Rental Property Investor · NH · Member since 2023 · 442 posts · 417 votes
Before we picked a single countertop on our Portsmouth 4-unit, we made the code list
Closing day, my contractor and I walked every unit and both basements. Line by line.
The first pass was about what has to be fixed no matter what the building looks like when we're done.
Here's what made that list:
A new fire alarm system for the whole building (already in the budget)
A half bath where the toilet-to-vanity clearance isn't up to code, so it gets shrunk or rebuilt
Fireplaces that need to be blocked so a tenant can't light one
Knob-and-tube wiring in the basement that we're verifying, plus a full rewire of the studio
A floor joist that needs to be sistered, and lolly columns to add
None of that shows up in listing photos. None of it raises the rent.
But skip any of it and you've got an insurance problem, an inspection problem, or a buyer's inspector killing your sale in the spring.
So here's how I sort a scope now. Must-do items first: code, safety, structure. Then the upgrades a renter or buyer will actually pay for. Everything else stays as is.
Honestly, the must-do list is the one that protects the budget. Price it first, and you know what's left for the stuff people see.
What's the first thing on your must-do list when you walk an older building?
Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 644 posts · 471 votes
23h
Roof, foundation, and water. In that order. Everything else is cosmetic math.
I buy pre-1978 houses in Memphis and my bread and butter is 2/1 to 3/1 and 3/1 to 4/2 conversions, adding 400-650 square feet. Before I price a single countertop, I check: does the roof have 10+ years left, is the foundation solid, and where is water getting in or sitting? Those three decide whether the deal lives or dies.
Then I walk it like a Section 8 inspector — I rent most of my houses on Section 8 at $1,395 to $1,950. Smoke and CO detectors, no peeling paint, working windows and outlets, hot water, solid doors and locks, no plumbing leaks. I know that punch list cold, so I can price it in my head room by room.
My rule: if the big three are clean, the rest is just a budget. If one of them is bad, I walk or I discount hard.