Bought first STR this weekend - Orange Beach, AL

Huntsville, AL · Member since 2017 · 14 posts · 10 votes

Long time landlord on SFHs for over 12 years, but bought our first Vacation Rental/STR this weekend. Under contract for a 3 BR, 4 Bath OBA cottage about .4 miles off the beach. We are excited and a bit anxious as STRs are a different game. Cottage was built in 2022 and needs no work, fully furnished. With only one STR currently, what is your best advice? Looking to do AirBnB, VRBO (likely the most used), and a direct booking site. Looking at both Lodgify and OwnerRez for PMS systems. Has been listed on AirBnB only up to this point. Closing on 24-April and want to be ready on day one. For all you seasoned STR experts, what is the one thing you would recommend for my first STR? Thanks in advance

4 Reply

351 views

Most Popular Reply

Andrew SteffensBusiness Member

Tampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes

7mo

I agree with John, you do not need a PMS for 2 properties. Just list direct on Airbnb and VRBO. I cannot personally vouch for Houfy but people on here do for direct booking site. Pricing is important, I do not trust OTA pricing, especially Airbnb though I have heard VRBO is a little better. You can get PriceLabs or similar for pricing pretty inexpensively.

[email protected]813-563-0877

Vacation Rentals of Florida53 Reviews

Website View Page

3 Reply

See this reply in the discussion

15 Replies

Jump to latestLatest

Sort by

John UnderwoodPro Member
Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
7mo
You really don't need a PMS site for one or two properties in my opinion.
Definitely get on Vrbo for a vacation rental.
Vrbo and Airbnb can sync calendars with each other.
2 Reply
Andrew SteffensBusiness Member
Tampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
7mo
I agree with John, you do not need a PMS for 2 properties. Just list direct on Airbnb and VRBO. I cannot personally vouch for Houfy but people on here do for direct booking site. Pricing is important, I do not trust OTA pricing, especially Airbnb though I have heard VRBO is a little better. You can get PriceLabs or similar for pricing pretty inexpensively.
[email protected]813-563-0877
Vacation Rentals of Florida53 Reviews
Website View Page
3 Reply
Jules Aton
MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
7mo
Congratulations!
2 Reply
Tyler Carter
OP
Huntsville, AL · Member since 2017 · 14 posts · 10 votes
7mo
Thanks all. So good point about PMS. What about a direct booking site, are they worth it initially? I have a software development/engineering background so creating one and managing it wouldn't be a problem, just didn't know if it was worth it in year 1.
What about tracking expenses/maintenance? For my LTRs, I use Innago and have been very happy to quickly take pics of receipts for expenses and it handles all maintenance request tracking. For just 1 STR, are you saying I am better off just doing that manually through spreadsheets and emails?
1 Reply
- Josh Ball
  Real Estate Agent · Louisiana · Member since 2017 · 215 posts · 149 votes
  7mo
  Quote from @Tyler Carter:
  
  Thanks all. So good point about PMS. What about a direct booking site, are they worth it initially? I have a software development/engineering background so creating one and managing it wouldn't be a problem, just didn't know if it was worth it in year 1.
  What about tracking expenses/maintenance? For my LTRs, I use Innago and have been very happy to quickly take pics of receipts for expenses and it handles all maintenance request tracking. For just 1 STR, are you saying I am better off just doing that manually through spreadsheets and emails?
  
  Year 1, save the money you'd spend on software & increase your ROI. 1 property you aren't going to have crazy bills, maintenance, renos (hopefully) so you can simply track via excel or google sheets. Don't sweat it about a direct booking site either. Unless you're pushing hard on social media, direct booking site traffic is mainly going to come from recurring guests or people you refer (friends & family) to the site.
  Congrats on the purchase. You're in the right place for getting started.
  2 Reply
Brittany Henry
Member since 2026 · 1 post · 1 vote
7mo
I’d agree with the others here, a PMS might be more than you need right now, and a direct booking site probably won’t give you the exposure you’re looking for yet.

I’d keep it simple and stick with Airbnb or VRBO. The biggest thing to focus on is the quality of your listing making sure your photos and description really draw people in, and prioritizing great reviews so your listing gets more visibility and traffic.

I’ve been helping owners host their properties on these platforms for over 8 years, so if you have any questions at all, feel free to reach out. I’m always happy to help.
1 Reply
Derek D.
Property Manager · Old Orchard Beach, ME · Member since 2015 · 108 posts · 11 votes
7mo
Hey @Tyler Carter congrats! @Josh Ball and @John Underwood are right, you probably won't need much software on your first property. A good PMS we use is Hostaway but again, there are ways to connect to multiple OTA's without a PMS starting out.
1 Reply
Koba Molenaar
Cape Town, South Africa · Member since 2026 · 23 posts · 13 votes
7mo
Congrats and welcome to STRs! I always feel it's a good idea to list on multiple platforms and Airbnb and Vrbo are good places to start. Once you list on more than platforms, double-bookings become an issue — that's why a PMS is such a good investment. Last time I checked the calendar sync offered by Airbnb and Vrbo has a delay. But if you use a PMS like iGMS or Lodgify, any new bookings or price changes shouldn't take more than a few seconds to synchronize between the calendars. Full disclosure — I’m part of the iGMS team. Feel free to reach out to me with more questions about platforms, software, or getting started with STRs.
1 Reply
- John UnderwoodPro Member
  Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
  7mo
  Quote from @Koba Molenaar:
  
