Finding properties with enough room for profit is definitely near the top of the list. Between rising rehab costs and tight inventory, running accurate numbers early on is essential.
Reliable contractors are a close second—having a strong boots-on-the-ground team makes or breaks a deal in Cleveland.
Curious to hear what methods others are using to find decent margins in this market!
Same thing in Memphis. Finding properties with enough room for profit is the bottleneck, not money and not contractors. I run 236 single-family rentals, and I buy under $100K with an ARV of $180K to $265K, 3BR or more, Section 8 rent of $1,395 to $1,950. If a deal does not hit the 1% rule and work on a DSCR loan at 70 to 80% LTV, I pass, no matter how good the contractor is. Most deals I see fail on price, not on the team. I also convert 2/1s to 3/1s and 3/1s to 4/2s when the rehab math supports it, because the extra bedroom is what moves the rent. So my answer is simple: the biggest challenge is deal flow. What is working for you right now to find properties that actually fit your numbers?
Good topic, Matteo. From the financing side, what I see holding a lot of investors back in Cleveland is underestimating rehab costs and not having financing lined up before they make offers, so they either lose deals or get stuck on the refi when the appraisal comes in low. Knowing your purchase and refi path before you close makes a big difference, and so does having a contractor who gives realistic scopes. I do lending and have a local construction and property management team, so if you or anyone reading this is working on a Cleveland deal, give me a call (my number's in my signature below).