Am I wasting my time investing in the Twin Cities?

Am I wasting my time investing in the Twin Cities?

Member since 2025 · 8 posts · 13 votes

I am a new investor (I work full time in another career). Just purchased a duplex in Minneapolis a couple months ago. I'm looking to go the BRRR route with long term rentals, but I'm finding deal flow to be very difficult. I have also looked in Milwaukee but not a lot of luck. Could someone lend a helping hand and let me know if there are other midwest cities I should be looking in? Would also need a realtor, property mgr, GC in that city.

Alternatively, I could pivot strategies and aim to start 1-2 AirBnBs/year in my state. Advice?

6Reply
293 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
1y

Well, we are in a real estate recession: fewer people are buying or selling, in Milwaukee transaction volume has been down about a third for the last 3 years compared to historic norms. On top of that prices have doubled since 2015 and are on track to increase another 7.5% or so this year - same as the last years.

I have done brrrs for 15 years, but its not worth it to me anymore - too much work and not enough equity. In fact on the last few I made as much on market appreciation over the 6 months we were working on it as from the rehab. The market does not give you a discount for condition anymore, some first time home buyer will overpay. So we've been basically buying move in ready homes instead and focus more on negotiating a discount and less on improvements.

Looking for another city is pointless, the market conditons are the same all over the Midwest. You can get deals in most Sunbelt States right now, they see home values decline, but from a very high level. My advice: leverage your home field advantage as much as you can. We are not getting away from inflation any time soon, so assets are bound to go up (measured in USD)

See this reply in the discussion

17 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Get yourself trained before doing something inadvisable. · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Stephanie Deppe:

    I am a new investor (I work full time in another career). Just purchased a duplex in Minneapolis a couple months ago. I'm looking to go the BRRR route with long term rentals, but I'm finding deal flow to be very difficult. I have also looked in Milwaukee but not a lot of luck. Could someone lend a helping hand and let me know if there are other midwest cities I should be looking in? Would also need a realtor, property mgr, GC in that city.

    Alternatively, I could pivot strategies and aim to start 1-2 AirBnBs/year in my state. Advice?

    Your comment "in my state." 

    Well, are you in Alaska or Hawaii? 

    We don't have a clue how to advise you until you state your state. :-) 

    Starting local, where you can drive to the property and return in the same day, is the best when you are first starting out. 


    • Member since 2025 · 8 posts · 13 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Ken M.:
      Quote from @Stephanie Deppe:

      I am a new investor (I work full time in another career). Just purchased a duplex in Minneapolis a couple months ago. I'm looking to go the BRRR route with long term rentals, but I'm finding deal flow to be very difficult. I have also looked in Milwaukee but not a lot of luck. Could someone lend a helping hand and let me know if there are other midwest cities I should be looking in? Would also need a realtor, property mgr, GC in that city.

      Alternatively, I could pivot strategies and aim to start 1-2 AirBnBs/year in my state. Advice?

      Your comment "in my state." 

      Well, are you in Alaska or Hawaii? 

      We don't have a clue how to advise you until you state your state. :-) 

      Starting local, where you can drive to the property and return in the same day, is the best when you are first starting out. 



       Hey! I live in Minnesota. What do you think now? :)

  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    1y

    Well, we are in a real estate recession: fewer people are buying or selling, in Milwaukee transaction volume has been down about a third for the last 3 years compared to historic norms. On top of that prices have doubled since 2015 and are on track to increase another 7.5% or so this year - same as the last years.

    I have done brrrs for 15 years, but its not worth it to me anymore - too much work and not enough equity. In fact on the last few I made as much on market appreciation over the 6 months we were working on it as from the rehab. The market does not give you a discount for condition anymore, some first time home buyer will overpay. So we've been basically buying move in ready homes instead and focus more on negotiating a discount and less on improvements.

    Looking for another city is pointless, the market conditons are the same all over the Midwest. You can get deals in most Sunbelt States right now, they see home values decline, but from a very high level. My advice: leverage your home field advantage as much as you can. We are not getting away from inflation any time soon, so assets are bound to go up (measured in USD)

  • Charles ClarkBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2020 · 307 posts · 209 votes
    1y

    @Stephanie Deppe

    Congrats on your first duplex!Deal flow can definitely be tough right now, but the Midwest still has gems if you know where to look. Markets like Kansas City, Indianapolis, and Cleveland are showing solid BRRR and cash-flow potential. If you ever explore Milwaukee again, my team can help with boots-on-the-ground support from sourcing deals to management

    Raise the Standard RE LLC55 Reviews
    View Page
  • Kerlous TadresBusiness Member
    Realtor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    Hey @Stephanie Deppe, if deal flow’s tough, it’s usually not the market; it’s your setup. Focus on finding one solid, investor-minded realtor who sends real deals that meet your numbers. BRRRRs take patience; most good investors only land one or two solid ones a year. Use the slow time to build your team and financing so you’re ready when the right one hits. If you’re burning out, pivot to something lighter, like an Airbnb or turnkey to stay active.

