Real Estate Broker · Tampa, FL · Member since 2019 · 113 posts · 68 votes
Got the email every furnished-rental operator dreads this afternoon: an 18-night booking over Christmas and New Year's at one of my Tampa Bay area houses just cancelled. Full refund, plans change, no hard feelings — but now I'm holding Dec 15 through Jan 2 wide open, which should have been some of the easiest weeks of the year to fill.
Here's what I'm weighing:
1. Hold the 30-night minimum and market it to traveling nurses and insurance-displacement placements starting in January, accepting the holiday gap
2. Drop the minimum stay for just those weeks and catch snowbird / holiday overflow
3. Push it out to my direct list instead of waiting on the platforms
For those of you running midterm / corporate furnished rentals — when a prime-window cancellation hits, do you discount to fill it, shorten the stay requirement, or stay patient and protect your rate? What actually worked?
For context, I'm the broker of Investing N Florida, an investor-friendly brokerage here in Florida, and most of what we do is furnished midterm housing — so this comes up more than I'd like.
@Nadia Daggett I'd split it rather than pick one. Those 18 nights are worth more as holiday stays than as the front end of a nurse contract, since most January assignments start the first or second week anyway.
Drop the minimum to 7 nights for Dec 15 to Jan 2 only, price it at holiday nightly rates rather than your monthly rate divided by 30, and give your direct list 48 hours before it hits the platforms. If it's still open around Dec 1, then discount. Keep Jan 2 onward at the 30-night minimum for nurses and insurance placements.
Just confirm the HOA and city allow stays under 30 nights at that address first.
For Dec 15 to Jan 2 gaps I usually go after insurance-housing and corporate placement leads first, not another vacation guest. Those guests often need the unit for weeks and will take furnished if the deposit and lease are ready. Gap pricing a bit under the holiday rate can move it faster than sitting empty. Worth checking whether your cancellation policy for holiday long stays needs a higher deposit or a non-refundable portion so the next cancellation does not leave you scrambling.
Hossein already covered the 7-night minimum and pinging the direct list, so I will not rehash that. How long is the open stretch now?
Before promoting those dates, I’d confirm who can cover turnovers around Christmas and New Year’s. Two shorter bookings can create a holiday cleaning handoff that the original 18-night stay didn’t need. If coverage is tight, a single stay spanning both holidays may be much simpler to deliver well. That also gives you a concrete window to offer your direct list.
Nadia, this is the situation I set my calendars up for, so here's how I'd handle it.
I run my units as a mid-term/short-term hybrid. The calendar is set for 30+ day stays with a 30-60 day minimum, and short stays only fill gaps of a few days up to 2 weeks. A cancelled 18-night block is just a bigger gap. So I'd open Dec 15–Jan 2 to shorter holiday stays at holiday rates, and keep early January onward at the 30-day minimum for nurses, insurance placements and relocations.
Two things I'd watch:
Don't let a short stay block a longer one. I keep a 60-day minimum after a stay so a mid-term guest can extend. I had a construction crew extend 4 times and stay over 90 days because that window was open. Make sure a holiday booking can't run into the dates a January guest would start on. Also leave the door open for a 30+ day guest who wants to start Dec 15. That one booking would cover the holidays and January.
Set the rule once, in one place. I manage minimum stays in PriceLabs along with pricing, so a date-specific minimum for that window goes to Airbnb and Vrbo at the same time. Otherwise you get the settings-drift problem from your other post.
On discounting, I'd look at the market's booking window before touching price. I pull it from the PriceLabs Market Dashboards. In one of my markets, guests typically book just 3-7 days out, so I don't start discounting more than 7 days ahead. Drop the rate earlier than that and you're giving away revenue to guests who would have booked at full price anyway. I'd rather hold a little longer, watch how the market is pacing for those dates, and only make a big change once I can see it's falling behind.
Nadia, what a great spot to be in, even with the cancellation!! Displaced families are exactly who could use those weeks. My team and I, working with ALE and CRS, placed over 1,000 families displaced by fire or flood over 25+ years through my property management company in Tacoma. Holidays hit those families hardest. I'd be happy to reach out to ALE and CRS for you, and we'd build you a free listing, flyer and social kit from your photos. Even one more view is amazing for us! Are you open to sharing a few details about the place?
I'd shorten the stay before I'd cut the rate, since a discount on the best weeks of the year is money you don't get back. Going to your own list is a smart instinct. It just moves a few jobs off the platform and onto you. Florida sales tax applies to rentals of six months or less, plus the county tourist tax, and the platforms usually collect and remit that for you. On a direct booking you collect and remit it yourself. Platform damage protection only covers bookings made through that platform, and some furnished-rental policies exclude stays under 30 days. Are your units already registered to collect and remit sales tax and the county tourist tax on direct stays?
I'd quote the whole Dec 15-Jan 2 block and a stay running into January, then compare what each leaves you after cleaning and utilities. A lower nightly rate on the longer booking could still leave you ahead. Keep both options available while you see which gets real inquiries.