  Congrats and welcome to STRs! I always feel it's a good idea to list on multiple platforms and Airbnb and Vrbo are good places to start. Once you list on more than platforms, double-bookings become an issue — that's why a PMS is such a good investment. Last time I checked the calendar sync offered by Airbnb and Vrbo has a delay. But if you use a PMS like iGMS or Lodgify, any new bookings or price changes shouldn't take more than a few seconds to synchronize between the calendars. Full disclosure — I’m part of the iGMS team. Feel free to reach out to me with more questions about platforms, software, or getting started with STRs.
  
  In over a decade I have never had a direct booking from Vrbo or Airbnb syncing delays.
  1 Reply
- Koba Molenaar
  Cape Town, South Africa · Member since 2026 · 23 posts · 13 votes
  7mo
  Quote from @John Underwood:
  In over a decade I have never had a direct booking from Vrbo or Airbnb syncing delays.
  I hope your comment didn't jinx that now!
  1 Reply
Chizoba Ani
Virtual Assistant · Abuja, Nigeria | Remote · Member since 2026 · 75 posts · 28 votes
7mo
Congrats on your first STR
That’s a strong setup and you’re in the right space.
As an Airbnb co-host and STR optimisation specialists I will say; start with Airbnb and VRBO that's a great combo. You can add a direct booking site later once operations are stable.
Before launch, make sure you have professional photos, use searchable benefit driven title to improve visibility, a smart lock for easy check-in, automated guest messages, a reliable cleaner and handyman and a simple house manual.
Communication is very important so be proactive with your guests send a quick mid-stay check-in to catch and resolve issues early.👌
That’s what protects your reviews and drives consistent 5⭐️ stays and repeat bookings.
2 Reply
Kate Stoermer
Real Estate Consultant · Ann Arbor, MI · Member since 2023 · 85 posts · 93 votes
7mo
Direct booking is a numbers game. With a 1 to 2% conversion rate, the numbers of warm leads you need to get eyes on your site are big. Unless you are a social media maven, you won't get them.
I'll echo that you don't need a tech stack; that's money not needed for 1 property.
Managing expenses: adapt whatever you already do and just tag for this property.
Market positioning is key; this is the piece that can be difficult. How to position the property to be a top choice for your specific market? What photo to lead with, what pricing, what amenities are key. Some people easily navigate this by realizing they are their ideal client and intuitively make those decisions. Use the new listing discount - that also means the platforms will put you up to the top in search results initially. That also means people will take the risk to book where there aren't many reviews. Make sure you have photos of all the spaces - and the experience. This isn't real estate; its part of a vacation experience. People want to imagine staying, walking to the beach, enjoying local amenities, drinking coffee or a beverage on the balcony. Congrats and good luck!
1 Reply
Rod HanksBusiness Member
Insurance Agent · Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 743 posts · 462 votes
7mo
@Tyler Carter

Congrats—that’s a great market and newer build helps a lot. Biggest thing I’ve learned is get your systems locked in early—cleaner, turnovers, pricing—because that’s what really drives performance, not just the property. I used Guesty on mine and it made life a lot easier once it was set up right.

First few months just watch your numbers closely, STRs can shift quick with seasonality.
Rod Hanks Insurance4.9158 Reviews
Website View Page
2 Reply
Landon ReidPro Member
Investor · South Jordan, UT · Member since 2026 · 62 posts · 38 votes
6mo
Congrats Tyler! 12 years of SFH landlording is serious experience to bring to the STR game.

One thing I'd recommend before closing on April 24: confirm the STR licensing and zoning status on that specific parcel. Orange Beach and Gulf Shores have been tightening STR regulations, and some areas require specific permits that take time to obtain.

Also check whether the property sits in a flood zone — .4 miles off the beach in coastal AL, flood insurance can be a significant line item that Rabbu and AirDNA projections don't account for. A quick zoning and buildability check on the parcel will tell you the flood zone, any environmental overlays, and whether your STR use is permitted by right.

For your question about the one thing to get right: I'd say it's knowing your regulatory constraints before you invest in furnishing and marketing. I've seen coastal STR buyers get surprised by permit timelines and zoning restrictions after they've already committed capital.

The property sounds solid — 2022 build, fully furnished, great location. Just make sure the regulatory side is locked down before day one.
1 Reply
Matthew Tregoning
Property Manager · Melbourne, FL · Member since 2019 · 468 posts · 173 votes
3d
For that cottage, I'd make the route to public beach access really clear. .4 miles on a map can feel different carrying chairs and a cooler. A simple walking map and a place to rinse off beach gear would be high on my list.
0 Reply

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.