    Kerlous Tadres | Reafco Real Estate542 Reviews
  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    1y

    Ask and yee shall receive @Stephanie Deppe 

    Unless your swinging a 9 figure bat, or have ridiculous expectations, deal-flow is a non-issue.  

    I have 4 in off-market pipeline this minute, with a handful of additional potentials. I only share that to state a perspective of flow. That's about par for the course for me, so i am not seeing a down tick BUT I am hearing a lot about things getting tighter, clicky. 

    I think it's more an issue of a less "deals" via MLS, less to go around for the 2nd, 3rd, 4th hand wholesalers. And it's an action where one really has to key into knowing the actual source producers like myself.

    This isn't a pitch, I'm not from OH, i don't know enough about your situation to say if your even interested in same class assets I work in to pitch. This is all speaking to a question of viable deal flow in Twin Cities market. 

    Which yes, there is 100% viable deal flow, but I bet it is getting tougher to find because gate keepers like myself and others I know, we don't really market to the fact, were more word-of-mouth to be honest. 

    Maybe share a bit more on the details. Asset class, budget, expectations etc.. 

    And NO, no need to go to OH, if you want cheap C class we got markets right here for those too. ~50% of replacement cost is pretty dang cheap in my opinion. 

  • Member since 2025 · 8 posts · 13 votes
    1y

    Hey James! Thanks for sharing the insight. That makes sense. I can see where it's more difficult to find deals because they never hit the MLS. I'm on a handful of off market email lists, but I have a feeling that even those are being combed through prior to being sent out.

    My main goal right now is cash flow, so I primarily having been looking at small multifamily within 45 min of the Twin Cities/Southwest metro. Budget is a little flexible as I have a HELOC and personal line of credit to work with as far as down payment. I have been trying to do BRRR, though, as I need to acquire enough so that I can go part time. My goal is to generate enough cash flow that I can spend more time with my kids and have the option to homeschool when they get to that age.

    Do you have any other advice for me? Thanks!

    • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Stephanie Deppe:

      Hey James! Thanks for sharing the insight. That makes sense. I can see where it's more difficult to find deals because they never hit the MLS. I'm on a handful of off market email lists, but I have a feeling that even those are being combed through prior to being sent out.

      My main goal right now is cash flow, so I primarily having been looking at small multifamily within 45 min of the Twin Cities/Southwest metro. Budget is a little flexible as I have a HELOC and personal line of credit to work with as far as down payment. I have been trying to do BRRR, though, as I need to acquire enough so that I can go part time. My goal is to generate enough cash flow that I can spend more time with my kids and have the option to homeschool when they get to that age.

      Do you have any other advice for me? Thanks!


      Thank you for the details Stephanie, and yes I do. 

      Ok first is the most important thing, correct defining of the reality of the ask. This may seem harsh, or a crappy thing but with so much disinformation and distortion out there around the subject via those selling fantasy narratives to get people buying programs, it is as said a very important first step. 

      Firstly, there is no trick, secret hack or hidden thing on getting cash-flow. Cash-flow is not a thing itself. Cash-flow is not hiding under a rock or taking up residence at a different zip code each month. Cash-flow is a RESULT.     Cash-flow is a RESULT, not a thing itself.    

      There was a time, in years past, that a person could buy revenue producing things at a low multiple. That no longer exists. The multiples have changed. This just is the reality of todays market and one needs to wrap there head around it. 

      Next is the lie that there is anything passive about any of it. There is only varying degrees of ACTIVE. 

      Cash-flow is the result of when revenues, have a margin above capitol investment and operations. That's it, it's that simple. 

      So the true target is MARGIN. 

      Then one has to ask what is the cost for that margin. Money is just one price, there is also Stress, Time, Energy and Resources. 

      I have a market with CF potential to it here in MN but, it's class C & D property dominated. That generally means maintenance. Either doing reno at buy, ongoing maintenance during tenancy etc.. That means the time and energy to obtain, coordinate and manage the resources. And if want to just outsource everything including a person doing everything, well there is giving away a big chunk of margin for that so CF diminishes as a result. 

      For some, CF is best obtained via a Midway Duplex and putting 50% down. That lower leverage and debt service creates the margin to get CF. 

      Others, it's investing self to go to the depressed satellite market, doing some BRRR and with that create better margin and thus CF results.

      What budget are you working with? Maybe DM me that if want to prevent getting spammed by starving agents here. 

      If inside the Twin Cities proper, generally your not going to get viable deals UNLESS your direct sourcing them yourself or have a pro doing that for you. Your on lists, that means 3rd/4th/5th hand. There is no "deals" that far down the feeding chain. 

  • Min ZhangBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    That's awesome, Stephanie! Deal flow has been pretty tight lately, especially for BRRRR-type returns. Many investors I work with have started expanding their search to other affordable midwest markets where cash flow still makes sense and teams (PM, GC, etc.) are easier to build out.

