What do YouTube gurus leave out about running a short-term rental?

Question

The highlight reels make STRs look great, but conversations with operators have me looking closer at vacancy. Some have told me bookings are slowing as more travelers choose hotels. I’m interested in the space and haven’t bought one yet, so I want to understand what ownership looks like when the calendar isn’t full.

For those running STRs, what’s the unglamorous part of ownership you wish you’d known before buying?

John Racine · Answer

Andrew, the operations points above are right. On your vacancy question specifically, here's what I'd want to know before buying:

1. Guests compare the total price, not the nightly rate. Once cleaning and platform fees are added, a 2-night STR stay often costs more than a hotel. That's a big part of the shift you're hearing about. STRs still win where a hotel can't serve the guest well: groups, families, longer stays, people who want a kitchen and space. Buy for that guest, and the hotel competition matters a lot less.

2. Underwrite month by month, not annually. Annual revenue projections average away the 3-4 slow months that decide whether a deal actually works. Pull monthly comps (AirDNA, PriceLabs market data) and price those slow months at the rate you'd really need to fill them.

3. Have a plan B built into the property. I'm moving a couple of my units toward mid-term stays. A property that works as an STR in peak season and a mid-term rental the rest of the year is a lot more forgiving than one that only works at full nightly rates.

Are you looking at a specific market yet? Vacancy risk looks very different from market to market.

Inder Singh · Answer

What the gurus skip: the operations. I run a studio near Boston and the listing is the easy 10% — the business is turnovers, pricing reviews twice a day, guest messages at 10 PM, and protecting your rating because one bad arrival experience lives in your reviews forever. They also don't model the platform taking a bigger cut — VRBO's host commission goes to 12% this month, and that comes straight out of your margin. The revenue screenshots are real for some people, but the job is hospitality plus asset management, not passive income. Happy to compare notes with anyone running one in MA.

Jules Aton · Answer

The platform and cleaning fees are astronomical. If you go with a management company they will likely price it for heads in the bed. Guests' expectation of the perfect experience is difficult to meet at times.

Alexandra Kemp · Answer

I think one of the biggest things people overlook is how much the local market matters. A unique property can be an absolute cash cow in the right location, but that doesn’t mean the same concept works everywhere.

I'd also pay close attention to zoning, permits, insurance and financing before buying. I've seen some great STR concepts that don't fit traditional lending guidelines. The more unusual the property, the more homework I'd do upfront.

Andrew Steffens · Answer

Agreed with the above, the operations almost as a whole. The course videos Ive seen on social media show flashy properties and big payouts, but skip the absolute brain damage getting there and what happens if you fall short. This business is 24 hours and now extremely competitive. You have to be constantly adapting and up on the changes in the market including both supply and demand sides. This requires systems in place, and usually not cheap. Dealing with needy, unruly, or generally disagreeable guests, unhelpful OTA customer support and more make this a business not for the faint of heart. I purposely paint a grim picture when asked questions like these to see if the interested party does not flinch. If you're still interested, you could have the right traits needed to be successful. If not, then maybe this is not for you. I will also say 90%+ of stays are easy and uneventful, but operating over 50 properties as a PM means I likely have 3-5 fires to put out at all times.

J Coyle · Answer

The unglamorous part is that empty nights are the baseline in most markets, not a surprise. A few things I'd want to know before buying: underwrite with a conservative occupancy and see if the deal still works at an even lower number, because cleaning contracts, utilities, software and insurance keep running when the calendar is empty. Once live, gaps matter more than photos. Lower the minimum stay on orphan nights, offer a small last-minute discount for dates inside a week, and use dynamic pricing instead of a flat rate. Keep a repair reserve too. Finally, ask hosts in your exact submarket for their off-season calendar.

Clifton Harris · Answer

I think one thing that gets overlooked is the difference between getting bookings and actually running a profitable vacation rental.

Disclosure: I'm a Property Manager with Kindful.co, a vacation rental management company in the Smokies.

Matthew Tregoning · Answer

The part I’d stress-test is who handles the second problem while the first one is still open. A cleaner cancellation and a guest locked out can happen on the same afternoon. Before buying, I’d map out the backup cleaner, local maintenance contact, and after-hours coverage, including what happens when you’re unavailable. That makes the workload more tangible than an average hours-per-week estimate. Would you be local to the property?

Basit Siddiqi · Answer

STR being treated as an investment used to be a 'niche' investment.
As there were few investors/competition, investors has an overall higher profit margin.

I think the market is maturing in a sense that margins are thinning.
Furthermore, professionalization in the space has increased.

There are companies and teams who live and breathe this 24/7.
They have management companies that respond and provide professional care 24/7 with quick response times.
They have staffed cleaners who are cheaper than those who need a one-off.

I think its a harder thing to do now if you don't plan to scale.

Jim Hanseder · Answer

Lodging tax is the one I see trip people up, and it's easy to forget when you're focused on operations. Airbnb collects some of it in a lot of places, but not always the county or city portion, and many counties want a return every month even if nothing booked. Before your first guest, look up your county's tourist or lodging tax page, register, and put the filing date on your calendar. I learned this on my own condo in Clackamas County, Oregon, where I had to catch up on months Airbnb wasn't covering. Full disclosure: I run a filing service for this, but the DIY route is free and fine for most single-property owners.

What do YouTube gurus leave out about running a short-term rental?

What do YouTube gurus leave out about running a short-term rental?

Most Popular Reply

11 Replies