will have FICO scores under 560 (almost 30% probability of default), little to no good tradelines, lots of collections & chargeoffs, recent evictions. Verifying last 2 years of rental history and income extremely important to find the “best of the worst”.
Make sure you understand the Class of properties you are looking at and the corresponding results to expect.
The City of Detroit has 183 Neighborhoods we’ve analyzed.
PM us if you’d like to discuss this logical approach in greater detail!
@Celine Li I am curious if, before posting this, you clicked on the search function in top right, and tried looking up this subject/ answer/ question????
I truly feel a need to understand your process, because this question seems to get asked almost hourly. And yes, that's a rather accurate measure.
The question comes with various customized details but it's the same answer over-n-over again, to such a degree that answer-burn becomes a very real thing.
Which means for those later asking, they won't get the kind of care of answer the earlier persons get.
So I gotta know, did you try that? If not, why not? Maybe you were not even aware of the function? Or was it too complicated or frustrating to complete a search that way?
Or did you just directly go to posting? If so, I am curious the thoughts and drives behind that, like, maybe really wanted exact answers to you so thought posting on your specifics was best approach?
I just want to understand.
Because a flood of the 1 same question does not do anyone a service on BP. It floods out variety of content, makes for answer burn-out, etc etc..
--------------------------------------------------------
To answer your question, fact and reality is there is no such thing as a "golden ticket" market. The best market for YOU, is the market that fit's YOU; you're situation, your preferences, you're resources, your knowledge level, you're risk aversion and about 40 other personalized factors to you.
So start with STRATEGY.
Develop YOU'RE strategy.
Than, once you have that, the strategy will describe exactly what market it works in and which it doesnt.
From there it's just math, the metrics of where best fit's for that strategy deployment. Next is getting to the work of researching that market to confirm viability, building the TEAM, the How-To for strategy.
If you ask others you will only find out what's best FOR THEM.
We don't know you, we have no idea how you act under pressure, how much hair a sec8 tenant will have you pulling out or how thick you skin is. It's a very personal thing, it really is.
If your asking where the profit is: EVERYWHERE. It's literally everywhere, 98.7% of places. All that changes is how to profit and how much.
Perfection is not a place, it's a process.
To me the biggest issue with out of state investing and long term rentals is that you have to deal with property damages and/or evictions. Depending on the state and even the county, the eviction process can be a nightmare. And typically long term rentals don't make it easy to include property management fees into the numbers and have them still work well.
I would consider looking into STR type areas where you can avoid the risk of property damages (str and pm insurance covers almost everything that they might damage) and evictions/collections. If you have a tenant that doesn't pay and you have to evict, you might lose 3 to 5 months of rent payments plus have make ready costs of 5k to 6k depending on what they do. That house won't have a profit for 3 or 4 years now.
As an out of state investor, I think STRs are now the way to go. Built in property managent. Less risks of significant cash outlays and/or collections defaults. And you still get the same benefits in terms of tax benefits (depreciation is a beautiful thing), rental profits, principal paydown and appreciation.
What has your personal experience been with your Short term rentals and is there an area that you would recommend?
Hi everyone,
My name is Celine, and I live in Los Angeles. I've been learning about real estate investing and am ready to take action on my first out-of-state property using the BRRRR method (with plans for short-term rentals). I have enough cash to invest and am considering cities like Indianapolis, IN; Cincinnati, OH; Cleveland, OH; Atlanta, GA; and Charlotte, NC.
I’m looking to purchase houses around $300K, with the intention of fixing them up. For experienced out-of-state investors, where have you invested? Which cities and areas do you think have the greatest potential for appreciation?
Thanks in advance for sharing your insights!
If you're looking at Cleveland from LA, everything probably looks like a great deal to you since everything out here is so cheap. Not always the case. Yes it's all cheap, but there is more to it than that. Investors from LA can make a ton of money out here but even easier than making it is losing it out here. Check out The Ultimate Guide to Grading Cleveland Neighborhoods before spending any money on a Cleveland rental property. You gotta understand why things are as cheap as they are before you buy them.
Hi everyone,
My name is Celine, and I live in Los Angeles. I've been learning about real estate investing and am ready to take action on my first out-of-state property using the BRRRR method (with plans for short-term rentals). I have enough cash to invest and am considering cities like Indianapolis, IN; Cincinnati, OH; Cleveland, OH; Atlanta, GA; and Charlotte, NC.
I’m looking to purchase houses around $300K, with the intention of fixing them up. For experienced out-of-state investors, where have you invested? Which cities and areas do you think have the greatest potential for appreciation?
Thanks in advance for sharing your insights!
Hey Celine, from my understanding its very difficult to grow a portfolio of short term rentals using the BRRRR method as an out of state investor. The biggest challenge is finding a team you can trust that will run the business for you because its not passive at all. I haven't heard of any property managers in any market that will manage your short term rentals but I could be wrong. Let me know if you have any interest in LTRs and I could help you find plenty of BRRRR deals with under $100K in Memphis, TN. Best of luck to you!
Jordan,
Across MN in the heavy tourism areas, STR PM's are very common. So common that we also have STR-PM's across the urban Twin Cities, but it's driven because of the Lakes Region, the ski resorts, etc..
And in general, it's "only" gonna cost a person 40% gross rents......
Yup, you read that right FOURTY (4-0) percent!
And it would blow your mind the massive demand for there service. Why such demand? Because there is so many novices who jump into STR without the skill, knowledge, ability to actually operate it and rapidly are bleeding-out.
As someone who lived in Los Angeles and also needed to invest out of state, I've dedicated my career to market analysis and selection, and I personally think you've chosen pretty good markets. I'm currently biased towards Indianapolis based on its job growth and affordability, but you could honestly find deals in any of the markets you mentioned (and if your heart is set on the Atlanta metro area, I'd strongly suggest the towns Union City and Fairburn based on their growth, appreciation, and price -- I almost closed on a good BRRRR deal in Fairburn but the rehab was just out of my budget).
My suggestion is to start looking for on-market deals immediately to get a better feel for the price points and rents for each market. Then, narrow down from there and reach out to an investor-friendly agent you can find on the BP agent finder.
Im open to connecting in Central IN