FHA Self Sufficiency

Anchorage, Alaska
House Hacking
2wFollow

FHA Self Sufficiency

Slavik Lund
Lender · Anchorage, AK · Member since 2013 · 37 posts · 13 votes

A quick update for those who may run into this as a problem, because I deal with this a lot in my area.

Just to be clear I'm setting the definition right up front: self-sufficiency measures the appraised rents not the current market rents. In certain regions this is a problem because your appraisal doesn't come in until the very, very, very end. If there's a major flaw in the numbers, it's a nearly impossible equation to solve.

Lots of lenders trip over this and generally speaking this is heavily regionally specific because of values versus rents.

But in Alaska even in the high 6s, low 7s, this is generally a pretty straightforward issue to solve upfront during the pre-approval. Now that the rates are bit higher than that, this is becoming an almost impossible issue to solve.

The reason is that the deal needs to be built in such a way as to allow enough seller credit for you to get an unreasonably low (lower-than-market) rate in order for this equation to work out.

FHA will allow 6%. VA will allow between 4% and 6% as well. Conventional generally only 3%.

The ones that have been overcoming this with no problems, are generally real estate licensees who are building the deal for themselves & including a version of their commission and maximum seller credit creatively.

-Slav

1Reply
3,416 views

Most Popular Reply

Ray WilliamsBusiness Member
Lender · Denver, CO · Member since 2017 · 181 posts · 83 votes
2w

Slav, good post, and Juan's math shows how big the gap gets at today's rates. A few things I'd add for anyone running into this.

The test only applies to 3 and 4 unit properties on FHA. A duplex doesn't have it at all, so if a triplex won't pencil, a duplex in the same area sometimes works fine.

Conventional is also worth a look. You can buy a 2 to 4 unit primary with 5% down now, and there's no self-sufficiency test. The tradeoff is that PMI pricing leans heavily on credit score and reserves matter more, but for a buyer with good credit it often beats fighting the FHA test. VA doesn't use a self-sufficiency test either, though most lenders will want to see reserves on a multi-unit.

On the timing problem, two things help. Pull rental comps yourself before you write the offer so you're working from the number an appraiser is likely to use, not the listing's pro forma rents. This is where I see more people get tripped up. They do zero underwriting on a home before moving on it. Research is key to smart acquisitions, don't lean on a lender or appraiser. And make sure your contract contingency covers the rent side too, not only the value. If the appraised rents come in light at the very end, you want a clean way out of the contract.

I'm a mortgage broker in Denver and invest, and the duplex vs. triplex point is the one I see buyers miss most.

3Reply
See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Juan Pedro López
    Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 2 votes
    2w

    @Slavik Lund Good post. To put numbers on why rates make this so hard: take a $600K triplex with 3.5% down, units appraising at $1,500 each, about $550/mo in taxes, $250 insurance and ~$150 MIP. 75% of $4,500 is $3,375. At 6.75% the full payment is about $4,705, so it fails by a wide margin. To pass at those rents, principal and interest would have to fall to about $2,425, which on a $579K loan means a rate of roughly 3%. That's why your point about building the seller credit in from the start matters: at today's rates, a buydown alone rarely closes a gap that size.

    The quick check buyers can do before writing an offer: appraised rents x 0.75 = the most the full payment (PITI plus MIP and any HOA) can be. If the payment is well above that, rents or price have to move, not just the rate.

    2Reply
  • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
    Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 959 posts · 347 votes
    2w

    @Slavik Lund good heads up for the house hackers. Appraisals have been coming in light for us across the board lately, so anything that depends on the appraised number at the very end makes me nervous. Working it out at pre-approval like you said seems like the way to go. Appreciate you posting it.

    [email protected]484-791-6200
    CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme548 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Ray WilliamsBusiness Member
    Lender · Denver, CO · Member since 2017 · 181 posts · 83 votes
    2w

    Slav, good post, and Juan's math shows how big the gap gets at today's rates. A few things I'd add for anyone running into this.

    The test only applies to 3 and 4 unit properties on FHA. A duplex doesn't have it at all, so if a triplex won't pencil, a duplex in the same area sometimes works fine.

    Conventional is also worth a look. You can buy a 2 to 4 unit primary with 5% down now, and there's no self-sufficiency test. The tradeoff is that PMI pricing leans heavily on credit score and reserves matter more, but for a buyer with good credit it often beats fighting the FHA test. VA doesn't use a self-sufficiency test either, though most lenders will want to see reserves on a multi-unit.

    On the timing problem, two things help. Pull rental comps yourself before you write the offer so you're working from the number an appraiser is likely to use, not the listing's pro forma rents. This is where I see more people get tripped up. They do zero underwriting on a home before moving on it. Research is key to smart acquisitions, don't lean on a lender or appraiser. And make sure your contract contingency covers the rent side too, not only the value. If the appraised rents come in light at the very end, you want a clean way out of the contract.

    I'm a mortgage broker in Denver and invest, and the duplex vs. triplex point is the one I see buyers miss most.

    3Reply
    • Keenan Fitzpatrick
      Realtor · Anchorage, AK · Member since 2017 · 230 posts · 179 votes
      1w

      Good point. We are definitely having to pivot clients towards the 5% Conv loans and duplexes depending on their situation. It's tough to see the performance of 4plex's in our market fall off so much because most of them are going to be 50+ years old as well and it's hard for a buyer to come out of pocket $30k - $50k to get into a building that makes $200/month after they raise rents to market value and rent out their unit.

      You're also spot on with underwriting a deal on the front end and pulling rent comps. Only a small amount of rentals are on our mls here and I've had to spend tons of time calling investor friends to get lease comps for an appraiser to make a deal work but that's what we gotta do sometimes!

      Cheers!

      0Reply
  • Ryan ThomsonBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Colorado Springs, CO · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5d

    The test only trips up 3 and 4 unit purchases, not duplexes. Worth saying clearly because I see buyers panic before they even know which tier they're in.

    For triplexes and quads, the math got ugly when rates crossed 6.5%. The appraiser's rent schedule (typically 10-15% below actual market in most areas) combined with a 7% rate means the self-sufficiency equation rarely works without a buydown or maximum seller credit.

    There's one angle most people aren't considering though. If the existing seller has an FHA loan at 2.75-3.5%, an assumption changes the whole picture. At 3% on a $350K balance, the payment is about $1,476/month. At 6.8%, that same balance runs $2,329/month. The self-sufficiency test is applied against the lower number and usually passes without any games.

    I've run this scenario multiple times in Colorado Springs. Assumption timeline is 45-90 days, costs about $750/side. If it's the difference between a quad that clears the test and one that doesn't, that's not really a cost.

    The seller credit buydown works if you need a new loan, but you're spending cash to solve a problem that might not exist on the right deal.

    The Assumable Guy544 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.
Log InJoin for Free