    If you decide to stay local, the STR route can work well too especially if you're in an area with strong year round demand and clear local rules. Both paths are solid; it really depends on whether you prefer active management (Airbnb) or longer-term stability (BRRRR rentals). Happy to keep the conversation going!

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Stephanie Deppe:

    I am a new investor (I work full time in another career). Just purchased a duplex in Minneapolis a couple months ago. I'm looking to go the BRRR route with long term rentals, but I'm finding deal flow to be very difficult. I have also looked in Milwaukee but not a lot of luck. Could someone lend a helping hand and let me know if there are other midwest cities I should be looking in? Would also need a realtor, property mgr, GC in that city.

    Alternatively, I could pivot strategies and aim to start 1-2 AirBnBs/year in my state. Advice?


     Cleveland yo.

  • Investor · Rochester, MN · Member since 2020 · 85 posts · 57 votes
    1y

    Hey @Stephanie Deppe

    I'm in MN and have been on the hunt in multiple markets across MN.  No you're not wasting your time in the Twin Cities.  There are a lot of exciting things happening all over the place. I would say though that @James Hamling has some real nuggets in his post. It so densely steeped in reality that it's worth reading 3 times over, haha.  I'll add that to find the deals you need to dig, dig and dig.  In my journey, I've been able to find the "hidden" deals building my network, making contacts I know, like and trust, add value to people, make mistakes, and ask questions.  It does take time and effort but by doing it you just might find what you're looking for.  My favorite story is after I listened to a BP podcast where the guest said he would mow the lawns of his properties just to meet the neighbors and ask to buy their properties, well, I did just that at one of my rentals and was able to buy one of my neighbor's properties.  It did take a year of staying in contact, though, but when they were ready to sell, I was top of mind for them.  

  • Investor · Toledo-MetroDetroit-Dallas · Member since 2022 · 122 posts · 71 votes
    1y

    @Stephanie Deppe, highly suggest looking into Toledo Ohio it's quite the hidden gem, with low entry costs and really great cash flow

    happy to share the specifics!

  • Member since 2025 · 8 posts · 13 votes
    1y

    This is helpful insight. Thank you.

  • Member since 2025 · 8 posts · 13 votes
    1y

    @Jeff Rogers super interesting! I’m starting to get it. One needs to build a network to get the deals. Real estate is a slow burn. It seems that there is so much misinformation out there about how “easy and passive” it is to get going. Good tip re getting to know your neighbors! 

    • Investor · Get yourself trained before doing something inadvisable. · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Stephanie Deppe:

      @Jeff Rogers super interesting! I’m starting to get it. One needs to build a network to get the deals. Real estate is a slow burn. It seems that there is so much misinformation out there about how “easy and passive” it is to get going. Good tip re getting to know your neighbors! 

      There are plenty of ways to get "good deals" without a "network". Most real estate agents never take the time to learn those sources, but people can if they want to.
      You can start by using sources off of this list
      https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/311/topics/1265103-ways...
  • Tim SwierczekPro Member
    Lender · White Bear Township, MN · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    @Stephanie Deppe I won't rehash all the good points made here. I can tell you as someone who mostly works with investors and house hackers, there are plenty of deals in MN. They come as you are more active. As you network and do deals, you will be offered deals when others know you close, and you likely have already passed on a deal that you couldn't yet see the profit. That comes with time. The last rental I purchased was because a client of mine passed on it. They backed out of the deal, and I bought it a few days later because I knew it was a steal. I CF $2K/month. They were surprised I purchased it and asked me if I was worried about all the things they brought up. And while some of their concerns were valid. The $2K per month makes the minor issues worth it. Hang in there and learn your home market. You will be glad you did.

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Stephanie Deppe:

    I am a new investor (I work full time in another career). Just purchased a duplex in Minneapolis a couple months ago. I'm looking to go the BRRR route with long term rentals, but I'm finding deal flow to be very difficult. I have also looked in Milwaukee but not a lot of luck. Could someone lend a helping hand and let me know if there are other midwest cities I should be looking in? Would also need a realtor, property mgr, GC in that city.

    Alternatively, I could pivot strategies and aim to start 1-2 AirBnBs/year in my state. Advice?

    Hey Stephanie, congrats on getting that first duplex locked in! Minneapolis and Milwaukee have gotten tighter over the last few years, so you're not alone in feeling the deal flow pain. If you're open to other Midwest markets, Columbus, Ohio is definitely worth a look. I moved here from Portland in 2020 to invest and now own 10+ rentals, and what drew me here was the strong macro story—population and job growth, major companies like Intel, Amazon, Google, Honda, and Facebook investing heavily, and properties that still hit the 1% rule in the $120K–180K range. It's very landlord friendly, and there's a strong investor community with solid agents, property managers, and contractors who regularly work with out-of-state investors. A lot of folks use BRRR or long-term rental strategies successfully here because the numbers still work. AirBnB can definitely be a good play too, but it usually requires more active management, so it really depends on how hands-on you want to be while working full time. Happy to connect and answer any questions you have!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.